Introduction
6:29. Some tricky stuff in here I was lucky to semi-biff. I’ll be parsing many of these clues fully for the first time as I write the blog!
Solutions
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation is otherwise irrelevant. Proper nouns will appear capitalized, but otherwise capitalization is irrelevant as well.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
After the solutions, I list all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in a Glossary.
Across
1 Record is set in Washington (4)
DISC = IS in D.C.
3 Stiff material [made from] deer and sheep (7)
BUCKRAM = BUCK + RAM
8 Good having confirmation of legality [for] indulgent pleasure (13)
GRATIFICATION = G + RATIFICATION
Lovely construction by Joker here!
9 Remains quiet after answer (3)
ASH = SH after A
10 Object to holiday in New Guinea initially (5)
THING = first letters of TO HOLIDAY IN NEW GUINEA
12 Move to a more upmarket café (7)
TEAROOM = anagram of TO A MORE
14 Mediterranean island reported big growth (7)
CYPRESS = homophone of CYPRUS
16 Ace / catch includes new spy (5)
AGENT = A + GET around N
17 Admit working full of whiskey (3)
OWN = ON around W
20 Blameworthy messing up order to replenish beer (13)
REPREHENSIBLE = anagram of REPLENISH BEER
Totally missed the wordplay here!
21 Joke about girl [being] strictly moral (7)
PURITAN = PUN around RITA
22 Clothes you and I / are having shortened (4)
WEAR = WE + ARE without last letter
Down
1 Assertive canine I caught eating carpet (8)
DOGMATIC = DOG + I + C around MAT
2 Samuel swallowing ecstasy [in] joint (4)
SEAM = SAM around E
3 Frustrate British brilliance (6)
BLIGHT = B + LIGHT
4 Devilish practice removing sulphur / after cleaner / fuel ultimately [is] fraud (12)
CHARLATANISM = SATANISM without S after CHAR + last letter of FUEL
I saw the CHAR and the SATANISM vaguely and biffed the answer.
5 Again take liberties so empire is reconstructed (8)
REIMPOSE = anagram of SO EMPIRE
An incredibly misleading definition!
6 Chaps getting / start of drugs fix (4)
MEND = MEN + first letter of DRUGS
7 Misunderstanding unfortunately denigrates me (12)
DISAGREEMENT = anagram of DENIGRATES ME
11 I’m / in favour of / exercising — right unfit (8)
IMPROPER = I’M + PRO + P.E. + R
13 Greek character / can, / always, [make] an insurrectionist (8)
MUTINEER = MU + TIN + E’ER
15 Single / man, heartlessly serious (6)
SOLEMN = SOLE + MAN without middle letter
18 Bag [of] grouse mostly (4)
GRIP = GRIPE without last letter
19 Arab League is partially competent (4)
ABLE = hidden in ARAB LEAGUE
I had a MER at ‘misunderstanding / DISAGREEMENT’ but it’s in Collins Thesaurus and I accept that in some circumstances they can be synonymous.
Edited at 2021-08-04 04:31 am (UTC)
For islands I also had Capri, trying to make ‘caprice’ fit. An early runner was ‘corsica’, which as a seven letter Mediterranean island starting with ‘c’ was very tempting for us biffers.
COD IMPROPER: just follow the recipe and in it goes.
Edited at 2021-08-04 09:54 am (UTC)
All perfectly fair and high quality clues, Joker was just a bit too good for me today. Finished in 16.18 with LOI GRIP.
Thanks to Jeremy for the blog and Joker for the workout
Lovely puzzle and very helpful blog
BW
Andrew
I liked DOGMATIC best of all, and apart from my LOI, everything was parsed.
6:46
I managed to keep going just about with several semi-biffs and LOI was TEAROOM as I was thinking coffee.
Time was 13:02.
Another high quality puzzle from Joker.
My favourite was DOGMATIC.
David
I liked GRATIFICATION, PURITAN, CHARLATANISM, MUTINEER, SOLEMN and the long anagrams REPREHENSIBLE and DISAGREEMENT. My LOI was actually BLIGHT.
