Introduction
No time today, as I solved with my five-year-old son, Oliver: his first introduction to the art of cryptic crosswords. He has a much easier time with these than he does with US crosswords because, on the whole, the demands on his vocabulary are far gentler. The letter-play makes sense to him as someone who’s been fascinated with letters since he was 1, and reading since he was 3.
Solutions
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation (and capitalization) is otherwise irrelevant.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
After the solutions, I list all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in a Glossary.
Across
1 Purple loo with poster, not the first (8)
LAVENDER = LAV + (S)ENDER
Post = mail = send. Not a usage Oliver was familiar with, though of course he has heard of the ‘postal service’.
6 Grass going back inside garden wall (4)
LAWN = hidden reversed in GARDEN WALL
Our first in.
8 Sight of German — is one inside? (6)
VISION = VON around IS + I
9 Not exactly / a / part [for] a girl (6)
CAROLE = C + A + ROLE
10 Odd bits of beefcake [seen in] Northern stream (4)
BECK = odd-numbered letters in BEEFCAKE
11 Team coming in has pay altered: [that’s] breathtaking! (8)
ASPHYXIA = XI in anagram of HAS PAY
12 Set to be in / church (5)
BATCH = BAT + CH
13 Briefly sample new sacred song (5)
PSALM = SAMPLE without the last letter, anagrammed
15 I might need a ruler, me — a certain king? (8)
MEASURER = ME + A + SURE + R
Cute clue.
17 Breathe in sharply when embraced by doctor (4)
GASP = AS in G.P.
19 Remove coarser elements [from] puzzle (6)
RIDDLE = double definition
‘Riddle’ is a synonym of ‘sieve’.
20 Hang around, at first, looking on in the extreme rear (6)
LOITER = first letters of LOOKING ON IN THE EXTREME REAR
21 Boy is without a pulse (4)
BEAN = BEN around A
‘Within’ = ‘inside’, so ‘without’ = ‘outside’.
22 Time / to have / everything including hospital [and] municipal building (4,4)
TOWN HALL = T + OWN + ALL around H
Down
2 Beer keeping one very animated (5)
ALIVE = ALE around I + V
3 Unusual kite etc, one not made of paper (1-6)
E-TICKET = anagram of KITE ETC
4 Dull / agent demanding payment (3)
DUN = double definition
To dun is to demand payment; and a dun duns.
5 Insubstantial fare I prepare roughly / about / start of Christmas (4,5)
RICE PAPER = I PREPARE anagrammed about first letter of CHRISTMAS
Wrapper for spring rolls (and more).
6 Word of apology, / large, not small, one’s articulated? (5)
LORRY = SORRY with L instead of S
7 Boy is going to / India / in the morning (7)
WILLIAM = WILL + I + AM
11 Hateful injury to the person, or tear (9)
ABHORRENT = A.B.H. (actual bodily harm) + OR + RENT
12 Hairstyle / for busy people? (7)
BEEHIVE = double definition
14 Agony [as] Dicky hugs Ian (7)
ANGUISH = anagram of HUGS IAN
16 American saloon re-used anisette bottles (5)
SEDAN = hidden in RE-USED ANISETTE
The bar car on a train. Never heard of her.
18 Hard quality [that’s] appropriate when speaking? (5)
STEEL = homophone of STEAL
20 Behold, start of week [makes you] depressed (3)
LOW = LO + W
– Blorenge
PlusJ, could you let me have PlusO’s email, so I can ask him for parsing when I’m clueless on a Monday.
Tell him he can’t have my slot yet – in case he he gets ideas!
I needed 14 minutes for this, my longest QC solve for a while, and I’m not sure why, although the second meaning of DUN was unknown to me and I needed both checkers before coming up with it.
Edit: Following the nudge from Marty (below) and an anon poster, it’s now confirmed there is a ‘Dad’s Army’ Nina, although a bit of a strange one as some of the names are only approximations. I see TOWN HALL was relevant after all as there was a very famous episode with its climax set on the the roof of the town hall and its clock with mechanical figures.
Edited at 2021-04-28 08:51 am (UTC)
Finished with ASPHYXIA in 12.51 with my favourite being RIDDLE.
Thanks to Jeremy and Oliver
I’ll now go through the clues again to savour the best ones from a fine selection. Thanks to both. John M.
