Introduction
6:33. Found this very straightforward for about 93%, but the other 7% really made me pause to scratch my head.
Solutions
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation (and capitalization) is otherwise irrelevant.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
After the solutions, I list all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in a Glossary.
Across
1 | Pick up / awful cheat, [causing] grief (9) |
HEARTACHE – HEAR + anagram of CHEAT | |
6 | Staff reminder, no parking at the front (3) |
ROD – PROD without P | |
8 | Vagrant recalled / heading for Portobello / market (5) |
TRAMP – reversal of P + MART | |
9 | Looks / round / centre of Florence, not a pretty sight (7) |
EYESORE – EYES + O + middle letters of FLORENCE | |
10 | Money for extra work done ahead of season (8) |
OVERTIME – OVER + TIME | |
11 | Lake inside game reserve (4) |
MERE – hidden in GAME RESERVE | |
13 | Bid by Conservative [for] collection (9) |
OFFERTORY – OFFER + TORY | |
16 | Stake required, unlimited (4) |
ANTE – WANTED without first and last letters | |
17 | Sheath [found in] taxi caught by southern poet (8) |
SCABBARD – CAB in S + BARD | |
20 | Seaman, on his tod, [finds] shellfish (7) |
ABALONE – A.B. ALONE | |
21 | Head leaving specimen, more than enough (5) |
AMPLE – SAMPLE without first letter | |
22 | Last letters of Guy de Maupassant, until now! (3) |
YET – last letters of GUY DE MAUPASSANT | |
23 | Sit with Santa’s new helper (9) |
ASSISTANT – SIT + SANTA’S anagrammed |
Down
1 | Heated / chow, perhaps? (3,3) |
HOT DOG – HOT + DOG Here the entire clue is the definition and the wordplay as well. |
|
2 | Stagger [out of] a labyrinth (5) |
AMAZE – A + MAZE | |
3 | Court official, man after gratuity (8) |
TIPSTAFF – STAFF after TIP | |
4 | Pick nuts [and] biscuits (5,8) |
CREAM CRACKERS – CREAM + CRACKERS ‘Pick’ = CREAM as in “the choicest part”, and ‘nuts’ = CRACKERS as in crazy. |
|
5 | Fair / flat (4) |
EVEN – double definition | |
6 | Group of nesting birds [in] castle on European lines (7) |
ROOKERY – ROOK + E + RY | |
7 | German chap, / one eating less? (6) |
DIETER – double definition Dieter is a German name. |
|
12 | VIPs [with] supporters in T-shirts? (3,5) |
TOP BRASS – BRAS in TOPS This took me a terrifyingly long time to get. |
|
13 | Persona non grata forbidden to go on pitch (7) |
OUTCAST – OUT + CAST | |
14 | Illness [of] mother, noblewoman (6) |
MALADY – MA + LADY | |
15 | Notice express coming (6) |
ADVENT – AD + VENT As in ‘vent one’s feelings’. |
|
18 | Top grade hotel in mountain area (5) |
ALPHA – H in ALP + A | |
19 | Part of conservation area, an early centre of Christianity (4) |
IONA – hidden in CONSERVATION AREA Read about the Christian part here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iona |
Glossary
Wordplay indicators
after = next to
ahead of = next to
and = linking word
awful = anagram
by = next to
caught by = containment
causing = linking word
centre of = middle letter(s)
finds = linking word
for = linking word
found in = linking words
(to) go on = next to
head = first letter
heading for = first letter
in = containment, linking word
inside = hidden word
last letters of = last letters
leaving = removal
new = anagram
no … at the front = remove first letter
of = linking word
on = next to
out of = linking word
part of = hidden word
recalled = reversal
unlimited = without first and last letters (“limits”)
with = linking word, next to
Abbreviations and little bits
area = A
conservative = TORY
European = E
hotel = H
mother = MA
notice = AD
parking = P
poet = BARD
round = O
seaman = AB (also: OS, JACK, RATING, TAR)
southern = S
supporter = BRA (also: TEE)
taxi = CAB
Edited at 2021-02-03 02:57 am (UTC)
WB
WB
It’s also the second time within a few days I have seen the DIETER / DIET-ER thing and the same goes for TIPSTAFF although these examples may have been in the main puzzle or a Jumbo or even The Guardian which I do every day now. It all goes to show there’s nothing like practice and experience for honing one’s solving skills as there comes a time when you have seen so many things before. Those answers then go in easily and provide checkers on which to build and help with working out the other clues.
Thanks to Jeremy
LOI 1D: HOT DOG
Thank you, plusjeremy and Tracy
Thanks Jeremy for the elegant descriptors and Tracy for a QC that fitted the bill for me, allowing me to get to work on time with a clear head.
