At under 7 minutes this was one of my fastest QC solves for a long time, and everything just seemed to roll off the tongue for a mostly sequential solve. Hopefully, you all found it equally quick and easy. I certainly can’t see anything to frighten the horses, unless POTUSs in the 19th Century are your blind spot.
As indicated before Christmas, you can find my favourite clues from the puzzles I blogged during 2021 at the end of this blog entry. These choices are obviously subjective, and reflect my taste only. To all Setters, if you aren’t listed, please don’t despair, you may have been one of the very close runners-up in one of the categories, and I appreciated each and every one of you during the year.
To all readers, bloggers and commentators, you probably have your own favourites (remember, my choice is just for those puzzles I blogged (those with numbers ending with a 3) on alternate Thursdays).
Across
1 Rain very lightly in small mine (4)
SPIT – S{mall} and PIT (mine).
4 Crucial trial dictates changes (4,4)
ACID TEST – Anagram (changes) of [DICTATES]. Originally, an ACID TEST was a test for gold using acid.
8 Spotted former US president at party being held (5,3)
POLKA DOT – POLK (former US president, James K POLK, 1845 – 1849) followed by AT (at) containing DO (party – being held).
9 Element of skill on piano (4)
PART – P{iano} and ART (skill).
10 Unguarded ring, enclosure (4)
OPEN – O (ring) and PEN (enclosure). An OPEN prison is an unguarded one.
11 Police officer enthralled by famous writer’s version that’s printed (4,4)
HARD COPY – COP (police officer) surrounded by (enthralled by) HARDY (famous writer – Thomas Hardy).
12 Doing wrong to storm after her, heading off (6)
ERRANT – RANT (to storm) after {h}ER (hER – heading off, drop first letter).
14 Is to touch down in Madagascar, perhaps? (6)
ISLAND – IS (is) and LAND (to touch down), Madagascar being an example of an ISLAND.
16 TV programme, extremely childish – so what’s new? (4,4)
CHAT SHOW – Anagram (new) of [SO WHAT] and C{hildis}H (extremely).
18 Black bird of prey in hollow (4)
BOWL – B{lack} and OWL (bird of prey).
19 Cab charge beginning to irritate (4)
TAXI – TAX (charge) and I{rritate} (beginning to).
20 Nothing left? That’s OK (3,5)
ALL RIGHT – Double definition.
22 Ran out of gear? (8)
STREAKED – All-in-one or &Lit clue.
23 Benevolent type (4)
KIND – Double definition
Down
2 Professional agents, upwardly mobile, do well (7)
PROSPER – PRO{fessional} and REPS (agents) reversed (upwardly mobile in this down clue).
3 Acceptable to enter number, or symbol (5)
TOKEN – OK (acceptable) inside (to enter) TEN (number).
4 Servant blowing top gets help (3)
AID – {m}AID (servant) blowing top = drop first letter.
5 Meeting with candidate in Bury to contend with (9)
INTERVIEW – INTER (bury) with VIE (contend) and W{ith}.
6 Newsworthy subject – Capone? (7)
TOPICAL – TOPIC (subject) and AL (Capone).
7 Remove second slip (5)
STRIP – S{econd} and TRIP (slip). Nothing to do with cricket!
11 Husband at church with second car (9)
HATCHBACK – H{usband} AT and CH{urch} plus BACK (second).
13 A celebrity embracing one eastern dancer (7)
ASTAIRE – A STAR (a celebrity) containing I (embracing one) and followed by E{astern}. Fred ASTAIRE – surely the greatest dancer of (nearly) modern times.
15 Reproachful words? Let me see (3,4)
NOW THEN – Double definition
17 Runs in preliminary round, showing courage (5)
HEART – HEAT (preliminary round) containing R{uns}.
18 Quick chance to support British (5)
BRISK – RISK (chance) beneath (supporting) B{ritish}.
21 Top firm? Not so (3)
LID – {so}LID (firm = solid) remove so (Not so).
