Time: 47 Minutes Music: Mahler, Symphony #9, Levine/Philadelphia Orchestra When I started at 1 across, I thought this was going to be very easy indeed. I did go at blazing speed for a while, only to get thoroughly stuck with 2/3 of the puzzle complete. This was in part due to a wrong answer – I found ‘minimal’ a very convincing answer for 18 down, fitting both the cryptic and the definition perfectly, but unfortunately it was quite wrong, as I discovered when I saw ‘extractor fan’. The other problem was the use of words that while not obscure, are not often used- ‘patchily’, ethnical’? Most people would say ‘patchy’ and ‘ethnic’, and let it go at that. I also have some serious doubts about my LOI, which I will get to in due couurse. Overall, I would be inclined to rate this as an easy-to-moderate puzzle, with just one or two possible quibbles. If I had been the editor, I probably would have sent several clues back for revision or replacement. Across |
|
1 | Wild, like a kangaroo? (7,3) |
HOPPING MAD – Double definition, one jocular. | |
7 | Sunscreen and singlet I put on (4) |
TOPI – TOP + I, where you need to know what kind of hat a ‘topi’ is. | |
9 | Proper to fix name of race (8) |
ETHNICAL – ETH(N)ICAL. | |
10 | For unruly lot, hard to get into subject of parable (6) |
SHOWER – S(H)OWER. This was my LOI. The cryptic works well enough, but I don’t see how a ‘shower’ can be an ‘unreuly lot’ – a shower of invective? A shower of missiles? Either I am not seeing something, or the clue has gotten garbled. Comments invited. My ignorance of 50s UK slang got me into difficulties here, but the usage is fully explicated in the comments below. | |
11 | Olympic sportsman who joins panels? (6) |
FENCER – double definition, although fences do not necessarily involve panels, and you have to do more than join them or your fence will fall over. | |
13 | A grass mutates like this into a weed (8) |
SARGASSO – anagram of A GRASS + SO. | |
14 | Posh accent that gets Parliament going! (6,6) |
QUEENS SPEECH – douible definition – you can’t get more posh than ER herself! | |
17 | One no longer keen on farm machinery that does away with steam (9,3) |
EXTRACTOR FAN – Double definition, one, ‘EX TRACTOR FAN’, jocular. | |
20 | Girl, cold, losing pounds in odd places (8) |
PATCHILY – PAT + CHI[l]LY. A random girl, and neither C nor ICY makes this a little difficult, especially since ‘in odd places’ suggests either an anagram or every other letter. | |
21 | Sailor comprehending what ocean is, turning dial (6) |
SPEEDO – O(DEEP)S, all backwards, with our old friend the Ordinary Seaman. The thing next to the tacho, and not the abbreviated bathing suit. | |
22 | Drop off tin with leak (6) |
SNOOZE – SN + OOZE, perfectly simple, and I still couldn’t get it for a very long time. | |
23 | Back in the morning, queuing at this station? (8) |
MAINLINE – AM backwards + IN LINE. Not a branch line, presumably, although this term probably has different meanings in various countries. | |
25 | A very short book (4) |
AMOS – A MOS[t], book of the Bible, of coruse. | |
26 | Unavoidable shortly to do favour for a politician (10) |
OBLIGATORY – OBLIG[e] A TORY. |
Down | |
2 | Trying to escape joining in a marathon? (2,3,3) |
ON THE RUN – Double definition, and a very simple one. | |
3 | Hurt as I dropped vessel (3) |
PAN – PA[i]N | |
4 | Improved new freezer (5) |
NICER – N + ICER. | |
5 | Effete type weaving silk into unruly hair (7) |
MILKSOP – M(anagram of SILK)OP | |
6 | Confuse with combination of noise and dirt (9) |
DISORIENT – Anagram of NOISE, DIRT. | |
7 | Hard worker on heroin a danger on computer (6,5) |
TROJAN HORSE – TROJAN + HORSE in different slang senses. | |
8 | Under pressure, let out imploring word (6) |
PLEASE – P + LEASE. | |
12 | Bright guy means to lift in a couple of hundred pieces of fuel (6,5) |
CLEVER CLOGS – C(LEVER)C + LOGS, a UK-centric slang phrase that vaguely rang a bell over here. | |
15 | Start blazing row, full of feminine emotion (3,4,2) |
SET FIRE TO – SET (F IRE) TO | |
16 | One with a tale to tell finished interrupting queen (8) |
PARDONER – |
|
18 | Very poor baby, small, uncovered (7) |
ABYSMAL – hidden in [b]ABY SMAL[l]. | |
19 | Chap grabs glass that girl’s left: I’m not sure there’s much wine in it (6) |
MAGNUM – MA(G[lass]N + UM, a rather busy clue that most solvers will just biff. | |
21 | Confess about part finally in police operation (5) |
STING – S([par]T)ING. | |
24 | Random allocation of large amount (3) |
LOT – double definition, and another easy one. |
I found this quite easy until I got stuck in the SW corner. I had ‘welder’ for FENCER for a while, thinking there might be an athlete of that name. PATCHILY did for me in the end.
