This one delayed me for 44 minutes. Much of it was straightforward but I became bogged down over five clues, all on the right-hand side. There were two words unknown to me, one was the answer at 8dn and the other an element of the wordplay at 26ac, although in the latter case the answer was eminently biffable so my lack of GK was of no consequence.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]
Across | |
1 | What’s expected of orchestra, pure playing (3,3,3,6) |
PAR FOR THE COURSE – Anagram [playing] of OF ORCHESTRA PURE | |
9 | Neglected child needs caressing, housing of superior character (9) |
FOUNDLING – FONDLING (caressing) containing (housing) U (of superior character as in U / non-U) | |
10 | Seaman comes to island, back in old harbour (5) |
OSTIA – OS (seaman), AIT (island) reversed [back]. The ancient port of Rome. | |
11 | I beam, receiving collection of books — something to put on desk (2-4) |
IN-TRAY – I + RAY (beam) containing [receiving] NT (collection of books – New Testament) | |
12 | TV doctor had one work of fiction (8) |
WHODUNIT – WHO (TV doctor), ‘D (had), UNIT (one). It took me far to long to think of the TV doctor in question. Finlay, Kildare, even House were considered before the obvious one. I’d be more inclined to spell the answer WHODUNNIT, but the alternative single ‘N’ is permissable. | |
13 | Would-be lover wanting men at back of clubs? (6) |
SUITOR – SUIT (clubs?), OR (men – Other Ranks) | |
15 | Horse above average height, one reined in by boy (8) |
STALLION – TALL (above average height) + I (one) contained [reined in] by SON (boy) | |
18 | A bit that’s positive about Italian in honourable mention (8) |
CITATION – CATION (a bit that’s positive) containing [about] IT (Italian). The positive bit is a word I only know from crosswords. | |
19 | Consider hunt gatherings savage ultimately, on reflection (6) |
ESTEEM – MEETS (hunt gatherings), {savag}E [ultimately] reversed (on reflection). Not the most familiar usage of ‘esteem’ perhaps, but one can, for example, esteem it an honour to do something or other. | |
21 | Claim spa town is lacking hospital (8) |
ARROGATE – {h}ARROGATE (spa town) [lacking hospital]. | |
23 | Rocky location with risk — one approaching it may be doomed (6) |
GIBBET – GIB (rocky location – Gibraltar), BET (risk) followed by a cryptic definition | |
26 | Part of City invested in Indian money no longer (5) |
PIECE – EC (City – of London), contained by [invested in] PIE [Indian money no longer]. An old currency that’s beyond my ken. | |
27 | Insist on fan keeping quiet for minutes (9) |
STIPULATE – STI{m}ULATE (fan – as in ‘fan the flames’) changes m (minutes) to P (quiet) | |
28 | Release from complicated relationship — gentleman ends it with difficulty (15) |
DISENTANGLEMENT – Anagram [with difficulty] of GENTLEMAN ENDS IT |
Down | |
1 | Birds wanting home when caught in air currents (7) |
PUFFINS – IN (home) contained by [caught in] PUFFS (air currents) | |
2 | Stir created by French author’s introduction being cut (5) |
ROUST – {p}ROUST (French author) [introduction being cut] | |
3 | Possible clue to mad don being a misfit (3,3,3) |
ODD MAN OUT – The anagrind ‘out’ and anagrist ‘ODD MAN’ could possibly be part of a clue to which the answer might be ‘mad don’ | |
4 | Tease / silly person (4) |
TWIT – Two definitions | |
5 | Get weight reduced somehow — one component of breakfast food? (3,5) |
EGG WHITE – Anagram [somehow] of GET WEIGH{t} [reduced] | |
6 | Old invalid like Humpty Dumpty (5) |
OVOID – O (old), VOID (invalid) | |
7 | Like a memory of event — tries forgetting the end somehow (9) |
RETENTIVE – Anagram [somehow – again] of EVENT TRIE{s} [forgetting the end] | |
8 | Energy and most of remaining protein (7) |
