Solving time: 14.50.
I thought this was a good mixture of tricky clues and more straightforward ones. Had some problems with the wordplay in a few places but the definition and/or crossing letters were usually helpful, and where the definition wasn’t immediately familiar (e.g. 5d) the answer was gettable from the wordplay.
There were some very neat clues – I liked 3D, 10A and 23A in particular. Left myself at the end with 4 symmetrically placed empty spaces, 1A/1D in the NW corner and 21D/25A in the SE, spending an inordinate amount of time on the not particularly difficult 25A.
Across | ||
---|---|---|
1
|
DUMP TRUCK – I’ve agonised for a while over how this one works. DUMP=ditch is easy enough – can the rest really be the end bits of “traffic is stuck”? Surely not. Is DUMP=ditch a red herring? Help. | |
9
|
BINOMIAL THEOREM – an anagram of “mobile home grant”, with the G replaced by an I, indicated by “one’s given for good”. I got the theorem bit right away, but had to subtract, replace and contemplate the results for a few moments before seeing “Binomial”. I have heard of it but have absolutely no idea what it is. | |
10
|
SINGLE – a double meaning. | |
11
|
W,HA(LE O)IL – after trying with some bafflement to figure out how HAL or AL fitted into this poignant shower scene, I realised the man in question was LEO. | |
13
|
BE(H IN)D, HAND – the H IN (hour at home) manage their lie-in by being in BED. | |
14
|
STAG – “game” here is in the sense of a wild animal hunted for sport, though my first thought was that STAG would be a poker variant (probably I was thinking of STUD, though the picture of a group of guys sitting down for a game of Stag is awfully convincing.). | |
16
|
FA,TE, both being notes in the do re mi scale. | |
17
|
I,N,TERN,MENT – here the note is N, an abbreviation for the word “note” rather than an actual note. It always seems a bit unstylish to repeat a significant word in consecutive clues, though my approach to clue-solving is so haphazard that unless actually blogging I doubt that I’d ever notice. | |
19
|
ESCAPIST, being C (about) inside (pasties)*. | |
20
|
DE NOVO, Latin term meaning “anew”, hidden, reversed, in “ChekhOV ONE Discovered”. The words “back” and “fragment” in the clue gave this device away to me at once. | |
23
|
CHAPTER AND VERSE – “given cryptically in code” because CODE breaks down to C=chapter and ODE=verse. I thought this was quite clever. | |
24
|
(t)RUSTY | |
25
|
DEPOR,TEES – DEPOR being ROPED backwards (bound, returning) and the river obviously TEES. I can’t remember a clue for which I came up with so many wrong answers along the way, starting off with DESERTERS, then, after the P fell into place, trying DEPARTERS before moving onto DEPARTEES, which at least had a river, though unfortunately isn’t a word. The key was to realise that “land” belonged to the definition, not the wordplay. | |
Down | ||
1
|
D(EB)US – EB (BE, up) inside DUS(k) – the half-light, shortly. DEBUS works like DEPLANE or DETRAIN. | |
2
|
MEN IN WHITE COATS – (a chemist in town)*, with an E (the drug) stored inside. | |
3
|
TUM,BLING, an admirably succinct description of a navel piercing. | |
5
|
KITCHEN TEA, an anagram of “a ticket” plus “hen”. A kitchen tea apparently is the OZ/NZ version of a bridal shower. | |
6
|
P(A)E,LL,A – “A” is the top grade, PE=exercises, LL=learners and A=a. | |
7
|
PAR FOR THE COURSE – PAR is “blow up” (RAP, upwards), stronghold is FORT, HE= high explosive. | |
8
|
LIMELIGHT, a 1952 Charlie Chaplin film. | |
12
|
CHINESE RED, a colour I didn’t recognise, but the wordplay is very helpful. | |
13
|
B(U FF ETC)AR | |
14
|
ONCE OVER – “Head ignores bad start” is BONCE (slang term for the head) with the B removed. | |
18
|
S,POTTY | |
21
|
OW(E)NS, a reference to Jesse Owens, star of the 1936 Olympics. Not sure I’ve understood this correctly as the word “has” in the clue seems to be required both as a definition for OWNS and as part of the instruction to put E inside it. | |
22
|
SNAP, being a shot in the sense of a photo, and I guess firstly in the sense of to break, though snapping and collapsing don’t actually seem very similar. |
Koro will like 9ac I suspect and will enlighten us all as to what it actually is. COD has to go to 3dn — TUM-BLING — wonderful!
Did the adjectival in 6ac worry anyone?
10ac was nice for ex-scousers — though I’m not too sure about “hit”.
Curiously, I had put in ‘deportees’ as my first try, but erased it because I couldn’t see the cryptic. When I came back, I saw it at once, and ‘Owens’ and ‘snap’ soon followed.
I did misunderstand a couple. ‘Chapter and verse’ I interpreted as the kind of cipher based on page numbers in a book. ‘Snap’? That must be a missile from a slingshot. Answers right, reasoning wrong. But I suspect ‘dump truck’ is exactly what our astute blogger thinks it is.
I did want to put in ‘shale oil’ for the longest time, but resisted.
Yes, sadly, it has to be TR[affic is st]UCK. Strict Ximeneans beware!
