I found this crossword very intricately, I’d probably go so far as virtuosically, constructed, while perhaps not quite having some ineffable spark that would put it in my very top tier of puzzles. Oh, I don’t know, it’s very likely to be a case of “it’s not you, it’s me”, as I felt much the same way about yesterday’s puzzle and may well still be feeling grumpy! The surfaces are all immaculate here, and while *I* generally like a bit more obscure vocabulary and GK to keep me on my toes, I expect the majority will feel the opposite.
COD to 17dn, as obviously I’m always up for a bit of Mail-bashing. Some great technical cluing here, too: “first son being cross”, “deliver sermon without church’s backing”, a solid &lit at 16dn… there’s so much here that’s so clever. The solution to 6dn looked wrong to my eyes, I think my instinct would have been to spell it CHOCKA, but I’m sure that’s just me…
Almost certainly an A grade puzzle then, any withholding of a coveted A+ can only be down to the marker’s curmudgeonliness. Many many thanks to the brilliant setter!
Across | |
1 | BREADTH – sweep: BREAD [money] + TH{is} [“is” lost by “this”] |
5 | TICKS – sound made by, say, grandfather (i.e. clock): STICK [cane “heading for the back”, i.e. moving the first letter to the end] |
9 | ROOST – sleeping place: ROOT [ferret] “has gone across” S [singular] |
10 | JUXTAPOSE – to stand side by side: JUST A POSE [a mere sham] with “first son being cross”, i.e. the first S being replaced by an X |
11 | ALSO-RAN – it’s not among the top few: {jour}ALS OR AN{nnuals} “to display” |
12 | MEERKAT – carnivore: (ARK*) [“beaten”] in MEET [sporting contest] |
13 | INDELICATE – immodest: {b}E{l}L{e} [“appearing regularly”] in INDICATE [show] |
15 | CREW – double def: party / was triumphant |
18 | ELMS – source of timber: SMILE [beam] “I overlooked | in recess”, i.e. losing the I and being reversed |
20 | CAERPHILLY – Welsh town: PREA{ch} [deliver sermon “without church’s | backing”, i.e. missing CH, and reversed] in CHILLY [unfriendly] |
23 | TANTRUM – paddy: TT [abstainer] “imbibing” AN, + RUM [alcoholic drink] |
24 | PERSONA – character: N [name] in (OPERAS*) [“comic”] |
25 | SAY CHEESE – “I’m about to take a photo”: SAY [roughly] + CHEESE [20, maybe, referring to Caerphilly, the solution to 20ac] |
26 | SEIZE – appropriate: homophone of SEES [witnesses “heard”] |
27 | RUDDY – florid: D{ad}DY [father “out of puff”, i.e. minus AD] after R.U. [game] |
28 | SHEBANG – business: BANG [report] on S.E. [Home Counties] “nursing” H [hospital] |
Down | |
1 | BROWSED – casually inspected: ROWS [ranks] in BED [base] |
2 | ENTIRELY – in every respect: ELY [see] “about” N TIRE [new | flag] |
3 | DIJON – somewhere in France: D [daughters] + (JOIN*) [“frolics”] |
4 | HEXAMETER – six-footer: H EXAM {d}ETER [height | test | put off “capital unavailable”, i.e. missing its first letter] |
5 | TEAMED – matched: TEA MED [light meal | vast amount of water] |
6 | CHOCKER – packed: {s}HOCKER [sensational tale “apart from second”, i.e. minus an S] “supporting” C [chapter] |
7 | SPELT – was likely to produce: S PELT [small | coat] |
8 | CREATIVE – original: C [hundred] + RE{l}ATIVE [“pounds squandered by” (i.e. minus an L) one of the family] |
14 | CHARMLESS – unattractive: M [male] in CHARLES [Dickens possibly] + S [succeeded] |
16 | WAYFARER – (WEARY*) [“vagrant”] “that’s got around” FAR [a great deal], &lit |
17 | CHARISMA – appeal: CHAR [daily] + (MAI{l}’S*) [“unorthodox”, “line lacking” i.e. minus an L] |
19 | MONEYED – flush: ONE-{e}YED [like cyclops “disheartened”] after M [maiden] |
21 | LOOMING – menacing: {b}LOOMING [“bishop leaves” in fine fettle] |
22 | ARCHLY – with cunning: ARCH [crook] + LY [“emptied” L{ibrar}Y] |
23 | TASER – stunner: reverse of RESAT [struck another pose, “looking up”] |
24 | PIECE – part: homophone of PEACE [“the Sound of” Silence] |
TICKS opened it up for me (which I, like Jack, parsed on the basis of the grandfather clock) and then eventually the rest fell into place.
Many great clues – favourites 24dn and 10ac.
As the R and H arrived in 22dn, and looking at CROOK as possibly being the definition, I started thinking of a certain former peer of the realm – but a) he’s not dead yet (as far as I know) and b) The Times would not want a libel suit on its hands and c) that’s possibly a bit uncharitable…
Thanks to setter for a beauty, and to V for the usual entertainment.
Edited at 2015-09-18 09:56 am (UTC)
Thought this was brilliant, great surfaces, COD to SHEBANG.
Thanks setter and great blog V. But come on, give it an A+. You know you want to.
I thought this was going to be real trouble but it came together nicely after I had got started eventually in the bottom half, though working upwards through the grid is always something of a disadvantage. I clocked out in 37 minutes which is not too bad for me at the moment.
Edited at 2015-09-18 09:24 am (UTC)
somewhat tenuouscompletely spurious parsing! Told you I was not quite with it this week…Edited at 2015-09-18 11:15 am (UTC)
Like you, verlaine, I like a bit of arcane vocab to keep me on my toes (provided it’s fairly clued of course, so we won’t talk about OREADs and LEG-BYEs!) but I also admire a puzzle that manages to pose a challenge without resort to such obscurity. This was one of those, so thanks to the setter.
Edited at 2015-09-18 10:24 am (UTC)
About an hour – top half 1ac held me up.
COD 10 ac
horryd Shanghai
In defence of the Welsh town, it was a rainy day when we were there several years ago now but the people were definitely friendly.
Lovely puzzle with some terrifically crafted clues so thanks all round.
I’m always game for a bit of arcane vocab, so long as I know it.
Edited at 2015-09-18 12:52 pm (UTC)
Nice puzzle.