As crosswords go it’s simply but effectively clued but with a nice sprinkling of wit and surfaces that make you think “ooh, that’s clever”. As you will know if you are long-time reader I really like clues that seem aware of their context and as such I really enjoyed 26ac, 5dn and 19dn which are all above averagely “crosswordy”; I’ll give 19dn my Clue of the Day award, by a nose.
The long answers around the edge were also all interesting phrases and tantalisingly close to being thematic with one another. Compulsory minor quibble to avoid looking like a complete brown-noser: 25ac is a bit archaic and/or a barred puzzle type word – cursory investigations make me believe its modern meaning is something completely different than “stink”. But overall, much enjoyed, and many thanks to the setter!
ACROSS
1 Joy seemingly from sweets one’s found in row of shops (5,8)
FOOL’S PARADISE – FOOLS [sweets] + I’S [one’s] found in PARADE [row of shops]
9 Something uplifting from rubbish men (5)
ROTOR – ROT O.R. [rubbish | men]
10 Expel university staff, mostly cutting charge (9)
RUSTICATE – U STIC{k} [university | staff “mostly”] cutting RATE [charge]
11 Refusal to inhabit Bel Air curiously impractical (10)
INOPERABLE – NOPE [refusal] to inhabit (BEL AIR*) [“curiously”]
12 Lawyer’s right to prolong rest, wanting one (4)
LIEN – LIE {i}N [to prolong rest, “wanting” I (one)]
14 Heartless demagogue made choice to be loyal (7)
DEVOTED – D{emagogu}E + VOTED [made choice]
16 Flipping veteran sneakily conceals trap (7)
ENSNARE – hidden reversed in {vet}ERAN SNE{akily}
17 Marks in sum docked, after number’s very low (7)
NOMINAL – M IN AL{l} [marks | in | sum “docked”], after NO [number]
19 Gather in most of tough clothing (7)
HARVEST – HAR{d} VEST [“most of” tough | clothing]
20 Speaker’s blunt and cross (4)
ROOD – homophone of RUDE [blunt]
21 Diner’s complaint, given pink articles used in bodega? (10)
SALMONELLA – SALMON [pink] + EL LA [two Spanish grammatical articles]
24 Restriction initially withdrawn for take-off (9)
IMITATION – {l}IMITATION [restriction, “initially withdrawn”]
25 Stink outside of malodorous object returns (5)
MIASM – reverse all of M{alodorou}S + AIM [object]
26 Trouble is to do with anagram helper (4,9)
GOOD SAMARITAN – (IS TO DO + ANAGRAM*) [“trouble…”]
DOWN
1 Offer put in exchanged for refund: it’s an enticement (9,5)
FORBIDDEN FRUIT – BID [offer] put in (FOR REFUND IT*) [“exchanged…”]
2 Wrong note is better (5)
OUTDO – OUT DO [wrong | note]
3 Windy river, confined in another river (10)
SERPENTINE – R PENT [river | confined] in SEINE [another river]
4 Show resistance, then support strike (3-4)
AIR-RAID – AIR R [show | resistance] then AID [support]
5 Pardon a crack about bishop (7)
ABSOLVE – A SOLVE [a | crack] about B [bishop]
6 Heading for insolvency again, one has a large bill (4)
IBIS – I{nsolvency} + BIS [again]
7 Get rid of animal, in decline after a period (9)
ERADICATE – CAT [animal] in DIE [decline], after ERA [a period]
8 Primitive criminal alarmed, then arrested by old lady (11,3)
NEANDERTHAL MAN – (ALARMED THEN*) [“criminal…”] arrested by NAN [old lady]
13 Scientist and epicure missing grand opening of restaurant (10)
ASTRONOMER – {g}ASTRONOME [epicure “missing” G for grand] + R{estaurant}
15 A beastly noise in verse, with Carol scatting (9)
VAMOOSING – A MOO [a | beastly noise] in V with SING [verse | Carol]
18 Element’s gripping during overtures (4-3)
LEAD-INS – LEAD’S [element’s] gripping IN [during]
19 Day aboard boat with maiden, no relative to know? (7)
HOMONYM – MON [day] aboard HOY [boat] with M [maiden]
22 Rested in spare time (5)
LEANT – LEAN T [spare | time]
23 Drop round for sweet food (4)
SAGO – SAG O [drop | round]
Edited at 2018-02-09 08:31 am (UTC)
Two issues: (a) maybe still thinking about yesterday’s bread rolls, I put BUNS in confidently at 23dn (Drop=snub reversed, obvs.) And that meant I stared at the 26ac Anagram for ages. (b) I didn’t spend enough time on each clue. Once I started giving them an extra 30 secs before moving on, they tumbled much more quickly.
