Time taken: 20:46 – and with that, one silly typo, so if you are looking for a chance to get on the leaderboard well ahead of your blogger, today is an exceptional day.
With all apologies to the setter, as this is a good crossword, with some fine clues and all of the wordplay works: it seems for a third time in a row I am going to have a quibble. The last two daily puzzles I blogged both had errors in the wordplay, leading to headache-inducing days (and in one case, corrected clues in the online version of the puzzle). This one uses my least favorite cryptic crossword convention twice – clueing a non-English proper noun as an anagram. This renders a clue as an exercise in hopeful letter-juggling.
I see some of my contemporaries have very quick times indeed today, but I struggled.
The first definition in each clue is underlined.
Away we go…
Across | |
1 | Start to devise style in office (4-4) |
OPEN-PLAN – OPEN(start), next to PLAN(devise) | |
5 | A small fishing boat returned every time (6) |
ALWAYS – A then S(small), YAWL(fishing boat) reversed | |
10 | To do nothing and go back to risk regret is barely credible (3,4,2,2,4) |
TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE – crafty wordplay here – TO, then DO, O(nothing), and GO all reversed then TO, BET(risk), RUE(regret) | |
11 | Striking style of film, Renoir work of art is fun (10) |
RECREATION – remove film NOIR from RENOIR, then CREATION(work of art) | |
13 | When to pen court decrees (4) |
ACTS – AS(when) containing CT(court) | |
15 | Hat comes adrift with open carriage (7) |
PHAETON – anagram of HAT and OPEN | |
17 | Old sultan’s envy, perhaps, about a young man (7) |
SALADIN – Envy is a deadly SIN, containing A, LAD(young man) | |
18 | Might piano add second instrument for gripping effect? (7) |
FORCEPS – FORCE(might), P(piano), S(second) | |
19 | Resolved to include mint, say, in Australian beer (7) |
SHERBET – SET(resolved) containing HERB(mint, say). Been a long time since I’ve heard this slang, but it was most commonly used in a band name, best known for Howzat | |
21 | Fell back in space (4) |
ROOM – MOOR(fell) reversed | |
22 | Make public concert attendance around middle of July (10) |
PROMULGATE – PROM(concert), GATE(attendance) surrounding the middle of jULy | |
25 | Chinese space shot means quarantine (9,6) |
TIANANMEN SQUARE – anagram of MEANS,QUARANTINE | |
27 | Check reversing speed in road (6) |
RETARD – RATE(speed) reversed in RD(road) | |
28 | Records judge is for hanging (8) |
TAPESTRY – TAPES(records), TRY(judge) |
Down | |
1 | Yield more than rock (7) |
OUTCROP – if you yield more than, you OUT CROP | |
2 | I make good, to some extent (3) |
EGO – hidden inside makE GOod | |
3 | Landed respectable neckwear given by daughter (10) |
PROPERTIED – PROPER(respectable), TIE(neckwear), D(daughter) | |
4 | Warm approval is out of place for vetting of books (5) |
AUDIT – the warm approval is a PLAUDIT, remove PL(place) | |
6 | Made up a story and was heartless (4) |
LIED – LIVED(was) missin the middle letter | |
7 | Charm of rogue flanked by a couple of supporters (11) |
ABRACADABRA – CAD(rogue) surrounded by two of A BRA(supporters) | |
8 | Walks over younger member of family (7) |
STEPSON – walks over is STEPS ON | |
9 | Giant company supported by America admits defeat (8) |
COLOSSUS – CO(company) over US(America) containing LOSS(defeat) | |
12 | Bad actor vainly looking at the future (11) |
CLAIRVOYANT – anagram of ACTOR,VAINLY | |
14 | Sign up for the famous indecent film covering canines? (4,6) |
BLUE PLAQUE – cryptic double definition (and my downfall, since it is BLUE PLAQEE in my grid). A sign advertising an indecent filme might be a BLUE PLAQUE… and it is also the result of rubbing a piece of tape on your teeth to see where you haven’t cleaned properly. It has been pointed out in comments that this is probably meant to be “Sign up for the famous” = BLUE PLAQUE (usually circular), and the wordplay is BLUE(indecent), PLAQUE(film covering canines). This seems more plausible, though BLUE PLAQUE is not in Collins or Chambers, | |
16 | Conrad’s novel motors on in chaos (8) |
NOSTROMO – anagram of MOTORS,ON – novel by Joseph Conrad | |
18 | Help to include right author (7) |
FORSTER – FOSTER(help) containing R(right) for the author E. M. FORSTER known for A Room With A View amongst others | |
20 | Three changed in multiplication with about that amount (7) |
THEREBY – anagram of THREE, then BY(in multiplication with) | |
23 | Madness of king over leaving country (5) |
MANIA – remove R(rex, King), O(over) from ROMANIA(country) | |
24 | Just stylishness gets left out (4) |
FAIR – FLAIR(stylishness) missing L(left) | |
26 | Cunning regularly displayed by parrots (3) |
ART – alternating letters in pArRoTs |
NOSTROMO was a gimme, NHO SHERBET, biffed 10ac. George, you haven’t underlined the definition for 14d, which I assumed was ‘Sign up for the famous’, i.e. the plaque on a building saying X was born here or whatever. BLUE=indecent, PLAQUE=film on teeth (‘covering canines’).
