Introduction
7:42. A good, strenuous test. I worried for a bit I might not finish but persistence, as always, is key. (Edit on writing the blog: I see that my problem may have been that a lot of the “charades”-style clues don’t put the bits together in a straightforward order. Tricky!)
Follow along with my efforts here: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1135582892 .
Solutions
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation is otherwise irrelevant. Proper nouns will appear capitalized, but otherwise capitalization is irrelevant as well.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
Here is a Glossary of all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in this puzzle.
Glossary
Wordplay indicators
Abbreviations and little bits
Across
1 Lame inspector’s / guided by Jack (8)
DISABLED = DI’S + LED next to AB
5 Cry of bird bearing large talon (4)
CLAW = CAW around L
8 Make-up / remains on daughter, hastily and carelessly done (8)
SLAPDASH = SLAP + ASH next to D
9 Scrap a / safety test, on reflection (4)
ATOM = A + MOT reversed
11 Article / Rosie emptied in that place (5)
THERE = THE + first and last letters of ROSIE
12 Like to broadcast / new author (7)
TOLKIEN = anagram of LIKE TO + N
13 Bit of a word quietly by referee, and football team retreating (6)
PREFIX = P + REF + XI reversed
15 One of five kids with constant / energy [gets] fruit (6)
QUINCE = QUIN + C + E
18 Rubbish book found in outbuilding (7)
GARBAGE = B in GARAGE
19 Bury — popular / market, quite popular ultimately (5)
INTER = IN + last letters of MARKET QUITE POPULAR
21 Central sections of park tidy [and] dry (4)
ARID = middle letters of PARK TIDY
22 Is the suspect, / after drink knocked back, most aggressive? (8)
PUSHIEST = IS THE anagrammed, after reversal of SUP
23 Irritable newsman / Gary‘s outside (4)
EDGY = ED + first and last of GARY
24 Boss meets key / member where horses are bred (4,4)
STUD FARM = STUD + F + ARM
Here ‘boss’ refers to a raised bump or stud, sometimes called an ‘umbo’ in these parts. Vinyl points out that this is definition 2 in Berstan.
Down
1 Desmond / initially knowing / best type of computer (7)
DESKTOP = DES + first letter of KNOWING + TOP
2 Bluish-grey / pan (5)
SLATE = double definition
SLATE = ‘pan’ as in “to review unfavourably” (Chambers).
3 Move / equipment — upset artist[‘s] pet perhaps (10)
BUDGERIGAR = BUDGE + RIG + reversal of RA
4 Fake art’s sculpted / by European / unknown (6)
ERSATZ = ARTS anagrammed, next to E + Z
6 Reluctant individual overlooking an area of Scotland (7)
LOTHIAN = LOTH + I + AN
Alternate spelling of LOATHE LOATH, I believe.
7 Ladies [and] Gents south of Waterloo vacant (5)
WOMEN = MEN below first and last of WATERLOO
10 Brandished baking ingredient / one / dropped (10)
FLOURISHED = FLOUR + I + SHED
14 Each / gang around noon receiving payment for work (7)
EARNING = EA + RING around N
16 Printing mistake, rare, unsettled / corporation (7)
ERRATUM = RARE anagrammed + TUM
17 Religious adherent[‘s] tunic regularly / appeared in joke (6)
JESUIT = even-numbered letters of TUNIC in JEST
18 Fireplace large, we hear (5)
GRATE = homophone of GREAT
20 In contest, he taunted Greek character (5)
THETA = hidden in CONTEST HE TAUNTED
No problem with STUD FARM as there is one just across the road from my nearest pub.
Back on the road again after a failure yesterday- pen and paper solving much better for me. I can now use the paper for my list of the day.
I enjoyed the vocabulary in this puzzle
Edited at 2021-09-01 07:18 am (UTC)
This seemed easy enough, but can’t have been, as I missed my target.
FOI CLAW
LOI TOLKIEN (because I mistyped “ersaaz !)
COD ERRATUM
TIME 5:15
Atom=scrap? I guess “he doesn’t have an atom of sense in him”, is that it?
DESKTOP today and I think LAPTOP was yesterday?
