I found this a strange puzzle for a Friday, three of the first four clues going straight in Quick Cryptic style, quite a few chestnuts e.g. 4ac, 14dn. However it soon became clear that maximum speed would not be possible with biff-traps like 13ac (I almost put RANG) and 6dn (AGITATE) to contend with, and 20ac where I started with SCAN. And I still don’t understand 9ac but maybe I just haven’t had time to understand anything properly yet. I did like the more humorous clues at 27ac and at 17dn, that latter of which is definitely my Clue of the Day, thanks setter. Anyway, must rush. Sorry sorry sorry! I will pop by for my deserved excoriation in due course…
ACROSS
1 Adapted to established woodland (6)
FOREST – FOR EST [adapted to | established]
4 Dirt about celebrity — some hot stuff (7)
MUSTARD – MUD [dirt] about STAR [celebrity]
9 What might have exuded from trees in former times (5)
LATEX – LATE X [former | times]
10 Retinue has to remain outside, holding back (9)
RESTRAINT – TRAIN [retinue] has REST [to remain] outside
11 Nothing happening with girl chasing lone man at an event (9)
STAGNANCY – NANCY [girl] chasing STAG [lone man at an event]
12 Anger with rogue husband (5)
WRATH – W RAT H [with | rogue | husband]
13 Called to work before golf (4)
RUNG – RUN [to work] before G [golf]
14 Deign to climb down after deception (10)
CONDESCEND – DESCEND [climb down] after CON [deception]
18 Sight of London and power attracting ancient ruler? (6,4)
PEARLY KING – P [power] attracting EARLY KING [ancient ruler]
20 See second container? (4)
SPOT – S POT [second | container]
23 What bereaved do with second container for ashes (5)
MOURN – MO URN [second | container for ashes]
24 Be very dear and try entering downland valley (4,1,4)
COST A BOMB – STAB [try] entering COOMB [downland valley]
25 Aromatic fragrance knocked caliph out (9)
PATCHOULI – (CALIPH OUT*) [“knocked”]
26 What’s poetic greeting heard the country over? (5)
HAIKU – homophone of HI [greeting “heard”] + UK reversed [the country “over”]
27 Approve last one in ‘unt? (7)
ENDORSE – the “last one in ‘unt” is presumbably the END ‘ORSE
28 Go to put on weight, giving up following diet initially (6)
ATTEND – {f}ATTEN [put on weight, “giving up F for following”] + D{iet}
DOWN
1 Series of projections covering sierra journey (9)
FILMSTRIP – FILM S TRIP [covering | sierra | journey]
2 Coach again is wet with downpour, perhaps (7)
RETRAIN – RET [wet] with RAIN [downpour, perhaps]
3 Vote on being in state and part of Germany (6)
SAXONY – X ON [vote | on] being in SAY [state]
4 Your setter — oddly sassy and difficult to deal with (5)
MESSY – ME [your setter] + S{a}S{s}Y
5 Run into woman with desire to be ill-natured (8)
SHREWISH – R [run] into SHE [woman] with WISH [desire]
6 Keep moving stone with internal magnetism (7)
AGITATE – AGATE [stone] with internal IT [magnetism]
7 Days on long canal (5)
DITCH – D [days] on ITCH [long]
8 Get annoyed about working argument over metal craft (8)
IRONWORK – IRK [get annoyed] about ON [working] + ROW reversed [argument “over”]
15 Family crunched its candy (8)
DYNASTIC – (ITS CANDY*) [“crunched”]
16 Tax link limits university with firm obligation (4-5)
DUTY-BOUND – DUTY BOND [tax | link] “limits” U [university]
17 Someone grappling with a 12’6” item? (8)
CLINCHER – a 12’6″ item would be an 150-incher, and should you desire to express that in Roman numerals for some reason, a CL-INCHER
19 Touched on commercial about dairy spread that’s yet to be finished (7)
ABUTTED – AD [commercial] about BUTTE{r} [dairy spread “that’s yet to be finished”]
21 Extent of public notice for data collection (7)
PROFILE – PRO FILE [for | data collection]
22 Posed holding revolutionary bag (6)
SACHET – SAT [posed] holding CHE [revolutionary]
23 Plot with hollow lime tree (5)
MAPLE – MAP [plot] with L{im}E
24 Water slide is very appealing when it’s hot inside (5)
CHUTE – CUTE [very appealing] when it has H [hot] inside
Very easy in parts, very hard in others. I was slow to see the PEARLY KING and spent a long time thinking 1d must be some Germanic geographical term — a feldstrup or something.
