Looking over it now, there is little that seems enormously problematic, but I’ll give you a blow-by-blow of how I made it so. My first pass of the across clues yielding little fruit until 25ac and 27ac, at which point I had a solid in to the SW corner. And then 10dn is a write-in for anyone with two little grey cells to rub together, and 5dn not much trickier. Nevertheless, if there was a way to get the wrong end of the stick for a clue I found it on this puzzle: I wanted 22ac to be a phrase meaning “moving”, was sure 3dn had to be a word for animals inside a US region, searched in vain for a word meaning “news” at 6dn, saw that 7dn, ending with an A, could not be a plural so had to be the name of an obscure philosopher… you get the idea. Part of the art of the best setters is writing a clue where the correct way to solve it is not immediately clear, and I’m going to say that our designated cryptic tormentor for today was a dab at hand this, so thanks to you, sir!
Apart from the cluing this felt a little more Fridayish just because there was a slightly higher obscure GK quotient than usual: the Belgian detective is surely well known, but I was a very young ‘un I might raise an eyebrow at needing to know the naval admiral, Goethe’s contemporary, the 70-year old date movie and the so-called “lawmaker” at 1dn: 1ac might not be easy for non-foodies, on two separate counts! But I am going to be 43 on Monday so I thought all this stuff was great. (43! Is that too old to be doing this young man’s pastime with full dignity? Maybe I should retire!) Lots of COD candidates to choose from but I’ll give my award to 3dn simply because it’s got a nice surface and pulled the wool over my eyes for way longer than it should have. I think there’ll be a range of favourites on this one, though, so what were yours?
ACROSS
1 Residue of apple and spice added to reduced-size pot (6)
POMACE – MACE [spice] added to PO{t}
4 Problems in book with small cover wrapped round (8)
DILEMMAS – EMMA [book] with S LID [small | cover] “wrapped round”. I guess “wrapped” is the containment indicator and “round” actually orders the “reversal”, much though my brain rebels against it…
9 Courtier just wasting time drinking beer (7)
RALEIGH – RIGH{t} [just, “wasting (T for) time”] “drinking” ALE [beer]
11 Author wanting introduction for scary book (7)
CHILLER – {s}CHILLER [author, “wanting introduction”]. The 18th century German poet and man of many parts Friedrich Schiller.
12 To fall asleep during sex is …. (5)
INAPT – NAP [to fall asleep] during IT [sex], semi-&lit
13 Declined to look into S African capital (3,2,4)
RAN TO SEED – TO SEE [to | look] into RAND [South African capital (as in money)]
14 Great drink, um … ah … wolfing dessert back (5,5)
SUPER DUPER – SUP [drink] + ER ER [um… | ah…] “wolfing” PUD reversed [dessert “back”]
16 Probably had read Steinbeck’s last novel (4)
KNEW – {Steinbec}K + NEW [novel]. I’m not *sure* I know most of the things I know from having read them…
19 Older relative’s articles for retirement (4)
NANA – AN AN reversed [(two) articles “for retirement”]
20 Recover speed after useless start in park and gym (10)
RECUPERATE – RATE [speed] after U{seless} in REC + P.E. [park (and) gym]
22 Moving, tho’ not new film (2,3,4)
ON THE TOWN – (THO’ NOT NEW*) [“moving”]. 1949 Gene Kelly and Frank Sinatra musical comedy.
23 All right to scarper (5)
LEGIT – to scarper being to LEG IT
25 Cook limits lunches at first for dieter (7)
SLIMMER – SIMMER [cook] “limits” L{unches}
26 Some land in Valence for redevelopment (7)
ENCLAVE – (VALENCE*) [“for redevelopment”]
27 Watch muscle is in condition (8)
SPECTATE – PEC [muscle] is in STATE [condition]
28 Unlimited free produce from cattle show (6)
REVEAL – {f}RE{e} + VEAL [produce from cattle]
1 Lawman put pressure on family involved in crime (9)
PARKINSON – P [pressure] on KIN [family] “involved in” ARSON [crime]. Parkinson’s Law, that “work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion”. Wonder if it applies to solving?
