Solving time: 26.12.
Found this really hard going – almost every clue seemed to present a problem. I actually had everything filled in after 18 minutes or so, but after my mistakes earlier in the week (PRECEDENCE for PREFERENCE, and then there was the whole ESTUARIAN saga yesterday that I decided not to try your patience with) I was in a more careful mood than usual, and went back to think some more over the ones I was unsure of, especially 4a and 6d.
Across | ||
---|---|---|
1
|
MI,S(H)AP – the definition being “blow”. | |
4
|
PO,OP(D)EC,K. Took a while to figure this out. PO is the naval officer (Petty Officer, I think), OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries) are the exporters of fuel, + K, chemical symbol for potassium, storing the large amount D (500), | |
11
|
SH,RUB. Not sure it’s altogether wise to deal with the perennial loquacious masseur problem in quite such an abrupt way as this. They can thump quite hard. | |
12
|
HA(PP)Y-CLA(PP)Y, an enthusiastic style of worship that might be practised at a Christian mission. | |
14
|
H,AS – in the sense of “you’ve been had” (cheated). | |
15
|
V(A TIC)AN, The definition is “See City”, as in Holy See, VAN=lead, and the brief moment is TIC(k). | |
17
|
ROO FED | |
19
|
JUST,SO. JUST=fair; SO is an alternative spelling for SOL, the fifth note of the scale. | |
21
|
LETITIA – (I + a title)* | |
24
|
WOUNDED KNEE (nuke endowed)*. Saw right away that this was an anagram but couldn’t get it without the N of KNEE, which pretty much placed the K – even then it took a while to see it as I wasn’t on the lookout for body parts (for once). | |
26
|
SO,DOM – being MOD (Ministry of Defence) and OS (outsize) all reversed. Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed with brimstone and fire by the Lord, hence “City fired”. | |
29
|
POP IN,J,AY, a fop or dandy, hence super-smart in the sartorial sense. | |
30
|
OR PHAN. OR (other ranks) = men, and PHAN sounds like fan. | |
Down | ||
1
|
MUS,TH(A V)E. MUS=Sum, up, then A V (a verse) inside THE – leaving just “requirement” which is the definition. | |
2
|
S(WEE)P. SP = starting price, and SWEEP is a sweepstake. | |
3
|
ADD – alternate letters of “Candide”, and cheers to the setter for not using “regularly”. (I think I’m in danger of starting to sound obsessive about this issue. I won’t mention it again. For a while.) | |
6
|
PUSSY,F(OOT)ED. I spent a ridiculous amount of time at the end trying to justify this. Still not entirely sure I have it right, but here goes: The definition, “Stolen” is in the sense of “moved stealthily”. OOT is “too upset”, and “when handed round” means that FED, meaning “handed” in the sense of passing something to someone, has to go round OOT. | |
8
|
KI,BOSH, with KI being “skin unclothed”. | |
9
|
MUS(t) L,IN | |
13
|
Y,ACHTSWOMAN. Y=”lady ultimately”, and the rest is an anagram of (who can + mast). | |
16
|
TRU(MP)E,D UP. The party is DUP (Democratic Unionist Party) | |
18
|
L,A,SERPEN(t). Took a while to get to SERPENT, thinking I needed a specific type of snake. | |
20
|
O(PUN)TIA, being PUN inside AI TO all reversed. I fell into the trap of thinking “cracking” was telling me to put something inside something else, when in fact it’s just an adjective meaning “very good” (or A1). OPUNTIA is a kind of prickly pear, which I had just about heard of. | |
21
|
LUD,WIG. LUD being a form of “lord” used when addressing judges. | |
22
|
PAS,SUP – Pa’s sup being the drink he has. | |
25
|
canNOT CHange – a neatly concealed hidden word. |
I am not absolutely sure about 28 Dn. “our” (of us) is the obvious answer. I get the “OR” for heraldic gold ringing another letter, in this case “U”. Is this used as a symbol for “For All”. When I did predicate calculus we used an inverted “A”.