THE ROTTER AWARDS
My choice of some favourite clues from the puzzles I have blogged through 2021 (in no particular order). Some of my record-keeping is a bit shambolic, so I hope that I have all of the references correct.
Rotter’s IKEA clue of the year – Hurley QC 1923 – ‘French article, popular monk’s garment, editor finds lifeless’ (11)
Rotter’s COD of the year – Hurley QC 1823 – ‘Denied win, unwind in rugby playing, wine producing region’ (8)
Rotter’s DD / TD of the year – Joker QC 2013 – ‘Catherine earmarked money for cat’ (5)
Rotter’s Anagram of the Year – Wurm QC 1783 – ‘We help in their shambolic call to vote’ (5-4,4)
Rotter’s Word of the Year – Noel QC 1893 – ‘Large stain ruined old pegs’ (6)
Rotter’s Cryptic of the Year – Orpheus QC 1953 – ‘Indoctrinate supporter swimming off Hunstanton?’ (9)
And finally, my themed crossword of the year goes to – Alfie for QC 1893.
My sincere thanks to the Editors and the Setters for their inspiring and challenging work in 2021.
Readers, bloggers and commentators, thanks to you too, and happy 2022.
My time was 6.30ish with a pen problem after just two minutes. Sub used.
FOI 1ac SPIT
LOI 3dn TOKEN
COD 8ac POLKA DOT
WOD 15dn NOW THEN — sounds better if repeated in a Yorkshire accent
Is MADAGASCAR WEEK over yet!? Or is it to be MADAGASCAR MONTH?
Edited at 2022-01-06 03:38 am (UTC)
COVID wife demands an early start so I can give the dog his 90m before the school run. I can use some of that to decide what to make for tea. Having done chicken pie and pizza this week already (both homemade so don’t judge too harshly) it’s going to have to be something with pasta. But what?
A bit studenty — but surprisingly tasty.
Spag Carbonara. Just don’t add egg mix if pan still hot…it scrambles
I made the same mistake as Paul, biffing blink instead of brisk. So all done in 12 but with 2 errors – a typo in now then too, more care needed!
Thanks Rotter for the blog and great summary of the clues of 2021. I will attempt to resolve them now!
FOI Spit – always nice to get 1A first
LOI Streaked – although technically a DNF as got brisk wrong
CoD Streaked
Edited at 2022-01-06 08:20 am (UTC)
I did answer POLKA DOT, but I did not get the ex-President part, having never heard of President POLK. However, from the letters I had, POLKA DOT was the obvious answer.
25 minutes, with Chambers used three times.
I chuckled at STREAKER, but was forced to think throughout. LOI BRISK, once I’d shaken BLINK out of my mind.
7:02
Finished in 8.48 with LOI BRISK and COD to HATCHBACK.
Thanks to Rotter for the blog and I shall return later to enjoy your top clues when I have a bit more time.
Thanks to rotter (a bit of a streaker today — good time!) and to Tracy for a good QC.
Now to see if I can still solve rotter’s favourites. Won’t be easy — I have a sieve-like short-term memory so I will be starting from scratch but with no crossers to help. 🙄 John M.
Edited at 2022-01-06 09:18 am (UTC)
COD and LOI was STREAKED
A puzzle with lots of good clues. I’ll pick ACID TEST as my COD.
I’m now going to read Rotter’s awards. Thanks Rotter for this and to all the bloggers who do a great job.
David
Edited at 2022-01-06 10:20 am (UTC)
NHO POLK (was trying to work in ABE), mis-read “servant” as “serpent” and biffed in ASP, and on first pass at the acrosses carelessly put STREAKER not STREAKED. Still came in at K+30 seconds so this must have been an easier one. Lots of fun on the way.
FOI SPIT, LOI LID, COD STREAKED (made me chuckle), time 06:55 for an Excellent Day. Many thanks Rotter and Tracy.
Templar
Never heard of Polk!!? James Knox Polk 11th president 1845-9 ‘As President he oversaw the largest territorial expansion in American history — over a million square miles of land —acquired through a treaty with England and war with Mexico.’ Wikipedia. This took me 5:30 mins with Polka Dot my COD & WOD.