Edited at 2021-04-28 07:47 am (UTC)
COD ASPHYXIA.
All dun in 40 mins. Thks Marty, Jeremy and Oliver
Several clues seemed to me to be constructed of rather too many moving parts, and more like 15×15 clues — a common indicator of this being long clues with rather clunky surfaces as the setter works all the bits in.
Oh well. Tomorrow is another day, but personally, I am quite glad Marty is only a very occasional setter. Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog — much needed today
Cedric
FOI: 6a. LAWN
LOI: 11a. ASPHYXIA
Time to Complete: DNF
Clues Answered Correctly without aids: 11
Clues Answered with Aids (3 lives): 11a, 11d, 14d
Clues Unanswered: 9a, 12a, 13a, 15a, 19a, 21a, 4d, 5d, 12d, 16d, 18d
Wrong Answers: 2d
Total Correctly Answered (incl. aids): 14/26
Aids Used: Chamber’s, Bradford’s
My first Marty crossword, and what a tough one. I only answered 15, including using 3 lives and having one of my answers incorrect.
11a. ASPHYXIA – I couldn’t get this one without help, but on seeing the answer I thought it was a clever clue. First life used.
11d. ABHORRENT – Ditto above; a great clue. Second life used.
14d. ANGUISH – Totally missed that it was an anagram. Third and last life used.
21a. BEAN – One of my unanswered clues. I kept thinking too much of pulse relating to heartbeat.
So, no excuses from me, I simply was not experienced/good enough for this one. I didn’t dislike this puzzle though. It had some really good clues.
Bah! I have a candy bar in the fridge in the hope for a completion. I hear it calling to me now. I bet I succumb by tea-time.
Oh, and well done Oliver. I am worried now that a 5-year-old boy beat me on this one. I definitely will need that candy bar to comfort me now.
Even with the blog, for which thanks, I didn’t find it easy. “Re-used” as a hidden indicator defeated me.
Roll on tomorrow.
Diana
The indicator is ‘bottles’ as in ‘holds inside it’. So you will find ‘sedan’ inside ‘re-used anisette’. It’s a very clever misdirection to use the hyphenated word!
My problems were in the NE and NW. LORRY was very good but it took me a while to see the parsing. CAROLE followed. The real head slap moment was in the NW. I was completely perplexed by 1ac, not bringing to mind a synonym for purple and running through all the possibles for loo (gents ladies wc bog throne) but missing the most obvious. Perhaps because it started with the same letter as loo? Dunno. DUN then followed — I think I know the debt meaning better than the dull one but at any rate it’s unusual to have a three letter word as the LOI for a quickie
Fat fingered typo at the end as well 😬
Good challenge — thanks Jeremy and Marty
A little slower than usual – I had not come across the non-dull definition of dun, so it was a partial guess.
Thank you, plusjeremy and Marty.
I did think this puzzle reeked of a Nina, so I was not surprised to see Marty’s comment above and then the one from Anonymous (Marty again?). Very clever, but I’m not surprised people didn’t pick up on it. Anyway, much to enjoy. COD to ASPHYXIA. Thanks Jeremy and Marty.
Who do you think you are kidding 😉
M
Got ASPHYXIA wrong – invented a word!
Looked up RIDDLE which I knew involved shaking out the ash with the, er, riddle grid in a woodburner or old-fashioned range, so belated PDM.
Thanks vm, Jeremy
Edited at 2021-04-28 12:19 pm (UTC)
R
1ac took much longer than it should of as I just couldn’t get “Magenta” out of my head. Then I thought 9ac might be “Erroll”, which screwed up 5dn for a while. “Batch”, “Steel”, “Bean” and “Anguish” all caused problems.
FOI — 8ac “Vision”
LOI — 21ac “Bean”
COD — 17ac “Gasp” — lovely and simple
Thanks as usual!
Edited at 2021-04-28 10:28 am (UTC)
Edited at 2021-04-28 10:36 am (UTC)
I did enjoy some of the clues in their own right – ASPHYXIA and ANGUISH in particular.
FOI Alive
LOI joint Batch and Beehive – I was playing around with those two for a while
COD William – I liked the surface and it’s my son’s name – nuff said 😉
Time 19 minutes – aaagh!
If you haven’t tried the biggie yet, you may find some of it easier than this although there were a few tricky ones. I did it in 30 minutes.
