FOI was 10ac, LOI 19d. My Clue of the Day was probably the comparatively elaborate 2dn, but for once I have an anti-COD, the slur that is the surface of 22ac. The only way I’m going to countenance “light blues good, dark blues bad!” in these parts is if it’s just an Orwellian prelude to “light blues good, dark blues BETTER!” Despite, um, the two most recent boat race results…
ACROSS
1 First stronghold to protect an indefinite number after retreat (8)
FOREMOST – FORT [stronghold] to “protect” reversed SOME [indefinite number].
5 Something surgeon provides for pain (6)
STITCH – double def
10 Artefact of Catholic priest being held? (5)
RELIC – R.C. [Catholic], ELI [priest] being “held”
11 Bound to take chaps into extraterrestrial sort of escape (9)
ELOPEMENT – LOPE [bound] to take MEN [chaps], into E.T. [extraterrestrial]
12 The fellow is entertained by Greek following rationalist philosophy? (9)
ATHEISTIC – HE IS [the fellow | is] “entertained” by ATTIC [Greek]
13 Language of love used by wise man (5)
OSAGE – O [love] used by SAGE [wise man]
14 Stand where gateman has returned (7)
ETAGERE – hidden reversed in {wh}ERE GATE{man}
16 A top man, weak initially, is getting aroused (6)
WAKING – A KING [a | top man], W [weak] initially
18 Old soldiers being gathered came to the same conclusion (6)
AGREED – AGED [old], R.E. [soldiers] being “gathered”
20 Food Rosy brought around as a possible first course? (7)
CHOWDER – CHOW [food] + reversed RED [rosy]. Soup is a good first course
22 Oxford will always be beaten (5)
LACED – double def, Oxford as in a shoe. Outrageous surface
23 Glow of one about to engage in 11? (9)
FIRELIGHT – I RE [one | about] to “engage in” FLIGHT [11 = elopement]
25 Conservative head receiving a guy who lives on an island? (9)
CARIBBEAN – C BEAN [Conservative | head] “receiving” A RIB [a | guy]; guy as in “tease”
26 Part of America with no room for trendy goddess (5)
DIANA – {in}DIANA [part of America, with “no room for” trendy = IN]
27 One going quickly turning miserable, star losing love (6)
DASHER – reversed SAD [miserable] + HER{o} [star, “losing” love = O]
28 Diner travelling in carriage prepared to talk to fellow passengers? (8)
FRIENDLY – (DINER*) [“traveling”] in FLY [carriage]
DOWN
1 Confronts having to collect ash container — they may be very hot (8)
FURNACES – FACES [confronts], having to “collect” URN [ash container]
2 Man perhaps writing half of the letters (5)
RALPH – R [perhaps writing] + ALPH{abet} [“half of” the letters]. Reading, writing and arithmetic are the “three R’s”
3 A line became hard to sort out, as only fit for computer input? (7-8)
MACHINE-READABLE – (A LINE BECAME HARD*) [“to sort out”]
4 Son — little couple’s beloved one (7)
SWEETIE – S WEE TIE [son | little | couple]
6 Mad golfer keen to wed — a temptation that should have been avoided? (4,2,9)
TREE OF KNOWLEDGE – (GOLFER KEEN TO WED*) [“mad”]
7 Parent upset over boy getting cut in the head (9)
TREPANNED – (PARENT*) [“upset”] over NED [boy]
8 Instruction to give girl corporal punishment here? (6)
HITHER – or else, HIT HER! [instruction to give girl corporal punishment]
9 Great big bully pursuing maiden in the capital (6)
MOSCOW – OS COW [great big | bully] pursuing M [maiden]
15 Cigars given out with ale and port (9)
ALGECIRAS – (CIGARS + ALE*) [“given out”]
17 Dry area sinking into sea somewhere across the Channel (8)
BRITTANY – TT A [dry | area] “sinking into” BRINY [sea]
19 Minimal length after incompetent person cut cloth (6)
DUFFEL – L [“minimal” length] after DUFFE{r} [incompetent person “cut”]
20 Investigator given a ring in awkward situation (7)
CORONER – O [a ring] in CORNER [awkward situation]
21 Not half thin, like many a birthday cake cut up (6)
SLICED – SL{im} [“not half” thin] + ICED [like many a birthday cake]
24 Delighted to take in Jehan’s last for organ (5)
GLAND – GLAD [delighted] to “take in” {jeha}N. Just discovered that Jehan Alain was a French composer and organist, which does help appreciate this clue
If you have never heard of Algeciras, it is difficult to get the correct placement of the three leftover vowels.
