Introduction
5:58, with a minute spent on my last one in (2 Down).
Solutions
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation (and capitalization) is otherwise irrelevant.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
After the solutions, I list all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in a Glossary.
Across
7 Old magistrate always going round / full of energy (5)
REEVE = EVER reversed, around E
8 Condition [of] ground is v poor (7)
PROVISO = anagram of IS V POOR
10 Fit one new counter (7)
INSTALL = I + N + STALL
11 British study [making] money (5)
BREAD = B + READ
12 Bookish detective with rules [for] system of communication (5,4)
MORSE CODE = MORSE + CODE
14 Brewed tea, had breakfast? (3)
ATE = anagram of TEA
15 Something swimming in garlic, oddly (3)
COD = hidden in GARLIC ODDLY
16 Error on / set of web pages, we’re told (9)
OVERSIGHT = OVER + homophone of SITE
18 Religion is assigned / unlimited blame (5)
ISLAM = IS + BLAME without first and last letters
20 Characters mixed up: a horse and sheep (7)
ANAGRAM = A + NAG + RAM
22 Trade fairs with English diamonds on show (7)
EXPOSED = EXPOS + E + D
23 Empty pan filled with uncooked seafood (5)
PRAWN = PAN without middle letter, around RAW
Down
1 A much niftier, refurbished gaming device (5,7)
FRUIT MACHINE = anagram of A MUCH NIFTIER
2 Considered meeting everyone initially / on a certain day (8)
MEASURED = first letters of MEETING EVERYONE + A + SURE + D
Tricky.
3 Huge precious stone mounted / on / middle of tiara (4)
MEGA = GEM reversed + middle letter of TIARA
4 A survey / about, at heart, God (6)
APOLLO = A + POLL + middle letter of ABOUT
5 Rubbish / American fruit pies (8)
COBBLERS = double definition
Didn’t know the first meaning.
6 Shoot beginning to emerge beneath tree (4)
FIRE = first letter of EMERGE after FIR
9 Modest talent put out collection of books (3,9)
OLD TESTAMENT = anagram of MODEST TALENT
13 Dessert seems not set (4,4)
ETON MESS = anagram of SEEMS NOT
14 Ornate regalia on / head of noblewoman from North Africa (8)
ALGERIAN = anagram of REGALIA + first letter of NOBLEWOMAN
17 Animals [in] European countries (6)
ELANDS = E + LANDS
19 Run from the police, northbound (4)
LOPE = hidden in a reversal of THE POLICE
21 Current measures a politician / outlines, finally (4)
AMPS = A + MP + last letter of OUTLINES
Glossary
Wordplay indicators
in = linking word
Abbreviations and little bits
European = E
One thing that helped is that there are a lot of cryptic-themed clues: Old Testament (OT in puzzles), anagram (yes, we’ve seen them), and Inspector Morse (a well-known solver).
Was pleased to see REEVE straight away, not a common word. I believe ‘sherrif’ comes from shire-reeve.
I think the surface reading of 18a may cause consternation for some who don’t understand cryptic. Imagine this clue reported out of context. “Today, in The Times, the word ISLAM was defined as “Religion assigned unlimited blame”. Setters and their editors should probably avoid clues like this.
COD PRAWN
Others with a sensitive disposition might object to the Old Testament being of but Modest Talent.
Hopefully solvers here and beyond are more concerned with the why rather than the wherefore.
I thought it was a good clue based on its construction. I hope that setters have enough to contend with without additional burden of political correctness.
However, in light of the recent announcement by Mattel that a swathe of words have been removed from acceptance in Scrabble, will we see similar censorship here I wonder.
Flushed with recent discovery of &lit I assumed that the o in God qualified as such for 4D, and didn’t notice about. Since none of the speedsters have commented I guess it isn’t.
Wondered if there was a balance of popular UK versus US desserts going on. Never much taken with cobblers, aptly named, as too sugary. COD ANAGRAM probably an old chestnut but a first for me.
Thanks Jeremy and Jalna.
Wondering if the plumber will turn up today. One of life’s mysteries.
Finished in 10.07.
Thanks to Jeremy
… with only 3 clues filled in on the first pass, but more eventually came and in the end — and somewhat to my surprise — all done in 13 minutes.
Had to think hard to see counter = stall in 10A Install, and like Mendesest it was the second meaning of 5D Cobblers that I did not know.
That school keeps appearing, doesn’t it, even when not clued as a school.
Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog
Cedric
Pb
Seeing the grid sent me straight to 1D which gave me a good foundation for working outwards. Liked ANAGRAM and MEASURED amongst others. Counter = stall made me hesitate but it was obviously what was required. PROVISO wasn’t promising looking anagram fodder but the lone v meant it had to be, then it clicked.
