Sunday Times Cryptic No 4919 by Dean Mayer — Chef’s surprise

My LOI was 13 down, as I needed all the checkers… and then some. I hope and trust others will find the definition less elusive. It had to be some kind of -ISM, so what else could it have been?

Maybe I just didn’t want to face the grisly reality. In any case, as things are grisly enough, I’ll refrain from going into any detail about how a certain right-wing radio personality spoke of the Donner Party as role models some weeks ago.

It seems I’ve already been rather loquacious below, so let’s get on with it.

I indicate (gasmanar)* like this, and italicize anagrinds in the clues.

ACROSS
 1 Resist love for boy from Ireland (5)
BUCKO — BUCK, “Resist” + O, or 0, “love” I thought of Buck (loveless?) Mulligan immediately, but it’s not a proper name, just a synonym of “lad” that is used more often in Ireland than elsewhere.
 4 One showing pulse will stand in for me (9)
PROGRAMME — PRO(GRAM)ME… yes, I looked it up, and one meaning of GRAM is “pulse,” in the sense of a kind of leguminous plant, or its comestible seeds, such as peas; here poised between PRO, “for” and ME, “me.”
 9 Financial investigation involves tax (5,4)
MEANS TEST — MEANS, “involves” + TAX, “test”… MEANS in the oblique sense of “summer is over, and that means returning to school” (and good luck with that).
10 A new hair product, darling (5)
ANGEL — A + N(ew) + GEL (not the hydro-alcoholic stuff)
11 It’s my intention to like the afflicted (3)
ILL — DD
12 That’s just how Parisian put on light (4,7)
FAIR COMMENT — FAIR, “light” avec COMMENT, “how” en français
14 Tense as bloke, one with deadly wild animal (9,5)
TASMANIAN DEVIL — T(ense) + AS + MAN, “bloke” + I, “one” + AND, “with” + EVIL, “deadly”
17 A care home’s nice new menu offering (8,6)
MACARONI CHEESE — (A care home’s nice)* Comfort food, how nice indeed for the care home. I’ve usually heard MACARONI and CHEESE, over here.
19 Great author’s rule, you might say (5,2,4)
RIGHT AS RAIN — “writers” or “writas” + “reign”
21 No closer to one group of colleges (3)
UNI — UNI[-t]
22 Gathered and gutted more sheep (3,2)
MET UP — M[-or]E + TUP, “sheep”
23 New members taking part? Returning group excellent (9)
INITIATES — IN IT, “taking part” + SET + AI <=“returning,” both
24 In audible shock, boy ducks with missile around (5,4)
SONIC BOOM — SON, “boy” and then two “ducks,” OO guarded by an I(nter)C(ontinental)B(allistic)M(issile)
25 King welcomed by bloody old author (5)
GORKY — GOR(K)Y “Old” is not necessary for the definition, only there to help “bloody” sound natural in the surface, but it’s not in any way part of the wordplay.

