My clue of the day was 9ac. I laughed when I finally saw it. Thanks to the setter for a very enjoyable puzzle.
Clues are in blue, with definitions underlined. Answers are in BOLD CAPS, then wordplay. (ABC*) means ‘anagram of ABC’, with the anagram indicator in bold italics. Deletions are in [square brackets].
Across
1 Be unable to find Scottish island on map at first (6)
MISLAY: M[ap], ISLAY. True – I couldn’t find it on a map either. Not my part of the world!
4 Dependable and firm, the moment I left (8)
CONSTANT: CO (firm), [i]NSTANT (moment, “I” leaving).
9 Chess shows one it can be a game for four (7)
DOUBLES: since the spelling of “chess” ends with a DOUBLE-S! I guessed the answer well before I saw the wordplay.
11 Beg one extra place to be reserved (7)
IMPLORE: I (one), MORE (extra), “reserving” PL (place).
12 Shock from head of church shifting a little power to the right (5)
APPAL: PAPAL, with the first P (power) moved a little to the right. On edit: “papal” as in “a papal bull” would be “a bull from the head of the church”.
13 Egyptian leader’s staff in an inn shortly needing parking (9)
AMENHOTEP: well, I’m glad the wordplay was specific about the spelling! It’s A HOTE[l] (an inn, shortly), around MEN (staff), and then the finishing touch is a P (parking).
14 Notice second decoration a few have received and worn (10)
THREADBARE: AD (notice) and BAR (second decoration, as in “DSO and bar”, meaning winning the DSO twice), all inside THREE (a few).
16 Centre for heretics has heart knocked out of legal defence (4)
ALBI: AL[i]BI.
19 Grain cost reduced by a penny (4)
RICE: [p]RICE.
20 Does he give relatively painful advice? (5,5)
AGONY UNCLE: cryptic definition. Agony aunts are much more common, I suspect.
22 Furiously thump boxing youngster, the latest of many (9)
UMPTEENTH: the youngster is a TEEN, in an anagram (“furiously”) of THUMP.
23 Elevated construction beginning to bend in wind (5)
GABLE: B[end] in GALE.
25 One liked no end to take passage in ship (7)
FRIGATE: FRI[end] (“no END”), plus GATE.
26 Lost balance, carrying child — safer with this on? (4,3)
SKID LID: KID in SLID.
27 Offer to contribute to very modest gaudy (8)
TINSELLY: SELL (offer) “contributing to” TINY (very modest).
28 Regularly take in Hesiod poem (6)
AENEID: alternate letters. And very happy I was to be told how to spell it!
Down
1 Cryptic threat for member of the Tea Party (3,6)
MAD HATTER: since HATTER is an anagram (“mad”) of THREAT, the answer is a cryptic clue for threat.
2 Look defeated, seeing bad house prices? Only at first (5)
SLUMP: a SLUM might be a bad house (or houses). Append P[rices], “only at first”.
3 Wartime signal that would not be misunderstood? (3,5)
ALL CLEAR: double definition.
5 Peaceful offers: “Please take up residence on British farms” (5,8)
OLIVE BRANCHES: O LIVE all to be put on top of B[ritish] RANCHES.
6 Poet’s program hard to break into in this way (6)
SAPPHO: APP (program) and H (hard) in SO (in this way). I didn’t realise she was a poet.
7 Pauline for one has no way to stop a detailed government plan (9)
APOSTOLIC: O (no) and ST (way) inside (“stopping”) POLIC[y]. Since Paul was an apostle, of course.
8 Ass: it was almost quiet (5)
TWERP: T’WER[e] followed by P (quiet).
10 Babe she gently rocked, keeping up appearances (6-7)
SHABBY-GENTEEL: anagram (“rocked”) of BABE SHE GENTLY.
15 Quality of signal in first class (9)
RECEPTION: double definition. The second definition was a complete puzzle until I guessed it might be something to do with the British school system. I gather that four or five year olds start school in reception.
17 In ecstasy, composer died — really! (1,5,3)
I NEVER DID: IN plus E (ecstasy) plus VERDI (composer) plus D (died).
18 Complex situation in meeting as papers circulated (8)
QUAGMIRE: QUIRE (papers) “circulating” around AGM (meeting). My last one in.
21 Conflict divides work team in cave (6)
BEWARE: WAR “divides” BEE. “Cave” is Latin for “watch out”.
22 Force adopted by military group is not appropriate (5)
UNFIT: F in UNIT.
24 Normal sort of curve on European beauty (5)
BELLE: BELL curves figure in statistics, describing the normal distribution. Add E for European.
DNK ALBI, but the parsing was clear. Wasn’t enthused by the clue for FRIGATE.
COD THREADBARE
On 13ac, we’re used to ‘man/staff’ as verbs but I don’t recall seeing ‘men/staff’ as nouns before and am not entirely sure that it works. Anyway I didn’t think of it.
Sorry everybody. Good puzzle. Thank you B and Setter.
ALBI was the centre of the Cathar insurrection to which the Pope took exception and he had them persecuted and slaughtered. It is a pleasant small city on the Tarn, allegedly the warmest in France.
I got most of the NW and SE in my first session. Then Olive Branches opened things up in the NE. I managed to construct the unlikely looking AMENHOTEP.
A first try of Shabby Elegent ( I know how it should be spelt) was corrected by my Agony Uncle but I failed to find TINSELLY; and ALBI I had as Alii.
Some good stuff in here but I am still tender about Tinselly.
I had not realised quite what was happening at Bolton. I only realised the stadium had been renamed watching Championship highlights last Saturday. Leeds will be a big test today.
David
Started off with hair of the dog at 1a; Islay is one of my favourite places. Next time you get to a decent bar, perhaps try a Bunnahabhain, Bruichladdich, Caol Ila, Laphroig, Kilchoman, Bowmore, Ardbeg or Lagavulin—all from this small isle (let’s hope some of those don’t come up in the 15×15 in the future; I still have to look up the spelling of one of them even though I’ve been to all the distilleries multiple times!)
Finished off with 7d APOSTOLIC, religion not being my strong point, though at least I recognised AMENHOTEP from somewhere (probably Stargate: SG-1!)
This was a different story from today’s, which I struggled with terribly, then managed to leave one letter out when transcribing and submitting! D’oh.