My FOI was 15ac, rather strangely as I couldn’t have told you what the word actually means before today, but having thought of the DG, the answer fell quickly into place. The bottom half of the puzzle was then completed without too many speed bumps, and then I returned to finish off the top, which I have to say would probably have been just as easy if the anagram at 1ac had resolved itself immediately in my mind. As it was, the initial T plus the enumeration was certainly enough to biff the rest in.
I think the vocabulary level of this puzzle is just right for a good Times 15×15, some lovely rare words without resorting to anything dredged up from the lightless depths of the dictionary into which only setters of barred puzzles dare venture. The surfaces are all fine and dandy too without anything jumping out at me particularly. I’ll give my COD to 1dn despite the egregious wrongness in the wordplay: toast is for life not just for myrtilus000‘s breakfast! Thanks to the setter.
ACROSS
1 Only part of the problem is eg the fibre-optic, sadly (3,2,3,7)
TIP OF THE ICEBERG – (IS EG THE FIBRE-OPTIC*) [“sadly”]
9 Act timidly as cat’s-paw (9)
PUSSYFOOT – more or less a double def
10 Lower barrier enclosing empty space (5)
BASER – BAR [barrier] “enclosing” S{pac}E
11 In method of access, university going for good pay back here (6)
AVENGE – AVEN{u->G}E [method of access, mutatis mutandis]
12 Benefit includes free new playing field (8)
GRIDIRON – GIRO [benefit] “includes” RID [free] + N [new]
13 Sound quality of wood finally being turned (6)
TIMBRE – TIMB{E<->R} [wood, mutatis mutandis]
15 Head of BBC wearing curious sleeve that shouldn’t unravel (8)
SELVEDGE – DG [head of BBC] “wearing” (SLEEVE*) [“curious”]. This is a distaff rather than a sword word, so unfamiliar to a macho type like myself, but it is literally the edge on a woven fabric that prevents unravelling.
18 Rabbit’s little problem: caught by predator (8)
CHITCHAT – HITCH [little problem] “caught by” CAT [predator]
19 No time for wildly enjoyable event about to be hosted by prize solver (6)
POIROT – RIO{t} [wildly enjoyable event, m.m.] reversed, “hosted by” POT [cup]
21 Top up, backing partner to drink litre (8)
PULLOVER – UP reversed + LOVER [partner], to “drink” L [litre]
23 With unfulfilled potential, chap starts to question universal education (6)
MANQUE – MAN [chap] + Q{uestion} U{niversal} E{ducation}
26 Report of British members losing way in German League (5)
HANSA – HANSA{rd} [report of British members (of parliament), losing RD = way]
27 A guilty man, I cried uncontrollably after charge withdrawn (9)
PARRICIDE – (I CRIED*) [“uncontrollably”] after RAP [charge] reversed
28 Book on unfinished temple has unusual origin (15)
PARTHENOGENESIS – GENESIS [book] on PARTHENO{n} [“unfinished” temple]
DOWN
1 In part of ship, breakfast food served around wrong time of day? (7)
TOPMAST – TOAST [breakfast food] served around PM [wrong time of day (for breakfast food)]. I must interject here that if you only eat toast for breakfast you are not living live the verlaine way…
2 Type that’s confused about way in mountain track (5)
PISTE – PIE [type that’s confused] about ST [way]. I hesitated over the definition of “pie” here but it can mean “an indiscriminate mixture of printing types”, so there you go. Viz also the Magpie barred puzzle magazine perhaps (in a good way).
