Solving time : 24:20 on the club timer, which is my slowest time in a very very long time. This is a bit of a beast, and I can’t quite put my finger on what made it so difficult to me, since I think everything is above board, I was just a million miles away from the wavelength of the setter and some of the phrases and one reference are not in my addled little brain.
Some very odd phrasing in the clues, I should single out the clue that ends in a preposition but I’m not going to.
Away we go…
Across | |
---|---|
1 | OF RIGHT: O(old), FRIGHT(person looking very unkempt) |
5 | CAMELOT: CAME(turned up), LOT(chance) |
9 | STATIONER: TI(note),ONE(I) in STAR |
10 | SPASM: SPAM containing S |
11 | DRYAD: DRY(quietly witty),AD(notice) |
12 | HAD BETTER: BETTER(gambler) after HAD(cheated) |
13 | AIRS AND GRACES: SAND(grit) in an anagram of CARRIAGES |
17 | THE BLUE DANUBE: TUBE(train) containing HE, BLUE(sounds like BLEW), DAN(anagram of AND) |
21 | ALL BLACKS: New Zealand rugby team, and if you had the maximum break in a game of snooker/pool, you would pot the black each time between potting reds |
24 | BAKER: double definition, the more obscure one being in the RAF phonetic alphabet, BAKER is the word for B, while Charlie is the word for C |
25 | GHANA: H with A,NAG reversed around it |
26 | SPUN A YARN: S, and then PUNY,RN each of which contains an A |
27 | TUESDAY: anagram of UNSTEADY missing N |
28 | SADNESS: hidden reversed in captiveS SEND A Signal |
Down | |
1 | ONSIDE: my take on the first part is it is ON(willing), SIDE(play ball) but it might just be a longer definition for ON SIDE. The second one refers to the legal position in soccer, hockey etc |
2 | READY-MADE: READY(cash), MADE(earned) |
3 | GUILDER: GUIDER(captain in the Girl Guides) containing L |
4 |
TENTH-RATE: |
5 | CORED: dispensed with the centre – CO,RED |
6 | MASSEUR: (ERASMUS)* |
7 | LEAPT: P in LEAT |
8 | TAMARISK: TASK surrounding MAR,1 |
14 | DEAD SOULS: a book by Gogol – D,SOU(small bit) in DEALS |
15 | CHECKMATE: HECK,MAT in CE and a crafty definition, excellent clue! |
16 | STRAIGHT: SIGHT surrounding ART reversed |
18 | LOLLARD: LOL(laughing out loud), LARD. Something rang a bell here – it turns out I blogged an almost identical clue in 2010 (I’m amused by fat follower of Wycliffe) |
19 | UPBRAID: anagram of PUB, then RAID |
20 | PRUNUS: sounds like PRUNE US! |
22 | L,EASE |
23 | CUSHY: anagram of SUCH,Y |
I am always putting in ‘tamarind’ instead of ‘tamarisk’, but I managed to avoid that trap this time.
My big breakthrough was thinking about what English folk album to play, and suddenly seeing ‘Airs and Graces’, which of course is an LP by June Tabor. However, I decided to play Martin Carthy anyway. My big mistake was only trying one through nine for what turned out to be ‘tenth-rate’ – I was quite irked when I finally went one more number.
It really shouldn’t have been that hard, but it was not a very conventional puzzle.
1. I don’t think the clue quite works (shouldn’t it be “prune me”?).
2. I failed to solve it.
I won’t chunter on about obscure plant names as it’ll probably turn out that I’m the only one who’s never heard of it.
Enjoyed the rest of the puzzle, which did seem to have a slightly quirky feel about it. Thanks setter and George.
BTW George, for 1dn I had ONSIDE as “willing to play ball”, without the need to separate the parts.
Serious struggle this morning. Didn’t understand the banter at 24 ac. (“Bally Jerry, pranged his kite right in the how’s-your-father …”). And assumed the promotions at 14dn were ADS; so a parsing failure there. And that’s just a couple of em. Ta to George for the untangling.
There’ll be someone on later with a dig about 21ac. Now who could that be?
Edited at 2016-02-11 03:54 am (UTC)
I thought 1a and 12a were very good, and my penultimate PRUNUS quite fair, as the question mark provides the necessary leeway to include the colloquial (and common) use of the plural (‘Lend us a quid, mate’). Sorry, Gallers. (Great time by the way.)
I finished with DEAD SOULS, which really is unfair, given a) the parsing is quite sophisticated and b) I’m familiar with Dostoevsky and Tolstoy’s works, but not Gogol’s.
Apart from that glaring inequity, a very fine puzzle and a tip of the hat to the setter, and thanks to G for the full parsing of AIRS AND GRACES, where I missed the anagram.
Edited at 2016-02-11 04:09 am (UTC)
Didn’t NZ beat the Aussies again in the final – with 7 on the pitch?
2. I failed to solve it.
I think I’ve volunteered to blog a Jumbo some time in the near future. Might pick your brains over coffee to add what will be some much-needed erudition to the blog.
Didn’t know BAKER as an alternative to ‘Bravo’, nor DEAD SOULS nor LEAT (despite not knowing it before in November 2012 and July 2013). No problem with the grammar at 20dn as many parts of England use ‘us’ for ‘me’ in local dialect.
I pretty much began with GOT BETTER with a distinct queasiness about the grammar.
“Unconventional”? – yup, that’s about right.
But horror – I find that my BY RIGHT/BESIDE is incorrect.
Thanks for parsing 17a.
I’m taking my cue from Vinyl and going off to listen to some Watersons to cheer myself up.
Edited at 2016-02-11 08:30 am (UTC)
Jerry W, not logged in
On the whole I rather liked the clues.
I’m going to ruin Sotira’s theory on this puzzle and state that I neither loved nor hated it. I enjoyed a lot of the originality but overall didn’t find it as much fun as other quirky puzzles of yore.
I agree that 1a was a lovely clue and I also ticked checkmate. I biffed the two long acrosses and had to piece the Gogol thingy together from wordplay and trust to luck. LOI stationer, probably because I’m used to seeing one for I but not t’other way round.
Leat, lollard and tamarisk (attorneys at law) are all words I’ve picked up along the way doing these puzzles.
A puzzle with a DEAD SOUL!
THE BLUE DANUBE !! tortuous.
GUILDER! pathetically weak.
45 unrewarding minutes
horryd Shanghai
I enjoyed this a lot, although there was perhaps a bit more satisfaction at having faced down a stiff challenge than joy at the wit and inventiveness of the clues.
Edited at 2016-02-11 08:47 pm (UTC)
PRUNUS was no problem, but if I hadn’t heard of it, there would be precious little chance of getting it from the wordplay. NHO LOLLARD (I’d have guessed it was someone who lolled, if I were given to guessing). Neither had I heard of DEAD SOULS (and was fairly smug when I worked it out) – who’d have guessed that the world’s most popular search engine also wrote books? Vaguely knew the “leat” of LEAPT, or perhaps I’m just retrospectively filling gaps in my memory.
Apart from those, I can’t really see why I found it so difficult, and can only blame it on today’s being Thursday, yet again.
Overall an interesting and enjoyable puzzle.