Solving time: 15.24, with one mistake. I wrote in TAXES at the very end at 9ac, and stopped the clock – I didn’t really understand how it worked, but then I rarely do understand anything tax-related and don’t like to think about it too deeply. Saw the right answer about thirty seconds later and corrected it, but a stopped clock is a stopped clock, alas.
Was expecting something really easy after the rigours of this week but found this distinctly tricky, and it’s been quite a few weeks since I took so long over writing a blog, though to be fair I’ve had half an eye on the Aussie cricket.
Across | ||
---|---|---|
1
|
FRESHER. Two quite cleverly opposed meanings of FRESH here, using different meanings of “familiar”: something that is fresh in the sense of “new” is less familiar, while a person being fresh in the sense of “cheeky” is more familiar. | |
5
|
MA(PUT)O – formerly Lourenco Marques, the capital of Mozambique. This took a while; for most of the time I was looking at it I only had the P, and all kinds of things seemed possible, including LAPUTA, which I was certain I’d heard of but which turned out to be the flying island in Gulliver’s Travels. | |
9
|
TEXAS – being “taxes” with the even letters swapped. I got nowhere near this till I’d solved TAX YEAR at 7d – the only ways I’d found to decode it were “Take every even letter from ‘State duties’ and rearrange” – which gives TITUS, but not a lot else; or “Take a 2-letter state abbreviation, add the even letters of ‘duties’ and rearrange”. I was so sick of this clue at the end that, as described above, I just thought “Must be TAXES”, and wrote it in, spotting the mistake almost immediately after. | |
11
|
R(EGA)N – EGA being “a long time back” (AGE reversed) and RN the service. Regan was one of King Lear’s less charming daughters. | |
12
|
H(ALLOWE)EN – ALLOWE(d) = “almost let”. Not sure how the “out of” bit of the clue works. | |
13
|
PEELINGS – (sleeping)* | |
15
|
GLORIA – (o,a,girl)* | |
17
|
R.U.,SKIN – John Ruskin, Victorian art critic, author, poet, artist etc etc. | |
19
|
GOUR(MAN)D – one of the few clues I got at first glance, this one solely from the definition. | |
22
|
E.G.REGIO(n),US. “For one” here means, as it presumably did in the previous clue, “for example” | |
23
|
QU(IT)O. I enjoyed QUO for “one with status”. | |
24
|
TIKKA – sounds like “ticker”. Does it really? Not when I say it it doesn’t. | |
25
|
LOO(KALI)KE. Kali is the Hindu goddess of death and destruction and LOOKE(d) is “made inspection briefly”. | |
26
|
PROS(e),IT – a drinking toast of Latin derivation. | |
27
|
ST,KIT,TS – “Kit” being approached by ST (way) in both directions. | |
Down | ||
1
|
FUTURE PERFECT. My spirits rose slightly when this long 1d was the first clue I solved, leading immediately to 8 and 11ac, but progress thereafter was slow. | |
2
|
E,CLOGUE – CLOGUE being “catalogue” (list) with the “ata” removed, indicated by “not at a”. An eclogue is a short pastoral poem. I had the L and G early and so suspected the LOGUE ending before I worked it all out. | |
3
|
HERON – “eaten by” here just indicating a hidden word, not some kind of complex containment operation. | |
4
|
ROUG(HAG)E | |
5
|
MIDDLE – I dread to think what possibilities will have flashed through people’s minds before brought down to earth by geography. Middlesex is a former English county, still used informally as an area name. | |
6
|
POTBOILER = (let rip boo)* | |
7
|
T,A,X,Y,EAR – again, like everything to do with taxes this caused me untold grief. I think the definition is just “I start in spring”, with “time” being T, “a” being A, the axes being X and Y and EAR the part of wheat. | |
10
|
SONS AND LOVERS | |
14
|
ISINGLASS – (sailing SS)*. I had no idea what this had to do with beer, or what fining meant, and am grateful to the Wort and Beer Clarification Manual, which sounds like it should be a guest publication on HIGNFY, for the following: “The objective of isinglass fining is the removal of particles from beer, either to reduce the particle load presented to the filter, or to prodice a visually bright beer at point of sale.” I’m sure we will all remember that. | |
16
|
HOTS,HOTS – HOST = army, with “succeeded to rear” meaning “move the S to the end”. Rinse and repeat. | |
20
|
ANIMIST – Belfast (NI) has disappeared from view due to being surrounded by A MIST. | |
21
|
JOB,L,OT. JOB = book, OT=where it’s found. |
Two mistakes. At 1ac I had “Further” – “more” in the oratorical sense of “further(more)” or “moreover”, and also “more distant” i.e. less familiar. (Well it almost works!) Did not get 2dn as a result.
