I last blogged a QC by Wurm in October, and it generated lots of interesting discussion. I really enjoyed this one too. Like last time, I found it a little wiggly in places, but with some neat and entertaining clueing. A couple of clues, I thought, would not be out of place in the 15×15, so I think those who were looking for an easier one today may be disappointed. Bits I liked, in particular, were the gangster at 1A, the sneaky definition at 20A, the misleading bar paraphernalia at 2D and the filthy book collection at 12D. At just under 6 minutes I was over my average time and it was my slowest of the week, so I, at least, found it a bit trickier than usual. No real hold-ups for me but those slithery wiggles mite cast some muddy hillocks on your path and cause your solving to slow to a crawl and dragon a bit. [That’s enough – Ed]. Thank-you Wurm. Top hole! [I said that’s enough – Ed]. How did you all get on?
Definitions underlined in bold italics, (Abc)* indicating anagram of Abc, deletions and [] other indicators.
Across | |
1 | One Mr Bad also awaiting trial (2,6) |
ON REMAND – (One Mr)* [bad] AND (also). Lovely one to start – nice surface and neat wordplay. | |
6 | Youngster brought to a Caribbean island (4) |
CUBA – CUB (youngster) then [brought to] A. A bit of a ‘chestnut’ (a term to add to the Glossary, perhaps?). This has appeared at least 5 times before in a QC, most recently in this Izetti puzzle in September last year. | |
8 | Go away for trial (3,3) |
TRY OUT – TRY (go) OUT (away). A fine lesson in the technique of “lift and separate“, where you need to split the “go” and “away”. And we get to practice that some more a couple of times later. | |
9 | Grand pubs prepared to welcome monarch (6) |
SUPERB – (pubs)* [prepared] outside [to welcome] ER (Her Majesty; monarch). | |
10 | House Chinese military guards (4) |
SEMI – Hidden in ChineSE MIlitary [guards]. Do important people in China live in semi-detached houses? | |
11 | Party favourite in power (8) |
DOMINION – DO (party) MINION (favourite). My LOI. I hadn’t seen that definition for “minion” before, but I see from checking the dictionary I’m just ignorant. Not for the first time, I may add! | |
12 | Son in tree produces sacred poem (5) |
PSALM – S (son) [in] PALM (tree). | |
13 | Divine messenger in a new set (5) |
ANGEL – A N (new) GEL (set). One of those sneaky setter’s tricks is to use a noun in the clue that you have to treat as a verb in the wordplay. In action here for ‘set’. | |
15 | Generous support for footballer (4,4) |
FULL BACK – FULL (generous) BACK (support). Full as in a generous helping/full helping. | |
17 | Arrest the devil (4) |
NICK – Double definition. A missed opportunity for a triple definition, perhaps? “Arrest and jail the devil”? I’ll get my coat. | |
19 | Oracle’s place, quiet in Asian metropolis (6) |
DELPHI – P (piano; quitet) [in] DELHI (Asian metropolis). The Oracle aka Pythia. | |
20 | Owner of bark in films sails out east (6) |
LASSIE – Ha ha. Great disguised definition – which has nothing to do with saling vessels. (sails)* [out] E (east). The famous canine star.![]() Image in Public Domain. |
|
21 | Surprise as lunatics returning (4) |
STUN – NUTS (lunatics) reversed [returning] -> STUN. | |
22 | Ask again for change in Japanese city (8) |
NAGASAKI – (Ask again)* [for change]. |
Down | |
2 | Bottle perhaps attached to optic? (5) |
NERVE – This is another sneaky one. Ignore the fine surface reading, where an optic is “a device fastened to the neck of an inverted bottle for measuring out spirits“. This is a double definition with “optic” in the second meaning, the eye, to which the “optic nerve” is attached, the perhaps indicating a definition by example. Or have I over-complicated that? | |
3 | Blue material ripped up at ICA (7) |
EROTICA – TORE (ripped) reversed [up, in a down clue] -> EROT. Add ICA to get what used to be on the top shelf. | |
4 | Six-footer among banyan trees (3) |
ANT – Hidden [among] banyAN Trees. In case you haven’t seen it before, “six-footer” refers to an animal with 6 feet – i.e. an insect. | |
5 | Bird makes moves to leave boat (9) |
DISEMBARK – (Bird makes)* [moves]. You could easily be misled (as I was briefly) to think the definition here was “Bird”. But it isn’t. Another bit of slitheriness from our Wurm – you need to separate “Makes moves”. | |
6 | Chicken in vessel crossing river (5) |
CAPON – CAN (vessel) outside [crossing] PO (river in Italy). Another bird as the answer. | |
7 | Bird in pub now large (4,3) |
BARN OWL – This time “Bird” is the definition. BAR (pub) NOW L (large). As with 1A this is another example of a setter’s trick. When the answer is in multiple parts, e.g. (4,3) as here, the wordplay doesn’t have to follow that enumeration – here the parts of the charade are (3,3,1). | |
11 | Eternal punishment in Mother land? (9) |
DAMNATION – DAM (Mother) NATION (land). | |
12 | Discreet page fronts filthy book collection (7) |
PRUDENT – P (page) [fronts] i.e. is before RUDE (filthy) NT (New Testament; book collection). | |
14 | Start rock band (7) |
GENESIS – Double definition. Rock is not my cup of tea. But, distractedly diving down a wurmhole, I was amazed to find there is a fictional Genesis Worm. I don’t remember that episode. Do you? | |
16 | Learner at university in bloomer (5) |
LUPIN – L (learner) UP (at university) IN. Here are some blooming…![]() |
|
18 | Conservative connection in prison (5) |
CLINK – C (Conservative) LINK (connection). I wonder if our setter was tempted to cross-reference 17A? But no. This isn’t the Guardian crossword. | |
20 | On length for example (3) |
LEG – L (length) EG (for example). Our cricketing clue of the day. Another sneaky trick – another “lift and separate”. You need to separate the phrase “On length” into its constituent parts. |
I agree with your parsing of NERVE, John, and minion as favourite was new for me as well. An etymology website helpfully pointed out it comes from the French ‘mignon’ meaning darling or favourite which may explain filet mignon being considered a choice cut.
