Time: 39 Minutes
Music: Fleetwood Mac, Then Play On
I found this puzzle a bit more difficult than one might expect, but maybe that’s just me. I had particular trouble with ‘to the life’, which doesn’t seem to be clued with the exactness I would expect. On the other hand, there were some truly fine clues in the toreador’s whirl and the object added to gallery, so I would say there is much to admire here.
The blog is a little late because I spent the day watching the US Open, and then could not resist going out and hitting a few shots on the holes adjoining my condo. Congratulations to Brooks Koepka, and condolences to Tommy Fleetwood, who I really thought might win.
| Across | |
| 1 | Calm after retreating journalist went off (10) |
| DECOMPOSED – ED backwards + COMPOSED. | |
| 6 | Some time, so to speak, for you and me (4) |
| OURS – Sounds like HOURS. If you reversed the clue and put HOUR, the crossing letters will set you right | |
| 10 | Defector in pursuit of spy, one going underground in Africa (4,3) |
| MOLE RAT – MOLE + RAT, in entirely different senses, making the actual animal a double agent. | |
| 11 | Singular protection for pugilist in love (7) |
| SMITTEN – S + MITTEN, where the pugilist is more often said to be wearing boxing GLOVES. | |
| 12 | Feline in revamped Disney corporation (9) |
| SYNDICATE – CAT inside anagram of DISNEY. | |
| 13 | Here the Spanish may meet Dad carrying short loaf (5) |
| PLAZA – P(LAZ[e])A, The urge to see ‘the Spanish’ and put EL must be resisted here. | |
| 14 | Restrictive level (5) |
| TYING – Double definition, the second not exactly fitting, but close enough. | |
| 15 | Precisely where the reader may resort for memoirs? (2,3,4) |
| TO THE LIFE – Double definition, one factitious. | |
| 17 | Elder priest shunning current hosts by turning about (9) |
| PRESBYTER – PR[i]S(BY)T + RE backwards. | |
| 20 | Fraudster making journey back in regret (5) |
| ROGUE – R(GO backwads)UE | |
| 21 | Supposed repository of lost car, with black interior (5) |
| LIMBO – LIM(B)O. With a glancing allusion to the comic folk meme that lost objects end up in Limbo, found in mock-heroic poetry of the 16th and 17th century. | |
| 23 | Closeness of Jane and Cecily in distress, Neil having left (9) |
| ADJACENCY – Anagram of JANE AND CECILY – NEIL, a rather awkward cryptic technique, in my opinion. | |
| 25 | Object added to gallery a very timely gift (7) |
| GODSEND – GODS + END, where GODS refers to a seating area in the theatre so remote from the stage that it is closer to heaven. | |
| 26 | Tweet greeting bishop in competition (7) |
| CHIRRUP – C(HI RR)UP. | |
| 27 | Charge for using ring on regular basis (4) |
| TOLL – double definition, very well put-together. | |
| 28 | Boy participating in gym to improve as an individual (10) |
| PERSONALLY – PE R(SON)ALLY, a clever cryptic, but most solvers will just biff the obvious answerr. | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Marches taking up a number of days (5) |
| DEMOS – SOME D upside-down. | |
| 2 | Plant borders of Chinese territory in East (9) |
| CELANDINE – C[hines]E + LAND IN E. | |
| 3 | Union negotiator (8-6) |
| MARRIAGE-BROKER -Cryptic definition, an easy one. | |
| 4 | Keep going past contrary sailor in old hat (7) |
| OUTLAST – OU(SALT upside-down)T | |
| 5 | Most relaxed English afternoon break, last to start (7) |
| EASIEST – E + SIESTA with the last letter moved to the front. | |
| 7 | Extremist detected in unlawful trading (5) |
| ULTRA – hidden in [unlawf]UL TRA[ding] | |
| 8 | Asian gets a breath of air in Kent, perhaps (9) |
| SINHALESE – S(INHALES)E, where it helps if you are familiar with the two main ethnic groups in Sri Lanka. | |
| 9 | Division represented by lowly Republican in caucus (6,8) |
| SIMPLE FRACTION – SIMPLE + F(R)ACTION. | |
| 14 | Fantastic escape after vessel overturned (3,6) |
| TOP FLIGHT – POT upside-down + FLIGHT | |
| 16 | College ultimately cuts organised learning across the board (2,7) |
| IN GENERAL – anagram of [colleg]E + LEARNING. | |
| 18 | Toreador whirls, primarily to confuse bull (7) |
| TWADDLE – T[oreador} W[hirls] + ADDLE, which will certainly confuse the solvers who try to make an anagram of some part of TOREADOR | |
| 19 | Those excluded from court amid random jeers (7) |
| REJECTS – CT in anagram of JEERS. | |
| 22 | Olympian dreams of this mess, it’s said (5) |
| MEDAL – Sounds like MEDDLE, probably as a verb. | |
| 24 | Tail of husky walking on air, commonly barking (5) |
| YAPPY – [husk}Y + ‘APPY. | |
Vinyl, I don’t think one has to resort to poetic allusions to justify the definition of LIMBO as “repository of lost,” but your reference is intriguing, and I have tried (in vain, so far) to find, via Google, an example of such 16th- or 17th-century verse.
