Introduction
10:31, a slowdown after a string of faster times. It feels good to roll up the sleeves. Some nice tricky stuff in here — I enjoy being fooled by Joker. Commentary below.
Solutions
Across
1 Useful plant, one doing badly (6)
INDIGO = I + DOING anagrammed
Useful? I hadn’t known. Drugs.com says, “Chiefly a source of dye, indigo also has been used as a nematicide and treatment for a range of ills including scorpion bites and ovarian and stomach cancer.”.
4 Reported effect of traffic jam in Paris? Sad (6)
RUEFUL = homophone of RUE FULL
Tricky and cute.
8 Right result upset cattle thief (7)
RUSTLER = R + RESULT anagrammed
Had HUSTLER for awhile which held me up.
10 Great disappointment about English not on top (5)
BELOW = BLOW around E
11 Begin royal house when banishing first of usurpers (5)
START = STUART without U
12 Appealing victory by a few (7)
WINSOME = WIN + SOME
13 Feeling thrilled about November period (9)
SENTIMENT = SENT around N + TIME
17 Outline for dossier (7)
PROFILE = FOR + FILE
19 Put down and leave a jacket (5)
PARKA = PARK + A
‘Put down and leave’ is an accurate, misleading definition!
20 Long for clubs with electronic dance music (5)
CRAVE = C + RAVE
I was trying to get EDM in there somehow…
21 A fool chasing home counties bird (7)
SEAGULL = A + GULL after SE
22 Work persistently beside river with great intensity (6)
DEEPLY = PLY next to DEE
23 Second piece of pollen removed from another part of stamen (6)
ANTHER = remove O from ANOTHER
Biffed this one after much consternation, only to realize the answer was staring me in the face!
Down
1 Result of implosion badly ruins hotel (6)
INRUSH = anagram of RUINS + H
2 Is ardent love during romantic meeting fair? (13)
DISPASSIONATE = IS PASSION in DATE
3 Italian ice creams with new food ingredient (7)
GELATIN = GELATI + N
5 Headgear but not the topper in town (5)
URBAN = TURBAN without first letter
6 Golfer’s action to succeed with first two of three below par? (6-7)
FOLLOW-THROUGH = FOLLOW + TH + ROUGH
Quite tricky. Ultimately I biffed it.
7 Tom, perhaps needs pounds for second legal representative (6)
LAWYER = SAWYER with L for S
9 Eats surrounded by arguments and loud behaviour (9)
ROWDINESS = DINES in ROWS
14 Clear up former flat (7)
EXPLAIN = EX + PLAIN
15 Coming at intervals in spring crocuses exceed daffodils at first (6)
SPACED = SPA + C + E + D
16 Fashion to follow as an alternative (6)
TAILOR = TAIL + OR
Like others I was slightly puzzled by ‘useful’ at 1ac, and even given indigo’s medicinal properties ‘useful’ is too vague a description of these and proved to be more of a distraction than an aid to the solver. If the clue had been simply ‘Plant, one doing badly’ I’m sure I’d have solved it quicker. This is bearing in mind of course that this is a Quick Cryptic where setters really shouldn’t set out to be deliberately obstructive.
At 13ac SENT for ‘thrilled’ is dated slang never particularly widely used in the first place.
Edited at 2022-03-02 06:05 am (UTC)
ANTHER from wordplay
FOI: INRUSH
COD: FOLLOW THROUGH even though I saw it quickly.
Lots didn’t immediately spring to mind but kept moving around and the accumulation of checkers (and finally twigging INDIGO) helped
Thanks Jeremy and Joker
Liked RUEFUL and LAWYER
Was scrolling in my mind through town names before I saw URBAN, was stumped for a long time by RUEFUL (terrific clue) ANTHER and FOLLOW THROUGH.
DEEPLY almost had me throwing in the towel – glad I persevered, it’s good to get beaten up every now and then and still come out the other side.
Thanks Joker & Jeremy
Thank you Jeremy for providing solutions to frustration and to Joker for setting the bar too high for me but giving me something to learn from. I don’t think I will be the only DNF today. No time to take my usual corner chair in the club, better luck tomorrow.
No problem with indigo being a “useful” plant as a dye.
RUEFUL top clue. DISPASSIONATE LOI.
8:13
… and I needed just over 17 minutes, much of it spent on the SW corner.
Most of my stumbling blocks have already been mentioned — why “useful” in 1A Indigo, DK pine = deal in 18D Ideal or sent = thrilled in 13A Sentiment. Also thought rave for “electronic dance music” in 20A Crave was very questionable: I thought the rave was the party itself not the music played at it (but then what does my generation know of such things?). And finally, biffed but never parsed 6D Follow through.