FOI Superb
LOI Try out (I’m forever forgetting try is a synonym of go)
COD Nagasaki for its very plausible surface
Many thanks to Wurm for a difficult but satisfying puzzle and John for his excellent blog and terrible jokes.
I have had some absolutely dreadful times with the run of difficult puzzles this week, coming in at nearly 20 minutes more than once. I can’t really explain why I could solve this one so quickly, but the lack of long anagrams, and long answers in general, certainly helped. If it wasn’t a chestnut, I grabbed either the cryptic or the literal and made short work of it.
Like our blogger I thought twice about ‘favourite / minion’ but what else could it have been?
LASSIE, rather surprisingly, was my LOI as, on seeing’owner of bark’ in the clue I started thinking about trees beginning with L!
Seeing Wurm’s name when I started put my brain into Wurm mode. I know he’s a tricky setter but every clue I read at the start I solved almost immediately with parsing. I thought I’d be easily under 10 minutes.
Hold-ups were DOMINION which I left until BARN OWL appeared. When rushing I had tried to type in BROWN OWL which caused a correction delay. SUPERB required time for parsing and LOI was SEMI where I was racking my brains for something Chinese-ish -JEDI was waiting as an impatient final entry.Happily I paused once again to parse and SEMI emerged; this word has caught me out before. 13:00 on the clock.
Excellent puzzle and lots of good clues. COD to DISEMBARK.
David
FOI ON REMAND, LOI CAPON (I kept trying to make “crock” work – cock crossing r = vessel – but inconsiderately the words were all in the wrong order in the clue) and COD NERVE. Did anyone else think that 3dn was a really clunky clue? What on earth is ICA anyway?
Thanks Wurm (no really) and John.
Templar
The lack of long anagrams helped, but I was definitely on the right wavelength and everything just clicked (for once).
Thanks to Wurm and to John for the blog.
Brian
Edited at 2020-01-17 09:49 am (UTC)
Thank you Wurm!
PlayUpPompey
As noted above, some great surfaces for the clues with criminality and filth seeming to pop up everywhere.
Whilst some of these were well thought out, they were also quite easy to biff. As a result, the main hold ups for me were 11ac “Dominion” and 18ac “Delphi”. Didn’t realise “Minion” meant favourite which made me doubt my original answer. I also wasn’t sure about Prudent=Discreet, and as it started with a “P” was almost tempted to put in something relating to the top shelf.
At least I spotted the “Up” for University today.
FOI – 1ac “On Remand”
LOI – 11ac “Dominion”
COD – 12dn “Prudent” – great surface that made me laugh
Thanks as usual.
Edited at 2020-01-17 12:52 pm (UTC)
Thanks to Wurm and John.
Edited at 2020-01-17 01:09 pm (UTC)
Nice puzzle from Wurm which kept me engaged over my pre-work pint of Pedigree. Solved just inside my target time – I’d have been quicker if I hadn’t tried to start 5D with “duck”.
FOI ON REMAND
LOI DOMINION
COD LASSIE
But thanks anyway, Wurm, John and the rest of you – maybe one day I’ll get there.
Diana.
I’ll never make the main cryptic (and don’t really want to , to be honest) but thoroughly enjoy the QC nearly every day.
Old age takes its toll.
Diana
Bluestocking
Phil. As u solve in sub 4 minutes how do u manage a pint at the same time? Do u hold the paper above your head as u swallow? Or are u also a sub 5 second pint man?
Johnny
Thanks to John for the blog
Lots of really entertaining surfaces – like Louisa, I had smiley faces all over! Nick, Lassie and Nerve were particular favourites.
Started to post this at 11am – been out all day, so a bit late now. Anyway –
FOI On remand
LOI Barn owl
COD Ant
Mood 😊
Edited at 2020-01-17 07:25 pm (UTC)
Cod prudent.