Bizarrely, Sabine’s marvellous blog was like reliving the entire experience (albeit in slow motion). I too was left unconvinced by DUMP TRUCK and OWENS, same problem with LEO (is hail a shower?), and so on. And yes MCText, I thought PRESS after discarding OVETT as extant.
A little help to get going but otherwise a very satisfactory performance for me of just over the hour (perhaps I should get up at this ungodly hour every day) but needed blog for explanation of CHAPTER AND VERSE which is way too clever for me.
Looks like a consensus on TUMBLING. First in for me and immediately marked COD.
I took SNAP to mean a nervous collapse, though I’m not sure that helps.
As for the binomial theorem, I’m presuming it’s the one that gives the expansion of (x + y)n in terms of Pascal’s (for one) co-efficients, but I’ve never thought of that as a theorem. Newton’s extension of this to non-integer n’s is actually worthy of the title, and a very useful thing it is too. Actually, now that I think about it, I used the result just the other day when I attempted to calculate the probability of getting a match in two crosswords, since 1 – (1 – 30/n,000)30 is approximately 900/n,000 or roughly 1/n. The Babylonians could probably have done that calculation, although as far as I know, no cuneiform crossword has yet been found (some examples in The Listener aside).
I also found this puzzle oddly like yesterday’s–obvious answers (if one had some crossing letters), but hard to justify with the wordplay. Unless I’m missing something, the definition at 11ac seems obscure: whale oil was, apparently, used long ago in the manufacture of detergents, but “typical ingredient of soaps”?–I don’t get it, unless “whale oil” is recent British slang for something that happens in soap operas.
As others have already pointed out the problem at 25 was that there are several words that might have fitted the definition “people leaving” and three of them would have worked with the checking letter “P” which I didn’t have anyway, so DESERTERS was also still a possibility. But unfortunately I never even thought of DEPORTEES otherwise I might have spotted that it is defined precisely as “people leaving land” and the first part is ROPED backwards.
I also wasted time considering OVETT at 21dn. Never heard of KITCHEN TEA, BINOMIAL THEOREM nor of CHINESE RED but these were easily solved by other means.
TUM BLING had me laughing out loud, but also liked ESCAPIST for it’s excellent surface.
Paul S.
I think 10 is a triple definition – a single is a one-run hit in cricket (or a one-base hit in baseball).
Edited at 2009-07-24 07:53 am (UTC)
total agreement on 3D – a rare laugh out loud clue, although had spent a time expecting it to end -RING.
Also wasted some time with BEHINDTIME, with the lie in being BEDTIME rather than just BED, but soon realised that the K-T-H-M set up was unlikely.
I worked my way through this one steadily enough in 25 minutes. I nearly felt the Chinese red mist descend over DUMP TRUCK until I realised that “stuck at the side” was a long winded instruction. I agree SINGLE is a triple definition with “hit” being a bit of obscure cricket jargon. I thought CHAPTER AND VERSE was very clever and a better clue that the rather obvious TUM-BLING
1
1 1
1 2 1
1 3 3 1
1 4 6 4 1
1 5 10 10 5 1
Beautiful, isn’t it? Well, certainly better than my grid in today’s crossword.
Anonymous Nick
N
1 1
1 2 1
1 3 3 1
1 4 6 4 1
1 5 10 10 5 1
Edited at 2009-07-24 12:15 pm (UTC)
Thanks, Pete
I tackled the long ones first, so 2d was my first in. I spotted that 9 was something THEOREM, but it took me far too long to extract the first word from the anagram (especially for a maths graduate!).
There were numerous mistakes in my reasoning that delayed me. I convinced myself that the worker in 13a was going to be a BEE around the outside, so I struggled with BEHIND—E for ages. I too had to go through DESERTERS & DEPARTERS for 25 before settling on the right answer.
At 9 I spotted binomial quickly but had to do lots of scribbling and striking out to find theorem.
Not happy with shower = hail and and marked single as suspect (not necessarily a hit) until seeing the comments on the triple def.
Can any of our anipodean contributors shed some light on kitchen tea?
Put me down as another simple soul who liked 3d more than 23a.
‘Ruck’ in 1A can mean wrinkle or draw together – I remember this from learning to use a sewing machine -‘Look, it’s all rucked up at the back.’ So, I suppose it could be T(ransport)+RUCK.
In the study of discourse analysis, binomials are pairs of words such as ‘spic and span’, so when my cheating machine suggested it, I decided ‘eunomian’ must be the answer. Consequently, I didn’t get ‘debus’ or ‘single’ (which was clever).
I didn’t mind, because TUM BLING was so excellent. I love this non-stuffy 21st century kind of clue. I doubt if my dad does, though.
“I’m very well acquainted too with matters mathematical,
I understand equations, both the simple and quadratical,
About binomial theorem I’m teeming with a lot ‘o news
–
With many cheerful facts about the square of the hypotenuse”.
Incidentally, the Major-General also claims that he “can write a washing bill in Babylonic cuneiform,/And tell you every detail of Caractacus’s uniform”.
“…the age of twenty-one he wrote A Treatise on the Binomial Theorem, which has had a European vogue. On the strength of it he won the mathematical chair at one of our smaller universities, and had, to all appearances, a most brilliant career before him.”