My clue of the day is 5dn, only because “pother” is such a lovely word. I also liked the well-disguised definitions in 28ac and 6dn. Thanks to the setter for a very enjoyable puzzle.
Clues are in blue, with definitions underlined. Anagram indicators are in bold italics. Answers are in BOLD CAPS, followed by the wordplay. (ABC*) means ‘anagram of ABC’, deletions are in {curly brackets}.
Across
1 Haul put back beside church in valley (5)
GULCH: LUG backwards, then CH.
4 Source of wine, mulled, perhaps — peppery stuff? (9)
GRAPESHOT: GRAPES of course, HOT from being mulled. Peppered with gunfire, in this case.
9 Meat company importing a lot of hoax wine (9)
LAMBRUSCO: LAMB / RUS{e} / CO.
10 Difficulty entertaining millions with a dance (5)
RUMBA: M in RUB, then add A.
11 Insect was initially found in each fiddle (6)
EARWIG: EA / RIG, with W{as} inserted.
12 Queen to marry in this decade? (8)
THIRTIES: insert R and TIE in THIS. Yes, it’s a decade. No, she didn’t marry until 1947.
14 Father crying sadly about English words of praise (9)
PANEGYRIC: PA (CRYING*), and insert E for English.
16 Transport system satisfied staff will need day off (5)
METRO: MET / RO{d}.
17 Would rather, having no power to pass on (5)
REFER: {p}REFER.
19 Some journey to catch good bit of game? (9)
PARTRIDGE: PART RIDE, and insert G for good.
21 Crime writer to emerge after penning note on chapter (8)
CHRISTIE: CH for chapter, then RISE around the note TI.
22 Seafood sensitivity initially affected one (6)
SCAMPI: S{ensitivity}, CAMP, I.
25 Closer in middle of fun run (1,4)
U BOLT: U in the middle of {f}U{n}, then BOLT. I nearly wrote in U BOOT without further thought, but saved by divine intervention! A rather elliptical definition … to me, a u-bolt seems more like it fixes things rather than closes them.
26 Clot spoiled catalogue (9)
COAGULATE: (CATALOGUE*).
27 Flower, say, brought in for one seasonal gift (6,3)
EASTER EGG: ASTER and EG=say, inside EG=for one! Refreshingly unusual that a flower is flora, not a river!
28 Be coming in at six even when kept back (5)
EXIST: reverse hidden answer. Delightfully unassuming definition!
Down
1 Pay-off presumably not going down like a lead balloon? (6,9)
GOLDEN PARACHUTE: cryptic definition.
2 Large misgiving after beheading mammal (5)
LEMUR: L{arge} {d}EMUR. I don’t think of DEMUR as a noun, but the dictionary allows it.
3 Hero of opera in girl’s series of operas (7)
HERRING: HER / RING, as in the Wagner operas.
4 Effusiveness upsets son in expression of affection (4)
GUSH: S in HUG, reversed.
5 About to be involved in a commotion over variable old pharmacist (10)
APOTHECARY: CA in A POTHER, then Y is the variable.
6 Oppose relinquishing initial spirit, one hears (7)
EARDRUM: {b}EARD, then RUM. I think of BEARD as confront more than oppose, but again it’s in the dictionary. Clever that “one hears” is the definition, rather than indicating a homophonic clue.
7 Inept writing possessed by the writer — had to restrict that (3-6)
HAM-FISTED: a “Russian doll” clue … FIST inside ME inside HAD.
8 Limit heatstroke with treatment, getting encouraging response (5,4,4,2)
THAT’S MORE LIKE IT: (LIMIT HEATSTOKE*).
13 Tip of rocket in police cordon possibly evidence of alien visitation? (4,6)
CROP CIRCLE: R in COP, then CIRCLE=cordon.
15 Developed for use in a base (9)
NEFARIOUS: (FOR USE IN A*).
18 Very much in character, shedding pounds, picking up award (7)
ROSETTE: SO=very much, LETTER=character. Put one inside the other, lose L for pound (sterling), and turn upside down. Did anyone actually solve this from the wordplay, rather than biff it from the helpers?
20 One’s not involved regarding items for detective, seeing twist at the end (7)
RECLUSE: RE=regarding, CLUES for detectives, twist the last two letters.
23 I damage upcoming resort (5)
MIAMI: I MAIM, upside down.
24 Criticise an end to grieving or strong emotion (4)
PANG: PAN=criticise, G from grieving.
Edited at 2017-12-23 09:32 am (UTC)
FOI 1a GULCH, which was a nice start; LOsI the crossers of U-BOLT and ROSETTE, which I probably did have to painstakingly work out from the wordplay. Sometimes those biffs just don’t appear. Looks like I enjoyed the double-EGging of 27a.
Thanks for the explanations; I didn’t know “pother”, the eponymous opera hero, nor that meaning of “demur”…
Edited at 2017-12-23 01:27 pm (UTC)
Does anybody here ever win a £20 voucher? Just curious.
Phil R
Edited at 2017-12-23 02:27 pm (UTC)
Have to say, I’d wager that WHSmith will be the next major UK high street retailer to go bankrupt, given what it feels like every time I go in there. Feels like the chain that time forgot: very much like Woolies did just before they went under.
In answer to Phil R, I have won the L20 voucher twice but now the powers-that-be have decided to exclude non-UK residents from the drawing (yah boo). A WHSmith voucher is in fact no use at all in NYC so I donated the second one to a nephew in London. The first one I attempted to use at Heathrow on my way home from a visit and chaos ensued. It was too much for the check-out clerk to deal with so she summoned the manager who looked at it as if it had been a Sanskrit cuneiform so she had to phone for instructions. Meanwhile a long and justifiably infuriated queue built behind me… Good luck!
16.04 which was just good enough for 140th place out of 300 in the ludicrous weekend standings.
Edited at 2017-12-23 02:30 pm (UTC)
And I have never won a prize despite now having submitted many entries. I stopped sending in by post when I calculated I’d spent about £20 on postage! I wonder how they select winners when many enter online and others by post. David
Ong’ara,
Kenya.