Introduction
My solve is here: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1175154969
5:35, a nice time for my “birthday” puzzle. I was born in 1982. Cue snarky comments in 3…2…1…
General remarks
A brief summary of cryptic crosswords —feel free to skip— :
- Each clue has at least one “definition”: an unbroken string of words which more-or-less straightforwardly indicates the answer. A definition can be as simple as a one-word synonym; but it can also be a descriptive phrase like ‘I’m used to wind’ for REEL or SPOOL. A definition by example must be indicated by a phrase like ‘for example’, or, more commonly, a question mark (?). Thus ‘color’ is a definition of RED, while ‘red, for example’ or ‘red?’ are definitions of COLOR. Punctuation is otherwise irrelevant. Proper nouns will appear capitalized, but otherwise capitalization is irrelevant as well.
- Each clue may also have an unbroken string of words which indicates the answer through wordplay, such as: using abbreviations; reversing the order of letters; indicating particular letters (first, last, outer, middle, every other, etc); placing words inside other words; rearranging letters (anagrams); replacing words by words that sound alike (homophones); and combinations of the above. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but the general theme is to reinterpret ordinary words as referring to letters, so that for example ‘lion’s head’ indicates the first letter of LION: namely, L.
- Definitions and wordplay cannot overlap. The only other words allowed in clues are linking words or phrases that combine these. Thus we may see, for example: “(definition) gives (wordplay)” or “(definition) and (definition)” or “(wordplay) is (definition)”.
- The most common clues have either two definitions, or one definition plus wordplay, in either order. But a single, very misleading definition is not uncommon, and very occasionally a definition can also be interpreted as wordplay leading to the same answer. Triple definitions (and more) are also possible.
My conventions in the solutions below are to underline definitions (including a defining phrase); put linking words in [brackets]; and put all wordplay indicators in boldface. I also use a solidus (/) to help break up the clue where necessary, especially for double definitions without linking words.
Here is a Glossary of all the wordplay indicators and abbreviations in this puzzle.
Glossary
Wordplay indicators
Abbreviations and little bits
Solutions
Across
1 Spoke enthusiastically, [as] one with radical views about Bible (5)
RAVED = RED around A.V.
4 A harp being played / by the Spanish artist (7)
RAPHAEL = anagram of A HARP + EL
8 Bill, a noble fellow abroad from what we hear (7)
ACCOUNT = homophone of A COUNT
9 Pulse [in] broth getting stirred (5)
THROB = anagram of BROTH
10 Wine difficult for prisoner to drink? No (10)
CHARDONNAY = HARD in CON + NAY
14 A child finally / gets round labyrinth full of wonder (6)
AMAZED = A + last letter of CHILD around MAZE
15 Dances around [to provide] pickled food (6)
CAPERS = double definition
Sneaky!
17 Country’s abandoning a / Greek island [as] a complete undivided unit (10)
INDISCRETE = INDIA’S without A + CRETE
20 Former PM [in] unproductive territory? (5)
HEATH = double definition
Chambers has “barren open country”.
22 It’s more frightening / needing to be in the barber’s seat for longer? (7)
HAIRIER = double definition
23 Recognise record getting “Merit” but not “Ace” (7)
DISCERN = DISC + EARN without A
24 Furry animal hiding in strange nettles (5)
GENET = hidden in STRANGE NETTLES
Chambers has “a carnivorous animal […] related to the civet”.
Down
1 The way travelled reportedly (4)
ROAD = homophone of RODE
2 Part of workshop [that is] failing (4)
VICE = double definition
3 Dicky guards the family members (9)
DAUGHTERS = anagram of GUARDS THE
This one fooled me.
4 Answer dealing with / wrongful act (6)
RETORT = RE + TORT
5 Head of university occupying sort of training place (3)
PUT = first letter of UNIVERSITY in P.T.
6 Fixed agenda modified / to accommodate bishop (8)
ARRANGED = anagram of AGENDA around R.R.
7 Old boy taking Times / with inclination to go round [as] campaigner (8)
LOBBYIST = OB + BY in LIST
11 Glove puppet isn’t / under control (2,1,6)
ON A STRING = (another) double definition
12 Exceptionally bad sin — he [gets] cast into the wilderness? (8)
BANISHED = anagram of BAD SIN HE
Sneaky past tense there.
13 Difficult nutcases? You see them on building sites! (4,4)
HARD HATS = HARD + HATS
‘Nut’ = ‘head’ so ‘nutcase’ = HAT. That’s two times we had ‘difficult’ = ‘hard’ in this puzzle.
16 Mischievous child [and] companion in old city / home (6)
URCHIN = CH in UR + IN
18 Mark something of one’s ignorance (4)
SIGN = hidden in ONE’S IGNORANCE
19 Courage / that may help motorist on winter drive (4)
GRIT = (yet another) double definition
But “X is indiscrete” would be synonymous with “X is a complete undivided unit”, no?
