Oh dear. I began this with high hopes, not of finishing in the 3 minutes or so remaining within my theoretical hour, but at least getting it right in 20 minutes. It started well, I had about two-thirds of it done in ten or eleven minutes, and felt pleased with seeing some of the longer clues like 12a and 21a as well as taking a correct punt on 19d. Then we went off the rails; I hastily bunged in RIO GRAND for 17d, which caused a few problems, not least with 26a. Then I thought, hang on, it ought to be GRANDE, must be wrong.
Left after thirty-odd minutes with 4a, 7d and 5d, with 4a being probably something WEB, I chewed the pencil for another long minute before seeing MENTORING and MOB. Guessed LAKKA (spelling it wrongly) and guessed 4a correctly although not an expression I’d heard. So, all in all, a disaster, darling.
Anyway here are the correct answers and my attempts at explaining them.
Well done to all those who did this in under 20 minutes, I thought it was the hardest of the three in Heat 1.
Left after thirty-odd minutes with 4a, 7d and 5d, with 4a being probably something WEB, I chewed the pencil for another long minute before seeing MENTORING and MOB. Guessed LAKKA (spelling it wrongly) and guessed 4a correctly although not an expression I’d heard. So, all in all, a disaster, darling.
Anyway here are the correct answers and my attempts at explaining them.
Well done to all those who did this in under 20 minutes, I thought it was the hardest of the three in Heat 1.
Across | |
1 | Wife leaving farm building knocked on the head? (6) |
COSHED – A COW SHED is your building, drop the W for wife. | |
4 | Fool in fat group coordinated online (5,3) |
FLASH MOB – I didn’t know this expression and only made a lucky guess as I didn’t understand the wordplay either. I now see it is FLAB for FAT, around SHMO, a variant of SCHMO which apparently is a Yiddish word for fool, especially in USA. Yiddish and poetry are two wide gaps in my otherwise reasonably wide GK. | |
10 | Meat and drink obtained by Ben maybe, crossing street (4,5) |
RUMP STEAK – RUM = drink, PEAK = Ben, mountain in Scotland, insert ST for street. | |
11 | Article returned by fellow is an unexpected gift (5) |
MANNA – MAN = fellow, NA = AN reversed; as in Manna from Heaven. | |
12 | Sanctuaries with oil desecrated in movement against religion (14) |
SECULARISATION – (SANCTUARIES OIL)*. Quickly spotted and unravelled with S and C in place. | |
14 | Management notice time is short (5) |
ADMIN – AD = notice, MIN = short time. | |
16 | Resourceful monarch lay in foul environment (9) |
VERSATILE – VILE = foul, insert ER and SAT = lay. | |
18 | A lot of work left, mostly for unnamed hero (9) |
PORTFOLIO – PORT = left, FO = mostly for, LIO(N) = unnamed hero. | |
20 | Trivial affront son brushed off (5) |
LIGHT – SLIGHT loses its S. | |
21 | Call about individual rolling round pub before dash to get sedative (14) |
PHENOBARBITONE – Complicated wordplay, but easy to biff. Call = PHONE. insert ONE reversed (ENO) then BAR (pub) and BIT (dash). | |
25 | Lively row lacking any extreme language (5) |
HINDI – SHINDIG = row, loses its first and last. | |
26 | Always wearing fur that could be split (9) |
SEVERABLE – EVER inside SABLE = fur. Easy once I’d established S*V- instead of S*N-. | |
27 | Women’s team has got established in part of New York (4,4) |
WEST SIDE – W SIDE insert EST for established. | |
28 | Heading off, hobbled with little energy — cramp? (6) |
IMPEDE – (L)IMPED, E for energy. |
Down | |
1 | Dodgy dealers entertaining people, quick to get involved (4-6) |
CARD-SHARPS – CARDS = entertaining people, SHARP = quick, involve sharp into cards. | |
2 | Copper’s grabbing a maiden climbing tree (5) |
SUMAC – CU’S = copper’s, insert A M, reverse all. | |