2 In Massachusetts, “key” is an island (5)
MALTA – in MA [Massachusetts], ALT [(computer) key]
3 Restrict wild animals in parts of America (8)
CRITTERS – (RESTRICT*) [“wild”]
5 As a result, popular party game hasn’t succeeded (2,11)
IN CONSEQUENCE – IN [popular] + CONSEQUENCE{s} [party game, “hasn’t (S for) succeeded]
6 News chief travelled up carrying computers etc (6)
EDITOR – RODE reversed [travelled “up”] carrying I.T. [computers etc]
7 Philosopher, one engaged by queen over many years (9)
MILLENNIA – MILL [philosopher (John Stuart, utilitarian)] + I [one] “engaged by” ANNE reversed [queen “over”]
8 A small amount of extremely smooth wine (5)
SHRED – S{moot}H + RED [wine]
10 A detective, I report louche suspect (7,6)
HERCULE POIROT – (I REPORT LOUCHE*) [“upset”]
15 Cut up tat for trouser material (9)
PINSTRIPE – SNIP reversed [cut “up”] + TRIPE [tat]
17 Ingredient of bread we’ll eat hot at dinner, say (9)
WHEATMEAL – WE will eat H [hot] + AT MEAL [at | dinner, say]
18 Firm making explosive, perhaps, quoted for naval admiral (8)
JELLICOE – rather whimsical homophone [“quoted”] of JELLY CO, as in gelignite company [firm making explosive, perhaps]. John Jellicoe, Royal Navy admiral circa WW1, commander at e.g. the Battle of Jutland.
21 Deal with unruly hair thus, OK? (6)
PERMIT – one way to deal with unruly hair is to PERM IT
22 Watering hole regularly serving locals first (5)
OASIS – {l}O{c}A{l}S {f}I{r}S{t}, regularly served.
24 Exam mark, we’d argue, should be raised a bit (5)
GRADE – hidden reversed in {w}E’D ARG{ue} [“should be raised, a bit”]
The LHS went in at record speed – but Dilemmas was murder (geddit) until Recuperate gave Millennia away.
Mostly I liked: Critters (great word) and Legit (a chestnut, but makes me smile every time).
Minor eyebrow raisers (MERs): super-duper (hyphen?); lawman (too clever?)
Thanks super-duper setter and V.
So for a while I get to solve crosswords sitting on a balcony overlooking a dense, jungly garden of mangos and palms and no doubt a bunch of other plants I’ve previously only assembled from wordplay but can’t recognise now they’re right in front of my face. At least, I’ll be able to solve puzzles as long as the electricity doesn’t keep going out, as it did a few times last night while a seasonal thunderstorm raged a little further inland. This morning is peaceful and a little cooler, with a nice breeze blowing off the Lakshadweep Sea (there’s a challenge to setters).
Lovely puzzle, with some really nice surfaces. CRITTERS is great, and INAPT actually made me laugh out loud, catching the attention of the lady sweeping the path below. Last in, without much confidence, was JELLICOE, which might have been spelt with a G for all I knew.
b) blimey, that’s a good clue (sorry, boltonwanderer, but sawbill gets the nod)
c) loggerheads and split? You couldn’t make it up. Double-namaste
Jellicoe is famous enough to have had a namesake in Star Trek the Next Generation, though they spelt him wrong.
“Lawman” for Parkinson et al has scuppered me in the past, and will doubtless do so again.
INAPT earworm for today: “Joshua fit the battle of Jellicoe”
I really liked this crossword which is right up my street. Too many good ones to choose a COD. Oh OK, INAPT.
Definitely my COD.
.. or the tobacco and turkeys, viz. Bob Newhart
LOI DILEMMAS which, as above, I still don’t think it works. There isn’t a reversal indicator, so I feel I can justify some miffedness in the extra time it took to complete this.
After being very pleased with myself with PARKINSON, I thought this was going to be a toughie, but many of the clues were more like quickies. My main problem was a friend looking over my shoulder and saying that 17d was WHOLEMEAL, which I duly typed in without reading the clue properly. I briefly considered RECUPERATO….
