My overall impression of this one is that there is some virtuoso cluing going on – three &lits or thereabout, an excellent cryptic def, fine surfaces, a great mastery of the setter’s arsenal on display (I know it’s completely obvious what’s going on whenever it comes up now, but I am still tickled by “sandwiches” as a containment indicator) – but somehow I didn’t enjoy this as much as some tough Friday fare, there being a few clues that felt slightly forced into shape. The peasant in 19ac would be completely fair game in a barred puzzle but I’m sure many of us won’t have known it without looking it up here; I was a bit confused about the grammatically convoluted definition “being arranged again” at 22ac (though fair play to the clue for making me waste long minutes pondering RESISTING and RESITTING before finally getting there); is an ovoid really an “egg”; plus a couple of bits of sporting terminology, one of which at least was quite difficult, that always rub me up the wrong way, though I accept that the flaw is in my not in sports, which I do now have to learn much more about, for quizzing purposes…
But yes, I did love the multiple &lits, of which 2dn was I think my favourite, and the cryptic def is clever enough that I think I might even give it my COD. Thanks setter! How did everyone else fare with the today’s tricksiness, mostly irk or mostly smirk?
ACROSS
1 Pack up stuff for temporary abode (5,3)
CRASH PAD – CRASH [pack up, as in a computer] + PAD [stuff, as in a bra, maybe]
5 Noisy pigeon set about quiet old Hollywood actor (6)
COOPER – COOER [noisy pigeon] set about P [quiet]. Gary Cooper, who won Best Actor Oscars in 1942 and 1953 for Sergeant York and High Noon.
10 This could be M’s part? Yes (9)
SPYMASTER – [“this could be”] (M’S PART YES*), Bond-based semi-&lit. FOI
11 Daughter, passionate, celebrated nude (5)
DAVID – D AVID [daughter | passionate]. Michelangelo’s David which you can find in Florence.
12 Finally blow into warm club providing cosy environment (4)
WOMB – {blo}W {int}O {war}M {clu}B
13 He’d put out east from the Caymans, somehow? (9)
YACHTSMAN – (TH{e} CAYMANS*) [“somehow”], nautical semi-&lit
15 Nothing, within reason, eclipsing first of these, apparently (10)
OSTENSIBLY – O [nothing] + SENSIBLY [within reason] “eclipsing” T{hese}
17 Have a go at someone’s short cut (4)
SNIP – SNIP{e} [have a go at some one “is short”]
19 Old peasant to rear woodland creature (4)
HIND – triple def with multiple levels of obscurity
20 Promise fair puzzle (4-6)
WORD-SQUARE – WORD SQUARE [promise | fair]
22 Opposed to golf, on balance, being arranged again (9)
RESTAGING – AGIN G [opposed to | golf], on REST [balance]. Slightly confused about whether the definition has the same transitivity as the answer?
24 Fall for American, not half: love his car! (4)
AUTO – AUT{umn} [fall for American, “not half”] + O [love], to get an American word for car.
26 Starter of duck becoming duck and egg (5)
OVOID – {a->O}VOID. Duck is AVOID, make its starter into a duck [O] and get something that is approximately an egg.
27 Bloomer as drug agent sends out missing drug (9)
NARCISSUS – NARC [drug agent] + ISSU{e}S [sends out, missing E]
28 Fur coat owner’s embarrassed admission? (6)
ERMINE – punctuate differently to get the diffident claim of ownership “er… mine”
29 Declined to pot, for example, first and second reds (8)
LEFTIST – LEFT [decline to pot, for example] + IST + S. In snooker, the “leave” means the position in which a player leaves the balls for the next player, and I assume it works as a verb too.
DOWN
1 Attack pacifist leading appeal for peace (4)
COSH – CO [= conscientious objector = pacifist] + SH! [appeal for peace]
2 Desperate option many tars ponder ultimately? (3,4,2,1,5)
ANY PORT IN A STORM – [“desperate”] (OPTION MANY TARS {ponde}R*), &lit.
3 Lockkeeper to become a leading musician? (8)
HEADBAND – lock-as-in-hair-keeper; and to HEAD a BAND is to become its leading musician.
4 Even pieces of carpet I lay so as to fit (5)
APTLY – every second letter of {c}A{r}P{e}T {i} L{a}Y
6 Refusal to lift tax for working (2,4)
ON DUTY – NO reversed [refusal “to lift”] + DUTY [tax]
7 They need walk-on parts for their sketches (8,7)
PAVEMENT ARTISTS – cryptic def, the pavement artist being one that sketches on the parts of street people walk on
8 Fish from tin, roughly prepared sandwiches (3,7)
RED SNAPPER – SN [tin], “sandwiched” by (PREPARED*) [“roughly”]
9 Ran slowly in what’s deceptive light (8)
TRICKLED – TRICK [what’s deceptive] + LED [= light emitting diode = light]
14 One expecting the right to wear second medal (6-2-2)
MOTHER-TO-BE – THE RT [the | right ] to wear MO OBE [second | medal]
16 Africans, a Welshman, and some Scots? (8)
IVORIANS – IVOR [a Welshman] + IANS [some Scots], Ivorians being inhabitants of Cote d’Ivoire. Still not as good an African people’s name as Equatoguineans though…
18 Time to stop a curiously old-fashioned etching technique (8)
AQUATINT – T [time] to “stop” A QUAINT [a | curiously old-fashioned]. AQUATINT is a word that comes up in crossword puzzles more than you’re expect.
