Solving Time: 26 minutes, about average for my blog efforts. I suspect this may be on the harder side rather than the easier. It calls for some general knowledge (quite right too), a wee bit of science, bless it, and there are one or two tricky bits of cluing (translation: there are still some clues I haven’t worked out) – overall, a good crossword with nothing too controversial.
cd = cryptic definition, dd = double definition, rev = reversed, anagrams are *(–).
ODO means the Oxford Dictionaries Online
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | easy-going – (Captain) Marryat’s character = EASY + failing to stay = GOING. A familiar book to most people my age, I guess |
| 6 | shtum – Henrys’ returned = HS + bread basket = TUM. The H being a reference to the SI unit of magnetic inductance, I guess |
| 9 | crouton – heavy defeat = ROUT in racket = CON |
| 10 | zooming – ZOO + MING. I was all set to complain that Ming was a dynasty not an emperor, but Wiki says there have been seven Emperor Mings. Eight, if you include this one |
| 11 | let-up – don’t stop = allow = LET + climbing = UP. So presumably fell is the def., not sure if I have that right? |
| 12 | I Claudius – constant = C + praise = LAUD, in “couple in Latin” = II + US. A very neat clue indeed, top class. I Claudius being a very high-class novel by Robert Graves, plus film, play, TV, radio, you name it |
| 13 | part song – certain subjects = ARTS in PONG, the def being lay |
| 14 |
Brno – |
| 17 | romp – PROM, with the P moved from front to back. Dance = romp seems a teensy bit of a stretch to me |
| 18 | white tie – with = W + buffet = HIT + film = ET + that is = IE. White tie being what one wears when black tie is just not dressy enough.. |
| 21 | upholster – UP HOLST + ER |
| 22 | miles – Miles being a boy’s name, and far away.. seemed a bit weak to me, this one |
| 24 | Teheran – well, what = EH, time = ERA with a T at the front and N = noon at the rear.. I always used to know it as Tehran, when did the extra E get added? |
| 25 | ooziest – island – I in ducks = OO + relish = ZEST |
| 26 | yappy – programme = APP in axes = YY. I spent far too long trying to fit XY in somewhere |
| 27 |
Damascene – ASCEN |
| Down | |
| 1 |
excel – EX CEL |
| 2 |
shoot from the hip – |
| 3 | gatepost – wicket = GATE + stick = POST. As in “Between you, me and the…” |
| 4 | inn signs – “in sines,” a homophone. That’s sines as in cosines |
| 5 |
guzzle – |
| 6 | Shogun – appropriate = HOG in paper = SUN. This use of appropriate took a while to dawn on me |
| 7 |
trinitrotoluene – TRINIT |
| 8 | megastore – *(GASOMETER), an instant solve for me as I’ve seen it somewhere before and quite recently too, Though I’m not sure where. According to Google it was in a Guardian crossword in 2011 and also a Crossword Championship final in 2008. Interesting blog, that! |
| 13 |
parquetry – QU |
| 15 | Khartoum – “car tomb” |
| 16 |
atomizes – cat = TOM in |
| 19 | Blu-Ray – BLURRY, with one R changed to A. Don’t ask me about blu-ray, I’m still wondering what to do with all my cassettes |
| 20 |
stoned – |
| 23 |
Satie – |
I thought we were in for a pangram but we are missing J and V, I think. I liked the clues to OOZIEST and SHOGUN but I agree MILES is a bit feeble.
I wasted a while trying to fit BLUE RAY into 19dn which only goes to show how unobservant I am when it comes to new technology! My cassettes and LPs don’t concern me, but I have no means of playing my 78 collection at the moment.
Slogan backing Holst = “Up Holst!”
Rob
Besides the problem with ‘romp’, there were a few other quibbles. ‘Blu-ray’ is a storage medium, not a recording method, and a ‘part song’ is by no means a ‘lay’.
I knew Brno from the Brno Philharmonic, recorded by Supraphon during the communist era.
There were some fine clues with very smooth surfaces throughout the puzzle. I especially admired ‘zooming’, ‘ooziest’, ‘Teheran’, and ‘Brno’.
PART SONG appears to have a very loose meaning along with its more usual specific one and in the former guise I think “lay” might cover it.
No problems here with ROMP for “dance”
Had to think a bit about the parsing of LET-UP (see above); though now I look at it, neither of the proposed defs seems to require a hyphen.
TEHERAN took a bit of finding as well: penny dropped when I found you have to take “time” and “noon” together as the bookends.
Oh and … prompted by jackkt, what is UP doing as “slogan” in 21ac?
I will be one of the few who had to laboriously work out TNT from the wordplay. Give me Menander any day!
30 minutes for me with the same problems of struggling to understand LET UP and not seeing ROMP as dance (still can’t see that one) but “prom” was obvious. My thanks to the setter for the “perhaps” in 15D and congratulations on an excellent overall offering.
No complaints though about this first-rate brainteaser.
No problem with 11: I read it as something like his enthusiasm eventually fell/let up.
I don’t get the brickbats for Miles. It made me limes (anag) so I’m going to go against the grain and make it my COD although there are so many brilliant clues it’s hard to pick a favourite.
I had to guess at the significance of the Marryat character and had to trust the wordplay on Brno as both were in my unknowns pile.
At 6 I think hog is covered by “entirely appropriate”.
Thanks to Jerry for the blog and especially to the setter for a marvellous puzzle.
Edited at 2012-12-12 01:30 pm (UTC)
I thought this puzzle was absolutely marvellous. Really tough, but in just the right way, with lots of knotty wordplay to untangle, almost nothing entered from definition alone, and all sorts of eureka moments along the way.
I’ll join penfold in defending MILES: sure, not the finest clue ever written, but exploiting a particular phrase in a witty way.
Last in STONED, a fine clue entirely overshadowed by my second last in, 21ac. Up Holst! indeed. Clue of the day by a country mile among a very fine set.
Thank you setter.
Edited at 2012-12-12 10:02 pm (UTC)
I don’t understand LET-UP (with a hyphen) = “fell”. I’m not keen on I CLAUDIUS = “drama”, since it’s primarily a book – though I agree that “couple in Latin America” is very good. I hate DANCE = “romp”. S = “business all but disappeared” seems weak, as does 22ac (MILES).
Well, I’ve got that off my chest. I don’t usually complain so much about a Times crossword, but this one made me long for the puzzles of the past. Younger solvers who take a different view can just write me off as an old dinosaur.
Solved in 2 sessions – an uphill struggle followed by a downhill struggle.
Thanks Jerry for explaining Let-up, Shtum and Stoned. I couldn’t suss the wordplay for those at all and entered them just based on the checkers.
Misspelled Atomizes with a middle S initially so that caused delays getting Ooziest.
Top class puzzle – thank you setter.
Did anyone ever figure out how 11a works?
Clue: Don’t stop climbing fell? (3-2)
Answer: Let-up
Is the setter reading, to explain it?
Otherwise very tough, but I liked it enough to keep going over the hour before resorting to aids.
Rob