Solving time: 28.20.
I had hoped that the crossword gods would give me a break after Samuel Johnson two weeks ago, but no such luck – I found this very hard indeed. The top half remained dismayingly empty until I solved 1 across, which didn’t happen for a long time. There’s lots to admire here, and an unprecedented number of wordplays I was unable to work out until later – 10A, 20A, 22A, 24A, 3D, 7D.) I’m not really sure whether this is a particularly fiendish puzzle or if I was on very bad form tonight.
Across | ||
---|---|---|
1
|
NORFOLK BROADS, a very smoothly reading anagram that defeated for me a long time because it didn’t occur to me to look for it, a bad mistake. I suspect I’d have knocked at least 10 minutes off my time if I’d seen this at once. | |
8
|
STUN, a reversal of NUTS (Crank’s). It took me so long to solve either of the crossing clues that I seriously began to wonder if NUTS was actually the right answer. | |
9
|
EAR(L SCOUR)T. Flipping heck. SCOUR=comb, and EART is “‘eart”, the Cockney rendition of “heart” and therefore “middle, in East London”. All that immediately came to mind was Brent Cross, but I was reasonably confident of solving this backwards once I got a crossing letter or two, and as it turned out the initial E was enough. | |
10
|
LYNCH(P)IN, P=power, inside LYNCHIN(g). | |
11
|
THALIA, hidden. Maybe it was because I solved the neighbouring ISLA relatively quickly, but I just wasn’t looking for another girl’s name here. | |
16
|
ISLA, alternate letters of “at last is”, reversed. The desperate solver can usually rely on “regularly” to dig them out of a hole, though in the case of this puzzle the hole was of such trenchlike dimensions it made little difference. | |
17
|
STAT, the first letters of “skater trying axel turns”. “Turns heads” had me fooled for ages, trying unhelpful reversals. | |
18
|
HARD,DON,EB,Y – HARD=demanding, DON=follow, EB=be, turned over, and Y=authority ultimately. | |
20
|
EYELET, which sounds the same as ISLET (a minor key, since one meaning of key is an island). | |
22
|
V(ESTI)ARY – a vestry or robing room, and therefore “Where habits are”. The wordplay indicates that ESTI (SET I, rearranged) goes inside VARY (change). With the clock ticking ominously toward the half hour I took a punt at this and figured out the wordplay later. | |
24
|
BAR,B,I,ROLL,I -BAR=counter, B=British, ROLL=revolution, and the 2 I’s are the Isles. I had heard of John Barbirolli, but hesitated a while over the second vowel, the wordplay eluding me because I was fixated on British being BR. | |
26
|
PU(L)P. This was the last clue I solved. I had worked out what kind of litter was required, but was, completely wrongly, looking at it as the definition, some obscure farming term, with “recycle” being some kind of anagram or reversal device. | |
27
|
INSTANT,REP,LAY. INSTANT=flash, SET=lay (as in “set down”) and REP is a travelling sales representative. | |
Down | ||
1
|
NITTY-GRITTY – until 1 across went in I got nowhere with this, none of the fundamentalish things I could think of (brass tacks, grass roots) even fitting. NITTY=LOUSY is excellent, and for this alone I forgive the compiler most of the torture I endured solving this puzzle. | |
2
|
RU(NI)C = “of character” is the definition, NI (Northern Ireland) is the province (always try this when you see “province”) and the RUC, the Royal Ulster Constabulary, (renamed the PSNI in 2001) are the old force. It can only be a matter of time before a setter spots that PSNI is the start of INSPECTOR, reversed. Probably they already have. | |
3
|
OVER,P,ITCH – I only just this minute saw the elegance of this & lit type clue, having at a quick glance thought “oh, PAST=over, and, well, erm … you do indeed find the pitch at the bottom of a stump…” In fact OVER=deliveries, LONG=itch (desire) and the bottom of “stump” is P. Hoping this is not an ill omen for the game against Australia. (Again.) | |
4
|
KO,RAN,IC – KO=OK upwards, and therefore “allowed, to rise”. | |
5
|
RE,SET – RE=Religious Education. | |
6
|
ADO, RATION, – your ado ration being, of course, your share of troubles, and the rest of the clue is the definition. | |
7
|
S,IR – S=”seriously initially” heading IR (Inland Revenue, duty in the sense of tax.) | |
14
|
BATTLEBUS, a straightforward anagram that was one of my few early triumphs. | |
15
|
SIDES,WIPE – a criticism made in passing, and therefore “passing stick”. | |
19
|
RIV,U,L,ET – “student with driving ambition”, while an unusually precise description of a learner driver, actually baffled me far more than the more usual “student”. RIVET here is a verb. | |
21
|
T,ARK,A – TA here being “thank you”, ie “I’m obliged”. This was the first clue I solved; perhaps luckily, I do not know any other otters by name. | |
23
|
I(MP)EL – “Make” is the definition, and IEL = ELI, the crossworder’s favourite priest, with the I (one) risen to the top. | |
25
|
A,NI – simply IN A (area) reversed. An ani is a black cuckoo, which I did not know. |
At 3d I thought stump=electioneer=pitch could work, as in past=over (with a) bottom of stump=pitch, but your explanantion is far superior and makes for a good &lit.
