Solving time: 5 mins for all but 26ac and 9dn, on which I subsequently gave up.
In fact, my guess at 26ac (FIELDFARE) proved correct, but I wouldn’t have got 9dn in a month of Palm Sundays.
There were some comments on the quality of Sunday Times cryptics in last week’s blog, and Peter’s theory on the high error count. The worst error in this puzzle is ‘lock’ for ‘loch’ in 2dn. I’m not sure what’s going on at 15ac/5dn, but something’s not quite right there either. 24ac was also mentioned last week as being problematic, but I think that one’s ok.
* = anagram, “X” = sounds like ‘X’.
Across | |
---|---|
1 | PLA(I)CE – mishandling of the letter I (‘I get…’), which is a regular feature of these puzzles. |
4 | PROBABLE; (LAB)* in PROBE |
10 | RHEOSTATS; (SORES THAT)* – if this is intended as a semi-&lit, it doesn’t work cryptically (because of the word ‘that’, which is part of the anagram), quite apart from the question of whether a rheostat could actually give you a sore. If it’s just a normal clue, ‘devices’ seems an unfairly vague definition. |
11 | STORM (double definition) |
12 | DECORUM; rev. of ED, + CO + RUM |
14 | LIMPKIN – ornithology is not my strong point (see 26ac), and I made up this bird from the wordplay. |
15 | SCATTER-BRAINED; (CABINET RETARDS)* |
24 | PLUNGER; (PURE + L[uck] + NG)* |
25 | THE R.M. |
26 | FIELD FARE – I’m sure ‘food’ = ?A?E has plenty of possibilities so I was lucky to pick the right one (one of these), although I still spent ages looking for something more likely. |
28 | OBSTACLE; (STOLE CAB)* – not sure what ‘through’ is doing here. |
29 | AD + VICE |
Down | |
---|---|
1 | PARADISE; (A PADRE IS)* – a better semi-&lit. |
2 | AWE – this is presumably meant to refer to Loch Awe, but instead of ‘loch’ the clue reads ‘lock’, which cannot mean the same thing according to any dictionary I can find. |
3 | CAST + RATED – a curious clue with the definition (‘made impotent’) in the middle of the two elements of wordplay. |
5 | RUSTLER (sic) – the answer to this clue seems to be ‘rustled’, but it must be ‘rustler’ to fit with 15ac. The clue is: “Quietly took stock? Not entirely”. Not sure who to blame for this. Perhaps it was supposed to read “He quietly…”? |
6 | BOSOM (punning on ‘abreast’) |
8 | ER + MINE |
9 | PALMER (double definition) – the killer for me. This can mean both ‘a hairy caterpillar’ and hence ‘a bristly artificial fly’, i.e. bait, and ‘a pilgrim carrying a palm-leaf in token of having been in the Holy Land’. I’m not sure this second definition is quite equivalent to ‘monk’, which is given in the clue, but even with two straight definitions I wouldn’t have got this. I’m afraid I gave up rather quickly – there are so many mistakes in Sunday Times puzzles that it never seems worth persevering in case an apparent stumbling block proves to be another error. |
13 | CH(A RIOT)EERS – this doesn’t quite work cryptically but it’s probably close enough. |
16 | I’M POUNDED |
17 | AGGRIEVE; (VERA EGG I)* |
19 | WISTFUL; (W + IF LUST)* |
20 | HOPPER (double definition) – in the railway sense, ‘a wagon with an opening in the bottom for discharging its cargo’. |
21 | TATTOO (double definition) |
Thanks for blogging this and confirming a few worst fears. Despite this puzzle’s poor record I still waste a lot of time searching for answers, which is the real annoyance. 2 and 5 are just embarrassing, but I’m not sure anyone at the ST cares enough to be embarrassed.
I agree about the setter’s mental ellipsis at 5dn. It would be quite a good, witty clue as “He quietly takes…” (I think the setter believes that rustlers no longer exist).
Crossword by ST, editing by John Prescott.
Here endeth the Sunday rant.
Interestingly, my copy of the Sunday Times did read “loch” in the clue for two down.
It’s weird, years back I worked in newspaper journalism (pre-web days) and it was regarded as a golden rule of the business that if ever you were launching/relaunching/redesigning a newspaper, you sorted out the crossword before anything else – it was seen as the one thing you couldn’t afford to screw up. And perhaps rightly so, since people invest a lot of time in doing puzzles and become proportionately angry when they find out they’ve been wasting that time.
I guess, depressingly, papers are now run by executives rather than news people, and execs with their shiny MBAs know that so long as your PR is okay and your business model is polished, you can afford to drive a small proportion of your customers up the wall and still make your financial targets.
I’m pretty sure that you, or PB, or quite a few of the other regulars could have turned this into a good puzzle with half an hour’s work.
Hope you don’t mind my going on at length. I do it because:
a) I think blogging these must be somewhat thankless, and I’d hate for you to get no comments after all your hard work.
b) The last couple of weeks I’ve been helping my partner out with hours of mind-numbing transcription work and I’m desperate for something else to do!
c) I had to swear myself off Mephisto and others some years ago after becoming obsessed with crosswords and linguistics to the point of cracking up. So I’m stuck with daily Times and ST only.
Slightly stunned that talbinho seems not to have encountered the FIELDFARE before – there’s a very chestnutty clue about picnics – but LIMPKIN would had been new to me too.
I have to confess to not having even noticed half the misprints in last week’s puzzle (thanks to dorosatt for bringing them all to light), though it seems that some (all?) of these were unique to the online version, which is notoriously unrealiable.
I AM reasonable on my birds and FIELDFARE at 26a was a write-in – I am not surprised that this is a “chestnut” as PB has said above. The LIMPKIN – a moderate sized aquatic bird from the tropical to sub-tropical Americas – was new to me but it was fairly clued once all the checkers were in place.
I did not notice the mistake at 5d. I had RUSTLED until I solved the easy anagram at 15a just changing 5d to RUSTLER without trying to re-solve the clue. Good tactic as it turns out.
There are just the 5 “easies” omitted from the blog. This set could have been any 5 from 28 really despite misprints and mistakes.
18a Looking before buying a pane of glass? (6,8)
WINDOW SHOPPING
22a After a time, wearies of clothes (7)
ATTIRES
7a Accounting for one of the librarian’s activities (4-7)
BOOK KEEPING
23d After his traditional drink, sailor rising to dance (5)
RUM BA
27d Parisian’s friend is in a mi nk (3)
AMI