ELASTIN – E (energy), LASTIN{g} (remaining) [most of…]. I didn’t know this word. | |
14 | Prisoners put down, observed to be upset (9) |
INTERNEES – INTER (put down – bury), SEEN (observed) reversed [upset] | |
16 | Freedom, with saints for the first time showing sluggishness (9) |
LASSITUDE – LA{t}ITUDE Freedom, with SS (saints) replacing [for] the first T (time) | |
17 | Foreign lady in trick, valuable person going the wrong way (8) |
CONTESSA – CON (trick), ASSET (valuable person) reversed [going the wrong way] | |
18 | Restricted in temporary accommodation to house refugees primarily (7) |
CRAMPED – CAMPED (in temporary accommodation) contains [to house] R{efugees} [primarily] | |
20 | Most intimate relations shown in a bit of coarse material (7) |
MATIEST – TIES (relations) contained by [shown in] MAT (bit of coarse material) | |
22 | Pick up from valley around start of autumn (5) |
GLEAN – GLEN (valley) containing [around] A{utumn} [start] | |
24 | Indifferent and mean, having trapped girl finally (5) |
BLASE – BASE (mean) contains [having trapped] {gir}L (finally) | |
25 | One of the players in the side (4) |
WING – Two meanings |
Having been the new Friday, Tuesday stands in danger of becoming the new Monday.
Arrogate/Harrogate is a bit of a chestnut, but I still took a long time to think of it. I couldn’t remember ‘Ostia’, either.
But I’m coming down with a cold, which I think is why I couldn’t break into the bottom half here…maybe I haven’t heard of (h)arrogate or internees, but contessa and cramped seem very gettable in retrospect. I resorted to reasoning that 18d & 14d would end in D & S, and so 28a would begin with DIS
Didn’t really enjoy this one, but again probably more to do with snot pouring from my nose than the quality of the clues. Liked whodunit
Thanks to setter and blogger
CITATION was biffed on the basis of having an IT in it, cations being well outside my ken.
I suppose GIBBET is a brilliant word for being as horrible as its referent. Me, I prefer thinking about PUFFINS (please don’t tell me they’re vicious little buggers — I don’t need any more illusions shattered)
The real hold up was the very easy 18dn CRAMPED!
DNK 8dn ELASTIN but it was an early write-in.
WOD 21ac ARROGATE (East End Tarn)
Thank-you Mr.bletchleyreject – I was completely unaware that there were 192 Pies to the Anna! Napoleon Bonaparte would turn in his grave!
Edited at 2017-11-07 07:01 am (UTC)
FOI 1a, COD 7d for “Like a memory” cluing RETENTIVE, WOD LASSITUDE, which seems appropriate to my mornings this week. DNK ARROGATE; ELASTIN was nearly unknown, but luckily I vaguely remembered both OSTIA and “ait” enough from previous encounters here to stick all the crossers in and get there…
Well done to all the championship competitors! Sounds like you had fun…
The two longest ones were among the easiest.
Edited at 2017-11-07 07:24 am (UTC)
Elastin wasn’t quite the, er, last in. That went to Gibbet.
Mostly I liked: Stipulate (COD) and the top line anagram’s surface reading.
Lots of part-knowns, but gettable: Ait, Twit (tease).
M.E.R. at ‘put down’.
Thanks to the matiest of setters and Jack.
Edited at 2017-11-07 09:16 am (UTC)
Particularly pleased with the two long anagrams and the two decent letter substitution clues, and the (well telegraphed) work-out-your-own-clue for ODD MAN OUT. No “hidden” today?
Nice to see our Spanish outpost mentioned – now that we in the UK have changed our clocks for winter, the time difference between us and Gibraltar is only 48 years.
Richard
One of ‘us lot’ is an FRPSL and has written ten books on philately and markophily.
‘All science is either physics or stamp collecting.’ Ernest Rutherford 1871-1937
QED
No real problems, and as usual, no real speed. 45+ minutes over several sittings.