Really enjoyable so thanks setter, and for Jeremy’s meticulous blog.
Like others, I thought this was quite slow going but ended up in just under 20 so good time for me. I struggled a bit in the SE corner with “lope” where I kept trying to fit in “Lam” somehow, and my LOI “exposed”. Also DNK the sweet meaning of cobblers. I did think of Merlin when that school came up, even though it wasn’t clued as such.
Thanks, Jeremy, for helpful blog.
Of course, as usual, once I’d seen the answers worked out for me it made sense, but by then it’s too late to really enjoy it.
I didn’t even get ANAGRAM.
Thanks all the same to Jalna and Jeremy and here’s hoping that tomorrow brings a better day.
Diana
Took a little time to see APOLLO but otherwise straightforward.
Thank you, plusjeremy and Jalna
Last two were LOPE and APOLLO.
C’sOD were ISLAM, OLD TESTAMENT (a capital effort of balance by the setter, slightly disparaging surfaces covering all the abrahamic religions!), and MORSE CODE. ETON MESS is probably my favourite pudding, so a big thumbs up from me.
4:51.
FOI: 8a. PROVISO
LOI: 4d. APOLLO
Time to Complete: DNF
Clues Answered Correctly without aids: 19
Clues Answered with Aids (3 lives): 10a, 12a, 17d
Clues Unanswered: 22a, 19d
Wrong Answers: Nil
Total Correctly Answered (incl. aids): 22/24
Aids Used: Chambers,
Two left unfinished for a tricky but enjoyable DNF.
7a. REEVE – Never heard of him, but the clue seemed to indicate a REEVE, so in it went.
22a. EXPOSED. I got the English Diamonds (ED) but the rest of it eluded me.
19d. LOPE. At first, I saw the word LAWN (The Police = Law, Northbound = N). I did wonder if that could be a cryptic word for run, but it did not sit right with me. Unfortunately, I did not equate northbound as being a reversal in a down clue. I should have seen that.
17d. ELANDS. Another one that had me completely baffled.
I am pleased with my efforts, so not too disappointed in a DNF. On average I seem to complete 1 in 5 crosswords.
I needed time for APOLLO and EXPOSED (COD to that).
I also liked PRAWN.
No big hold-ups. I had to work out FRUIT MACHINE from the anagrist.
A fair puzzle; some testing clues.
David
FOI 11A Bread
LOI 3D Mega
COD 20A and 23A Really enjoyed both Anagram and Prawn!
Thanks Jalna and Jeremy for a fun morning
Does anyone know what “American” is doing in the clue? (5a), I don’t associate cobblers with America. My grandmother in law used to make cobblers, and I am sure she never went to America.
Andyf
Edited at 2021-04-14 10:25 am (UTC)
Andyf
Felt like there were lots of clues with single letter representations eg. diamond = d, day = d which felt very 15×15.
Wasn’t sure about 16ac “Oversight” — is it “over” = “on”, or does the whole homophone apply to the site being over and thus down? Presume it’s the former as the latter felt clunky.
All of this aside, I did enjoy it and after dismissing various Nintendo’s and Playstations managed to get 1dn “Fruit Machine” fairly quickly.
FOI — 1dn “Fruit Machine”
LOI — 5dn “Cobblers”
COD — 2dn “Measured”
Thanks as usual!
I too tried to put in Rot for too long for my LOI Cobblers. My daughter got the answer — she knew the fruit pie but not the rubbish and I knew the rubbish but not the fruit pie.
Enjoyable but difficult in places.
The hidden in 15a was clever as I fell for the other letter as did Kevin and no doubt others.
Likewise last but one Lope difficult to see.
COD 23a — I really thought that was simple and clever.
Thanks all
John George
Some fine clues in there, tip of the hat in particular to PRAWN, ISLAM and MEASURED.
FOI FRUIT MACHINE, LOI COBBLERS, COD ANAGRAM (very, very neat), time 10:12 for 2.1K and a Decent Day.
Many thanks Jalna and Jeremy.
Templar
Liked the anagram of FRUIT MACHINES and some other nice surfaces.
Thanks Jeremy for the excellent blog as always and Jalna
FOI – 7ac REEVE
LOI – 6dn, the incorrect PINE, entered with a shrug
COD – 23ac PRAWN
One and a half courses
FOI Reeve
LOI Cobblers
COD Cobblers 😂
Many thanks Jalna and Jeremy
FOI: PROVISO
LOI: LOPE
COD: ANAGRAM
Thanks to Jalna and Jeremy.