COD FLOURISHED, also my LOI
I thought this was tricky today. Maybe u was just off the wavelength but was firmly in the SCC. I thought Disabled was correct but had forgotten that Jack is yet another term for sailor so that confused me. Also held up by flourished where I was trying to get an anagram in. And Tolkien where I was looking for a word that sounded like “like to”. The (false) panagram helped me with prefix, ersatz and quince.
The latter are quite an odd fruit. We have a tree in our garden and they have a slight fuzz on the outside. You can’t eat them raw but are quite interesting cooked with a bit of a floral fragrance. And of course, quince jelly or membrillo is delicious if you can be bothered to make it.
… on this far from simple puzzle which took me 14 minutes in all. I think Breadman “has previous” on all-but-1-letter pangrams and I confess I fail to see the point of them, but looking out for the J helped me get 17D Jesuit and it definitely gave me the Z as the unknown in 4D Ersatz. Why incidentally is “by” used here to show that RSAT is inside the E and Z — I would have expected by to mean alongside not inside.
That apart, only minor query was over Make-up = Slap in 8A Slapdash. Not a meaning I am familiar with — but then most of the world of make-up is a totally closed book to me.
Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog
Cedric
Edited at 2021-09-01 08:45 am (UTC)
Slap and make-up are synonymous amongst the laddettes I have noticed — ‘I’ll just bung on a bit of slap’ comes to mind.
I think you may have gone into panic mode when nothing seemed to come easily. I’ve done that many a time myself, especially when I’ve had a deadline to solve and produce a blog. If you have no deadline the best tactic is to go and do something else for a while and come back to the puzzle with an open mind.
Thanks to Jeremy
Liked QUINCE, ERSATZ and LOI PREFIX, among others.
Thanks for much needed blog, Jeremy. Biffed a lot today.
Edited at 2021-09-01 10:20 am (UTC)
For example: having got used to ‘ultimately’ meaning the last letter of the preceding/following word, 19a needs letters from 3 words. 3d ‘artist’s pet’ was a hold-up: often the ’s’ would be required [RA’S], but not here. In 10d I took ‘one dropped’ to indicate a word with the ‘I’ removed (dropped). Ah, wrong again! And ‘regularly’ always confuses – is the odd or even letters that are required?
All just experience I realise… and not falling into the trap of believing there are strategies which apply in all contexts!
Overall an enjoyable solve. Thanks to Breadman for stretching me, and Jeremy for parsing things that I would never have seen without help!
I am going to walk carefully today to avoid the loose marbles. Thanks to both. John M.
FOI DESKTOP, LOI LOTHIAN, COD WOMEN, time 14:26 for 2.4K and a Terrible Day.
Many thanks Breaders and Jeremy.
Templar
quietly = P
unknown = Z
Why is that? Surely, X is usually the unknown? Is P quiet, like the pee in pool?
And, corporation = tum??
🙂
The unknowns are X, Y and Z. Try them in turn!
Lexico definition 3 for “corporation”: “(dated, humorous) A paunch.”
Edited at 2021-09-01 09:49 am (UTC)
Liked TOLKIEN
Thanks Jeremy and Breadman
FOI – 8ac SLAPDASH
LOI – 12ac TOLKIEN
COD – 7dn WOMEN, although there were a large number of contenders for the award today.
On the whole, I found this a fun challenge with a nice mix of clues and vocab.
FOI Claw
LOI and COD Slapdash
Thanks Breadman and Jeremy
Otherwise, not too bad, though a bit over target.
7:11
FOI 1ac DISABLED
LOI 15ac PREFIX
COD 8ac SLAPDASH — me!
WOD 15ac MEMBRILLO divine!
Like a few people, when I complete a clue that makes me chuckle or is clever in its construction I tend to mark it (in my case with a smiley face 😀). I can’t remember the last time I had so many happy faces looking back at me from the newspaper.
I particularly liked the fact that 6dn had “Ian” in its make up, even if it was pure coincidence and not obviously part of the clueing.
FOI — 1dn “Desktop”
LOI — 2dn “Budgerigar”
COD — 6dn “Lothian” — although it could have been a handful.
Thanks as usual!