Jeremy, I use the online version of the QC on my iPad and find myself flicking up and down the blog endlessly when I try to pick out my favourite clues whilst adding a comment. (My poor short-term memory does not allow me to memorise my ‘memorable’ clues as I go through the QC). I wonder if there is a way of including your very helpful glossary in the online version that avoids interposing it as a long list between your blog and solver’s comments? Just a thought — I wouldn’t want to lose it but I find the format frustrating.
Many thanks to Joker and Jeremy. John M.
Edited at 2021-08-04 09:02 am (UTC)
I was just making a suggestion. Others may not be bothered by this. In which case, leave it as it is — it is a very useful glossary. Thanks.
Pam
Biffed many of the long ones. Had a PDM with e.g. cleaner=CHAR which helped but I did not fully parse several.
FOI DISC, LOI OWN.
Solved a few round the edge like BUCKRAM, MUTINEER, DOGMATIC but slowed to a crawl towards the end partic in SW.
Thanks vm, Jeremy.
On 7dn I expressed misgivings in my own posting above, but for a synonym definition to be valid it’s enough for it to apply in one context; it doesn’t have to fit every occasion, so despite my MER I concluded it was okay.
On 14ac, the homophone seems close enough to me but they’re often controversial. On the size issue it’s all relative, and ‘big’ doesn’t have to mean the largest possible.
Edited at 2021-08-04 04:47 pm (UTC)
I also was somewhat misled by the definition of 5dn, but couldn’t see it to be anything else. Nearly put “bright” for 3dn, but knew the parsing didn’t make sense until I had a pdm. 12ac took ages — mainly because I was thinking of some kind of Italian bistro type thing (ending in “more” or “mora”) — doh!
FOI — 6dn “Mend”
LOI — 18dn “Grip”
COD — 13dn “Mutineer”
Thanks as usual!
FOI – 1ac DISC
LOI – 15dn SOLEMN
COD – 1dn DOGMATIC. Also liked 8ac GRATIFICATION
Some great clues and lots of super misdirection today. Thanks, Jeremy, for the, as always, excellent blog and thanks, too, to joker
So many ticks and smiles, but the clue for 1d made me smile ruefully. The puppy hasn’t eaten any carpet yet but was having a jolly good go at the hearth rug last week. Not any damage there, but he has left teeth marks all over my new kitchen chairs! I did like ASH, OWN and GRIP a lot.
FOI Disc
LOI Blight
COD Cypress
Many thanks Joker for the fun and to Jeremy too
(Even briefer posting than usual — we’re getting ready for guests to arrive)
FOI: DISC
LOI: GRIP
COD: GRATIFICATION
Thanks Joker and Jeremy.
FOI DISC, LOI CYPRESS (I too was hung up on Capri, with occasional thoughts of Crete), COD TEAROOM.
Many thanks to the two Js.
Templar
FOI DISC
LOI CHARLATANISM
COD IMPROPER
TIME 3:36
COD 20 ac “reprehensible” — and so true as well!
Thanks to Jeremy for a most succinct blog and to Joker for his witty contribution.
I finally put down my pencil after 56 minutes, very pleased to have survived this offering from Joker. However, having now read plusjeremy’s blog, I am hugely disappointed to spot that my BRIGHT (for brilliance) should have been BLIGHT. I clearly forgot to check back with the whole clue once I had come up with my answer.
Mrs Random also toiled away for twice as long as usual, but she completed the puzzle successfully in 44 minutes.
Many thanks to Joker and plusjeremy.
So from feeling it was going to be a lazy DNF it slowly became a success. So I guess ultimately pleasing, but a hard grind and not too much fun for me in the process.
Thanks all
John George
… with some clues that were definitely testing I thought. All done in the end in 11 minutes, but more than 2 of those was on my LOI 4D Charlatanism, which refused to come quietly.
Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog
Cedric
DNF on charlatanism. I suppose if I’d known char for cleaner (bit Daily Telegraphish!) I could have biffed it as others did.
Also got Cyprus wrongly spelt — thought it was the actual island
Never heard of buckram but guessed it
Nick