At 7 minutes I found this one straightforward but I shall be interested to read how others fared, especially our most recent recruits.
Before getting down to business, Jonathan (vinyl1) has asked me to post this message for the benefit of QC contributors who may not have seen it in his 15×15 blog last week, and I am happy to oblige:
…a word from TfTT Management. Some of the commenters have been posting pictures in their comments, which takes up a lot of space on the page and may be distracting to others. Live Journal is not consistent in their treatment of these posts, and you may get just a picture URL on the platform you are on, but that doesn’t mean that the whole picture won’t show up for those using actual computers. I am therefore requesting that you, our honored and honorable commenters, not do this. Thanks for your cooperation!
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions and substitutions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]. I usually omit all reference to positional indicators unless there is a specific point that requires clarification.
Across | |
1 | Good-humoured judge with eyepiece (7) |
JOCULAR : J (judge), OCULAR (eyepiece). I didn’t know ‘ocular’ as a noun. | |
5 | Unlikely to add up if short (4) |
TALL : TALL{y} (add up) [short]. ‘Tall stories’ are unlikely ones. ‘Tally / add up’ can be literal or figurative. | |
7 | Peninsula in Russian region (not south) (6) |
IBERIA : {s}IBERIA (Russian region) [not south – s] | |
8 | Hunted animal in stone pit (6) |
QUARRY : Two meanings | |
9 | Jo expecting a baby? Me too (4,3,4) |
JOIN THE CLUB : JO, then IN THE CLUB (expecting a baby – slang). Collins explains the meaning of JOIN THE CLUB: said to indicate that you have had the same experiences or feelings as someone who has been telling you about their problems or how they feel. | |
10 | Charm, a cross, first of three (6) |
AMULET : A, MULE (crossbreed), T{hree} [first of…] | |
12 | Pie keeping hot with foil (6) |
THWART : TART (pie) containing [keeping] H (hot) + W (with). I’m sure when I were a lad ‘pies’ were closed pastry dishes and tarts were open ones, but the distinction seems to have been lost now, at least in the dictionaries. But perhaps what I was taught was wrong. | |
14 | Head of coin in change causes heated row (11) |
ALTERCATION : C{oin} [head of…] contained by [in] ALTERATION (change) | |
17 | Criticise a mother’s hat (6) |
PANAMA : PAN (criticise), A, MA (mother) | |
18 | Circuit to power computer (6) |
LAPTOP : LAP (circuit), TO, P (power) | |
20 | What travellers pay for food (4) |
FARE : Two meanings | |
21 | The M25, for example — what may be said about small section? (7) |
ORBITAL : ORAL (what may be said) containing [about] BIT (small section). The circular motorway around Greater London. |
Down | |
1 | Jack on outside broadcast work (3) |
JOB : J (Jack – cards), OB (outside broadcast – TV jargon) | |
2 | Friendly drink (7) |
CORDIAL : Two meanings | |
3 | Smallest article in case put outside (5) |
LEAST : LEST (in case) contains [put outside] A (indefinite article) | |
4 | Petition concerning hunt (7) |
REQUEST : RE (concerning), QUEST (hunt) | |
5 | Runs inside dog track (5) |
TRAIL : R (runs – cricket) contained by [inside] TAIL (dog) | |
6 | Poet‘s line daughter stuck in Rob Roy novel with note (4,5) |
LORD BYRON : L (line), then D (daughter) contained by [stuck in] anagram [novel] of ROB ROY, then N (note). He attended Harrow School, don’t y’know? | |
9 | Cajun dish Juliet baked originally in a former British colony (9) |
JAMBALAYA : J (Juliet – phonetic alphabet), then B{aked] [originally] contained by [in] A + MALAYA (former British colony). The dish as celebrated in song by Hank Williams in 1952. | |
11 | A big blow to our sailors over a party (7) |
TORNADO : TO, RN (our sailors – Royal Navy), A, DO (party) | |
13 | Dog beat favourite (7) |
WHIPPET : WHIP (beat), PET (favourite) | |
15 | Guy drinks last of wine (5) |
TEASE : TEAS (drinks), {win}E (last of…] | |
16 | Impromptu remark from awkward lad I bowled (2-3) |
AD-LIB : Anagram [awkward] of LAD I, then B (bowled – cricket). Here it is again! Can we please have a break from ad-lib? | |
19 | Starts to order in lighter fuel (3) |
OIL : O{rder} + I{n} + L{ighter} [starts] |
Time, 7:00.
FOI 1dn JOB (for our esteemed blogger as was AD LIB)
LOI 4dn REQUEST
COD 6dn LORD BYRON again!
WOD The aforementioned Cajun dish at 9dn
I took the 9.45 this morning – I expect some newbies will miss their stop.
Edited at 2020-12-21 02:30 am (UTC)
Thanks Jack and Tracy for a puzzle that I seemed for once to be on the right wavelength.
COD JOIN THE CLUB.
Interesting comments on pastry typologies Jack. The recent habit of claiming something with pastry resting on top is a pie is controversial so this is certainly contested territory, so the focus there is on the bottom. On tarts, I’d be disappointed if an apple tart came without at least a lattice on the top – although I’d be less fussy for a treacle tart.
Edited at 2020-12-21 10:21 am (UTC)
I started doing the QC together a year ago, first on paper, lately
the app — today 18:44. Your tips have made all the difference !
Thought today was relatively plain sailing, though not sure defn of 15d.
Finished in 7.57 with LOI ALTERCATION with TALL just pipping JOCULAR for my COD.