Edited at 2019-05-02 08:13 am (UTC)
In 20 down, I think the literal is ‘with about that amount’, as Collins tells me that an old sense of THEREBY is ‘thereabouts’.
I knew the spelling of TIANANMEN well enough, having many times attempted to get a confident grip on its pronunciation. In fact, I just tried again, consulting various websites and getting multiple quite different suggestions. I know we have some Sinologists hereabouts. Can someone offer a definitive guide?
I don’t know how well-known NOSTROMO is these days (I have actually read it, which seems an unfair advantage) but where else are you going to put the T? Once you’ve done that all you’ve got left is Os.
I needed the checking letter from 25ac not to spell it TIENANMEN, but if you haven’t heard of the square, where have you been for the last thirty years? The answer is probably China.
Edited at 2019-05-02 05:41 am (UTC)
Also, although NOSTROMO is on my reading list, the word is of course most familiar as the name of the spaceship in Alien. PHAETON also familiar, though all it brought to mind were the spines of books; I suppose I must’ve read some of Phaeton Publishing‘s output.
So, luckily I knew all the tricky ones, making this one fall into my “firm but fair” category at 52 minutes. FOI 1a OPEN-PLAN, LOI 18d FORSTER just after I realised that COD 18a FORCEPS wasn’t going to start with the “p” for “piano”. WOD PROMULGATE. I enjoyed the definition for 14d BLUE PLAQUE, familiar enough even if it isn’t in the dictionaries.
Edited at 2019-05-02 06:47 am (UTC)
COD to FORCEPS, for which I thought the clue had a particularly smooth surface.
BLUE PLAQUE has come up before and was the subject of some discussion but I have been unable to find it because the LJ Search field now seems to be returning more general results which are not specific to TftT as has always been the case in the past. This must be a very recent change as I use it a lot. Has anyone else experienced this?
Edited at 2019-05-02 05:55 am (UTC)
I was perhaps lucky to type in TIENANMEN before I got to 24dn, so a right answer corrected a wrong one rather than the other way round.
For searching I use the google advanced search page, and limit the search to Tftt site or domain .. much more flexible than LJ
https://www.google.co.uk/advanced_search
Edited at 2019-05-02 02:11 pm (UTC)
Over an hour again: I have to blame a lack of of melatonin.
FOI 23dn MANIA
LOI 14dn Blue Plaque (Shades of Benny Hill and people being born half-way up walls!)
COD 12dn CLAIRVOYANT
WOD 16dn NOSTROMO – not bad for someone who didn’t speak English until he was nearly thirty!
Didn’t spot the Re(noir), very clever.
And schoolboy error on spelling TiaNNamen held up Fair for a couple of mins.
Thanks setter and G.
Biffed both 10A and the Square (and used Google to get the spelling right). Knew the carriage but not the book – so derived answer from anagram fodder. Liked the BLUE PLAQUE
Carefully pieced together the Square and knew Nostromo as I remember my sister doing it for A level Eng Lit (which put me off reading it).
Seeing Chinese Space shot immediately made me think of the Uxbridge, which has the definition “Chinese rocket launch” for “County Down”.
COD: PHAETON.
I would have been quicker had I not read ‘americaN’ in the clue. That lead me to entering ‘colossAL on the basis that Al is a typical American name (“You Can Call Me Al”) Took ages to sort that out.
My only quibble would be with the definition of THEREBY.
Sorry it didn’t work for you, George — but thanks anyway for your blog and for explaining the clever Re[noir] trick, which I didn’t get.
I find if I do these puzzles electronically, I speed up – it might be because I’m abusing the Check function with guesses 🙂
COD & LOI was TAPESTRY for me – took me ages to get that one. Had the puzzle done after 30 mins then got stuck on that and a couple of others.
Straightforward clueing, no super-unusual words or acronyms meant for a nice fast clean solve.
3 month challenge: 13/15.
Thanks to all!
WS
Edited at 2019-05-02 10:18 am (UTC)
I biffed TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE, and spent no little time post-solve trying to break it down, so thanks for that George.
There is a suggestion on the QC blog that this was a straightforward puzzle, and decent fodder for the less seasoned solver. I must demur – there’s some quite tricky stuff in there, and I found it a challenging and enjoyable workout.
FOI ACTS
LOI THEREBY
COD RECREATION (closely followed by BLUE PLAQUE)
TIME 10:20
No problem with SHERBET, NOSTROMO, PHAETON nor T SQUARE.
Nostromo is the spaceship in the famous movie Alien, so even those who aren’t up on their Conrad have a fighting chance.
Found this at the easier end of the Times spectrum with my initial misspelling of Tiananmen Square the only real hold up. Needed to check the spelling to eventually get FAIR at 21d.
SHERBET is not all that commonly used these days in this context, but was prevalent in my younger days – lead singer of Sherbet, Daryl Braithwaite, lingers on with his song “The Horses” becoming a bit of a racing anthem during the spring carnival here.
Did like unravelling TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE and learning about BLUE PLAQUES (subsequently remembering that some of the older buildings in Collins Street have them). ROOM and FORCEPS were the last couple in.