Is it possible to not be on the proverbial wavelength at all, but still post a decent time? I finished this one slap bang in the middle of the 12-14 minute range I’m usually quite happy with for a difficultish puzzle, and that was including spending a minute at the end staring blankly at 10ac, trying to convince myself it definitely couldn’t be ROB or RUB instead, and how RIB worked. (Still not sure the justification I found is convincing, so do correct me if necessary.) And there were quite a few other clues where I thought I saw roughly how it worked, but still felt slightly uneasy, at least until thinking it all through again after the event. Still, seems to have worked out more or less okay in the end.
I do have to say that I liked the vocabulary in this puzzle: something about it feels properly Timesy – ABSEILER, PRUNELLA, CORELLI, AGGRANDISE, etc – the sort of words that feel like old friends in a puzzle, but would be alarming if they started to crop up regularly in one’s everyday life (unless you’re Timothy West I suppose, in the case of 16dn). And there are certainly some pretty good surfaces and cunning devices in here – I see 1dn got an approving mention in the Club forum, but I think my personal COD might have been 22dn, not at all difficult given a crosser or two, but concise and clever. (See also 7dn and 16dn for further entries in the “concise and clever” parade). Thanks very much setter!
Across |
1 |
GIRAFFE – browser: GAFFE [error] “closes” I R [one | run] |
4 |
FRANCES – girl: R [right] “to replace” IN [home] in FINANCES [money situation] |
9 |
AT A LOOSE END – unemployed: and suggested by “ready to unravel” |
10 |
RIB – part of vault: R.I.B.{a} [architect “hasn’t finished”] |
11 |
SKIMPY – short of substance: SPY [espionage], KIM [novel] “held” |
12 |
ABSEILER – he swings on rope: AB [sailor] + reverse of RELIES [hangs “in turn”] |
14 |
THOUGHT POLICE – stiflers of dissent: THOUGH [still] + (PLOT*) [“shattering”] + ICE [to kill, “American”] |
17 |
REINFORCEMENT – something for concrete: REIN FOR CEMENT [check “| behind | building material] |
21 |
NOCTURNE – genre of music: C [{C}hopin’s “first”] + TURN [go] in (ONE*) [“new”] |
23 |
CLOCHE – hat: HE [man] “used to obscure one side of” CLOC{k} [face] |
25 |
LAM – repeatedly bash: LAM{b} [meat “chopping the end”] |
26 |
HAIR-RAISING – frightful: HAG [witch] “locks away” {m}I{r}R{o}R {m}A{g}I{c} [“regularly going”] + SIN [wrong] |
27 |
AIRDRIE – Scottish town: AIR DRIE{D} [like washing pegged out, “endlessly”] |
28 |
BUGBEAR – source of irritation: BUG BEAR [arrange to eavesdrop on | big beast] |
Down |
1 |
GDANSK – port: G D [“extremely” G{oo}D] + N [any number], ASK [request] “to circulate it” |
2 |
REALIST – who has feet on ground: in REST [repose], ALI [Muslim perhaps] |
3 |
FOOLPROOF – very simple: FOOL [pudding] + PROOF [“what eating it constitutes” – because proverbially the proof of the pudding is in the eating] |
4 |
ERSE – language: {v}ERSE [“very” (i.e. V) “lacking in” poetry] |
5 |
FLEA-BITTEN – trivially wounded: (FINE BATTLE*) [“raging”] |
6 |
ANDRE – Frenchman: emergent from {b}AND RE{placed} |
7 |
CORELLI – composer: CORE [heart] + reverse of ILL [sick “over”] |
8 |
SUBORDER – small group of families: reverse of US [“upset” American] + BORDER [immigration point] |
13 |
AGGRANDISE – exaggerate: (GRADES + GAIN*) [“improperly”] |
15 |
OVERLYING – showing some coincidence, as in spatially coexisting: OVER LYING [finished | telling story] |
16 |
PRUNELLA – worsted: PRUNE [cut] + reverse of ALL [everything “up”] |
18 |
INCOMER – one newly settling: INCOME [money] on R [{daughte}R “at last”] |
19 |
TACTILE – touching: TILE [ceramic], ACT [pretending] “to break it” |
20 |
LEDGER – book: “to held in” L R [both hands], EDGE [an advantage] |
22 |
USHER – escort: “a minimum of three people” being US [two plus persons] + HER [another person] |
24 |
GRUB – double def: beetle potentially / something to eat |
Like keriothe I was hesitant about CLOCHE as I thought ‘side of face’ was giving me the CE and I wondered where the LOCH was coming from. So thanks to verlaine for clearing that up.
Edited at 2015-09-25 09:01 am (UTC)
Edited at 2015-09-26 05:15 am (UTC)
I’d have been a bit quicker but I agonised over 23ac: I just couldn’t see how the wordplay worked for the life of me, and didn’t feel confident enough to biff it. In the end I just gave up and biffed it anyway, at which point I immediately saw what was going on. As if the only thing preventing me from getting it was the effort of trying.
I wondered about 10ac as well, but according to Wiki RIBA is a designation for architects as well as an organisation: a bit like RA. [Edit: great minds think alike I see!]
Edited at 2015-09-25 09:11 am (UTC)
COD … probably SUBORDER for the very neat surface.
Unfortunately, I’ve had to withdraw from the Champs for this year. A case of duty before pleasure. Hope to be back next year, though. Good luck to all heading for Murdoch Towers in October.
Next year.
I liked GDANSK
Not too bad for a Friday
Anyone know if The Times uses any American setters?
horryd Shanghai
Oh to be at Twickers tomorrow belting out the two greatest national anthems on the planet!
Thanks V for explaining CLOCHE, I was also looking for LOCH and CE.
As above, the irony of KIM in SPY at 11a is superb, presumably deliberate.
Edited at 2015-09-25 01:01 pm (UTC)
I find words distracting when I solve though so the solving band of choice are Mogwai – perhaps a happy medium between thrash metal and indie world music?
Worst were 5ac, which I kept wanting to be FIANCEE even though I could see that the answer ought to contain FRANCE (I once went out with a girl called FRANCES as well!), and 8dn (which I wanted to be something to do with EMBARK (to go with FIANCEE) even though it would have had to have been something to do with DISEMBARK to fit “immigration point”.
If I’d been the crossword editor, I’d have changed 10ac to “Part of vault architects haven’t finished (3)”. Apart from that, an interesting and enjoyable puzzle.
Am I being too literal to see an issue with spy for espionage? They don’t mean quite the same thing do they?
Thanks to anyone who happens to be reading this oldish thread & can be bothered to answer!
Alan