Thanks setter and V.
Edited at 2018-02-09 08:48 am (UTC)
I have no problem with ‘something uplifting’ for ROTOR, since the thing on a helicopter is such an archetypal example. So much so in fact that it has its own separate definition in Collins.
Hard to see past the several crosswordy clues. HOMONYM is very smart, but ABSOLVE gets my vote for the sweeter surface
Thanks to a search engine, I now know that v’s post title refer’s to a mishearing of ‘garden of Eden’ not unconnected to a gallon of Red Mountain wine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida#Background
Nice time by the way 😉
Thanks for the Simpsons reference (I gather the episode is ‘Bart Sells his Soul’). I’m once again in awe of the cultural scope of the series
Did the crossword in 26 minutes with LEANT LOI.
COD to HOMONYM – I thought ‘no relative to know’ was particularly cunning.
Could have done without memory of school dinners prompted by SAGO – awful stuff
My only slight disappointment was that both the scientist and the epicure in 13 were generic rather than the specifics I gallantly attempted to recall from my polymathic memory banks, especially since the semi-themed long ones were more in my comfort zone (didn’t make them any easier, mind).
Cheers V: pity I don’t like Oreos much or I might have been closer to your time. Chapeau to setter.
Edited at 2018-02-09 12:24 pm (UTC)
Another fine puzzle on a par with Wednesday’s for me. 39 minutes of which 10 spent on 13d and 25th my loi; for some reason I was looking for the surname of a scientist although only one word fits the checkers. Then MIASM as a must-be variant on miasma.
Our son is a helicopter engineer. The more he tells me about what can break, and occasionally does, especially the rotor head gearbox, the less I want to go in one again.
I also couldn’t let go of the jazz-style vocalising (put in ‘vocalising’ for a while even tho’ it wouldn’t parse) in 15d. I don’t think ‘scat’ (in the ‘get outta here!’ sense) is a fully-fledged verb which will inflect — cf. ‘Scram!’ –> ‘…and they were all scramming as fast as possible’?? It only exists in the imperative form.
I also love the linguistically tricksy clues like 19d, which is my COD. And the long edge clues were very witty. A great puzzle.
“The origin of the name Oreo is unknown, but there are many hypotheses, including derivations from the French word ‘Or’, meaning gold (as early packaging was gold),[citation needed] or the Greek word “Ωραίο” (/ɔ.ˈɾɛ.ɔ/), meaning tasty, beautiful, nice or well done. Others believe that the cookie was named Oreo because it was short and easy to pronounce. Another theory is that the name derives from the Latin Oreodaphne[,] a genus of the laurel family. In her book BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts, food writer Stella Parks notes that the original design of the Oreo includes a laurel wreath, and several of Nabisco’s cookies at the time had botanically derived names including Avena, Lotus, and Helicon (Heliconia).”
However, an article on “How the Oreo was invented” on the GIzmodo site does say, in passing, ‘It could also come from the Greek word for mountain or mound – ” oros,” since an Oreo is a “mountain” of a cookie.’
(I have a little trouble seeing how an Oreo is like a mountain.)
It goes on to say, ‘It has also been speculated that maybe it was named for the cookie itself, two “O” shape cookies sandwiching the cream, O-cream-O.’
But I don’t think that will satisfy anyone here, where the refrain would be, “what about the C, the A and the M?”
As I’m here…
Happy birthday, P.!
Edited at 2018-02-09 08:00 pm (UTC)
But did anyone else get served ‘Dead Man’s Leg’?
Edited at 2018-02-09 01:44 pm (UTC)
All complete and unaided, but timing was off the scale. Glad to have managed to sort it all out in the end!