So, all a bit of a struggle. But eventually all green.
Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog
Cedric
Edited at 2022-03-02 08:52 am (UTC)
btw isn’t the parsing of 17a outline / pro (for) + file (dossier)
I’d only heard of Indigo as a colour too, not a plant. But that’s a general knowledge thing so fair enough.
Shame because I loved RUEFUL and thought it was going to be an enjoyable one when I started, but it was not to be.
Thanks for the explanations Jeremy.
I’ll probably enjoy going over today’s many neat clues via Jeremy’s blog when I have settled down (there were some to enjoy, not least RUEFUL when it clicked together with SEAGULL; the misdirection in LAWYER and URBAN was subtle). However, this was too clever by half for a QC. I had no problem with ANTHER, DEAL, or INDIGO but I struggled generally and I didn’t enjoy it. I’m beginning to doubt the location of my marbles this week. John M.
Edited at 2022-03-02 11:14 am (UTC)
FOI START, appropriately. LOI TAILOR.
Some amusing clues from Joker inc RUEFUL, URBAN, PROFILE, WINSOME, PARKA. Some tricky though biffable like LAWYER and ANTHER and DISPASSIONATE. Also biffed FOLLOW THROUGH as soon as I got the F. Took ages to work out e.g. SPACED.
Need more coffee now.
Thanks vm, Jeremy.
Edited at 2022-03-02 10:59 am (UTC)
Edited at 2022-03-02 10:30 am (UTC)
I had the most unfamiliar experience of not being able to parse several clues – SPACED, ANTHER and FOLLOW-THROUGH – and needing the blog to explain them (thanks Jezza).
FOI INRUSH, LOI DEEPLY, COD RUEFUL, time 16:36 for an Awful Day.
Templar
DNK 23ac “Anther”, nor “sent” = thrilled or “deal” = pine, but they were obtainable from the clues. At some point I will have to go back and parse 6dn “Follow Through”.
Might be in the minority, but although I found this challenging, I also thought it fair.
FOI — 3dn “Gelatin”
LOI — 22ac “Deeply”
COD — 4ac “Rueful”
Thanks as usual!
Edited at 2022-03-02 12:28 pm (UTC)
This was definitely tricky, and took me past my target for the second time this week, but it’s well worth spending the time to look at Joker’s well written clues. As a training exercise for those who wish to progress as solvers, it was first rate.
FOI RUSTLER
LOI URBAN
COD RUEFUL
TIME 5:44
No chance.
A very nasty unfair one.
Unfortunately, I didn’t erase that I at the beginning of 2d so absolutely could not see what was going on when I tackled that one. It had been slow progress anyway – sorting that little mess out added several minutes to the whole thing 😅 Just as well it’s a horrible day and I didn’t have any plans this morning.
Despite that, I enjoyed this a lot. Joker’s clues are very witty – I liked WINSOME, URBAN and EXPLAIN a lot, but there were many other crackers. Only one got a smiley though!
FOI Gelatin
LOI Indigo
COD Rueful
Thanks Joker and Jeremy
Not completed were 4a and 5d. And 15d and 22a.
But I buckled in and enjoyed the challenge. I thought Follow Through was very tough and a bit disappointing as with Sentiment (thrilled = sent very obscure to me) and I hesitated for a long time over deal for pine…
COD probably 23a Anther just for the confusion yet simplicity
Thanks all
Edited at 2022-03-02 01:07 pm (UTC)
I can’t really debate any of the clues, as 22 of them remained unsolved after 20 minutes and two full passes through the grid. That triggered my first unscheduled pause. RUSTLER was my FOI and INRUSH was my only other pre-pause success. My second unscheduled pause came after 75 minutes, when I still had seven gaps and a couple of question marks in the grid. However, DISPASSIONATE appeared immediately after my return and I somehow managed to grind it out to the finish just over 20 minutes later.
My LOI was TAILOR, and I still had question marks on SENTIMENT, IDEAL and SEAGULL when I finally put down my pencil for the third and final time. Let’s hope tomorrow brings some lighter relief.
Many thanks to Joker and Jeremy.
Edited at 2022-03-02 01:16 pm (UTC)
FOI: RUSTLER
LOI: DEEPLY
COD: RUEFUL
Thanks Jeremy and Joker.
Finished in 16.04 with LOI TAILOR.
Thanks to Jeremy
David
Gary A