An excellent and chewy puzzle to ring in a new month with, I thought. My aged mum is staying with us for the Easter hols to perform important kid-wrangling duties, so the Blogging Room was out of bounds this morning, meaning I had to do the puzzle recumbent in bed this morning on an unfamiliar laptop; in such circumstances I was okay with coming in inside the quarter-hour. It seems from the Club forum that there may be an alternative plausible answer to 27ac that laid a number of solvers low, so I’m surprised and delighted that I didn’t fall into that trap, as it seems like the kind of thing I’d normally do unerringly, and I have no idea what a SEAMARK is when it’s at home.
Doubleplusgood economy of cluing on display here (though that may result in a couple of the anagrams being just too simple for some tastes, I don’t know) and some truly great surfaces: 5dn’s splendidness was a little muddied by the fact that I’ve spent a lot of time since mulling over in which senses the Holy See is a court, though I expect it is totally legit. No such qualms with 1D, my LOI (I thought of the right answer and most of the right lines early, but I was looking for a DEPPA or such!) and COD. 18ac gave me some pause but it’s just one of those lovely English words that means both itself and the opposite of itself, isn’t it? I did find 28ac slightly on the laborious side, unless I’ve parsed it incorrectly of course, and some of the clues were a little stomach-turning for a mostly-vegan like myself, but these are minor eggs and cream for a crossword that on the whole was thoroughly top-notch. All glory, laud and honour to the setter!
Across |
1 |
PLANCK – physicist: LAN{e} [“short” course] in PC K [computer | K{nowledge} “just beginning”] |
4 |
CHEMISTS – drug dealers: CHE MISTS [guerilla leader | films] |
10 |
NOURISH – supply with food: {s->N}OURISH [like grapefruit, “with different starter”] |
11 |
LAYETTE – first gear: L [learner] + YET [still], ATE [worried] about that |
12 |
ANTI – opponent: {c}A{n}N{o}T {w}I{n} “being regularly eliminated” |
13 |
DISSONANCE – lack of harmony: IS SON [is | issue] in DANCE [part of ballet] |
15 |
TAIWANESE – Chinese: T.A. [army] + WANES [loses dominance] in {or}IE{nt} [“central parts of”…] |
16 |
AT SEA – lost: about S [“start of” S{eason}], A-TEA{m} [top side “almost”] |
18 |
LIEGE – subject: {coll}EGE IL{logically} [“suffering cuts” … “put back”] |
19 |
BRASSERIE – restaurant: ASSER{t} [say, “cut”] (that) BRIE [cheese] sandwiches |
21 |
GRANT-IN-AID – financial assistance: (A GRAND I*) [“collected”] must include TIN [money] |
23 |
SNAP – break: reverse of PANS [“placed the wrong way”, slates] |
26 |
NITPICK – carp: NIT [egg] served with PICK [cream] |
27 |
SEAMARK – something observable in the water: SEAM ARK [join | sailing vessel] |
28 |
CAR PARKS – lots there (i.e. in the US): ARK [US state] going into CARP S [fish | {busines}S “ultimately”] |
29 |
STOREY – floor: Y [year] on STORE [shop] |
Down |
1 |
PANDA – creature: reverse of {h}AD NAP [slept “upside down”, “head tucked away”] |
2 |
AQUITAINE – French region: A QUIT A IN E [a | desert | area | in | eastern] |
3 |
CAIN – murderer: homophone of CANE [“mentioned” form of punishment] |
5 |
HOLY SEE – court: L{ad}Y [“case of”…] entering HOSE [tube] + E{arl’s} [“heading for”…] |
6 |
MAYONNAISE – sauce: YO{u} [“briefly”] tucked into MANNA [heavenly food] + I’S [one’s] served with {chees}E [“last of”…] |
7 |
SET ON – attack: (STONE*) [“thrown”] |
8 |
STEVENAGE – Hertfordshire town: reverse of VETS [checks “up”] on {m}ENAGE [household, “miles away”] |
9 |
SHRIKE – songbird: (HIKERS*) [“disturbed”] |
14 |
PALESTRINA – composer: PALEST [most unimpressive] + RIN{g} [opera cycle “left incomplete”] by A |
15 |
TELEGENIC – worth watching: E.G. [for example] during (ELECTI{o}N*) [“broadcast”, “nothing standing out”] |
17 |
STRANRAER – Scottish port: reverse of REAR N ARTS [back | new | cultural activities “set up”] |
19 |
BANGKOK – city: BANK OK [financial institution | agreed] to accept G [grand] |
20 |
AMIDST – in the middle of: A.M. [the morning] + ID {e}ST [i.e. “when energy is fading”] |
22 |
ASTIR – not still: ASTI R [sparkling wine | right] |
24 |
POKEY – having little room for manoeuvre: KEY [chief], (with) P.O. [petty officer] initially |
25 |
PAST – bygone days: PA’S T [old man has | “little” time] |
Happily I’d never heard of a sea lark (heard of a navy lark, but that’s different) so SEAMARK it was. I winced at the appearance of STRANRAER, which I misspelt at the champs in 2014; not that it still smarts or anything …
Another vote for the drug dealers. Great surface.