Edited at 2022-01-06 10:39 am (UTC)
Just when I thought I was getting stuck another nice clue was presented to get me going again. e.g. 4a, 5d, 6d and 11d.
I considered Blink but Brisk came in time as LOI.
Three letter ‘k’s helped.
Thanks all.
John George
Only stumbled on POLKA-DOT having NHO of Polk before, and STREAKED where I had to scratch my head for a while before parsing.
Thanks Rotter and Setter
Anyway thanks, Rotter. I enjoyed this puzzle but slowly.
In Cumberland in days of yore people would say NOW THEN as a greeting.
Congrats to winners of the Rotter awards!
Based on the times above, probably should have done better. Enjoyed 20ac “All Right”, 22ac “Streaked” and 16ac “Chat Show”.
FOI — 1ac “Spit”
LOI — 22ac “Streaked”
COD — 11dn “Hatchback”
Thanks as usual!
Will now have to have a look at Rotters list for 2021.
P.S. Why does BACK mean ‘second’?
Mrs Random “whizzed” through the grid until she got stuck right at the end. STREAKED was her LOI, but she was hamstrung by spelling ASTAIRE incorrectly. In the end, 24 minutes for her today.
Many thanks to Tracy and Rotter (I will try to solve the award-winning clues a little later).
FOI – 1ac SPIT
LOI – 21dn LID
COD – 20ac ALL RIGHT
Thanks to Tracy and the Rotter
Lovely puzzle today — fairly straightforward but entertaining. We finished in 9 minutes.
FOI: SPIT
LOI: BRISK
COD: STREAKED and I liked ACID TEST too (great anagram).
Thanks Rotter and Tracy.
FOI Spit
LOI Polka dot
COD Streaked
Many thanks Tracy and Rotter. Thanks also for the league table — your cryptic of the year certainly justifies the use of the ubiquitous supporter 😅
Slightly held up at the end wondering how ISK could mean chance. D’oh!
Also liked POLKA-DOT.
But loved the Rotter Awards 🙂
Thanks Tracy and Mr R
It is probably a worrying sign that I am thinking in crosswordese too much that when I saw “former US president” in the clue for 8A and a K as one of the checkers, I immediately tried to fit Ike in there somewhere. But the other checkers soon put paid to that and Polk was dredged out of the deep memory to complete the clue. Not being that good on US history, I couldn’t have told you his dates though, or even a rough idea of them. Mind you my knowledge of my own country’s political history — eg prime ministers from the mid-19th century — is pretty ropy too.
Much enjoyed Rotter’s Awards, but I wonder if we might also have a list of “Rotter’s Raspberries” for clues that send eyebrows into orbit or otherwise elicit a groan. Anything to do with a certain school near Windsor would certainly make my list!
Cedric
Rotter’s IKEA clue of the year – Hurley QC 1923 – ‘French article, popular monk’s garment, editor finds lifeless’ (11) — UNINHABITED
Rotter’s COD of the year – Hurley QC 1823 – ‘Denied win, unwind in rugby playing, wine producing region’ (8) — BURGUNDY
Rotter’s DD / TD of the year – Joker QC 2013 – ‘Catherine earmarked money for cat’ (5) — KITTY
Rotter’s Anagram of the Year – Wurm QC 1783 – ‘We help in their shambolic call to vote’ (5-4,4) — THREE-LINE WHIP
Rotter’s Word of the Year – Noel QC 1893 – ‘Large stain ruined old pegs’ (6) — SPLODGE
Rotter’s Cryptic of the Year – Orpheus QC 1953 – ‘Indoctrinate supporter swimming off Hunstanton?’ (9) — BRAINWASH
If you need further help, I can only refer you to the original blogs.
Thanks again
Got bogged down on the RHS — streaker had me fooled for ages.
Well over the hour — watching the golf.
Viktor Hovland is quite a player.
I try to watch the footie while I’m doing the crossword,
That slows me down nicely!