3 | Greek character’s record still regularly being played (7) |
EPSILON – EP = record, S I L = regular letters of still, ON = being played. | |
5 | Hundreds of thousands of Indians wanting needs to be heard (5) |
LAKHS – Oh dear. I vaguely remembered there was something called a LAK for a unit of 100,000 rupees, we’ve had it before. And it sounds like LACKS = needs. But I spelt it wrongly. | |
6 | Island’s Sanskrit sayings arts graduate collected (7) |
SUMATRA – For ages I was trying to put something Sanskrit into BA or MA to make the island. But it’s not so. MA goes into SUTRA which I should have clocked having like all naughty schoolboys seen the KARMA SUTRA a long time ago. | |
7 | Advising chaps on journey having left university behind (9) |
MENTORING – MEN = chaps, TOURING loses its U. I should have got this faster, as it’s what I used to do, for small businesses. | |
8 | Duck served in club — one may have gravy (4) |
BOAT – O for duck inside BAT for club. A meal without gravy, like a meal without wine, is like a day without sunshine, IMO. | |
9 | Censure for five, outwardly genuine (8) |
REPROVAL – REAL = genuine, insert PRO = for, V = five. | |
13 | I may forecast what’s coming, if I can get a hearing (7,3) |
WEATHER EYE – Weather eye sounds like whether I = if I. | |
15 | Car with county folk doing business (9) |
MERCHANTS – MERC = car, as in Mercedes-Benz; HANTS = Hampshire. Neat one. | |
17 | River I love that’s wonderful — this one in North America? (3,5) |
RIO BRAVO – R= river, I, O = love, BRAVO = that’s wonderful. Alternative name for the Rio Grande. | |
19 | Enjoyment ends for some strict believers (7) |
FUNDIES – the FUN DIES when enjoyment ends. Apparently fundie is a nickname or abbr. for a (Christian) Fundamentalist. I guessed it. | |
20 | Garland presented to neat county (7) |
LEITRIM – LEI = garland, as in Hawaii, TRIM = neat. Leitrim is a rather sad little county, one of the three Ulster counties in the Republic of Ireland. EDIT I have given you duff guff, I just looked it up on Wiki as, in spite of having lived in Ireland for 14 years until 1988, I couldn’t remember the name of the county town (Carrick-on-Shannon) and it’s not in Ulster, it’s in Connaught. The three Ulster counties in the Republic are, of course, Cavan, Monaghan and beautiful Donegal. | |
22 | Established plot involving poisonous element (5) |
BASED – BED = plot, holds AS, or As, chemical symbol for arsenic. | |
23 | Terrible boredom without party game (5) |
OMBRE – Remove DO = party from boredom, then you have (BOREM)*. Card game originating in Spain. | |
24 | Woodcutter set about hard wood (4) |
SHAW – SAW has H inserted. Shaw is an old name for a small wood or coppice. |
Unknowns or forgottens were SHAW as a wood, LEITRIM, LAKHS and FUNDIES. I was very pleased to know FLASHMOB.
Raised an eyebrow at Rio Grande’s spelling, but in it went. Quickly corrected by severally. Leitrim (cf Antrim) and Fundie guesses from the crossers, never heard of. Otherwise no problems, even knew the lakhs. Merc was helped by having all the brand names last week.
The West German Greens were split into FUNDIE and Realo factions, but I don’t know if I’ve encountered the word in any other context.
I’ve been drinking SUMATRAn coffee daily for 26 years. My LOI was another psychotropic substance, PHENOBARBIT… ONE! Hurray!
Edited at 2018-11-28 07:07 am (UTC)
I too guessed FUNDIE, and LEITRIM (there is a country I’ve never heard of, it seems), and SHAW (with that meaning).
LAKHS was no problem since I’ve done various things requiring budgets in India. It is really hard to get your head around counting in 10^5s (and 10^4s in Chinese is hard too).
Still, I count myself lucky to only have the one letter wrong, and at least I avoided the RIO GRAND trap.
