My time would have been much more impressive if I’d been able to look at H_E_I at the end of 9dn and immediately ALIGHIERI… as it was my brain was wrestling with the anagram fodder for quite some time and not coming up with much better than the likes of GARTH MARENGHI. Similarly the girl at 3dn, where I wasn’t looking for a surname so kept trying the likes of DOROTHEA in vain. 18ac was also a big holdout as clearly metonyms are a little above my solving pay grade. Honourable mentions to 12ac where the “Asian native in no hurry” took thematically appropriate ages to arrive, and 21dn whose gleaming penny only dropped a while after submitting.
So thanks to the setter for a very strong crossword indeed. COD-wise we could go for the very politically topical 1ac or indeed 2d, and I’ve already said how much I enjoyed the definition in 21dn, but really it has to be the splendid and difficult-to-untangle anagram at 9dn. The Iliad is even about rage, and indeed has “rage” or a close Greek equivalent for its first word… I had to Google to check such a perfect anagram wasn’t decades old, and discovered that it has appeared in a certain setter’s Independent and FT puzzles of the past, but of course it’s quite possible that this is the same person again! The classicist in me would be happy to see this clue in every puzzle (probably) so it’s all good…
Across
1 Conservative forte at end of day unclear (6)
CLOUDY – C LOUD [Conservative | forte] + {da}Y
4 Yankee eccentric in burning American plane (8)
SYCAMORE – Y CAM [Yankee | eccentric] in SORE [burning]
10 Reptile displays pride in Tarsus recklessly (9)
STEGOSAUR – EGO [pride] in (TARSUS*) [“recklessly”]
11 Small portion without starter’s more than enough (5)
AMPLE – {s}AMPLE [small portion “without starter”]
12 Trader, Asian native in no hurry to plug financial publication (7)
FLORIST – LORIS [Asian native in no hurry] “to plug” FT [financial publication]
13 Cork spokesman’s initial remark surpassing others (7)
STOPPER – S{pokesman} + TOPPER [remark surpassing others]
14 Working class making start (5)
ONSET – ON SET [working | class]
15 Daughter leaving waterside in distress, so to speak (2,2,4)
AS IT WERE – (WATERSI{d}E*) [“in distress”]
18 Force one to have home and family life (8)
FIRESIDE – F I RESIDE [force | one | to have home]
20 Copy material crook regularly supplied (5)
REPRO – REP [material] + {c}R{o}O{k}
23 Bear cat in bag hunter’s opening (7)
STOMACH – TOM [cat] in SAC [bag] + H{unter}
25 Judas for one bitter, perhaps, about situation (7)
APOSTLE – ALE [bitter, perhaps] about POST [situation]
26 Withdraw permission (5)
LEAVE – double def
27 Laurel for instance always an environmentalist (9)
EVERGREEN – EVER GREEN [always | an environmentalist]
28 Chosen people, endlessly wealthy, driven by power (8)
ELECTRIC – ELECT [chosen people] + RIC{h} [“endlessly” wealthy]
29 Breadwinner finally comes in to provide food bowl (6)
CRATER – {breadwinner}R “comes in to” CATER [provide food]
Down
1 Movement of money remains fluid in firm given direction (4,4)
CASH FLOW – ASH FL [remains | fluid] in CO W [firm (given) direction]
2 Emperor in love with America becomes demanding (7)
ONEROUS – NERO [emperor] in O US [love (with) America]
3 Girl made grand in swindle over small amount (9)
DOOLITTLE – DO O LITTLE [swindle | over | small amount]
5 Dray horses like running free in upland location (9,5)
YORKSHIRE DALES – (DRAY HORSES LIKE*) [“running free”]
6 Mission accomplished — like another mission — on all fronts! (5)
ALAMO – A{ccomplished} L{ike} A{nother} M{ission} O{n}
7 In theory, paid for by The Times? (2,5)
ON PAPER – double def with cryptic def, playing on “on” as in “on the house”, “on me”, etc
8 Erstwhile editor with artist making room for discussion (6)
EXEDRA – EX ED RA [erstwhile | editor (with) artist]
9 Rage in The Iliad troubled influential writer (5,9)
DANTE ALIGHIERI – (RAGE IN THE ILIAD*) [“troubled”]
16 Militarist marines ahead in punt (9)
WARMONGER – RM ON [marines | ahead] in WAGER [punt]
17 Ruler agonising over northern part (8)
GOVERNOR – hidden in {agonising}G OVER NOR{thern}
19 Irish cardinal collecting silver for a time (4,3)
IRON AGE – IR ONE [Irish | cardinal] “collecting” AG [silver]
21 Job description has worker keeping allegiance, under pressure (7)
PATIENT – ANT [worker] “keeping” TIE [allegiance], under P [pressure].
“Job description” as in “a description of Job in the Bible”.
22 Princess is no spring chicken, last in line (6)
ISOLDE – IS OLD [is | no spring chicken] + {lin}E
24 A set of books taking in extremely gullible representative (5)
AGENT – A NT [a | set of books] “taking in” G{ullibl}E
FOI 2d; COD 21d: as with our esteemed blogger I enjoyed “Job description”. I liked “girl made grand” a lot, too. One of those crosswords where things seemed a little beyond my grasp and then I got them and wondered what the problem had been. Great stuff. WOD SYCAMORE.
I rarely resort to pen and paper for anagram solving, but 9dn was an exception. I mean, who knew that Dante had another name? So he doesn’t belong on the same list as Pele, Bono and Lulu?
Have a good weekend everyone. Thanks setter and V.
Some very weird but entertaining surfaces. 2d …. Monsieur Macron, n’est pas?