My parsing for 1a was different: PLAN (short course) and C+K (initials of Computer Knowledge), but naturally V’s explanation is far superior.
5a LOI after just stopping myself from entering HALF SEE (a quick look or case? Hmm…)
I didn’t get a chance to solve or comment yesterday but reading the blog there are a number of references to the club site being for the chop. What’s that all about?
Edited at 2016-04-01 08:33 am (UTC)
(You totally made me go check, you rotter…)
I feel a bit cheated that I read Riddle of the Sands recently and SEAMARK didn’t come up once, even though I had my virtual thumb in a nautical dictionary for most of the read.
As a scientophobe, I rather liked 4a.
The first answer there is very complete, but I did quite like this line in the second answer: “It’s perfectly normal for there to be multiple feuding dynasties of ‘China’ in China”
Edited at 2016-04-01 11:03 am (UTC)
“According to the official maps and the official borders of the Republic of China, Taiwan is part of China. But then again, so is Mongolia, and parts of India, Burma, Vietnam, Bhutan, Japan, Afghanistan, Russia, Pakistan, and Tajikistan.”
Surely if the answers are obscure words there should be no alternative definitions for the components? Harrumph!
Oofy Prosser
27ac SEAMARK was fine for me but GRANT-IN-AID was a long time coming.
COD 20dn AMIDST FOI 7dn SET ON LOI 28ac CAR PARKS
A wretched hour on this after a scorching start with the top half to bed in ten minutes.
‘I am a proper fool.’
horryd Shanghai
To my chagrin, 20d alerted me to the fact that I’d reached the age of free transport in London without ever having known what i.e. actually stands for – I’m appalled! This is significantly more embarrassing than my experience a couple of Saturdays ago when I had not realised Frank Sinatra was dead (and has been for 17 years).
Thanks for the usual splendid blog V.
Edited at 2016-04-01 12:05 pm (UTC)
Since I had extra time, I decided to try this week’s Mephisto. I think that I was successful, for the very first time. At least I have an answer that makes sense for every clue.
Still, I got away with the unknown LAYETTE, SEAMARK, GRANT-IN-AID and PALESTRINA, so something was bound to give.
COD to PLANCK. Thanks setter and V.
PALESTRINA was a near thing, and I agree with Anonymous (surely one of our most prolific commenters here) that an obscure word should be gettable from the wordplay. Of course, PALESTRINA will only be obscure to those people to whom it is obscure but, given that “Lamestrina” was an equally alluring alternative, I think it was a poor clue. Much the same could be said for SEAMARK/sealark, especially given that there is an HMS Sealark, suggesting that someone, somewhere spells the bird with neither space nor hyphen.
Edited at 2016-04-01 10:01 pm (UTC)
For the second time this week I came horribly close to failure as I bunged in SEALARK at a first read-through of 27ac. But (like sotira) I wasn’t entirely convinced that such a creature existed (with or without a space or a hyphen), and fortunately when I came to review the clue on my final checkthrough, the familiar SEAMARK sprang to mind almost immediately. (Phew again!)
After rejecting DEPPA for 1dn, I thought of PANDA (made promising by the presence of NAP) but still had to write the damned word down before I could fathom the wordplay. And in the end I biffed PLANCK and only twigged the wordplay properly when going over the clues again afterwards. There was a time …
Edited at 2016-04-01 10:46 pm (UTC)