19:17 on the Club timer, which felt like a fair time for a tricky-ish puzzle (and from looking at my place on the scoreboard, I see my time is – in the standard unit used round here – around 1.5 Biddlecombes, which is usually about right for me; or 3 Magoos, if you prefer). I got bogged down in the SW corner at first, largely my own fault for writing in ANGLO-GERMANIC instead of ANGLO-AMERICAN; this is one of the perils of solving online, of course, rather than having pen and paper to hand for jotting down anagram fodder.
As a classicist, I was lucky enough to be familiar with 5 down, but it wouldn’t surprise me to hear a chorus of complaints about this clue demanding an excessive level of classical knowledge.
Across | |
---|---|
1 |
CAVY -CAV |
3 |
ESCARPMENT – [ |
9 |
NIRVANA – [R |
11 |
EPITHET – H.E. in E |
12 |
ORANGE TIP – O |
13 | TORTE – (ROT)rev. + T.E., as in Lawrence of Arabia |
14 |
MICROSURGERY – MIC |
18 |
AMBASSADRESS – A M |
21 |
AMOUR – A M.O. + U |
22 |
DERIVABLE – E |
24 |
TOBACCO – (CABOT)rev. + (0 C |
25 | CULVERT – (REV)rev. in CULT |
26 |
ORDINANCES – O |
27 | deliberately omitted |
Down | |
1 |
CONSOMME – |
2 |
VARIANCE – N |
4 | START – double def. |
5 | AREOPAGUS – (A POE)rev. in ARGUS leads to the Athenian tribunal. |
6 |
PRINTERS DEVIL – R |
7 |
EXHORT – EX + R |
8 | TITLED – TIT + LED. |
10 | ANGLO AMERICAN – (ALARMINGONCEA)*; just the one G, as I failed to notice at my first attempt. |
15 | deliberately omitted |
16 | TEA BREAK – a (very English) cryptic def. |
17 | ASSENTED =”AS SCENTED”. |
19 | TATTOO – as well as the inky sort, there are drum-based tattoos, which would be quite literally beaten. |
20 | MORBID – (ROM)rev. + BID. |
23 |
RECCE – RE: C |
Louise
20 dn.Colloquially, MORBID and macabre have long been interchangeable; but there is a difference between MORBID, relating to disease, sickliness or unhealthiness either physical or mental, and macabre, to do with death or the gruesome. I regret the loss of a useful distinction.
I’m fascinated by this constant evolution of the language but I find most people are completely disinterested.
I won’t give up the day job…
I did an informal survey recently to see how many people I could find who knew the “real” meaning of the word disinterested. I quite quickly reached the conclusion that the majority of people who think it means uninterested is so overwhelming that practically speaking it does.
But it was.
So it is not really surprising to see them flip-flop again. It happens every 200 years!
From the male half of Doniovanni
When I studied English Fowler was a figure of ridicule: I wonder if that is still the case. In my heart I’m with him and you, but in my head I know that we are all with Canute.
I agree, however, that the evolution of language is a Tyranny of the Majority: it is pointless trying to write elegantly and precisely if your audience misinterprets your words, no matter how righteous you might feel in choosing le mot juste.
My first point was a semi-serious one: language reinvents itself all the time and there is pleasure to be had in new words. The idea that language deteriorates is a myth, and a very old one at that.
The trouble is that the words and distinctions that pass out of usage are ones that we know and like. The new ones are a bit minging.
There were a few things in this puzzle that I suspect many solvers will have a hard time with. You have to remember that Cabot was really Italian, even though he anglicised his name, recall the root meaning of ‘epithet’, and be familiar with the tattoo they beat on the drums. Not exactly a beginner’s puzzle.
CAVY and PRINTER’S DEVIL was also new to me, but also gettable. As for ORANGE TIP, when I see references to butterflies, moths or plants I know I’m reliant on wordplay alone. So all in all no real complaints but a sense of relief not to have made any mistakes.
Generally this was one of those where the answers come from grinding through the options rather than inspiration. Not the most enjoyable puzzle as a result but a good workout.
With all the checkers in place at 5dn apart from the G I had considered POE as the writer for reversal but couldn’t make a word of it. This clue requires two somewhat obscure bits of GK so I’m not sure that it’s entirely fair in a daily cryptic.
MICRO was guessable for the first part of 14ac but I never saw MIC as a possible for “bug” and I’m afraid I woindered if it might have something to do with a possibly derogatory term for Irishman. I thought MICROCULTURE might be a fit for ‘Bug, possibly’ so I spent some time working on that but couldn’t make any of the wordplay work.
Other than that it was an excellent puzzle. Just a shame that the two most difficult clues intersected.
This one took me 14 minutes, so quicker than average, but enjoyable nonetheless.
I particularly appreciated TEABREAK, but CoD to RECCE, for a neat clue.
But every cloud… First in was MICROSURGERY. How do you like them apples?
Thanks to the publicity given to the matter by The Bridgnorth, Shifnal and Albrighton Argus (with which is incorporated The Wheat-Growers’ Intelligencer and Stock-breeders’ Gazetteer), the whole world to-day knows that the silver medal in the Fat Pigs class at the eighty-seventh annual Shropshire Agricultural Show was won by the Earl of Emsworth’s black Berkshire sow, Empress of Blandings.
Is this a first reference to Pinter since his demise?
I don’t see 5d as an unfair clue – the ‘Argus’ component would be guessable from its common use as a newspaper name, making the wordplay tricky but achievable once the crossing letters were in place.
I do think the ‘PB’ is the only practicable unit of solving time. The Magoo is really only applicable to conditions found near the centre of black holes where time itself is distorted.
I think getting MICROSURGERY straight off the bat earns you bragging rights for at least a week, Barry.
I guessed MICROSURGERY from MIC for Irish and SURGERY for operations – so right answer by wrong route.
I guessed POE from checking letters, ARGUS from doing these puzzles and Chambers to confirm. Ridiculously obscure.
Roll on the day when “tau lepton” makes an appearance.
Cabot was a citizen of Venice who signed himself Zuan Chabotto, as English as I am Italian, ie not even a little bit..
Checking back on the crossword I can see two typos, but one is in a checking letter (TOCACCO crossing MORCID) so I think the Crossword Club counts you as wrong twice if it’s a checking letter. Makes sense I guess
But I was determined to finish, and so I did. Like Tim I rushed into entering ANGLO-GERMANIC; that took several hours to sort out, making his 19:17 all the more impressive. Didn’t consider RORY as an Irishman despite those Rory Gallagher lps lurking in my record collection. And Argus proved elusive, even though my local paper used to be the Telegraph and Argus, and I even worked there for a time.
I see Wiki describes Argus as a neatherd. I bet it won’t be long before we see a neat around these parts again.