I tried hard to find the corner of this crossword where lurked the unknown that might attract complaints, but I really don’t think there is one. Perhaps the “Road to” clue will baffle those who expect to find Hope, Crosby, and Lamour wisecracking their way along it, but the actual literary reference is pretty well known (though I’ll look it up, just in case I make a fool of myself with the attribution). So nothing too tricky, but there are some pretty clues along the way, including a fine (perhaps pre-loved) answer-as-clue device. Here’s my unravelling of the mysteries:
Across
1 BOW-WOW Dog
The one daddy wouldn’t buy me (sensible chap – you’ve already got a cat). BOW polite greeting, WOW a sensation
5 LEAP YEAR
A Christmas crackerish variant on the cryptic definition. Springs are both leaps and seasons, so all years have them, not just those that divide by 4. Tee hee.
9 RED LIGHT
Another, rather laconic CD. A red light suggests stop (so no go), And of course no member of this august community would consider entering that sort of distrtict, so also no go.
10 MENDED cured
People are men (or some of them are). These ones are DEAD without the internal A, deleted by the phrase “not one”.
11 SHRAPNEL(shot in) pieces
I quite like this one, where shot should be seen as doing double duty as both part of the definition and as the anagram indicator. The anagram fodder is HER PLANS
12 MIRRORPaper
Or, of course, something for hanging on the wall, perhaps a rather vague indicator. There are many Mirror newspapers on the planet, not just the one once owned by Robert Maxwell (he who went swimabout from his yacht the Lady Ghislaine with large chunks of the company pension fund missing).
13 LYING LOW hiding
You just need to weld together LYING for dishonest, and LOW for mean
15 FLUE Escape shaft
Well it is for gases or smoke. Sounds like FLEW, got off the ground
17 SOCK Thump
One of the many Batmanesque words for hit, this one having uncertain origins as far back as 1700. Take H(usband) out of ShOCK, alarm.
19 GREENFLY Little pest
While solving, I wondered where the Y came from for “green” renewable energy. Of course, it’s FL(ourihed), or better Fl(oreat), in an anagram of ENERGY.
On edit: my trusted proofreaders and favourite pedants have pointed out that it should be FL(ourished) and floruit. I’ve left the post intact so as to save them from appearing foolish and to acknowledge that the last vestiges of my self esteem have been washed quite away.
20 SHELVE slowly get lower
SH “don’t say it”, ELVE from the plural of elf shorter by its S.
21 CONCLAVE selection meeting
The most well known being the one that ends with a puff of white smoke and the muttering among the crowd “who on earth is that?”. Politician is CON(servative, then L(eft) is found in CAVE, a common enough direct synonym for “chamber”
22 MICKEYMouse
One may, if one dares, take the Mickey, hoping the target will see it’s just a joke.
23 LAID BACKrelaxed
If laid back were a crossword clue, it would indicate DIAL. Pretty little clue.
24 BUTTRESSsupport
Wasn’t this a whimsical female goat a while back? Should have been, perhaps. We had the flying version only 3 weeks back, but this time its BUTT – cask, RE – on and SS – ship
25 GEEZER chap
The words do mean the same, of course, but, my dear, they are miles apart in social standing. G(ood) fronts FREEZER, domestic appliance, missing its FR (father).
Down
2 OVERHAUL service
There’s a sounds like indicator here in “called out” which acounts foe HALL, lobby, in a different spelling. Having crossed, you are OVER. Have a care with the “liftng and separating” here.
3 WELDABLEThus possible to repair
A plainly signalled anagram of LEAD BLEW
4 WIGAN PIER The road to it
The Road to Wigan Pier,is – um – George Orwell’s scathing depiction of working class poverty in the North of England. In case you ever wondered, here’swhat Wigan Pier looks like. In the clue, it’s constructed by wrapping an anagram of WEARING round the constant PI.
5 LITTLE GREY CELLSThey think
Or they do, famously, for Poirot. Equally, little grey cells would be a close, confined, hence little, boringly grey place to keep men in confinement
6 PREVIEW TV critic often given this
I think the way this works is that our critic, in the course of his duty, would add a review to the P(age) he was given.
7 EL DORADO fabulous place
The imagined golden city/nation/kingdom sought by the conquistadors, and a catastropihically bad BBC soap. E(ast) with an anagram of OLD ROAD
8 RODERICKboy
RODE is “survived” as in rode out the storm. Strain leads you to RICK. Conflate.
