Time taken to solve: Off the scale, but something like 90 minutes to complete the grid and at least another 30 working on the explanations, so about 2 hours of anguish for me this morning. I really didn’t like this puzzle though I don’t think I have any quibbles. I just found solving it a rather dull technical exercise with nothing to amuse or stimulate the mind with references to interesting subjects.
Across | |
---|---|
1 | FINISH,IN(G) TOUCH – The first part needs to be pronounced “fine-ish” to fit the wordplay |
9 | OS,CILL,ATE – “SO” reversed, then CILL (more usually spelt “sill”) is a block of stone or wood, then ATE is “worried” |
10 | T,HOLE |
12 | TASTE BUDS – Cryptic definition |
13 | D(ON)ATIVE – I spent ages trying to make the wordplay fit “donation” here but I’m glad I persevered otherwise I’d not have spotted my mistake |
15 | S(PL)EE,N |
17 | 0,RALLY – None rally so all remain bad |
19 | FAC(e)TIOUS |
22 | OUTSPRE,AD – Troupes* + Anno Domini |
23 | V,O,ICE |
24 | SLI(p),GO – Today’s cricket reference |
25 | IN(COG)NIT,0 – “Innit” being slang for “isn’t it” |
26 | INFERIOR PLANET – (Alpine frontier)*. The inferior planets are Mercury and Venus I.e. they are nearer the Sun than is Earth. |
Down | |
1 | FROM, BAD, TO W,OR,SE(nt) – TOW from “tow-path” at the side of a river or canal |
2 | NU(CLEO)N |
4 | 1,NA(C)TIVE – My comment at 13ac also refers to this one where I was trying to make “inaction” fit the wordplay |
5 | GRE(AS)Y |
6 | ON THE SPOT – I finally got the reference to snooker here. The coloured balls are returned to their spots after being potted, though not towards the end of the game. |
8 | PEASANTS REVOLT – (Pastoral events)* |
14 | T,ELEPH(ant),ONE |
16 | PANDA, CA,R – Sounds like “pander” meaning “pimp” |
18 | ANTLION – (In talon)* I didn’t know this can be one word but Collins and Chambers list it as such |
20 | O(PI)NION |
23 | VI(r)GIL |
Quibble: the inferior planets aren’t always warmer than the Alps. The temperature on Mercury at night can drop to as low as –200º C.
COD to SLIGO, BOW (Blogger of week) to Jack. My deepest admiration.
I thought “worried going to block” just meant attach one to the other without stipulating a particular order. At least that was my take on it and having thought of that I decided not to look for anything more complicated as my brain was hurting by then.
I’ve probably been a bit unkind to the setter in my opening comments. It IS technically a very clever puzzle.
Not my favourite kind of puzzle (‘technical exercise’ is right), but good for the soul.
First in BLEND, last in TASTE BUDS.
COD hard to see past the revolting peasants, but I enjoyed OPINION, too.
Well done and thanks, jackkt – service above and beyond.
Quite hard, and I didn’t see the cryptics for half a dozen of them, including even ‘Peasant’s Revolt’.
I had ‘lionant’ instead of ‘antlion’ for a long time, which really didn’t help.
I thought the clues I did understand were brilliant, so maybe we’re just not clever enough to see what a great puzzle this is. In particular, ‘inferior planet’, ‘factious’, ‘outspread’, and ‘telephone’ were all enjoyed as solved.
I seem to have failed by one on several occasions over the last couple of weeks. If anyone has any strategies for avoiding this (other than a brain transplant) I should be grateful for suggestions. The problem may be endemic to crossword solving since Peter, on the rare occasions when he dons his dunce’s cap, almost always has only one wrong.
This would have been much better set for a Saturday: it may then even have been rated as a classic.
JamesM
Wordplay to 17 completely beyond me. FACTIOUS a totally new word – fractious, yes.
Very difficult and not as enjoyable as these stinkers often can be. 8d COD
It’s interesting that a puzzle which is mostly technically sound and really quite difficult somehow manages not to deliver great satisfaction to many solvers. Like others I found it hard to like and a bit of a slog rather than a joy to wrestle with. No Doh! moments just detailed analysis and synthesis. Perhaps as Jack says its the lack of humour and interesting topics.
Very well done Jack, one to be proud of mate.
This comment is actually about the word ‘prelims’ in yesterday’s blog, which for the same busy-busy reasons I’d only just looked at. It’s not just a US definition of the preliminary pages (title, title verso, contents etc) in books, but ubiquitous in the UK publishing industry. Having spent my working life there, I put it in straight away.
Had to do this at any available opportunity, since it wasnt getting finished in the usual time, so approximately 50 minutes worth. I reckon you probably have to add some on for multiple time slots because I am sure your brain is subconsciously thinking about bits in between without you knowing about it. That would explain so often why you return to a grid and “suddenly” see three or four things quite quickly.
Anyhow – I thought todays was an excellent puzzle, because it was hard, but yet none of the content was unreasonable nor reliant on unknown vocabulary. It is one thing to struggle with unneccessarily difficult words, and another with especially clever deception. This was very much the latter, and having plodded slowly through bit by bit, there were many kick yourself moments and plenty of ah!s. My only gripe as above was the wording of 9a, as if anything the word block is both the insert indicator and the content. Funnily enough, I dont think the use of onto as suggested above would have made the surface that much worse (it isnt a great surface to begin with!)
At least two hours to complete – and with several pieces of wordplay needing illumination from the heavyweights on this site.
TGIF!
Ten minutes over an hour in all.