DOWN
 1 Light upon and behind horse (4,4)
BUMP INTO — BUM, “behind” + PINTO, “horse”
 2 Steps once taken to hide reaction to comic actor (7,8)
CHARLES LAUGHTON — CHARLES(LAUGH)TON The dance “the Charleston” was supposedly, as the song says, “Made in (South) Carolina,” not the state capital of my home state of West Virginia (never such a swingin’ place, I guess).
 3 Big bird is so upset over loud music (9)
OSSIFRAGA — ISSO<=“upset” + F, “loud” + RAGA, “music” Totally unknown to me before deciphering the wordplay and checking it on Google, this is one of many names of the southern giant petrel. I’ve heard many RAGAs sung, live and on recording, by La Monte Young and Marian Zazeela and their late guru, Pandit Pran Nath. Others may think of Ravi Shankar’s sitar improvisations.
 4 Loved to conceal skin blemish—rash? (11)
PRECIPITOUS — PRECI(PIT)OUS
 5 Some of you think this is wrong (3)
OUT — Hidden
 6 Concrete mass forming sphere (5)
REALM — REAL, “Concrete” + M(ass)
 7 A circumferential line drawing? (8,7)
MAGNETIC EQUATOR — CD MAGNETIC is what “drawing” is all about here. I’m not sure I ever realized there is, like a MAGNETIC pole, a MAGNETIC EQUATOR as well, but of course there is. It’s the imaginary line girdling the earth along which a compass needle will not dip from the horizontal.
 8 A stone tool, it will cut rough hole (6)
EOLITH — (hole)* incised by IT As a dictionary term, since EOLITH was long used to signify a “stone tool,” I guess it qualifies as a crossword entry under that guise. But I find on Wikipedia that “an eolith (from Greek “eos,” dawn, and “lithos,” stone) is [merely] a chipped flint nodule. Eoliths were once thought to have been artifacts, the earliest stone tools, but are now believed to be geofacts (stone fragments produced by fully natural geological processes such as glaciation).” I saw some of these in a fascinating exhibition on the modern concept of the prehistoric at the Centre Pompidou in 2019; the display of eoliths was juxtaposed with one showing the same number of actual human-worked relics, and the difference was striking, as was a teasing similarity.
13 Likes eating (11)
CANNIBALISM — CD… your “likes” being your counterparts, your semblables
15 Upgrading inn, change cocktail? (9)
ENHANCING — (inn change)* Hereby awarded the prize for Anagrind of the Week.
16 Incorrectly, he’d say I’m avoiding publicity (5-3)
MEDIA-SHY — (he’d say I’m)*
18 Particular American name in outdoor cooking (6)
PRIMUS — PRIM, “particular” + US, “American” Wikipedia: “The Primus stove, the first pressurized-burner kerosene stove, was developed in 1892 by Frans Wilhelm Lindqvist, a factory mechanic in Stockholm.”
20 Subject for photo (5)
TOPIC — TO, “for” + PIC, “photo”
23 One occasion to create artificial language (3)
IDO — I, “one” + DO, “occasion” IDO is a constructed language derived from the more well-known(-of) artificial tongue Esperanto (in which “ido” means “offspring”). To be precise, it’s derived from Reformed Esperanto, or Esperanto 1894. The idea behind inventing a language was, of course, to foster universal understanding. Wikipedia: “As of the year 2000, there were approximately 100–200 Ido speakers in the world.” I have a friend who cannot accept that our, or any natural, language is not entirely logical and that its implicit “rules” are not pre-established in some Platonic heaven; it seems he would be more happy with Ido or Esperanto, but he would not be able to converse with many people.

23 comments on “Sunday Times Cryptic No 4919 by Dean Mayer — Chef’s surprise”

    1. It is?! (What a snarky subject line.)
      I only did that to prompt your response. Ha

      Edited at 2020-09-13 01:09 am (UTC)

  1. 13d was worth the price of admission. A LOL PDM. Thanks to Dean in his sunday best again , and Guy for an informative blog. 42mins
  2. A rarity in Dean’s puzzles: a clue that takes 2 lines to print. OSSIFRAGA rather Mephistophelean, but the cluing was helpful, although I needed the checkers before I could come up with RAGA. With 7d, EQUATOR was easy enough, but not knowing there was a MAGNETIC one, again I had to wait for checkers. No doubt about it: CANNIBALISM the COD of CODs.
    1. Agree about EQUATOR, Kevin. Took me ages to work out what sort of equator Dean was referring to.
      And totally agree about your choice of COD!
  3. I had this down as “hard” in my notes but there were some beautifully worded clues. “Likes eating” = CANNIBALISM is just superb and easily a COD.
    Would that work in the singular as well as in “Like eating”?
    Thank you, Guy for an excellent explanatory blog.
    You also answered my queries on TASMANIAN DEVIL (and the little blighters really are devils!), GRAM in PROGRAMME and UNI.
    I did pause for a long time on 3d. I wanted it to be OSSIFARIA.
    Well done, Dean and well done, Guy!
  4. After working for 90 satisfying minutes, I threw it all away by putting GOREY — not seeing how it made any sense, but also not knowing GORKY. Ah well.
      1. When I saw the pink square I first googled GORRY. No luck. “It can’t be GORKY?!”, I thought. Well…
  5. CANNIBALISM is an exceptional clue that manged to eclipse half a dozen more great clues. Only OSSIFRAGA held me up because there is another bird called an OSSIFRAGE.
  6. 55 minutes on this absolutely brilliant puzzle, clue after clue giving rise to that warm feeling you get when the penny drops. I’ll make CHARLES LAUGHTON and CANNIBALISM joint CODs but it could have been many others too.Thank you Dean and Guy.
  7. Not only was 13D my COD (obvs !) but my time was a beautifully symmetrical 13:13 !