I might’ve seen the word CELANDINE somewhere, but had the impression I was building it solely from the wordplay.
My LOI was TYING, which seemed, in retrospect, very easy—but now that Vinyl mentions it, TIED would be a better fit with “level,” wouldn’t it?
[quote]John Milton in “Paradise Lost” gives us the Paradise of Fools as a “limbo large and broad,” where winds blow about Roman Catholic cowls, hoods, habits, relics, beads, indulgences, pardons and Papal Bulls.[/quote]
Milton here is using “limbo” in a figurative sense, “a limbo.” I maintain that the original sense, the “real” Limbo, fits the definition “repository of lost” well enough.
Bloom again: [quote]In the Italian Renaissance poet Luduvico Ariosto’s “Orlando Furioso,” the knight Astolfo visits the moon’s Limbo and discovers there all of earth’s wastages: talents locked up in named vases, bribes hanging on gold hooks, and much besides.[/quote]
Well, that’s the moon’s Limbo. These various “limbos” are called that simply because their purpose, broadly speaking, matches that given in the original concept (which is not part of Catholic dogma—as a publication authorized by Pope Benedict XVI merely confirmed. This publication, and erroneous headlines about the Pope’s abolishing Limbo, is what prompted the Bloom article).
Edited at 2018-06-18 04:01 am (UTC)
The DNK I solved without difficulty was MOLE RAT.
My problems in the NE segment started when I wrote in HOUR at 6ac – a perfectly acceptable answer when solving without checkers in place, so not the best of clues in my opinion – and it was quite late in the day when I realised my error and that much of the time and effort I had invested in trying to solve 8dn had been wasted attempting to think of an answer begining with R?N.
15ac also foxed me for ages but eventually I came up with TO THE LIFE which to me seems absolutely fine. As does TYING / ‘level’ at 14ac as competitors in a game that’s still in progress might be said to be ‘level or tying at the moment’, although ‘tied’ would probably be the word of first choice to describe this situation.
Elsewhere I spent time considering MARRIAGE AGENCY at 3dn but when BROKER occurred to me it seemed a better fit and therefore more likely. VULGAR FRACTION seemed perfectly possible at 9dn until checkers ruled it out.
Finally I failed to spot the obvious at 22dn and thought ‘Olympian’ was a reference to something in mythology that sounded like “muddle” (mess), so in the end I used aids and kicked myself.
Edited at 2018-06-18 03:37 am (UTC)
A lot of satisfying moments when the light suddenly dawned, especially SINHALESE
I enjoyed it until the NE where I corrected Hour to Ours but still was floored by the Simple/Smitten/Plaza/Sinhalese combo. And the last bit of To The Life – never heard of it.
Well played setter.
And thanks Vinyl
I know you like your music trivia and I think you’ll enjoy it (especially the very funny Aerosmith / RUN-DMC bit):
https://www.bbc.co.uk/music/articles/2b5f1d76-a6ff-46bb-8ac0-b68542f97592
DNK to the life.
I thought there were some clever touches here: RR not B for the bishop in 26ac; ‘gods’ not ‘Tate’ for ‘gallery in 25ac and I thought the anagram in 23ac was clever.
My LOI was TO THE LIFE. I had heard of it but it didn’t suggest itself as a solution for a long time.
Incidentally, vinyl1, what is your view of Mickelson’s bit of cheating? I thought he should have been disqualified. In footballing terms he has ‘brought the game into disrepute’.
I’m off to play myself. Fortunately, the greens on my course are about 6 on the Stimpmeter.
Edited at 2018-06-18 02:41 pm (UTC)
The parson told the sexton and the sexton tolled the bell.
Some nice clues here. I liked Easiest, which I couldn’t parse, not spotting siesta, Sinhalese, Godsend and Tying.
COD: Tying for first place, EASIEST and SINHALESE.
Eventually scrubbed anything in the NE that could be scrubbed, and arrived at the right answers, though I was tempted to put in SAMPLE FRICTION more or less as a commentary. 31 minutes, excessive for a Monday.
Jack’s spot on about TO THE LIFE, a compliment to the portrait artist.
I never could do LIMBO dancing, not so much a repository of a lost (art) but a never found.
I was another who put HOUR at 6a, which I agree is a perfectly plausible answer, but fortunately 7d was an easy one that quickly clarified the situation.
For 23a I’m of the school that says removed letters either need to be consecutive, or indicated as an anagram (e.g. “Neil unexpectedly having left”).