No solving time noted down this week – I had 15 minutes to spare before going out last Saturday, after which I was less than half way through it. When I got back I needed another 20 minutes or so to finish it. Some very good clues though – 13D is brilliant. Well, they’re all good actually (with the possible exception of 17D, see below). The great thing about blogging the puzzle is that you get to dissect each clue later (in my case a week later), and you see things you missed when you were solving. You get to appreciate the setter’s skill in finding convincing surface readings that consist only of wordplay + definition, and nothing else. Oh, and this one was also a pangram.
Across |
1 |
CRUSH – C(ar) + RUSH |
4 |
KICK-START – cryptic def, although you could say it’s literally true! |
9 |
LIFELINES – LI(on) + FELINES |
10 |
MOCHA – MO (little girl, i.e. diminutive for Maureen) + H(ot) inside CA (about). |
11 |
MUTTON – MUTT + ON (= being cooked) |
12 |
PEROXIDE – O(ld) inside (expired)* |
14 |
IN THE ROUND – I, N, (due north)* |
16 |
ZINC – middle of amaZINgly, + C(old) |
19 |
NOEL – NO(v)EL |
20 |
CENTIMETRE – TIME inside CENTRE, bird being Cockney rhyming slang (bird-lime = time) for a prison sentence. |
22 |
TIME LORD – TIM + (older)*. Dr. Who is becoming quite a popular subject for cryptic clues these days, but I don’t think you’ll find this answer in any dictionaries. |
23 |
ARGALI – GAL in (air)*. I knew this one, having researched types of sheep for a Listener puzzle back in the summer (Terminal Suspension by Schadenfreude, no. 3986). First one of his I’d managed to solve, too. |
26 |
BANJO – N + JO(b) after B.A. (one learnèd). |
27 |
EQUIPMENT – QUIP + MEN inside E.T. |
28 |
ANASTASIA – STASI inside AN + A + A (three articles). I immediately thought ALEXANDRA (which also has three articles, and who was also done in by the Bolsheviks). Anastasia was her daughter. |
29 |
RUDDY – RUD(e) + DY(namite). |
Down |
1 |
COLUMBIAN – BIA(s) inside COLUMN. For BIAS = bulge, think of a bowling ball (bowls, not ten-pin). |
2 |
UNFIT – F in UNIT. |
3 |
HALLOWED – (churc)H + ALLOWED. |
4 |
KIND – KIN (= one’s own) + D(rama) |
5 |
CASHEW NUTS – CUTS around AS HEWN. |
6 |
SIMOOM – MOO + M(editerranean) + IS, all reversed. |
7 |
ARCHIVIST – I + VIST(a) underneath ARCH (= chief) |
8 |
TRACE – T + RACE |
13 |
MORE OR LESS – take OR away from MORE to get ME. To refresh people’s memory, the clue was “Just about me?” |
15 |
THEOMANIA – THE OMANI A(rea). |
17 |
CHEMISTRY – H.E. + MIST inside CRY. Maybe the weakest clue – pipe for CRY is a bit loose, and the definition is only hinted at by the &lit-ish surface reading. |
18 |
IMPROPER – i.e. IMP-ROPER, someone who ropes an imp. |
21 |
ALL-OUT – U(nited) in ALLOT. |
22 |
TIBIA – A + 1 + BIT, all reversed. |
24 |
AMEND – AMEN + D(ictionary). Although the link-word and definition could also be wordplay for the answer (A(re) + MEND). Was that deliberate I wonder? |
25 |
CUBA – HECUBA minus H.E. |
BTW, hand on heart I can tell you this was accidentally pangrammatic. I had an email mentioning it earlier this week and was convinced the sender was referring to the wrong puzzle.
Wonder if any other setters have compiled a pangram without realising?
I thought there were an excessive number of clues that had to be gotten from the cryptic alone for those without specialized knowledge, such as ‘time lord’, ‘simoom’, and ‘argali’, all of which I entered because that’s what it had to be.
I hesitated for a long time between ‘jump start’ and ‘kick start’, although ‘kick start’ was the more likely choice.
As for too many specialist knowledge plus cryptic, surely this is pretty well the definition of a Times crossword! The eternal question is at what point does the specialist bit become too specialist to be reasonable. I feel that the more the checking letters restrict the possible answer (and increase the chance of a successful guess), the more arcane that answer can be.
Simoon I knew, and therefore – to me – is general knowledge. Hecuba and argali I did not know, and therefore – to me – are specialist knowledge.
Did not time it, but enjoyed it even though I had to resort to reference books (for the unreasonable specialist ones only of course).
COD 17 for the sneaky use of pipe, (Nothing to do with my uni major)
“What’s Hecuba to him, or he to Hecuba,
That he should weep for her?
That’s what I always think of whenever I see Hecuba.