Edited at 2018-01-15 02:07 am (UTC)
Yep, same as Jack, with a lot done quickly, welder in for a bit, then a long time at the end for PATCHILY. No problem with SHOWER=unruly lot.
But I don’t get why a pardoner has a tale to tell
Edited at 2018-01-15 02:59 am (UTC)
I think it’s army slang. T-T first used it in the Boulting Brothers film “Private’s Progress” (1956) set in WWII in which he played Major Hitchcock and turned up again as the same character post-war in the more famous “I’m All Right Jack”. He pronounced it “Shah”.
Like vinyl1, when HOPPING MAD went straight in, I thought this would be very easy but it proved more of a challenge and very enjoyable. With SPEEDO (not the swimwear), it took a while to figure out what an ocean is made of (water,sea?) and then decide which of many abbreviations for sailor to opt for. 54m 11s
Small point vinyl but I wouldn’t call 1ac a DD, since ‘like a kangaroo’ isn’t enough of a definition to get you the answer without the word ‘wild’. I’m not sure what I’d call it, but it it isn’t very cryptic. I’ll be surprised if it wasn’t everyone’s first in.
Edited at 2018-01-15 07:36 am (UTC)
This was an odd mix. Like our illustrious blogger I started quickly (FOI 1a HOPPING MAD et al) and then struggled. Glad I guessed correctly that the unknown 16d PARDONER was likely a Chaucer tale, and like Lou I also got it from “done” in “Parr”.
Didn’t know that the SARGASSO sea was named after the weed, but I’m glad it was otherwise I’d probably not have heard of it! TOPI I’d definitely never heard of, but I’ll try to remember it as at least I’ve seen them in real life…
Edited at 2018-01-15 07:56 am (UTC)
I thought this was the quickie until I was left with the last four fully checked: 9 and 10ac, 20 and 21ac. They fell one by one, except Stoney. I’m sure there is a parable about the stoney ground being the ‘hard to get into’ subject. Maybe it’s called the Sower and maybe it’s Stony. Heigh ho. Not a great clue IMHO.
Thanks setter and Vinyl.
Edited at 2018-01-15 08:06 am (UTC)
RAF) and was originally a ‘shower of sh-t’. Like a shower of rain but
less pleasant to stand under. When the offensive word was dropped the
expression gained wider currency, and when Terry Thomas took it up it
became part of the language, used by people who had no idea of the
original full form.
Doreen Simmons
PATCHILY crawled in, partly because PAT is not the first name that springs to mind as a girl: it’s more often an Irishman in these parts.
PARDONER started off as NARRATOR until the Canterbury link kicked in, and it has to be PAR-DONE-R
FENCER had me thinking it could be anything
Loved EX TRACTOR FAN and SHOWER – shades of Carry On Sergeant though apparently it’s not in the script.
It’s a very smooth and elegant pangram: so smooth it’s virtually no help with completing the clues and seems to have escaped notice thus far. Congratulations to setter and thanks to Vinyl.
Appreciation to Doreen S for the fuller story behind SHOWER.
Very short clip of Terry Thomas’s famous rendering of same in I’m Alright Jack: https://youtu.be/8L5LNIi5bAs
Edited at 2018-01-15 09:42 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-01-15 06:04 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2018-01-15 12:23 pm (UTC)
On the other hand, we have many rivers, towns, and railway stations that would stump a UK solver.
http: //www .private-eye .co .uk /covers/cover-1198
Edited at 2018-01-15 01:45 pm (UTC)
I remember TT fondly and his way of saying Shower; no problem with 10a.
And I really liked the Extractor Fan clue. David
My knowledge of UK slang is much stronger in the 1890-1940 period, as that can be acquired by reading. I shouldn’t have missed the Parr clue, however – unpardonable?
Edited at 2018-01-15 05:23 pm (UTC)
Quite where I dredged PARDONER from I don’t know – I can only assume that Canterbury Tales has been around for so long that it’s embedded in human DNA and therefore present from birth. Glad I didn’t think of “minimal” for 18d as our setter did, or it would have snagged me for a long time. Otherwise, all fairly straightforward and very enjoyable.
Just to be clear, I wasn’t suggesting that the clue was wrong, just that I didn’t like it. Yes, I’ve seen ‘L’ clued as both ‘pound’ and ‘pounds’.
Just to be clear, I wasn’t suggesting that the clue was wrong, just that I didn’t like it. Yes, I’ve seen ‘L’ clued as both ‘pound’ and ‘pounds’.