For those of you who’ve never seen a FLASH MOB, here’s a video I shot of one taking place in the local shopping centre.
Edited at 2018-11-28 08:20 am (UTC)
Held up by Flash Mob/Lakhs but eventually managed to guess them, including the H. But foreign homophone spellings are tricky if you don’t know the word.
I was pleased that words like Lei and Sutra, only known from crosswords, now spring readily to mind.
Thanks setter and Pip.
LAKHS from IPL, of course, where man of the match awards are given in one lakh or more amounts, with the curious 1,00,000 notation.
I was (yet) another RIO GRAND. Apparently the RIO BRAVO is the same river, only in Mexico, not that that helps much.
I wonder if the MERC inclusion was a pitch for sponsorship? Do Germans get cryptic crosswords?
Thanks Pip for working it all out and presenting in an entertaining was. (Rio) Bravo!
Edited at 2018-11-28 09:12 am (UTC)
Like others I hampered myself by putting in RIO GRAND despite knowing that it ends in an E. I also had CARD SHARKS in place for a while. Once I’d sorted them out I managed all but LAKHS.
Started at a sprint and crawled to the (DN)finish.
I think the ones I didn’t get were Lakhs, Flash Mob, Hindi and Fundies.
I don’t think I will do quite so well with the Heat 2 puzzles! However I have a copy of all three Heat 2 puzzles so I may attempt these in the allowed time before next week.
Great blog Pip but not sure why LEITRIM is “sad”. Very pretty place with mountains towards Donegal and lovely lakes of which Lough Allen is probably best known. It even has a very short coastline. In the news of course because it shares a border with Fermanagh which is in NI
More accurately, slow down ! 11A was altered to MANNA once SUMATRA was sighted.
Done in test conditions on the Monday after the Championship. Biffed FLASH MOB, and PORTFOLIO, both successfully parsed on completion, and finished in a single attempt.
Didn’t like PHENOBARBITONE.
FOI COSHED
LOI FUNDIES
COD FLASH MOB
TIME 14:14
SUMACs are the quintessential NY urban trees (A Tree Grows In Brooklyn) – they fill up all the vacant lots very fast. Sherlock’s giant rat of SUMATRA was the tale for which the world was not yet ready. 19.06
Regarding SCHMO, my mother (who had some Jewish roots somewhere along the line) used it to mean a daft or foolish person, but also as “Joe Schmo” to mean any arbitary person.
Edited at 2018-11-28 12:42 pm (UTC)
At least I saw at once that it couldn’t be Rio Grande!
I thought I was doing OK on this one – after 45 minutes I just had 23 down and 28 across left to enter. Worked out the anagram fodder for 23 down and came up with OMBER – Googled it to check the spelling – yup, it’s a card game – bunged it in and then hit the buffers. -M-R-E for 28 across was never going to let me finish.
Note to self: when checking unknown words, make sure there isn’t an alternative spelling.
Time: DNF in 50 minutes.
Thank you to setter and blogger.
Dave.
We’ve had SHAW at least twice before and I knew it anyway, and having written in LAKKS at 5 I knew it didn’t look right so we must have seen that in a previous puzzle as well.
So about 32 minutes for this and the puzzle from 2 weeks ago and another 16 for last week’s without ACONITE. Timing wise I’d have been on for top 25 but I’m not sure that aconite would ever have come to me.
Of course I tried the SIKHS as well, wondering how many of them there really were, until FLASH MOB made that impossible and I replaced it with LAKHS with a similar spelling turning out to be correct. RIO GRANDE wouldn’t fit, so it had to be RIO BRAVO and everything else, if not familiar, was clear from wordplay.
My time was 35 minutes, with the one mistake. Why can I do the competition puzzles so fast if I can’t manage the regular ones in under an hour?
Edited at 2018-11-28 08:33 pm (UTC)
They didn’t feel especially easy but they all yielded steadily in what for me is a pretty quick time. I suspect I may just have been on the right wavelength & will get my comeuppance in the rest of the puzzles.