PUSSY-FOOTED gave me pause (sorry), too. It’s an awkward surface with some tortured wordplay. I was going to question the definition until I saw that the dictionaries confirm an original, more literal meaning as well as the common metaphorical one.
I loved the ROO joke, but the sweetly concealed and indicated NOTCH gets my COD nod.
Q-0, E-6, D-7
COD 28 for a new (I think) clue to a common word, which reads well and fools you despite using standard stuff.
Edited at 2008-09-19 08:10 am (UTC)
But (and I address this to sotira as well) …
Imagine you’re in the championship final with this one last clue left, you’ve whizzed through the other puzzles and the other clues in this puzzle (12:00 is certainly a damned sight faster than I would have done for this one, though the other puzzles this week went pretty well) and no-one else has yet stuck their hand up. Do you take a chance with DRALON or think on?
Tough decision!
Cave testudinem ;-).
I had one error, URCHIN for ORPHAN at 30. I thought it was probably wrong when I wrote it in but I forgot to go back and look at it again after completing the rest of the puzzle.
17 is my COD.
QED: 0-8-7
I laughed at both 11A and 17A and thought 13D, 25D and 28D outstanding in a very high class field. I’m relaxed about the partial homophone at 30A and liked “child left” as the definition. About 40 minutes to solve.
Tom B.
I’m with you and Tom B on the ‘homophone’ in 30a, which I hadn’t picked up when solving but which is certainly worth a notch on the quibble stick.
Q-0 E-10 D-7 COD 28
Yes, 10.
So 31:06 with two boo-boos. Agree that this was a brilliant puzzle and I’d ticked 9 clues as potential COD contenders, some for making me laugh, others for sheer cleverness – for instance I didn’t see the container for notch until I had all checkers in place. Also agree that the phan/fan thing doesn’t work however.
Q-1, E-9, D-8, COD 18
I liked the double -pp- move at 12.
6 is a good instance of inane toughness in my book; there comes a point in clueing difficulty where the intuitive appeal is completely lost (for me at least!). I suppose that’s the big thing in construction, balancing the aesthetic wordsmith aspect with the logican aspect (Anax?)…
PUSSYFOOTED was one where I only grasped a little of the wordplay at first. Going back to it and giving it some decent parsing time allowed me to appreciate the setter’s ingenuity in disguising the def and wordplay elements. The experiences for others is bound to vary, but for me it was a case of finally spotting things which I immediately kicked myself for not having seen earlier.
We couldn’t have puzzles filled with this type of clue, of course, but the chance to delve deeply into clue make-up for one or two of this type is a good way for solvers to latch onto more devious (or, simply, more cleverly executed) techniques.
FWIW I’d possibly place a small quibble tick for the use of “when”. Grammatic pedantry would suggest “when handed is around” or similar – nonsense reading, of course, but on its own “when” isn’t quite right.
From an editor’s point of view, though, the whole thing is so convincing I’d probably give it the nod despite the slightly questionable shorthand used.
Good crossword.
GRM
Have a nice weekend.
Nico.
No way can I do the TC in anything less than 2 hours… will try harder 🙂
Not so with the unchecked URCHIN at 30a – I wondered why I could not parse the clue – Doh!
There are 6 “easies”:
10a Device delivering shock if one steps on it? (5,4)
SPEED BUMP. The “shock” in the form of a large fine in the post from a SPEED TRAP has been mentioned above. You need the crossers correct to get this.
23a It has leads to aid musical performance (3)
AMP. Aids Musical Performance – and it has leads except these days with wireless connections.
27a Lean over, showing scalp (4,2,3)
THIN ON TOP. Guilty as charged.
5d Exam may be in theory (2,5)
ON PAPER
7d The most coarse material for a tee-shirt (9)
EARTHIEST. Anagram of (a tee-shirt).
28 Gold rings for all of us (3)
O U R. Gold = OR (heraldry) “for all” = U (film certification) and “of us” is the literal.