I needed a little over an hour for this one with several guesses which fortunatley proved to be correct. As I started preparing the blog I still didn’t have all the parsings but I arrived at them whilst writing.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions and substitutions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]
| Across | |
| 1 | Helicopter heading off, one making short trip? (6) |
| HOPPER – {c}HOPPER (helicopter) [heading off]. A dead easy start as we had ‘chopper/helicopter’ only a few puzzles back. | |
| 4 | Piano player ultimately avoids Chopin’s pieces maybe (8) |
| PRELUDES – P (piano), {playe}R [ultimately], ELUDES (avoids). Chopin wrote a cycle of 24 Preludes covering all major and minor keys, plus 3 others that stand alone. | |
| 10 | Problem with electricity supply has firm in torment (7) |
| SCOURGE – SURGE (problem with electricity supply] contains [has…in] CO (firm) | |
| 11 | Agreement to impose restraining influence on prisoner (7) |
| CONCORD – CON (prisoner), CORD (restraining influence) following the ‘A on B = BA’ rule for Across clues. | |
| 12 | Appealed, having switched sides, for subs (4) |
| DUES – SUED (appealed) becomes DUES when its end letters are swapped over [switched sides]. ‘Subs’ in this context are ‘subscriptions’, ‘dues’ which have to be paid. | |
| 13 | Artful nude, terribly dishonest (10) |
| FRAUDULENT – Anagram [terribly] of ARTFUL NUDE | |
| 15 | Caution about English — result of much study? (9) |
| WEARINESS – WARINESS (caution) containing [about] E (English). I had no idea what was going on here but I have now found this quotation from Ecclesiastes in the King James version of the Bible which I assume is the reference in question: And further, by these, my son, be admonished: of making many books there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh. | |
| 16 | Plant for making mixed drink (5) |
| SHRUB – Another guess for me here and I so nearly went for ‘scrub’. Collins advises that ‘shrub’ is a mixed drink of rum, fruit juice, sugar, and spice. News to me! | |
| 18 | The French officer retreats, becoming confined (5) |
| LOCAL – LA (the, French) + COL (officer) reverses [retreats] | |
| 19 | Fellow works to produce plan (9) |
| MANOEUVRE – MAN (fellow), OEUVRE (works) | |
| 21 | Bit of skeleton encountered west of a Turkish city (10) |
| METATARSUS – MET (encountered), TARSUS (Turkish city). A group of 5 bones in the human foot. | |
| 23 | Shopping facility everyone’s found by motorway (4) |
| MALL – M (motorway), ALL (everyone). The clue follows the ‘on’ rule pattern here (as mentioned at 11ac) although we have ‘by’ instead of ‘on’. IIRC ‘A by B’ can mean AB or BA, but others’ views on this would be appreciated. | |
| 26 | Ace, endlessly gloomy, has nothing lovingly expressed (7) |
| AMOROSO – A (ace), MOROS{e} (gloomy) [endlessly], 0 (nothing). In this context it’s a musical expression, most usually translated as ‘tenderly’. | |
| 27 | Democrat in running to be US President once (7) |
| HARDING – D (Democrat) contained by [in] HARING (running). President Warren G Harding served barely half a term (1921-23), dying of a heart attack whilst in office. | |
| 28 | He has batted in cricket match briefly — in struggle for this? (3,5) |
| THE ASHES – Anagram [batted] of HE HAS contained by [in] TES{t} (cricket match) [briefly] | |
| 29 | Male leading Queen, an experienced performer (6) |
| STAGER – STAG (male), ER (Queen) | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Orthodox believer possesses half-formed notion (5) |
| HASID – HAS (possesses), ID{ea} (notion) [half-formed] | |
| 2 | Claim poet is misguided, having old-fashioned ideas about the stars? (9) |
| PTOLEMAIC – Anagram [misguided] of CLAIM POET. I didn’t know the word but ‘Ptolemy’ was familiar so I worked from there. I know nothing of astronomy but I gather his theories held sway for many a year until they were discarded in favour of somebody else’s. | |
| 3 | Make listener listen finally (4) |
| EARN – EAR (listener), {liste}N [finally] | |
| 5 | Precious one getting lost somehow gets back (7) |
| RECOUPS – Anagram [somehow] of PREC{i}OUS [one getting lost] | |
| 6 | Hiding pain, the Parisian wastes away (10) |