21 Benefit that people must carry over (6)
MAIDEN – AID [benefit] that MEN [people] must carry. A maiden is an over in cricket in which no runs are scored.
23 Stuff essential for giving or getting (5)
GORGE – hidden in {givin}G OR GE{tting}
25 Article female related unaltered (2,2)
AS IS – A SIS [article | female related]
A long time chewing over some bits – not made easy by MERs like Pack up = Crash (ok, computers, I see) and Attack = Cosh.
But it was worth it as there are some great clues.
Mostly I liked: Noisy pigeon, Lockkeeper, M-to-be, &Lit 2dn, and COD to the Pavement Artist (nicely done).
Thanks elegant setter and V.
Nearly put ostensible.. but didn’t.
MAIDEN in the SW was another beast of a clue, making OVOID look as if it might be wrong.
I did like the plethora of &lits, though, and have learned that HIND is an old (Chambers says Scottish, I say Posh) word for peasant. Good stuff.
Very much not a fan of 19ac. One person’s obscure is another’s commonplace of course but this one plainly escaped from a Mephisto.
Same concerns as V over the ‘transitivity’ (what a good word) of RESTAGING, but otherwise it’s all good stuff.
Snow days not appreciated here. My rented rural property has an antiquated private water supply that has been frozen solid since Wednesday evening. Turns out the life of an eighteenth century HIND is not all that idyllic
FOI 25dn AS IS
LOI 21dn MAIDEN
COD 10ac SPY MASTER
WOD NARCISSUS (Conrad)
I look forward to Monday’s stinker!
Edited at 2018-03-02 10:21 am (UTC)
Complete chaos here. Dorset is not geared up for snow. All major roads impassable last night and a trainload of commuters stuck outside Christchurch with no heating, light, food or drink. Thank goodness we can sit indoors and follow it all on the internet!
Edited at 2018-03-02 11:29 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-03-02 11:25 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2018-03-02 01:02 pm (UTC)
I must take the opportunity to say that I liked the semi-&lits, and 19ac, where I had heard of all three meanings.
My failure was on the nasty 19a where I seem to have come up with a unique wrong answer.
Old peasant = HUN (well they’re old and some of them must have been peasants)
To rear woodland = D, obvs
Creature = HUND (German dog).
QED
Be they knights or hinds or yeomen,
They shall bite the ground! (referring to the English, of course)
and I actually bothered to look ‘hinds’ up at the time.
Incidentally, the closing words of the song were gloriously jingoistic: ‘Cambria, God, and Right!’
Gary Cooper, as well as being a fine horseman, was also a dab hand at comedy, as Ball of Fire with Barbara Stanwyck amply demonstrates.
Edited at 2018-03-02 01:55 pm (UTC)
I found this the nearest to a stinker we have had in a while but that was mainly down to the SW corner which I found above average in difficulty, but elsewhere were gifts such as PAVEMENT ARTIST. I couldn’t decide between SENSIBLE and SENSIBLY at 15ac but eventually plumped for the required answer whilst remaining unconvinced that the alternative is not also valid.
Edited at 2018-03-02 02:17 pm (UTC)
With stinkers, I’m usually lucky to get 3-4 clues.
My flu must be Geri g better!
BW
Andrew K
I started well enough, and had the whole right hand side complete in 6 minutes, BUT….
I biffed three clues among that, and two more followed later.
Eventually beaten by 21A (which I thought was poor), and 22D (which I award COD, as it beat me fair and (word)square.
19A went straight in, though being an aficionado of AZED may have helped. I was denied my Sunday treat this week because they printed an 11 x 11 grid for a 15 x 15 puzzle, and doing it on a smartphone is a poor option. New style, but same old Grauniad I fear.
Thank you, setter. Thank you, Verlaine.
RESTAGING: No, no, no, “being arranged again” does not define that word; “arranging again” would. Massive fail, setter.
HIND: I suspected an obscure third def., but wasn’t in a place where I could check it.
OVOID: I had the same question as V, but this was mainly myself making heavy weather of it.
LEFTISTS: Could not parse—snooker!
MAIDEN: Could not parse, though I’ve seen the cricket term here before, admittedly.
And “pack up” = CRASH, as in computers, somehow? How? Not that this was one that hung me up.
The &lit I liked best was the one for SPYMASTER.
Fun fact: In the Thursday NY Times puzzle (so the same day I worked this), the theme answer was WORD SQUARE. Eerie.
Edited at 2018-03-02 05:24 pm (UTC)
Still, coffee to the rescue and I squeezed just inside my limit at 58 minutes.
FOI 4d APTLY, LOI 16d IVORIANS. Lots of “I like that!” exclamation marks in the margins, for 10a, 11a, 2d and 9d, especially the TRICK LED.
Thanks to setter and V.
It doesn’t seem too outlandish to have RESTAGING as an intransitive but I can’t actually find a dictionary that has it as such.
A chewy stinker IMHO.
Thanks as ever for the blog V.
horryd
Edited at 2018-03-03 03:47 pm (UTC)