Solving time: Easier end of scale.
A nice pleasant stroll today in the company of Grumpy. Nothing terribly complex, although I did wonder if 13 across should have had A in the clue as well (“A profit, which would equate to A GAIN).
I think this will go down well with our newer solvers.
| Across |
| 1 |
ATYPICAL – Definition is non-standard. A + anagram (variety) of CLAY PIT. |
| 6 |
DROP – Double definition. A word for a small amount and to cast off /throw away. |
| 8 |
SCAR – Def = mark. S (singular) + CAR (vehicle). |
| 9 |
MANDRILL – Big Baboon = def. CHAP (Man) + DRILL (exercise). |
| 10 |
DISAGREE – Don’t see eye-to-eye = def. An anagrasm (unfortunately) of REG & SADIE. |
| 11 |
IDOL – An object of veneration = def. I (1) + DOL (half dollar). |
| 13 |
AGAIN AND AGAIN – Repeatedly = def. A GAIN + Profit. Repeatedly = add another. Perhaps clue here should also indicate A? |
| 16 |
ANNA – Karenin’s wife = def. The name is a palindrome. |
| 17 |
FIRST AID – Emergency treatment = def. FIR (Tree) + STAID (Respectable). |
| 19 |
CAST IRON – Unassailable = def. A STIR (a prison) inside CON (prisoner). |
| 21 |
MEAD – Drink made from honey = def. E (energy) inside MAD (nuts). |
| 22 |
DRAW – Sketch = def. Reverse WARD (backward). |
| 24 |
ONE-LINER – Joke = def. ON (ABOUT) + E (energy) + LINER (passenger ship). |
| Down |
| 2 |
TACKING ON – Adding = def. O (nothing) + N (new) goes after TACKING (Changing course in sailing). |
| 3 |
PARKA – Coat = def. PARK (recreation place) + A (area) |
| 4 |
CUMBRIA – Northern county = def. C (Cold) + UMBRIA (Region in Italy). |
| 5 |
LANCE – Weapon = def. A word often placed in front of Corporal to give another rank. |
| 6 |
DARLING – L (Head of lettuce) inside DARING (Bold). |
| 7 |
OWL – Bird of prey = def. First letters (originally) of OBSERVED, WITHOUT and LIGHTS. |
| 12 |
ORIGINATE – Start = def. An anagram (changing) of INTO GEAR I. |
| 14 |
IN A STEW – Double definition. To be beside oneself and where you’d find beef and dumplings! |
| 15 |
DERANGE – Disorder = def. An anagram (goes off) of GRENADE. |
| 17 |
FORGO – Give up = def. FOR (on account of) + GO (square on Monopoly board). |
| 18 |
TEMPI – Musical speeds =def. Hidden inside First Empire. |
| 20 |
AIR – Song = def. (P)AIR -a word for a duo without the first letter. |
Don’t agree about 13ac – it doesn’t necessarily need the indefinite article. You talk about “profit and loss” not “a profit and a loss”, so “profit” can mean “a gain” in its own right.
Eurc.
Excellent blog, thanks, Macavity, it certainly went down well with me.
I think ANNA is OK as a clue – is your solver on the Clapham omnibus going to be into Tolstoy?
LOI CAST IRON I sort of solved clockwise. I have a battle for COD between FIRST AID for the groan factor or MANDRILL for the fast solve – I’m in to Munk1s 🙂 On balance, the former gets it.
I’m still regularly stumbling round in the dark trying to find many of the answers. For example, I put in CUMBRIA because it is a northern county. I know that Umbria is a region of Italy and I know that “C” is often indicated by “cold” in the clue, but it took me many more minutes till it dawned on me why CUMBRIA was right!
Can you tell me, are clues regularly repeated? When you’ve done this a lot, is it common to recognise a clue you’ve seen before? I can’t help feeling that there must be finite amount of good wordplay.
You will also find these conventions wax and wane in popularity such that one compiler will find a cunning way of expressing part of a clue and it’s then taken up by others so that it becomes orthodoxy for a while.
Hope this helps.
Yesterdays which took much longer to solve, felt far more satisfying.
Eurc.
It must be devilishly tricky for the setters to work out where to pitch the Quickie in terms of “degree of difficulty”. Today’s was probably ideal for the authentic newbie, whilst being fairly straightforward for those (like me) who are in the limbo land between Quickie and main (sometimes knock out the main, but often it leaves me totally bemused). And for the seasoned campaigners who knock over the main in half an hour (or less!) this would have been Olympians tackling the Under 10’s gym circuit.
Golf works so well as a sport because the handicap system allows players of wildly divergent abilities to have a good competitive game together. Ulaca might play off scratch and get down in 3, I might play off 14 and get down in 4, and docbee might play off 25 and get down in 6 – and it would all be pretty close as a competition. And we would all ultimately get the ball in the hole.
But with crosswords it’s very different. The handicap concept can work up to a point (as stated before, I aspire to be within 3 times jackkt’s completion time – it’s just a metric I’ve developed based on empirical observation over the last 4 months since joining this site). However, if you can’t get the ball in the hole at all, it gets very frustrating.
Not sure what the best approach is, but I offer this somewhat rambling comment as a start point for discussion.
Hopefully from next week England can avoid everything to do with yesterday’s 3d
Totally agree with Nick the Novice: it’s must be very difficult for setters to pitch it right; and it’s nigh on impossible for a crossword to generate the type of multi-ability competition enjoyed by golf.
But, in a round about way, the quickie does support competitive crosswording (apologies – terrible phrase) because it generates a whole host of new “players”. Before now, the world of the Times cryptic was completely shut off to me even because I had no guidance about how to break into it. The introduction of the quickie has been an absolute delight, and I’m determined one day to get good enough to join the big boys (and girls) tackling the main one.
incidentally, apropos of nothing but seeing as I’m posting a rambling comment anyway, I thought I’d mention that: I’m old school, and I still do it every day with a biro on the paper version. I know I’m in the minority but I just love doing it that way.
Thank you for indulging my long comment, and for the excellent support and blogs!
I’ve been following the blog since the beginning and am very grateful for the help and explanations they contain. Many, many thanks to the bloggers! I am finally finding a way into the cryptics. I hope one day to graduate to the grown up version, but based on today’s attempt, that is a long way off!