Having researched otter names for this week’s DIY COW as recently as yesterday, I can tell you that Mij (or Mijbil) was the favourite in Ring of Bright Water.
And speaking of uncanny coincidences, the final row of across unches spell NUKE PEL. For Australian audiences Archbishop George Pell is a well known figure. Whether the message is a reference to his preferred “green” energy source or something else is not for me to say. For those unfamiliar with the reverend gentleman, scroll down to “Doctrinal stances and responses to criticisms” in the Wiki article.
I finished in 45 minutes with several unexplained, all of which fell into place quite easily when revisited except EARL’S COURT at 9ac which I gave up trying to work out having completely overlooked the possibility of a Cockney angle. I should have spotted that “middle” in the clue must have a particular purpose as the contained LSCOUR was clearly not going to be in the middle of that which contained it.
New to me were ANI and THALIA.
I thought of Jimbo yesterday when I found myself doing the Telegraph puzzle where one was expected to believe that the A,C,I,A in ACACIA sounds like Asia!
A good end to the week.
Thanks to Sabine for a/ explaining VESTIARY, RUNIC, SIR amd ISLET, and b/ for another marvellous blog, so illuminating on the solving process.
Like Sly solved BARBIROLLI with 1 checking letter after briefly considering and rejecting Toscanini.
Last in, a wild stab at RUNIC but gets my COD. Interesting how often solvers’ last in gets nominated COD.
I struggled with this (possibly because it’s been so long in coming) but found it a really enjoyable 35 minutes. Some of the definitions are superbly misleading, some of the word play really brilliant.
It’s a mark of a good puzzle when without resorting to obscurities the setter thoroughly tests ones ability and leaves one with a real sense of achievement when one finishes.
COD for me is 21dn. If only because I can do this joke:
Have you heard of a Tarka Curry? It’s like a Vindaloo only a little bit ‘otter.
W
Everything else was good, but I did not understand a lot of the construction. ‘Norfolk Broads’ and ‘Earl’s Court’ were somewhat UK-centric, but not terribly. I wonder if any UK solvers can name a NYC subway station that fits the (5,5) pattern?
I did think the ‘ado ration’ was very clever, that was one of my last ones in. I have never heard of a girl named ‘Isla’ so I hesitated for a long time over that. It also took me a while to see ‘Barbirolli’, even though I had the ‘i’ at the end.
I pick ‘runic’ for the COD, simple, elegant, and very puzzling.
No particular problems for me, just a lot of concentration required throughout. Well done to Pete and linxit, and anyone else who gets below 15 minutes on this. Looks like this year’s Cheltenham could be a real Rumble in the .. er, Cotswolds. Cue Rocky music.
First in RESET, last in ADORATION, which also gets my COD vote for a lovely definition and some truly groan-inducing wordplay.
Tom B.
Thanks setter
1a went in quickly, and most of the down clues that came off it followed. Had the NW half done in about 15 mins then ground to a complete halt, and put in maybe half a dozen more over the next 45. Nothing unreasonable in there, I just wasn’t on the right wavelength at all.
Thanks to Sabine for explaining all the ones I didn’t fully understand (3, 7, 20, 22 & 27).
COD was going to be 17 for its wonderful misdirection, but now I fully understand 3, I think it has to be that.
Is The Inland Revenue called something else now (as an expat I’m not abreast with bureaucratic changes in the UK)? Otherwise how else to explain the past tense, ‘took’? I’m assuming IR is indicated by “who took duty”, not just “duty”.
I agree there are many gems – “Drop litter” for PUP, the whole construction for BARBIROLLI and RIVULET, to name but a few.
Bloomin’ Times wesite again playing up, just when I wanted to look at it over lunch!
I think we’ve had ANI in the Times daily before so no new words and nothing too obscure so as Jimbo says well done to the setter for presenting a challenging puzzle without resorting to arcania.
COD to pulp – drop litter for pup as a verb is terrific.
I wonder if Anax would have come up with an ever-so-slightly different treatment for 18?
I received an anonymous text today that just said GBNA. I think it’s bang out of order.
After getting 1a straight off thought it might be a dawdle. Liked T-ARK-A and ADORATION , last in VESTIARY.
Neil
Still, that’s part of what makes the puzzle challenging and interesting for me. The only clue/answer I would question is “Isla” – I don’t see much about it on the Internet. Is that name really much used in the UK (or anywhere)?