I had the same thought on 12ac.
Having taken execption to Manhattan=UN the other day, I would just slightly revise Sabine’s take on 20dn to “Belfast has disappeared from view due to A NI MIST”. (On reflection I suspect it may amount to the same thing!)
The RH was another story where despite solving 5D, 10 and 27 early on I struggled to make progress and gave up when the hour struck and resorted to books and on-line help. I still managed to come here with 7 and 9 unsolved. A more even distribution of conventional and “smart” styles of cluing might have helped. This was definitely a puzzle of two halves.
Quite an odd solve in that there were several flurries of 2 or 3 answers followed by lots of head-scratching, and a few instances of placing “only possible” answers and going back later to try and unravel wordplay.
No real quibbles, but 17A featured one of those instances I referred to yesterday; something in the clue that initially stopped me from seeing the answer and may possibly be unfair, namely the past participle “had” which doesn’t seem to have a valid role. Unlikely as it seemed, I wondered if there was a short synonym for “had” with some game serving as a container. Oh well. I suppose it can be read as “can be had using the wordplay…”
In our equality-conscious society I wonder if anyone will suggest “mother” in 10D could/should have been “parent”?
And to be honest I wasn’t at all keen on the first instance of “at a” in 2D. It helps with the surface but, for me, doesn’t really serve as a valid link-up between the wordplay components.
Several very good moments – 1A took a little while to understand but is a good clue, 9A is a nicely observed treatment, 1D is possibly an old one but worth seeing again, 4D caused a giggle (although “old woman” = “hag” I’m not 100% sure of) and 23D gets my COD for a very good deception and clever treatment of an awkward little word.
Q-1 E-6 D-8 COD 23D
I can’t let 24A pass without at least a comment. The lovely people in my local Indian pronounce it “teeka” and would certainly not recognise “ticker”. I don’t understand how or why good setters manage to produce these wierd homophones.
This is the last in a run of 24 puzzles that I have been analysing for topics contained within clues (a repeat of the exercise carried out last May). I should have some results early next week.
She said it is pronounced “ticker” and also volunteered that the word has Persian roots (tandoori food is of Mogul origin), although now (in common with a lot of English words) it has been absorbed into modern Hindi.
For what it’s worth.
COD .. 23d
Edited at 2008-11-28 02:48 pm (UTC)
Of course, there is a Middlesex county in Connecticut.
But the town where I grew up in had a Middlesex road, and a Middlesex Junior High school. When my father and 11 other punters joined together in 1964 to buy ten acres of rather swampy land for a new club, they called it the Middlesex Swimming and Tennis club. It is still there, much improved over the years.
Thought of EGREGIOUS but could not justify it and , I have to take my hat to the setter , the triumvirate of HOTSHOTS,LOOKALIKE and JOB LOT floored me. A long time since I have had such a dismal failure.
No complaints
JohnPMarshall
Quite apart from the fact that it is rather questionable to say that Middlesex is a place near London (most if not all of it is in London), it seems to me that ‘near London’ shouldn’t just be there, without anything introducing it.
All the letters except z are in the grid. You’d think it could be fitted in but I can’t see how to.
I’m also one of those convinced myself that 1ac was ‘further’ – I find clues like these where there is another plausible answer to that intended a little unfair… what made it harder in this case was lack of literature knowledge (2dn and 9ac).
Ian
Didn’t like it. Fell short of the answer being clear when the clue is solved
Harry Shipley
Had me floundering too.
Unlike Anax, I saw Ruskin immediately but otherwise had a lot of trouble in that corner.
I was also under the illusion that 3 down was a ‘hen’ devouring an ‘RO’, which must be either an RAF abbreviation or an obscure bird of New Zealand. Oh, well….
There are 3 “easies”:
8a Finally persuade to have discussion circle (4,5)
TALK ROUND
18d Batsman: he’s out (7)
STRIKER. Is that as in baseball with “3 strikes and you’re out” or something? I don’t understand this – is it correct?
23d Unqualified man may get called across the pond (5)
QUACK