    Didn’t know the “big bird” but once I’d dismissed “Sesame Street” from my thinking it flew in. Only parsed TASMANIAN DEVIL afterwards. The BUM PINTO made me smile..

    FOI ANGEL, LOI PRIMUS

  8. Hard work but worth persevering with and rewarding to complete. I enjoyed 2dn as a reminders of Charles Laughton a much underrated actor, and the Charleston. The song was written in 1923 with words by Cecil Mack. I don’t know him, but the music was by one of my jazz heroes, James P Johnson, a pioneer of the stride piano style.

    Edited at 2020-09-13 06:39 am (UTC)

  9. DNF. Similar to Saturday’s puzzle in that I had to put this one down and return to it a couple of times during the week. Unlike Saturday’s though, I couldn’t finish this. Never managed to get 13dn, too grisly for me to countenance perhaps? Tough.
  10. Reading Boltonwanderer’s report made me wonder what is the opposite of that warm feeling you get when the penny drops. I had that a number of times with this very difficult puzzle.
    I started with ILL and MET UP -scraps really, but soon had MACARONI CHEESE and TASMANIAN DEVIL -lots of letters to work with. However lots of blanks remained and when I saw what to do, it turned out to be wrong e.g. at 8d where I constructed HOLITE which still looks more likely than EOLITH. And at 2d I had the second word as LAUGHTER. I have never thought of Charles Laughton as a comic actor.
    I can see from the blog that there is much to admire in this puzzle, but it was too hard for me.
    David
    1. “I have never thought of Charles Laughton as a comic actor.”
      That realization could have helped you unravel the clue.
  11. I found this hard going, but slogged on to the end, which was 75:01, but it was all in vain as I didn’t know the author and plumped for GORRY from the wordplay. Drat! CANNIBALISM LOI, and COD. Thanks Dean and Guy.
  12. 18:02. Great puzzle, with my last in (by a long shot!) CANNIBALISM the best of the bunch. What a brilliant clue, and what a penny-drop/self-kicking moment.
    OSSIFRAGA is a bit Mephistoish, and I wonder if GORKY is well-known enough for an ambiguous clue like that. I knew him from the film adapted from the book whose title references the park named after the writer.
    I make MACARONI CHEESE every Sunday, so that one was rather topical.

    Edited at 2020-09-13 12:33 pm (UTC)

  13. Hello! Your entry got to top-25 of the most popular entries in LiveJournal!
    Learn more about LiveJournal Ratings in FAQ.
  14. 54 minutes, with a number of obscurities (like OSSIFRAGA). I would agree about CANNIBALISM’s being the COD. PROGRAMME took me a while to feel comfortable with, until I remembered the availability of GRAM flour in our local oriental food shop (which among other things, is my only source in Germany for dark brown sugar, so not entirely oriental).

    Edited at 2020-09-13 06:20 pm (UTC)

  15. I had “flip comment” rather than “fair comment”. It kinda fits. You flip on a switch after all.
  16. Thanks Dean and guy
    Another tough offering from this setter that took over the hour and a half – a mix of some unknown definitions (12a, 2d, 3d and 7d), tricky word play (4a (who knows that ‘pulse’?), 23a, 24a and 3d) along with that brilliant cd at 13d.
    Can always remember the Russian writer from GORKY Park and was pleased that my schoolboy French remembered COMMENT.
    Finished in the NW corner with the cleverly constructed BUMP INTO, MEANS TEST and PRECIPITOUS.

Comments are closed.