| LANGUISHES – LES (the, Parisian) containing [hiding] ANGUISH (pain) | |
| 7 | Crowd departs on journey lacking purpose? (5) |
| DROVE – D (departs), ROVE (journey lacking purpose) | |
| 8 | Team on top of list? One could be up against the wall! (4,5) |
| SIDE TABLE – SIDE (side), TABLE (list). Collins defines this simply as a table intended for placing against a wall. | |
| 9 | Charlie departing for good in order to get academic award (6) |
| DEGREE – DECREE (order) becomes DEGREE when C (Charlie) is replaced by [departing for] G (good) | |
| 14 | Disruptions — music-maker is not playing (10) |
| VIOLATIONS – VIOLA (music-maker), anagram [playing] of IS NOT | |
| 15 | Kind of average temperature after spring (4-5) |
| WELL-MEANT – WELL (spring), MEAN (average), T (temperature) | |
| 17 | Exposing cleric somewhere in London (9) |
| REVEALING – REV (cleric), EALING (somewhere in London). Historically part of my own home county of Middlesex. | |
| 19 | Place for three men in a boat, reported author (7) |
| MARLOWE – Sounds like [reported] MARLOW (place for three men in a boat). It’s probably helpful here to have only a superficial knowledge of Jerome K Jerome’s novel, i.e. just enough to realise the answer is going to be a place on the Thames somewhere between Kingston and Oxford. In fact 34 place names along the way are mentioned in the book. | |
| 20 | No time for stifling expression of disgust, revealing nothing (6) |
| NOUGHT – NO + T (time) containing [stifling] UGH (expression of disgust) | |
| 22 | Attempted to get lid off box of delights? (5) |
| TROVE – {s}TROVE (attempted) [to get lid off]. I wondered about the definition here but the ODO confirms ‘trove’ as ‘a store of valuable or delightful things’. | |
| 24 | Drink in African camp (5) |
| LAGER – Two meanings. The second more usually spelt ‘laager’, I think. | |
| 25 | Destructive fly makes one terrified (4) |
| FRIT – Two meanings. The second came up here recently but I didn’t know the ‘frit fly’ defined as ‘any of a family (Chloropidae) of tiny dipterous flies whose larvae destroy grain, esp. a black species’. | |
Having the crossers got me all the right letters into the right Ptolemaic orbits, ditto for my usually mis-spelt Manoeuvre. I did this for (almost) the first time on-line, and put my irritation down to pixels vs paper, but reading the comments above maybe it was the puzzle itself that was the root cause.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CCN8vwfVIAA6Kir.jpg
Edited at 2019-05-14 03:57 pm (UTC)
Basically, I thought this was a really poor puzzle. Guessed HASID as I’d heard of Hasidic Jews. DNK the fly, but the other meaning got me through.
FOU HOPPER
LOI DUES
COD THE ASHES (a diamond in the dirt)
TIME 13:35
Off to Iona, the only island in Scottish crosswordland, tomorrow. Will report back.
The three vowels (why _do_ the French do that sort of thing?) in MANOEUVRE always confuse me, so it’s as well that the checker from 6d eliminated 4 of the 6 possible options. HASID was an NHO, but I reverse-engineered it from “hasidic”.
The FRIT fly (which is presumably an even smaller version of the fruit fly, consisting of just the head and abdomen) was another NHO, but I still managed to justify the answer on the grounds that “fly” is a form of ash, often harsh and abrasive and therefore destructive; and a FRIT is also a sintered filter made from coarse particles, and so… well, now that I think of it, my reasoning eludes me. But it was good enough at the time.
NHO HARDING as a president, SHRUB as a drink, or MARLOWE (or indeed MARLOW), but they all seemed plausible. In summary, all the right answers, but not necessarily for the right reasons.
A DNF for me with FRIT unknown and with neither definition to be found in various searches before being directed here by one of them. Did enjoy working my way through the rest of the puzzle though.
A fair bit of general knowledge required with the Orthodox Jew, Three Men in a Boat and the towns that they visited, Christopher Marlowe, the Ancient Greek astronomer, the 29th POTUS and that ‘terrified fly’.
Thought that THE ASHES clue was the best from a surface perspective, the clever construction and the relevance of it.