6a=REP seems like a fair reading, with PREP=reminder, and REP=staff. Was then tempted by PIETER which is more Dutch than German, before DIETER forced a backtrack.
11a the misdirection of an L=Lake inside a word for game required a mercifully short alphabet trawl of -EE games. After ZELE, time for another backtrack.
16a (ANTE) is the kind of clue that once biffed I have no desire to try and find a word of unknown length to complete the cryptic definition.
COD: Joint Winners: CREAM CRACKERS and TOP BRASS
Stick with it!
Liked ROOKERY (clever parsing), CREAM CRACKERS. OFFERTORY amusing.
Knew ANTE but couldn’t parse. Guessed TIPSTAFF which must have been lurking in the depths somewhere.
I hope the helpful glossary is being stored somewhere. Thanks, Jeremy, for your extended blog.
I should have read through all the clues as YET being obvious made that corner much easier.
Edited at 2021-02-03 11:05 am (UTC)
Edited at 2021-02-03 11:31 am (UTC)
Especially liked CREAM CRACKERS and SCABBARD.
Thanks to the anonymous poster who identified the cockney origins of “on your tod” but who is Tod Sloan?
Thanks, Jeremy, and thanks too to Tracy
I loved your ‘Exasperometer’ the other week. May I ask how you would rate a puzzle that you are able to race through or work through steadily without too much difficulty, but one clue of which requires an inordinate amount of time to solve, or which you simply get wrong (even when you think you’re right)?
I find this possibly the most exasperating experience of all and, unfortunately, it’s a more-or-less weekly experience for me (as it was again, today).
I think I’d count a puzzle which was not too bad bar one clue as eg a 3+4, maybe ? Or a 2 + 5? Or whatever best fits?
The Exasperometer has really helped me to classify whether I’m making hopeless weather of a crossword or if I’m justified in bring grumpy.
COD to CREAM CRACKERS. About 15 minutes.
David
PS I’m also getting weird messages from Livejournal.
Not much to say, LOI was OUTCAST. I Liked TRAMP and OFFERTORY. TIPSTAFF was definitely in another puzzle within the last week.
5:47
Edited at 2021-02-03 10:23 am (UTC)
Overall a puzzle with enough striaghtforward answers to boost the morale, interspersed with some challenges.
Once again caught out by CRS ‘on his tod’, so athough had the answer, was unsure how/why.
Got 12D as BOY BANDS which fit, but despite my hope that the t-shirts referred to boy band fans, was clearly wrong.
A bit like the jaffa cake is-it-a-cake-or-a-biscuit divide, I don’t consider a CREAM CRACKER a biscuit!
Thank you to Jeffrey for the detailed explanations — have now added ‘unlimited’ to my list of indicators.
Edited at 2021-02-03 12:25 pm (UTC)
By extension, perhaps the American cookie originates from Cook once_ie
This puzzle took me 10 minutes and a handful of seconds, one of the quickest QCs for me for a goodly while. All good stuff, and very enjoyable. Thanks Setter and Blogger.
Edited at 2021-02-03 10:39 am (UTC)
I started off well, answering about ten clues fairly quickly, which gave me a false sense of hope. But yet again I answer a few then just get completely stuck. Quite often I simply have no idea what the clue is saying, no idea on even how to start thinking about working out the answer.
Perhaps I should look for cryptic crosswords aimed at children.
Oh well, pity party over. Let’s hope that tomorrow will bring some success. These QCs are not going to defeat me. They just keep giving me a black eye.
I enjoy your posts and your honesty but as others have said, nothing comes easily that is worth doing.
It’s all exercise for the mind. Enjoy the clues you solve and build your repertoire . There is repetition, old chestnuts and some days are trickier than others.
Do keep going if it’s something you would like to master ( not that some of us really feel we have ever completely mastered it…)
Keep going, keep posting and best wishes
I have private messages switched off in my settings here, so any message that you may have been able to send would not have reached me.
That was a kind offer though, thank you. I have my aids and this blog, so I’ll be okay.
Edited at 2021-02-03 11:26 am (UTC)
Overall — completed in 17 mins. Main trouble was 12dn “Top Brass” — once again the “bra” for supporter nearly defeated me — and 18dn “Alpha” which I knew had something to do with the Alps, but just couldn’t see the word.
FOI — 1dn “Hot Dog”
LOI — 16ac “Ante”
COD — 4dn “Cream Crackers”
Thanks as usual.
Having said that, the puzzle was not without its talking points. Unusually, there were two beheaded words (first letter taken off) at 6A Rod and 21A Ample, and the top-and-tailed at 16A: clearly a device Tracy likes. And 3D Tipstaff was not a word I knew — though generously clued and quite guessable.
