I officially pronounce myself uncertain how to assess this puzzle. I started slowly, so I thought it was going to be tricky, then I had a bit of a sprint in the middle, and changed my mind, then I struggled horribly in the SW corner, and went back the other way. Some clues seemed terribly simple and went in without any thought, others took a lot of thinking about; though with most of those ones, on subsequent reflection I couldn’t see why it had taken me so long. So whether it was difficult or not, I have no idea, but I can at least say that it took me 16 minutes and I mostly enjoyed it.
Across |
1 |
MANIPULATE – NIP(=squeeze) in MAUL, AT {gam}E. In the actual game of rugby, a maul isn’t the same thing as a scrum, of course, but like their close relative the ruck, the word outside the game of rugby has much the same meaning. |
6 |
EROS – {H}ERO, S{ucceeded}. |
9 |
CHIMERA – CHIME(=correspond with), RA, Egyptian god of the sun. |
10 |
AMNESIA – (NAMEAS1)*. Recollected meaning both to be remembered and to be re-collected i.e. distributed as an anagram. |
12 |
FORESHADOW – R{iver} in FOE, SHADOW(=in opposition). |
13 |
TOE – T{hesis} O{n} E{lectronics}. |
15 |
EDISON – (SIDE)rev. (=”reflective view”), ON. Thomas Alva was an extremely inventive inventor. |
16 |
CREOSOTE – [O{ld}, SO(=indeed)] in CRETE. Shield for the wood rather than made of it, nicely deceptive definition. |
18 |
EPIDEMIC – DEMI{se} in EPIC. |
20 |
STIGMA – T{ime} in SIGMA. |
23 |
INN – chaIN Nabs. |
24 |
GREENSWARD – i.e. GREENS’ WARD. |
26 |
LETITIA – [TIT I] in LEA. |
27 |
TILLAGE – LAG(=convict) in TILE(=flat block). |
28 |
DODO – 2 DOs combine to give the famously extinct bird, from which metaphorically comes the meaning of someone old-fashioned or reactionary. |
29 |
AIR HOSTESS – (ISASOTHERS)*. Cabin crew, obviously. |
|
Down |
1 |
MUCH – double def., one of them being a Merry Man of Robin Hood’s band. |
2 |
NAIROBI – AIR(=appearance) in N{ew} OBI. |
3 |
PIECES OF EIGHT – Arrr. The old Spanish dollar beloved of pirates, while 8 could be made up of “pieces” 2 and 6 added together. |
4 |
LOATHE – 0 in LATHE. |
5 |
TO AND FRO – AN(=article) in TOD(=old word for a fox), (FOR)*. |
7 |
RISOTTO – [IS O.T.T.] in R{hin}O. |
8 |
SIAMESE CAT – (ASEATSMICE)* &lit. |
11 |
NEW SOUTH WALES – (USESWEALTHWON)*. |
14 |
BEDEVILLED – BEDE(=scholarly monk), VILLE(=French town), D{eparts}. |
17 |
LITERATI – L{arge} ITERATI{ON} minus the ON. |
19 |
IGNITED – BIG UNITED minus first letters. |
21 |
GERMANE – GERMAN (Edward, composer of Merrie England), and the key of E. |
22 |
SNATCH – S{ons}, NATCH. |
25 |
TEES – sThElEnS. “Runner” worth noting as a lateral definition of “river” for people who’ve only just got used to “flower”. |
Edited at 2015-11-03 02:42 am (UTC)
STIGMA was one of the easier clues, but I had decided early on that time must be AGE, so I wrapped a Greek letter around it and will now have to live with the ETAGEA of my failure.
COD to CREOSOTE. Thanks setter and Tim.
In any case, I did some biffing–and now that I’ve seen Tim’s blog, I’m glad I did, as I never would have parsed MANIPULATE or TO-AND-FRO, not knowing MAUL or TOD. Some very easy clues (TOE, AMNESIA), but I was held up by 29ac (‘crew’ plus the enumeration suggested OAR **** to me), 28ac (lovely surface), and of course CREOSOTE, my COD. Enjoyable puzzle all in all.
Edited at 2015-11-03 03:11 am (UTC)
Also didn’t know Edward German. Did he do MUCH that’s important. (Vinyl?) Said MUCH known from the TV series. The one with Lily Allen’s dad as the wonderfully evil Sheriff.
And yep, I noted the preponderance of inclusion types, with the word “in” carrying most of the burden.
Looks like I was massively wrong about the four-legged race. But congrats to Michelle Payne and anyone who had a punt at $126.
Edited at 2015-11-03 05:29 am (UTC)
Edited at 2015-11-03 05:40 am (UTC)
Incidentally is “Much the miller’s son” Much, the son of an unnamed miller or is he the unnamed son of Much the miller? If the former it’s not terribly likely that his Dad is also called Much which would mean you must have imagined “Much the Miller”.
I had trouble parsing 16ac until I realised I was using the wrong I to make EPIC, and at 5dn I knew TOD = fox but ‘without progress’ was a shade of meaning I have not met before.
Like others, I had the note at the wrong end of GERMANE for ages, and was playing with something to do with garnering. I also biffed MONOPOLISE at 1ac with no hope of parsing – if it’s 1ac, you just assume the construction is really tricky in a tricky puzzle and hope for enlightenment later.
I (and Chambers) associate endless arguments with toing and froing, but there was no room for the ings, so heigh ho.
Edited at 2015-11-03 08:38 am (UTC)
Couldn’t remember names of Mick the Miller’s sons (it’s a matter of background and upbringing) but once I saw great deal=MUCH realised I was barking up the wrong dog
Edited at 2015-11-03 12:11 pm (UTC)
Thanks to blogger and setter.
I had exactly the same experience as Sotira where creosote was concerned (more Monty Python?). It cost me a good 3 minutes at the end.
I’ll add the the list of wrong assumptions at 29 and admit my first thought was that it had to be SEA something.
COD to pieces of eight.
On edit : Indeed he wasn’t so I feel better about this.
Edited at 2015-11-03 04:41 pm (UTC)
A straightforward, enjoyable puzzle.