14 OFFENDING liable to arrest
Concerned with is OF, as in Of Mice and Men”. FENDING gives coping as in fending for oneself. Conflate
15 FLASH MOB Sudden gathering
Those participating might not be flashy dressers. Unless they want to be seen on TV.
16 UPPER CUT blow
Possibly in the boxing ring. Part of a shoe UPPER, removed CUT
17 SYLLABLE barely a word
Because its a bit short. ALLY’s (friend’s) reversed, set before (I think) BLEW without its W from “hurried away”
18 CLAVICLE bone
Perhaps (though not by much) better known as the collarbone. One hanging in the cold is an ICICLE, which is executed by losing its first I. Its remains are thrown around LAV for small room.
19 GIVE EAR listen
Perhaps a rather old fashioned phrase. I’VE gets within GEAR for clothes.
Actually, looking back at it now, this crossword seems to have quite a few clues (MICKEY in addition to MIRROR and PREVIEW – maybe more) where I didn’t quite feel I’d been given enough. A bit like having ‘hotpot’ in Hong Kong…
Edited at 2014-12-11 03:29 am (UTC)
I did not understand the cryptics for: laid back, green fly, clavicle, leap year….but, nevertheless, they all went right in.
I did think Roderick was a bit of a stretch, as it is not a boy’s nickname like Ted.
‘Mirror’ was my LOI, a very clever clue.
“Riders on the storm
Riders on the storm
Into this house we’re born
Into this world we’re thrown
Like a dog without a bone
An actor out on loan
Riders on the storm”
…which could cast us as “survivors”, though it might well mean something completely different.
“The Road To Wigan Pier” has been discussed a lot in the media in the past few days following accusations of bias in BBC coverage of government spending cuts in which their correspondent compared conditions in Britain today with the era Orwell was writing about in the 1930s.
Edited at 2014-12-11 05:53 am (UTC)
… and that One Error was UPPERCUT, where I had undercut (unparsed, obvs), which, on checking, I see is what an uppercut was formerly known as…
RODERICK my last one in by ages. Needed to alphabet-run a couple of times for that one.
Also at MENDED I had MEN+D(I)ED. Can ‘were killed’ = both dead and died?
Couldn’t parse the BLE bit of SYLLABLE… Wouldn’t have thought of BLEW=’hurried away’.
Perhaps if the rule were relaxed we might get AA for 2 (or possibly 11). The possibilities are too horrible to contemplate.
Thanks setter, and thanks Z for correctly parsing GREENFLY.
I am a bit dubious of defining RODERICK as a boy – surely that would be ROD? Isn’t the convention that names are names, but boy’s names are contractions (Sid, Tim, Al etc.)?
11 is intriguing in that both “shot” or “in pieces” could be either the clue or the anagrind – neat!
Thanks for a really entertaining blog and for explaining that pesky Y in 19 (yup, I fell for it too).
Today’s blog was brought to you by the letter A (which gallumphed into two of my explanations in place of the intimidated I) and number 22 (which made two consecutive appearances before I spotted it and edited it to 23)
Edited at 2014-12-11 02:39 pm (UTC)
This was almost a PB at 24m; not often I beat some of the regulars, not to mention coming within 2½ Severs
JB
Edited at 2014-12-13 12:56 pm (UTC)
Fairly steady solve, starting with FLASH MOB and ending in LEAP YEAR. Is it possible to clue a puzzle entirely with cryptic definitions (I realise this is some contributors’ worst nightmare)?
I also liked RODERICK, not least for reminding me, as the name always does, of Life of Brian … Pontius Pilate being urged to release Roderick the Robber.
5D was a write in (it’s my e-mail address that is based on the phrase) but the cryptic definitions held me up as usual.
Great blog Z8
I was convinced that 8 began with LAD and 5 ended with WELL (for springs), which held me up no end, and made the NE my last corner in.
Very satisfying puzzle though.
Edited at 2014-12-11 11:01 am (UTC)
Thanks, yes, we’re making good process and trying to find out what, if any, damage has been done.
To clarify floruit for fl, used when indicating when an artist was known to be active, and floreat, let it blossom/flourish, when you are bigging up your alma mater.
Thanks for explaining where the Y in greenfly came from and for highlighting the niceties of flash mob.
Glad to hear the grandson is on the mend.
Thanks for parsing CLAVICLE and GREENFLY. I thought they must be right but couldn’t for the life of me see why.
I think janie_l_b is right about “were killed” = DIED. I believe the Times rule is that “one” is never used to represent A.