It also took me a time to see season = time in 10A Overtime, and as someone who generally struggles with random names of people even when they are English, I groan at the thought of now needing to know a list of German first names as well!
Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog
Cedric
Edited to correct spelling of Tracy — with apologies to our esteemed setter of the day
Edited at 2021-02-03 05:56 pm (UTC)
Held up trying to put an l into MERE and not being able to parse ANTE (thank you Jeremy)
Otherwise knew the vocab though in one case (ABALONE) purely down to doing these things. Never heard of it/them outside crosswordland
Thanks Jeremy and Tracy
I don’t mind being beaten fair and square (missing out by 3, 4 or more clues) but, for some reason, I find failing by a single clue much harder to take. Fortunately, Mrs R knows to play it softly with me for an hour or so now, especially as I’m also recovering from having my ears syringed first thing this morning.
Not happy, but thanks to plusjeremy and Teazel.
FOI 2D Amaze
LOI 21A Ample, which took forever to come out.
COD 4D Cream crackers, such a simple clue that I so often misunderstand. Lovely to get this one!
Thanks Tracy and Jeremy
R
DNK Tipstaff but biffed it
LOI Assistant
DNF Due to rookery and Iona both of which I should have got
Thanks for the glossary which I’ve added to my collection that various bloggers have kindly shared. Enjoying the challenge and understanding the parsing and wordplay more every day.
Thanks Tracy and Jeremy
FOI: rod
LOI: ante
COD: offertory
Thanks to Jeremy for the excellent blog
Reasonably straightforward for me today although was held up by the end by the hidden 11a and 16a, which I thought must be ante but could not parse. Thanks to Jeremy for the explanation. I also DNK tipstaff so googled to double check.
A question. I normally print out the crossword as find it easier to dip in and out & do anagrams on paper but tried to do it on my phone yesterday. I think I got submit by mistake as I was scrolling down, and then couldn’t go back despite only having done 1 clue. Is there a way to cancel your submission on the crossword club site? Thanks
This appeared tricky but was a steady solve just hanging in on the way.
Offertory was great to spot — not overly familiar with that — rare church attendances..
Abalone and Tipstaff just heard of enough to add in confidence and LOI Advent had me looking at Advert but saw the answer in time.
A few well known only from previous experiences — crackers, dieter, mere, etc.
Thanks all
John George
FOI Hot dog
LOI Outcast
COD Amaze — simple but effective, lovely surface
Time just under 7 minutes
Many thanks Tracy for the ego boost, and Jeremy for the blog
FOI TRAMP
LOI OUTCAST
COD ROD (I thought this was top drawer !)
TIME 3:50
Not usually on Tracy’s wavelength, so doubly good
Edited at 2021-02-03 04:33 pm (UTC)
Seemed to be on the right wavelength today but biffed outcast but unable to parse the pitch bit
pitch = throw = cast
As in pitch a ball, cast a net. But could be mistaken.
All you do is to slice the peach thinly and add it to the pan just before serving
I had one error with 1d Hot Dog – in my vocabulary, and Chambers Dictionary, chow=food so although it was supposed to lead us to =dog, I’m not sure I really need to accept that as the only correct answer and would be inclined to quibble that hot pot could be an acceptable alternative… I know this is a late post but any views on this?
FOI 8a. LOI 9a Eyesore. COD 4d Cream Crackers – a phrase I’ve not heard for a while (they probably wait until I’m out of earshot!).
Thx to Tracy for another easier solve after the recent run!
Oh – also getting the red ‘…you have been banned…’ error message on logging in. Possibly someone wants us to create new ID’s so they can pick these up…?
A relative easy offering today it seems. About 18mins or so, less than the episode of Schitt’s Creek which I was watching whilst solving. I don’t frequently comment on the blog but I am an avid reader of it. Today is special though. It is a year since I started on the QC and that first months were a series of DNFs. I wouldn’t have been able to reach the point of being able to amble through the crossword, whilst watching a distracting comedy series, if it wasn’t for the help of this blog. So my huge thanks to all the bloggers (and of course the setters) who have supported my adventure into the world of cryptic crosswords. FOI: 6a Rod LOI: 1d HOT DOG COD: 16a ANTE
NHO TIPSTAFF, or “Chow” for that matter which left me stuck on HOT DOG. Took me far too long to get CREAM CRACKERS too for some reason.
The rest of it was good fun though. Loved DIETER and OFFERTORY. I finished the Private Eye crossword once it had dropped through the door too so hopefully I’m not completely losing the plot. Fingers crossed I’m more in sync with the QC setter tomorrow.
Thanks Tracy and Jeremy.