I wish you hadn’t mentioned that Crossword Snitch app, verlaine. Now I have to obsess over that as well (average solving time half a minute higher than I’d hoped so I have to IMPROVE!)
I’m looking at a way to make individual solver’s trends more evident, based on verlaine’s feedback. But it will take me a little while to work out.
BTW, I think that an average time of around 16:30 is amazing, so don’t forget that you’re way ahead of many of us.
Edited at 2017-07-15 03:18 pm (UTC)
I’m very interested in your spreadsheet. How did you measure the difficulty? I was expecting that the crosswords might get steadily harder during the week, as you found, but my results show Tue-Thu pretty flat over the year and a half I’ve been tracking it.
And thanks also for your posts in the blog. I’m encouraged by your campaign against the “double obscurity”. As a solver from Australia, I occasionally get caught with not enough local UK knowledge. But usually I will know either the cryptic or straight definition and this confidence has helped me to persevere. On the odd occasions when both depend on something obscure, you’re usually fighting our corner. So many thanks from down under!
My spreadsheet is just my own times. It’s more complete than the club site because I don’t always solve online. Part of the reason I always post here is that this is where I note my times, and from time to time when I’m really bored at work I go back through TfTT posts to fill in my spreadsheet. Interesting that you don’t see the same pattern.
Glad to hear you agree with me on the double obscurities. There are many who disagree (including notably verlaine, who will see this post – hi v!) but I think this sort of friendly disagreement is part of what makes this site interesting. I will keep fighting the good fight – I sort of feel it’s expected of me now.
p.s. I knew keriothe would love the app … he can now do a spreadsheet of his spreadsheet merged with the Snitch. Or something 😉
Sorry to add to your burden. Bear in mind that the overall average (on the Trends page) shows that solving times overall are getting longer, which would suggest that the crosswords are getting harder. This doesn’t seem to be affecting Magoo very much, however.
I’m looking at a way to make individual solver’s trends more evident, based on verlaine’s feedback. But it will take me a little while to work out.
BTW, I think that an average time of around 16:30 is amazing, so don’t forget that you’re way ahead of many of us.
Re 9dn if I were DANTE I’d have adopted the surname SINFERNO! A tad more enduring.
FOI 1ac CLOUDY LOI 9dn the ALIGIERI bit!
COD 12ac FLORIST
WOD 3dn DOOLITTLE
CAM = eccentric? It’s a river innit!?
Edited at 2017-07-14 08:26 am (UTC)
CAM = “eccentric” + US = “American”. The CAM part might take some explanation – one of the nounal senses of “eccentric” according to Chambers is “A device for taking an alternating rectilinear motion from an revolving shaft”. That might be easier to understand from the animation on the Wikipedia page showing the motion of one type of an eccentric. A “cam” on the other hand, is defined by Chambers as “an irregular projection on a revolving shaft or rotating cylinder, shaped so as to transmit regular movement to another part, e.g. to open the cylinder valves of a car engine”. Similarly, Wikipedia has a nice animation showing such motion. It seems pretty clear to me from the definition in Chambers that a cam could be considered a type of eccentric, so I think that’s all fair and correct, although mechanics is far from my speciality!
Thanks mhl@15^2!
Edited at 2017-07-14 11:30 am (UTC)
As others have said, some great stuff today (esp. the Loris and Job description) LOI Sycamore. COD must be Dante. Thanks setter and V.
Edited at 2017-07-14 08:43 am (UTC)
I’m also with you on Judas as an apostle. There is a mention of “Judas son of James” as another of the disciples (who presumably did end up as an apostle) but that seems a bit obscure.
Solving DANTE ALIGHIERI was made much harder by being on the ipad and having to switch to the notes app and type out all the letters and spaces. Mental note to self to start carrying paper and pen in my bag (to be forgotten until the next such anagram).
Other than that, a very enjoyable solve with some great definitions all mentioned already. The anagram at 9dn had me stumped for a while too, and like Kevin I counted the vowels carefully.
Edited at 2017-07-14 08:12 am (UTC)
Put me down as another SNITCH obsessive, a brilliant piece of work.
[On edit: I now find that FIRESIDE defined as ‘home’ came up in the Quick Cryptic #53 in May 2014, clued as F (female), I, RESIDE (live in). I didn’t blog that one, but I completed the whole grid in 8 minutes and didn’t refer to the clue in my comment, so evidently I must have found it easy enough that day. But maybe it had more helpful checkers.]
Edited at 2017-07-14 09:19 am (UTC)
On edit: Loved LORIS too.
Edited at 2017-07-14 10:40 am (UTC)
*also nice to see that my solving forms part of the input, so I am playing a small part in this creative use of Big Data.
In a puzzle like this, you just have to follow the cryptics and see where they lead. That’s how I got my LOI, ‘fireside’ – look what I found!
Then did the TLS, all but the silly little 24d in half an hour, which is a big improvement for me. Got a week to wait to find out what I can’t see.
Monday 84.8
Tuesday 103.5
Wednesday 102.4
Thursday 104
Friday 113.9
which does seem to make the case for Monday’s puzzle being substantially easier on average, and Friday’s puzzle somewhat tougher than the midweek puzzles.
deke
Another possibility is that the selection of crosswords by the editors shows some unconscious bias. Perhaps they don’t realise that they are selecting easier crosswords for Monday and harder ones for Friday. Do they know which day they are selecting the puzzle for, I wonder?
Another interesting and enjoyable puzzle, but I wish I hadn’t lost the knack quite so badly.
Thanks for your contribution as a reference solver. You post amazing times.