Anyway I wasn’t feeling too ambitious with all these handicaps, but this morning’s puzzle was both clever and enjoyable and I took it at a leisurely pace to bring it home inside hopefully acceptable 25 minutes. Initially I thought it was going to be a really quick, as everything north of 13A went in really quickly starting from 9D (rather obvious solely from the enumeration) and the simple anagram at 11A (factually incorrect surface though in this classicist’s opinion – I’ve never found a translation of my beloved Iliad that really does it for me!), but the bottom half of the grid proved a steeper climb, and some most enjoyable mental exercise. Not 100% sure what my LOI was, 21A quite possibly.
Style-wise I found this quite congenial, with some excellent cleverness on display starting right from the first two across clues (1A is my COTD I reckon), and some textbook &lits at 13A and 6D. Still not quite sure about “decap” for “behead” and being a sporting ignoramus airshots and leg byes were all Greek to me in exactly the way Greek isn’t, but essentially this was another fine puzzle that I was well into. My thanks to the setter!
| Across | |
| 1 | MOONQUAKE – Donkey [MOKE] carrying on as [ON QUA] mare’s trembling |
| 6 | VOWEL – Promise [VOW] the Spanish [EL] a say |
| 9 | V AND A – Russian uncle [VANYA] swapping tips on {D}ostoievsk{y} for museum |
| 10 | RABBITING – Sound bell [TING] with teacher [RABBI] speaking |
| 11 | MOREISH – In translation, (Homer is*) hard to put down! |
| 12 | IMAGERY – Shots one girl’s [I MARY] injected with brin{g} respit{e} at last |
| 13 | NOT FOR THE WORLD – Reply of man [HE] in (front row told*) to move? |
| 17 | RECORDING ANGEL – Rope in team [CORD IN GANG] to open cylinder [REEL] for logger above |
| 21 | ECTOPIC – Civil Engineer sent back [CE] text [TOPIC] in the wrong place |
| 23 | VIETNAM – Old German rocket [V-1] turned miles before [M ANTE] finding land |
| 25 | ZOOKEEPER – Lions manager perhaps, reflecting, about to look over Australia [RE PEEK O OZ] |
| 26 | ALAMO – Unhappily cut short [ALA{s}] second [MO] mission |
| 27 | REEDY – Shrill, grasping Head has departed [{g}REEDY] |
| 28 | DIESEL OIL – Fuel processing ({o}peration initially lies idle*) |
| Down | |
| 1 | MOVEMENT – Doctor [MO] emphatic that he’s abandoned [VEHEMENT – HE] campaign group? |
| 2 | OWNER – One who has child{ren wo}uld upset nurses |
| 3 | QUASIMODO – Simple fellow briefly [SIMO{n}] seen in yard [QUAD] with old [O] bell-ringer |
| 4 | AIR SHOT – Embarrassing sporting blunder: fans [AIRS] furious [HOT] |
| 5 | EBB-TIDE – Live life the wrong way [BE]: one [I] gets in awful (debt*) going out |
| 6 | VOILA – Exclamation from one [I] opening book [VOL], getting answer [A]? |
| 7 | WHITE FLAG – Chess player [WHITE], following [F] delay [LAG], giving in token |
| 8 | LEG BYE – Extra stage [LEG] so long [BYE] |
| 14 | TWENTY-ONE – Pontoon repaired [WENT], (yet no*) supply crossing it |
| 15 | ON AVERAGE – Typically at border [ON VERGE] area [A] intervening on separate occasions |
| 16 | PLIMSOLL – Quiet [P] Cypriot resort, not as [LIMASSOL – AS] large [L]: one goes on foot |
| 18 | DECAPOD – Crab for one to behead? [DECAP] Dangerous thing to take [OD] |
| 19 | NAVARRE – Welshman going north [EVAN] has arrived [ARR] in Pamplona area |
| 20 | GEEZER – My [GEE] love, unending [ZER{o}], for bloke |
| 22 | PIETY – Devotion is irrational [PI], still putting head down [YET] |
| 24 | NGAIO – Every so often, y{o}g{i} h{a}s {g}o{n}e up tree |
In retrospect, it was worth the effort and a real mental work out. (I get a similar feeling after a day walking in the hills in foul weather.)
Edited at 2014-12-05 11:08 am (UTC)
I thought we were in for a pangram but we’re missing X and J.
Ngaio Marsh is due my thanks yet again for helping me remember the name of that obscure tree, and I feel guilty that I have never read, let alone purchased, any of her many detective novels.
Still, I liked this one a lot. A nice challenge with some well-hidden definitions.
Edited at 2014-12-05 01:39 pm (UTC)
I must be getting to be a rather UK-centric American, as I put in ‘leg bye’ without any hesitation.
An AIR SHOT is called an air swing down here, but a quick google search seems to suggest that we’re the exception. And the clue was straightforward anyway.
Thanks setter and blogger.
Some interesting vocab. in another lively puzzle. Been good lately, haven’t they?
13A was a cunningly disguised anagram, but I agree with Jack and Jimbo that the relevance of the answer to the clue’s surface reading was tenuous to say the least. NOT FOR THE WORLD could serve as a negative reply to any imaginable request with which the speaker did not wish to comply. There is nothing in it to suggest, even cryptically or obliquely, a particular reluctance to leave the front row. Unless of course I’m missing something.
Edited at 2014-12-05 03:50 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2014-12-05 04:26 pm (UTC)
I wasn’t too worried about NOT FOR THE WORLD (which went straight in), though I did raise an eyebrow at DECAP for “behead” (even with its following question mark). Fortunately my ignorance of the V-1 meant I wasn’t put out by 23ac, and so overall I found this an enjoyable puzzle.
It would not surprise me if I am not the first to point this out, but on 22D of 25,962, mathematically the number PI (π) is not strictly an ‘irrational’ but a ‘transcendental’ number. Furthermore, IMHO using this word in the clue would not only have been more accurate usage, but would perhaps also have improved it. After all, isn’t the ultimate aim of PIETY some kind of transcendental experience?
Yours,
The Belsize Pedant.
Now I’m in the club.
I was never much of a mathematician at school (it having been sold to me at the time more as accountancy than philosophy – if only I could go back and do it all again, knowing what I do now!) but this link, at least, suggests that it is both transcendent *and* irrational/…?
But fair enough. I shall press the point no further.
Thanks for noticing enough to check up on my assertion!
Mary
Mary