Edited at 2020-12-21 09:30 am (UTC)
Edited at 2020-12-21 11:56 am (UTC)
FOI: 16d AD-LIB
LOI: 9d JAMBALAYA
30 Minute Mark: 13
60 Minute Mark: 20
Time before use of aids: 33 mins
Total Answered: 20/24
I was rather hoping that, seeing as the world is supposed to end (again) today, fate would allow me my first completion of the QC. Alas it was not so, and I guess I am to be vaporised still a QC virgin.
Another DNF, with 4 short this time. At first I had entered AD-HOC as my FOI (16d), but I quickly realised this was wrong.
15d TEASE still puzzles me. I can’t see how Guy = Tease.
Took me almost my allotted hour to answer 9a JOIN THE CLUB. I keep thinking of ME TOO as in the hashtag. Just couldn’t get that out of my mind.
12a also stumped me as I concentrated too much on the first word (pie) being the definition.
Happy Winter Solstice everybody, or happy Armageddon.
Edited at 2020-12-21 10:02 am (UTC)
A gentle puzzle with some familiar answers. You wait ages for Lord Byron to turn up and here he is again.
LOI was TALL. COD to WHIPPET. Under 9 minutes on paper. David
FOI JOCULAR, LOI JOIN THE CLUB, COD THWART (I agree with your distinction between pies and tarts, Jack), time 3.6K for a Terrible Day. Next!
Thanks Tracy and Jack.
Templar
…and a bit of a plod through. Finished in 11 minutes, but not without hesitating several times (in particular I was not familiar with Ocular as a noun in 1A, or Tease as a synonym for guy in 15D – I was, as no doubt Tracy intended, looking for a man’s name).
I smiled at 16D Ad lib and knew there would be comments here. It is quite extraordinary how not very common words appear 2, 3, sometimes even more times in quick succession. I wonder if the setters are playing a private game to see if they can fit the “word of the moment” in.
COD 9A Join the club – very clever.
Many thanks to Jack for the blog, and having been one of the guilty ones, strictures on photos noted.
Cedric
But I enjoyed the puzzle. FOsI JOCULAR, LORD BYRON, JOB, IBERIA
LOI, or rather last correct one,THWART. COD JOIN THE CLUB
Thanks all, as ever.
Edited at 2020-12-21 11:00 am (UTC)
IBERIA appeared just last week.
Guy=Tease. Don’t get me started.
Very much liked ALTERCATION and JOIN THE CLUB. But Cod for PANAMA, which made me smile. Probably been done before, but new on me.
BTW the 15×15 is not too bad today, especially the NW corner which felt like almost like QC.
Edited at 2020-12-21 11:07 am (UTC)
FOI – 1ac JOCULAR
LOI – 15dn TEASRE
COD – 9ac JOIN THE CLUB
9a was a shoe-in, showing my age I guess.
FOI was 19d, the last one I looked at, and it gradually developed from there, but very slowly.
I never seem to find Mondays easy somehow, and no anagrams didn’t help.
WOD THWART, it takes me back to many happy days sailing before we sold our lovely boat.
Thank you, Tracy and Jack.
Diana
FOI: jocular
LOI: tease
COD: join the club
Thanks for the blog Jackkt and your seasonal avatar.
I tackle the puzzles in the old-fashioned way – using pencil and paper, so my rather embarrassing times don’t appear on the leader board. I also don’t permit myself to use any aids, electronic or otherwise – competition rules, I presume.
When I started, I was managing to solve fully about one in every three or four puzzles, but I now have an overall solve rate of 51% (74 of 146 puzzles). My average time to solve hasn’t really changed all that much, but I am often much quicker nowadays to the point at which I get stuck (typically with 4-5 clues to go).
I found today’s puzzle by Tracy really tough going and finished in 68 minutes, with the last 35 minutes spent on my final five clues (5a, 6d, 9d, 10a and 15d). However, it wasn’t a DNF and, for me, that’s counts as a good day. Many thanks to Tracy for the puzzle and to jackkt for the explanation.
68mins for today’s puzzle is perfectly respectable after just 6 months at this game. Pretty soon it will just be the curse of the last one (or perhaps two) that gives you grief, but either way the enjoyment of cracking the clues is what counts.
Edited at 2020-12-21 08:59 pm (UTC)
FOI JOCULAR
LOI ORBITAL
COD JAMBALAYA
TIME 3:02
This puzzle was just achievable with a lucky guess on 15dn. Took a while to get going as is the norm but it gradually revealed itself for a satisfying post lunch workout.
Thanks to the bloggers for their excellent contributions and improving my technique of cyrptics.
Graham
I also DNK “tease” = guy, and was getting ready for my usual annoyance that it was some obscure man’s name – but luckily I took a punt at it being something even more obscure. Will have to add that one to the list.
Other than that – a good workout with some nice clues. NW went in a bit too easy so I braced myself for something harder in the rest of the grid. Liked the contradiction of “tall” for 5ac with “short” in the wordplay, 9ac “Join the Club” and 4dn “Request”.
FOI – 1dn “Job”
LOI – 13dn “Whippet”
COD – 11dn “Tornado”
Thanks as usual.
11 mins, stuck on least, whippet, and thwart.
COD Tease or whippet.
But I do get to see everyone else’s comments. There’s a theme about words coming up for the second time, or the third, or more. I count four today: IBERIA, LORD BYRON, AMULET and of course AD LIB. Coincidence? It’s hard to believe but, if not, what’s happening?
Had to grapple with LEAST and TRAIL (too many dogs). I liked THWART, and I like Apple tarts but with a pastry lattice on top they are half way to being apple pies. COD ORBITAL. kap