We used to get ‘etagere’ every week, along with Tiepolo. Maybe he’ll be back as well.
Is ‘atheistic’ rationalist? It might be more rational to hedge your bet, just in case….
Is this the first appearance of DASHER outside a Christmas puzzle, I wonder?
I still had difficulty placing the E and I correctly in 15dn despite being well aware of the name of the Spanish port from history studies many years ago.
Edited at 2019-04-26 05:25 am (UTC)
Edited at 2019-04-26 06:48 am (UTC)
I wonder if ALGECIRAS will cause problems. It qualifies for my personal definition of GK but it’s not exactly the best-known port in the world.
I have three MERs:
1. 16ac. Is W an abbreviation for weak? If not and the ‘initially’ indicates the W, what tells you to put it at the front?
2. 22ac. I think this needs: ‘always be *this* beaten’ or ‘*As* Oxford will always be..’
3. 15dn. OWAA! Obscure Word As Anagram.
Thanks setter and V.
– in Chambers
– not in Collins, although the W boson is
– not in ODO at all
So setter and editor seem to be relying on Chambers for this one. Having said that I generally don’t like that yesterday, I will defend this instance on the basis that some knowledge (if not necessarily understanding) of the concepts involved in particle physics is a fair expectation in this day and age. It’s also much more interesting than where Goliath came from.
Edited at 2019-04-26 11:07 am (UTC)
My CODs were AGREED and HITHER although the latter would probably anger the politically correct.
I thought this a noticeably old-fashioned crossword. Nice to see Eli get his weekly outing. He was the very first crossword cliche I noticed, back in the 1960s, and still going strong today.
It took me a while to expand Algiers to fit into the space available, thereby moving it to Spain. If I had been asked to point out ALGECIRAS on a map, that’s not where I’d have hazarded. Don’t think I’d have looked for OSAGE speakers in Oklahoma either.
Thanks to V for the extra tidbits, especially for Jehan Alain. It’s always good to see that the setter has put in that little additional detail to make the clues more aesthetically pleasing.
Thanks for the blog.
I thought Oxford would always be LUCID. How many centuries since “laced” meant “beaten”? I guessed maybe there was Oxford Lace and D (deceased) was “beaten” rather than only D a draw.
Considered ATONEMENT for 11ac – “a sort of escape” from past misdemeanors? And maybe A TON is not earth-bound?
from Jeepyjay
That doesn’t in any way excuse my incorrect biff of “wakens” – I’d come here for enlightenment from Verlaine as to why Ken’s a top man. I’m grateful to him for parsing SLICED though.
As a confirmed atheist, I think I’m perfectly rational.
I had the same FOI/LOI as Verlaine, but, much as I appreciated RALPH, my COD has to be laced, not least since Oxford colleges have lost five of the last six finals of “University Challenge”, which is a far more pertinent yardstick than a rowing contest.
I, of course, never went to university at all.
I also took ages trying to decide how to spell ALGECIRAS, despite having spent a couple of days there.
Probably not my best solving day.
Cheers, all
Thanks all.
I parsed 25a slightly differently with ‘island?’ as def = C [Conservative head] receiving A RIB [a guy] + BE [who lives] on AN [an]. I agree though that ‘Conservative head’ rather than just ‘Conservative’ for C is unusual so I think this parsing doesn’t quite work.
I liked the simple ‘here’ def for 8d.
Thanks to setter and blogger
Edited at 2019-04-26 12:56 pm (UTC)
I’ve been to Southern Spain often enough to know Algeciras but was left wondering if OMAGE or OSAGE was the language they probably don’t speak there.
Nothing else to add other than that I didn’t even notice that W for weak might be a bone of contention.
Jim R
Jim R (another who fell into the MOONLIGHT trap, by the way)