I thought I was galloping through this but then ground to a halt. I didn’t know AV= Bible for 1 AC and took me a while to get the very obvious 1D. I also spent a good few minutes on my LOI Capers. So out of SCC at around 17 mins but not the speed record I thought it might be at the start. I also had a typo in 5d
Finished in 12.49.
Thanks to Jeremy and to Izetti for a quality puzzle that had me chasing my tail.
Happy birthday to you Jeremy, you young whippersnapper !
FOI RAVED
LOI ON A STRING
COD INDISCRETE
TIME 3:34
Not helped by having fat-fingeredly typed HART HATS, which meant INDISCRETE was my LOI. Had to write out the anagrist for BANISHED as well.
I liked HAIRIER.
9:22.
Nice puzzle!
Thanks for the blog
BW
Andrew
Edited at 2021-10-13 08:45 am (UTC)
A neat coincidence blogging the 1982nd crossword. (I’m also celebrating my birthday today, but my 61 years are clearly taking their toll).
No snarky remarks, young man! Happy birthday and thanks, plusjeremy
EDIT – Note to self: Must pay more attention to Jeremy’s use of punctuation when referring to his ‘birthday’ puzzle.
Edited at 2021-10-13 09:27 am (UTC)
DNK “AV” for Bible (thought 1ac may be “Rabid”) nor Genet. But the greatest head scratcher for me was 15ac “Capers” with a lot of time spent trying to find an anagram out of dances. Other difficulties included parsing the last part of 23ac “Discern” and 7db “Lobbyist”. What’s the “Times” element got to do with it?
However, at least I remembered “RR” for bishop!
FOI — 9ac “Throb”
LOI — 15ac “Capers”
COD — 11dn “On a string”
Thanks as usual!
PS. Noticed in the printed paper that Izetti was spelt izetti…has it always been thus or a typo?
4×4 = 4 times 4 = 4 by 4.
Edited at 2021-10-13 01:36 pm (UTC)
I was unhappy about 15a having become convinced it was anagram of Dances; hence CADENS. I could not think of any pickled food bar onions.
Genet unknown.
NO complaints; Izetti is always firm but fair.
David
Liked RAPHAEL, INDISCRETE, (undivided?), BANISHED. Not held up by DAUGHTERS as met recently in another Xword book. Could not parse LOBBYIST. FOI ACCOUNT.
Dicky is an old-fashioned word for dodgy or unreliable or e.g. a character in, say, an Agatha Christie might have a dicky heart.
Thanks and many happy returns, Jeremy.
Edited at 2021-10-13 12:03 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2021-10-13 09:11 am (UTC)
Spent ages thinking what “dicky” might be (Nixon, a Dinner Jacket) did not see it as an anagram indicator (number 532 on my list)
Also felt GRIP was a fair answer for GRIT, as in “Get a Grip”
NHO GENET
COD CHARDONNAY, though a bolder setter might have clued it
Wine gives a cold erection, no? (10)
FOI Raved
LOI Capers
COD Daughters — brilliant!
Many thanks Izetti and Jeremy (not the actual day today, I take it?)
Later: have just had a go at the 15×15 — I didn’t quite finish today (just two to go) but a couple of words from this crossword appeared which did help a bit! Coincidence? Or are the lizards taking over 😉
Edited at 2021-10-13 01:24 pm (UTC)
COD 22 ac “hairier” which raised a smile.
I wonder if some will comment that this puzzle is pitched at level too high for a QC and while I would sympathise, I also think it’s important for these puzzles to cover a range of difficulty, so that people new to cryptic crosswords can measure their progress towards solving the 15 x 15. And of course this site can be particularly helpful in this regard as well.
Thanks (and many happy returns) to Jeremy and to Don.
However, I think there are a few people who think the QC has shifted to being more difficult over the last year. The question is whether the QC equivalent “Overton Window” has moved with it.
Six balls for a century, opening range of acceptable policies (7,6)
So is there a conscious decision by the powers that be to gradually increase the difficulty? I think we should be told….
Its raison d’être is that it is “Quick”. It is simply meant to be solved in a fraction of the time of the main puzzle. That is why it is smaller, for example, and that is why some of the wordplay is much more straightforward. Naturally, these elements often contribute to making Quick Cryptics more appropriate for beginners, but that’s not why these puzzles exist. And sometimes these same elements can make Quick Cryptics harder for beginners: a smaller grid means fewer footholds, and a larger percentage of the puzzle depends on answering each clue. Also, there’s a lot of reliance on chestnuts and abbreviations which will allow more experienced solvers to finish quickly.
I’ve made the point several times (but most people disagree with me on this point) that in many cases the main puzzle might be more satisfying for a beginner, because there are more clues, more places to get a foothold, less chances to be stymied by one difficult clue, more clues that can be solved by “pure” wordplay rather than knowing chestnuts and abbreviations.