Lots to like but JELLICOE was silly enough to raise the biggest smile.
I suspect our blogger is perhaps being deliberately polite but for me 4ac doesn’t work. The phrase ‘with small cover wrapped’ taken on its own indicates that the small cover is being wrapped by something else. ‘With small cover wrapped around’ would indicate that the small cover is wrapped around something, but then there’s no reversal indicator.
Edited at 2017-10-06 08:37 am (UTC)
Probably best crossword this week 5/5 not a single bad clue. Not even dilemmas, which does work, or close enough to it as makes no difference
Just my type of crossword – looks impossible at first glance, but with a bit of application and thought, the clues kept dropping in.
LOI 18d – one of those odd names where none of the usual rules of English (double-L? double-E? -ache? –acte?) seem to help. Just kept staring and staring at it until the penny dropped.
Only quibble is “naval admiral” – what other type of admiral is there (apart from the butterfly?).
I’m not overseas, and my one blank today was….
This took me exactly 40 mins which wasn’t to bad for a Friday especially as the good Lord Verlaine wandered off!
I stuck in WHEATGERM @ 17dn but latterly realised it was WHEATMEAL – which lost me at least 5 minutes! Doh!
COD 3dn CRITTERS super-duper!
24ac GRADE gets hon. mention.
WOD 14ac SUPER-DUPER!
Edited at 2017-10-06 11:53 am (UTC)
The Laccadive Sea looks very pleasant, Sotira, I wish my Tardis could whisk me there now without the tedium of airline travel.
I suspected that ‘Jellicoe’ was an admiral every British schoolboy would know, but I hadn’t heard of. When I constructed him from the cryptic, he seemed vaguely familiar, so in he went.
I do apologise for the “stutter” in the SNITCH in the last couple of days. I have been making some minor adjustments to the reference solver list and combining some old and new results. There is a bug in the production environment that doesn’t show up in my test environment (also disappointing), which caused some scores to be counted twice. I’ve patched it for now so I’m hoping it will be okay. It looks like this error didn’t make much difference to the overall SNITCH score for today, so I’m still a bit surprised it wasn’t higher.
Thanks, as always, to the setter and V.
Like many people, I came to JELLICOE fairly late, and in my case, it was the only one I had to cheat to get (with all the crossers. It couldn’t be PELLICLE!). POMACE I got solely from the wordplay, was glad to see that it really is a word. (The first time I posted this, I confused this puzzle with the Jumbo I finished in the same evening and mentioned a clue there. It was a big night for puzzles.) SPECTATE is one of those words no one is likely to have used lately. And on the other side of the spectrum we have SUPER DUPER, which is said more often than it is writ, I would wager. 5d is incredibly easy for a long one (and for a Friday?). My LOI was pinstripe, which is odd, because I tend to wear them a lot.
Edited at 2017-10-06 04:11 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-10-06 05:12 pm (UTC)
Apologies if I’m just repeating what someone has said.
Agree that it is silly to talk of a naval admiral. You could hardly have an army admiral.
Although actually having spent far too much time thinking about it I’ve now decided it works. You have to read ‘book in cover wrapped’ in a Shakespearean way, but the word ’round’ can then apply grammatically just to the word ‘wrapped’. ‘A shield with golden stars adorned, diagonally’.
Edited at 2017-10-06 05:09 pm (UTC)
However as I said I think the clue is saying ‘book wrapped with cover, round’ just with olde-worlde word-order.
Edited at 2017-10-06 05:16 pm (UTC)
JELLICOE is every bit as obscure as the bits of the bible no-one in their right mind has heard of, so shouldn’t really have been clued with an ambiguous homophone IMO.
Wasted a few minutes because of my hand-writing doh – I mistook an E for a C. I suppose I can improve on that. Otherwise it would have been about 40 mins.
POMACE – new vocab for me – hey we were all straining apples together just the other day here.
I wondered about the “naval” part of admiral too. Why only one level of redundancy? For even greater clarity, why not call him a “naval sea admiral brackets wet brackets”? Just to avoid confusion.
COD: PARKINSON. And does his Law apply to times for the Times?