3 Be transported by a cigar, strange hallucinogen (3,6)
FLY AGARIC – FLY [be transported] + A + (CIGAR*) [“strange”]
4 Jump round ring; shouldn’t one jump through it? (4)
HOOP – HOP [jump] round O [ring], semi-&lit
5 One seabird in trap where people surf? (8)
INTERNET – I [one] + TERN [seabird] in NET [trap]
6 Fix smart girl and yours truly up (5)
EMBED – DEB + ME [smart girl | yours truly], the whole reversed
7 Is ready to edit royal film (4,5)
EASY RIDER – (IS READY*) [“to edit”] + ER [royal]
8 Wine-producing area has some striking iron deposits (7)
GIRONDE – hidden in {strikin}G IRON DE{posits}
14 Addict under control in a month (9)
MAINLINER – IN LINE [under control] in MAR [a month]
16 Opposed to solitary confinement, ignoring small infringement (9)
VIOLATION – V [opposed to] + I{s}OLATION [solitary confinement, “ignoring” S = small]
17 Pointer the continental snake tailed (5,3)
LASER PEN – LA [the “continental”] + SERPEN{t} [snake “tailed”]. Now that I go to London Saturday crossword meetups once or twice a month I see quite a lot of the setter Serpent, and a good time that always is too.
18 Nick is landed with hard work (3,4)
COP SHOP – COPS H OP [is landed with | hard | work]
20 Greek hero seen oddly in America (7)
THESEUS – S{e}E{n} in THE US [America]
22 Surprised reaction about publication in market town (5)
OMAGH – OH! [surprised reaction] about MAG [publication]. Not sure if the market is the first thing that springs to mind when considering Omagh, but presumably it does have a good one?
24 Throwing game drops ball and walks out (5)
QUITS – QU{o}ITS [throwing game, “dropping” O = ball]
25 Queen boards large sailing ship (4)
BRIG – R [queen] “boards” BIG [large]
1ac reminded me of the snail in the snail race who shed his shell in an attempt to go faster. But it only made him sluggish. The winner received a piece of lettuce, looked disappointed, but was told it was only the tip of the iceberg.
Two hold ups today: (a) pondering for ages over why Pie was confusing (DNK), and (b)discussing with Mrs M the precise meaning of Selvedge and its non-unravelableness.
Mostly I liked: Toast!, Pussyfoot, Poirot, Cop Shop and Violation (COD).
Thanks fun setter and V.
HANSA in on trust: I knew the Hanseatic League (who doesn’t?) but not the additional versions.
POIROT my CoD for its tricky definition (solver is usually me) and multilayered wordplay.
Wiki doesn’t make much of OMAGH as a market town, though it obviously used to be, but fitting in a reference to it as the home of the Western Education and Library Board might have been a step too far for our setter, not to mention us.
I’m with V on TOAST (hoorah!) as the not-just-for-breakfast food, but none of the other breakfast foods seemed to help.
Quite a few clues where I wasn’t sure of my ground (OMAGH, SELVEDGE, HANSA, MANQUE, PARRICIDE) but the wordplay and checkers led inexorably to the answers.
Like V, yesterday’s Holmes clue caused me to start out considering that for 19a.
In a crowded field, I’ll give a joint COD nod to the two Grecian clues, THESEUS and PARTHENOGENESIS
Praise be the setter, and Myrtilus, who continues to take the gentle art of punning to unsuspected depths
Cracker of cases yesterday and ‘solver’ today. Are we working our way through all the fictional detectives? Actually, come to think of it, ‘solver’ would be a rather good definition of Morse.
PISTE was my LOI, not helped by not knowing the required definition of PIE and in the end I just assumed that it might have a general meaning of something that’s confused or messy. ‘He made a pie of it’, for example, in the same way as ‘hash’ can be used.
Edited at 2018-03-09 08:52 am (UTC)
Did the good Lord Verlaine turn up yesterday? That was the stinker.
FOI 9ac PUSSYFOOT
COD 18dn COP SHOP
WOD 26ac PARTHENOGENESIS
Another double cross grid.
Edited at 2018-03-09 10:03 am (UTC)
I’m a bit surprised at the lack of familiarity with the printer’s PIE. I thought it was a crossword staple.
Thanks to Myrtilus for the Dad joke. I’m looking forward to inducing some serious eye-roll later.
COD to POIROT.
BTW, I first read the breakfast as OATS, for which I’m blaming Myrtilus.
And why Halloween or am I being sluggish?
Edited at 2018-03-09 09:43 am (UTC)
horryd
I had a bit of experience in the textile trade as a young fellow, so I still know a little of the terminology. The squares of denim in a salesman’s sample book would always include one side with the selvedge.