Sure, the main puzzle will be harder to finish completely, but I still stand by my statement that in many cases the main puzzle would be nicer to work on for a beginner. Certainly for me (and I was a beginner until very recently), I got better as a solver through the main puzzle, not the Quickie — which I mainly use to speed solve.
Edited at 2021-10-13 04:56 pm (UTC)
Honestly, I have no idea — it feels like it is, but that’s no scientific study and it seems experienced solvers don’t see much difference. However, if there is a slight shift then it’s probably bound to be more felt by those who are less experienced than those that aren’t.
Anyway its a fascinating subject and the emphasis on enjoyment is what is key. And a pleasng diversion from supply chains and heaven knows what else!
… saw me home with all parsed in 16 minutes. I was another who tried to find an anagram of dances for 15A Capers — great clue and a real PDM when I worked it out.
NHO 17A Indiscrete: I am always confusing discreet and discrete so this one was bound to cause me problems. But solved from wordplay and then looked up so Another Thing Learned.
A good puzzle and a most enjoyable workout. Many thanks to Jeremy for the blog.
Cedric
I was fortunate to see DAUGHTERS before realising it was an anagram, and many other clues had tobe written in faintly at first, before fully parsing later in the process. I had NHO GENET, but it had to be, and my LOI was CAPERS, which I found during an alphabet-trawl, having not trusted my initial guess (CADENS).
Mrs Random has just finished her effort in 38 minutes, thereby blowing my time out of the water by 1 minute (Drat!). Her LOI was also CAPERS, and she also fell into the anagram-of-DANCES trap.
What a difficult week, so far!
Many thanks to Izetti and William.
I know we can all find our preferred definition/spelling of words in some reference work or other. I simplify dislike the use of z in place of s. John
I can only find authorized spelt with a z in my phone Oxford Dictionary. It doesn’t allow the version with s.
Mind you, when I was doing my journalism training in the 70s, we were taught always to use an S rather than Z — more modern, and certainly house style in pretty much all UK publications these days, I’d say.
One language has gone even further — Icelandic has removed Z from the alphabet (quite recently, within the last 60 years) and replaced them all with S. Including in the Icelandic word for Icelandic, which was Íslenzkur and is now officially Íslenskur.
It caused a real problem when the verb “to zoom” became so common 18 months ago. Technically the Icelandic should be “súma”, but since all Icelanders speak English, it rapidly became “zooma”.
Cedric
So bible = ‘AV’ does it, are setters just making up random abbreviations for bible now ?
Why not ‘GB’ for Good Book or ‘CM’ Christian’s Manual ?
Hope that small group fo experts had some fun with this one – God help the rest of us.
When I started doing these, it was a satisfying journey to somewhere where I could complete 3/4 of them — now I never do. And whatever others say , the main puzzle I find impossible.
I don’t see why it should be designed as equal in difficulty to the main puzzle — where can those of us who’ll probably never get that far get satisfaction from finishing one?
Sorry, this has turned into a rant. But I really miss the earlier ones.
Diana
These days, I will fail to complete the QC, at least once a week and the other days, it’s around the 20-minute mark, for a parsed finish.
More experience usually = quicker, for most skills, so my take on it is that the QC is becoming more difficult. I’m not enjoying it, as I used to.
Since the AV dates from 1604, Authorized Version looks correct.
Its raison d’être is that it is “Quick”. It is simply meant to be solved in a fraction of the time of the main puzzle. That is why it is smaller, for example, and that is why some of the wordplay is much more straightforward. Naturally, these elements often contribute to making Quick Cryptics more appropriate for beginners, but that’s not why these puzzles exist. And sometimes these same elements can make Quick Cryptics harder for beginners: a smaller grid means fewer footholds, and a larger percentage of the puzzle depends on answering each clue. Also, there’s a lot of reliance on chestnuts and abbreviations which will allow more experienced solvers to finish quickly.
I’ve made the point several times (but most people disagree with me on this point) that in many cases the main puzzle might be more satisfying for a beginner, because there are more clues, more places to get a foothold, less chances to be stymied by one difficult clue, more clues that can be solved by “pure” wordplay rather than knowing chestnuts and abbreviations.
Sure, the main puzzle will be harder to finish completely, but I still stand by my statement that in many cases the main puzzle would be nicer to work on for a beginner. Certainly for me (and I was a beginner until very recently), I got better as a solver through the main puzzle, not the Quickie — which I mainly use to speed solve.
Definitely an intention there to attract beginners and inexperienced solvers with a view to graduating to the main puzzle.
Usually by this time everything has been said. But not today! Can I offer an alternative take on 8ac ACCOUNT with the definition at the other end of the clue. Bill = AC | a noble fellow abroad = COUNT | [from] what we hear = ACCOUNT.
That’s all from me. Good night
Edited at 2021-10-14 02:34 pm (UTC)
Sincerely,
Little Lord Humblebrag
-LLH
FOI: THROB
LOI: CAPERS
COD: ON A STRING
Thanks Izetti and Jeremy.