Edited at 2021-04-28 11:07 am (UTC)
So many abbreviations for Loo (“can” looked promising) and with this construction it is unclear how long the composite parts are so that makes it all the harder.
Had to look up German for “of” (got confused with “Mitt”). I know a lady called Carola, so that looked good at 9a.
MEASURER seemed like a contrived word to fit the Nina, I just checked the OED which had a surprising number of citations and usages.
RIDDLE was biffed, I though it was something to do with taking the G off “griddle”.
Also missed DUN and ABHORRENT: never heard of ABH, although tear=rent is very common in crosswords (and not IRL)
COD: E-TICKET
I was on the look out for a Nina from the start because of the unusually rare setter, and then reinforced when familiar sounding names came up. Lavender Lawn was a credible alternative to The Camomile Lawn, and William Steel and Carole Beck were credible characters / actors. However, I was unable to connect anything until I came here and saw Marty’s comment above, when the Lavender, Dunn and Measurier pennies dropped, and I saw the answer. Very clever Marty, and well done on getting past most of us.
Probably not part of the theme, but WILLIAM was Hodges’ first name, and also that of the actor who played him, James Beck’s middle name was Carroll (CAROLE), and (I’m not being that serious) Corporal Jones was obsessed with what he called “the old cold STEEL’!
– Blorenge
– Blorenge
Gosh, hardest QC for many weeks for me and six clues incomplete. I learned a lot so feel happy despite the disaster. Thanks PlusJeremy for the blog and Marty for beating me all ends up.
NHO ‘dun’ so good to learn something new. Also now realise the ‘appropriate’ can be read in two ways. Loved the misdirection of that and also of ‘bottles’ for contains.
Onwards and upwards.
Just thought I would share that.
I have not seen a Marty crossword before and, having given up after 60 minutes with 8 clues still unsolved, I rather hope not to see another one for some time. Sorry Marty – your clues were probably fair, but the puzzle as a whole was just too hard for me.
The clues I failed on were CAROLE, LORRY, BATCH, BEEHIVE, RIDDLE, SEDAN, BEAN and STEEL. I thought of CAROLE, STEEL and ‘sieve’ (and I know a RIDDLE is a gardener’s sieve, because I have one), but I just couldn’t see the parsing. All in all, I was thrashed today.
I think Mrs Random may not get to her attempt until much later, or tomorrow, so I can’t report her outcome yet.
Thanks to Marty and plusjeremy for his much-needed blog.
Mrs Random has now attempted Marty’s offering. She finished in 56 minutes, having struggled with the parsing of some of the clues that beat me. Sadly, however, she plumped for SHELL instead of STEEL, so it has to go down as a DNF.
Roll on tomorrow!
The puzzle definitely had a different “feel” to most QC’s, but I didn’t seem to find it as tricky as most.
My LOIs were LAVENDER then DUN, as MAGENTA kept intruding on my thoughts, even though it didn’t fit, either in number of letters, or in parsing! Only knew one meaning of DUN, but shoved it in as the most likely D?N.
I liked WILLIAM and RIDDLE.
7:24.
Quite pleased with myself to get 11a from the wordplay. Would never have thought of BAT for be in and still couldn’t understand the parsing when I read the blog, took a while to see what it was about. Nor do I understand 4d. I’m familiar with DUN as demanding money but why the AGENT?
Oh well, maybe I’ll try the big boys crossword….
ASPHYXIA and RIDDLE were late in.
Quite tough and it took me 15:19.
David
FOI – 6ac LAWN
LOI – 19ac RIDDLE
COD – 7dn WILLIAM
Thanks to blogger and setter.
FOI ALIVE, LOI LAVENDER, COD ASPHYXIA, time K+30s for an Excellent Day.
Many thanks Marty and Jeremy.
Templar
FOI LAWN
LOI CAROLE
COD WILLIAM
TIME not recorded today, but certainly over my target at around 7-8 minutes ?
* Yes, I know there was a mini-theme in my latest weekend puzzle, but I tried to sprinkle in a mere handful of St.George’s Day clues as a one-off. It’s not a road I intend to take too often !
So if less than 2% of people spot them it is no big deal.
FOI: LAVENDER
LOI: VISION (DNF)
COD: LAVENDER
Thanks Marty and Jeremy.