COD to LATEX
This morning’s unfortunate coupling is ‘Latex Restraint’.
This was more like it: fun, witty, do-able. Only one easy plant and one random personage.
And we got to do some arithmetic to calculate the inches – fantastic. It is difficult to choose between 12’6” and the End ‘orse for COD. But the use of arithmetic is the clincher.
LOI was Stagnancy where I was trying to use Ann for too long.
Mostly I liked: the aforementioned plus Pearly King and Filmstrip
Thanks super-witty setter and V.
PS One for the mathematicians. Show that (in the land of integers) 26 is the only one with a square immediately before and a cube immediately after.
Edited at 2017-11-24 09:06 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-11-24 10:12 am (UTC)
FOI 3dn SAXONY Dresden area.
LOI 1dn FILMSTRIP and my COD.
WOD 25ac PATCHOULI an Asian extraction of Asian extraction
Lord Verlaine: we used to have to get dressed (in the dark), do our latin homework, bike ourselves to school, gobble down our Readybrek* and do the Times Crossword, all within 15 minutes! Kids today, the Volvoed classes!
On the Verlaine scale my kids would have been at 11 minutes plus – late for school
Pearly King Meldrew
*I wonder what our Mr. Myrtilus had for his ‘brek back in the day?
Edited at 2017-11-24 09:29 am (UTC)
CLINCHER a bit convoluted. For me its normal usage means “decisive argument” or “final piece of evidence”. And why should I suddenly decide to switch into roman numerals having established the 150 inches part?
Edited at 2017-11-24 04:52 pm (UTC)
CLUNCHER the best of a good bunch of clues
Edited at 2017-11-24 10:16 am (UTC)
Got there in about 40mins. Never worked out the CLINCHER clue, but saw it had ‘inch’ in it (well done, me!), and PROFILE was another I was unsure of. Tried to make FILMSTRIP more complicated than it was, and never got past EX for ‘former’ in LATEX. Clever clue.
27a has one of my pet hates – the dropped H device as here in ‘unt. All much too ‘lor blimey guvnor’ Dick Van Dyke cockney for me.
Edited at 2017-11-24 12:00 pm (UTC)
Almost fell for the tense-trap at 13, but managed (geddit?) to reel myself in.
FOI CONDESCEND which was when the iPad decided that every letter I typed was, in fact, the delete button. On closing and reloading there was an expanse of grey and the options box but no grid. Or timer. Or clues for that matter.
LOI PROFILE because, well, yes, because.
particularly enjoyed (in no particular order) the ‘Untsman’s steed, CLINCHER (which I read to be a grappler is someone who has others in a clinch – bit of a stretch but just OK i think) and the aromatherapy substance that immediately brought back memories of dubious rock concerts in the 80s and the associated biker fraternity that would inevitably be present, along with their distinct whiff. Some of which may well not have been from legal substances.
Lots of enjoyable clues here, especially 18a and COD 17d. If all the clues were mathematical I’d probably finish in 2 minutes.
LOI 1a even though FOREST was the first word I thought of, but for some reason I couldn’t parse it.
Thanks for the blog. At the risk of nitpicking, you have an extraneous S at 1d.
Great blog, V, thanks.
Thank you, setter.
Glad I spotted the possibilities in 13a and plumped for the right one, especially as in my adopted city of Bristol, different grammatical rules apply. “Have you ran that script yet?” is a common call in the IT department here, and that’s just the way the word works among native Bristolians, apparently…
(*I console myself with the thought that two is the minimum number needed for a row.)
Edited at 2017-11-24 09:45 pm (UTC)