Surprised at the number of people who didn’t know PIE the jumbled pile of printers type turns up on a regular basis in cryptic crosswords, although now I come to think of it, usually always accompanied by a chorus of “I didn’t know that….”
Magoo took 7 and a half minutes over this one which is of course slow for Magoo. With the hindsight of having waded through my parsing duties I’m not quite sure why this was a hard puzzle, but it does seem to have been one!
I have certainly done the QC in blazingly fast times (by 15×15 standards) with mounting excitement and then been sorely disappointed that it wasn’t the crossword I thought it was, so you are very much not alone…
I biffed far more clues than I should have done, and that eventually led to my come-uppance.
The first biff was GRIDIRON. I long ago gave up trying to understand the game, so didn’t realise the colloquial name came from the shape of the pitch.
Entered GARONNE at 8D (much prefer real ale to vino) but luckily spotted the encapsulation just in time.
At 27A I entered the RICIDE part of the solution and only completed the rest once I got BRIG.
28A was an educated biff, since PARTHENOGENESIS is a particularly long instrumental by Canned Heat, and my misspent youth served me well for once.
26A was biffed too – a really good clue once V explained it. Alas, the final biff at 17D was my undoing. I was convinced it was some sort of pin, and entered LAPEL PIN more in hope than expectancy.
So 21.15 DNF. COD 19A, with honourable mentions to 18D and 26A. Thanks to the setter for a very enjoyable offering, and to V for his usual fine blog.
Bit tricky today – I got “Tip of the Iceberg” pleasingly quickly which gave me a head start on the top half of the X-word but – even when I cottoned-on happily to “Parthenogenesis” I still found the bottom half more difficult. I was not helped by thinking Patricide rather than Parricide, which threw me completely off on the Large Sailing Ship! Chitchat was tricky – I imagined that would be two words – nice clue, though. I had to look Manque up in the dictionary. I am pleased to say that I did not know Mainliner was a drug-user – I thought it was the Flying Scotsman.
Selvedge, I’ve seen before in a crossword but it did not come quickly to mind – one of those words you only see in crosswords! Ah well, good fun and got there eventually. Mike Cowking
I’m always surprised when words that I consider arcane Americana are well enough known to go into the puzzle – US States are one example, as I’m pretty sure that most Americans would be stuck for counties after Norfolk, Suffolk, possibly York, and Kent. So I hesitated over today’s Gridiron (it refers to the markings, every five yards, up the field) because in the US it is really only used by aging sports writers when they get to thinking they’ve written “field” one time too many.
Good challenge, though, cheers. Great blog too.
Edited at 2018-03-10 07:16 am (UTC)
Enjoyed this puzzle a lot, so much so that I pushed five minutes over my hour to finish it off. It seems I’m in good company putting in 19a POIROT last; glad I finally thought of “pot”… FOI 1a TIP OF THE ICEBERG, which was a good start, as was biffing 18a PARTHENOGENESIS on the basis of only two crossers about halfway through the struggle.
Liked 9a PUSSYFOOT, and 4d HOOP, having been helped on the latter by listening to Natalie Merchant’s Ophelia about ten times in a row on Thursday night. (“Ophelia is a circus queen/the female cannonball/projected through five flaming hoops/to wild and shocked applause…”)
Anyway. Enough of the hungover waffle. Thanks to setter and V, whose detailed parsings I shall now consult for the many question-marks in my margins here, not least of which was the “pie” of 2d PISTE. Coincidentally enough, I did wonder whether it had something to do with “pie-eyed”…
“Report” suggested a pun, and members suggested arms which suggested “hands”. So I provisionally biffed HANSE for a while, and tried to remember a market town called OTESH.
The clue for POIROT was so long at 13 words I had thought it might be celebrating some solver here for some competition.
PIE has a sense of harlequin motley, as in “piebald” so that was a confident biff. I’ve wondered if the most common sense of pie connotes such patchwork of pieces of food as a filling.
Thanks all
Thanks all.