Anyway I found today’s puzzle very serviceable, if not especially memorable. It took me a while to find an “in”, I think possibly 25A, combined with the conviction that 23A must end with “light”, but once some letters were in progress was quite steady, in the aforementioned stop-start kind of way. No really obnoxious vocab or requisite knowledge, apart from perhaps Auster, the south wind: an old friend to any classicist. I think my LOI was a classical one though, at 9A. 18D caused me the most puzzlement in the event, remaining unparsed until after I’d finished and submitted, though the penny did drop eventually.
“Things” in the sense of “crazes” makes a reappearance from a few weeks ago: I still don’t think I 100% get it, but at least I was ready for it this time. Also I seem to remember an outing for the mighty river Yangtze in recent months, which seems unlikely, but I suppose if the letters start to fall that way it must be irresistible for any setter worth their NaCl. COD-wise nothing blew my socks off inordinately, but I did enjoy the nicely tidy and deceptive cluing in e.g. 12D and 16D. A very solid puzzle all told, merci beaucoup setter!
Across | |
1 | FAVA BEAN – plant: F A VAN [following a vehicle] “outside” ABE [Lincoln] |
5 | ROBUST – tough: OB [old boy] in RUST [brown coat] |
8 | GASTRIC FLU – disorder: GAS [fuel] + TRIC{k} [scam “briefly”] + FLU{id} [liquid “I’d nicked”] |
9 | TROY – old city: {des}TROY [“some French abandon” wreck] |
10 | NAME AND ADDRESS – “police often demand them”: NAME [to call] + AND [with] + ADDRESS [tackle] |
11 | SONNETS – “works with fixed number of lines”: SON [young man] + NETS [scores] |
13 | RE-ENTRY – “risky time for Buzz”: RE{p}ENT [to rue “losing power”] + RY [lines] |
15 | AUSTERE – severe: blow [AUSTER] + E [{ey}E’s “closing”] |
18 | IDEALLY – if possible: I’D [I would] + {r}EALLY [without doubt, “shed top”] |
21 | RAILWAY STATION – Victoria, say: (IT ALWAYS*) [“has gone wrong”] in RATION [helping] |
22 | TIRE – “exhaust”: double def with “other car part in Daytona”, i.e. tyre spelt the American way |
23 | FLOODLIGHT – beam: in FLIGHT [trip], LOO D [can daughter] |
24 | TEA SET – china: T T [Times] “keeps” EASE [calm] |
25 | GEMSTONE – maybe ruby: GET ONE [secure unit] “binding” MS [document] |
Down | |
1 | FAG ENDS – useless bits: GEN [dope] “opens” FADS [things] |
2 | VESTMENTS – clothing: {in}VESTMENTS [shares possibly, “less” trendy] |
3 | BARRAGE – shelling: RA [gunners] “admitted to” BARGE [lighter] |
4 | ARCADES – “games here”: “partly” {cau}SED A CRA{ze} “in recession” |
5 | ROUNDHEAD – Parliamentarian: UND [and German] + HE [ambassador] “opened” ROAD [route] |
6 | BITTERN – BIT TERN [part diver], but a BITTERN is “all wader” |
7 | SPONSOR – double def of “the Godfather, perhaps” and “back” |
12 | THROW A FIT – blow up: (WAIT FOR TH{e} [the “unceasing”] *) [“winds”] |
14 | TALKING TO – carpeting: (TOTAL*) [“fiasco”] “without” KING [ruler] |
16 | UKRAINE – country: UK [this country] + RAIN [drops] + E [European] |
17 | TRICEPS – muscle: (PR{a}CTISE [“after pulling a”] *) [“wrestling”] |
18 | INSHORE – “not that far out in the deep”: homophone [“caught”] of INSURE, “by some”, i.e. those who don’t pronounce it to rhyme with “pure” instead |
19 | ENABLES – activates: E [European] + BAN [veto “over”] + LES [French article] |
20 | YANGTZE – “big flower”: (ANY Z{innia} [“initially”] GET*) [“freakishly”] |
I am tolerant of homophones but thought insure/inshore rather a stretch.
Auster familiar to aviation buffs as well as classicists..
I got 18dn comparatively early, but I thought to myself, even as I wrote it in, that the editor’s ears will be burning with all the comments of exasperated campaigners against debatable homophones, no matter how much the clue flags up the fact that it’s not supposed to be exact…
I only knew FAVA BEAN from the well known recommendation that they go well with chianti and a human liver.
Some nice surfaces such as 12dn and 17dn. Also enjoyed the Buzz reference, and who doesn’t love a dodgy homophone?
Great stuff, with a quality blog to boot.
And fava beans are what americans call broad beans
Edited at 2014-12-12 01:40 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2014-12-12 02:18 pm (UTC)
I’m not sure if Woody’s chum’s astronautical career wasn’t mostly in his head, now I come to think of it…
I found this really tough, but got there in the end, but did have to resort to aids for a couple. Now I’ve finished, it all looks fair and reasonable.
Put me firmly in the Lightyear camp for Buzz, without even knowing the rule re living peeps.
‘Fava bean’ was my FOI – ah, there’s an easy start. It all flowed very nicely.
I’m with topicaltim, inasmuch as the puzzle didn’t feel easy while I was doing it and I enjoyed it.
Count me as an ALDRIN, and I had no problem with the clue for INSHORE because of the “by some” in the clue.
Ocker Austroylians would have no quarrel with the homophone.
19:54, with no real holdups, and Buzz Lightyear – even not knowing Aldrin was still alive.
Rob (Ocker)
As an Australian, insure and inshore have the same vowel sounds, but in insure both vowels are shorter. Pure comes out as PEW-ER, a maker of church benches, almost stretching past dipthong to double syllable. Nothing like insure.
The comment above came from a previous disputed homophone – a Scot claimed POOR rhymed with INURE, and sounded nothing like PORE. POOR/PORE is a perfect homophone for Aussies, and Londoners too I’m guessing.
Rob
Meantime, can someone help me with Barge = Light? Thx
Edited at 2014-12-12 11:03 pm (UTC)
Very late solve, very late comment. I seem to have found the wavelength with this one though and did it in 8:45, with a couple at the end on 15ac, which eventually went in from the definition. I didn’t know or had forgotten the wind. A shrug of the shoulders for the homophone. I thought Buzz was Aldrin and the living person rule didn’t occur to me.
a flat-bottomed barge or other unpowered boat used to transfer goods to and from ships in harbour.
Who knew?
Thanks,
An interesting and enjoyable puzzle, about which I’ve no complaints. Andy Borrows is absolutely right to point out “by some” in 18dn, a usage which I’m pretty sure Ximenes would have entirely approved of. He’d probably have been less keen on “Some French abandon …” in 9ac, but it doesn’t bother me in the slightest.
I half-assumed from 13ac that Buzz Aldrin had snuffed it, but I’m pleased to find that, like Umberto Eco (who appeared in No. 25,951), he’s still alive. Perhaps the convention about not including names of living people is being gradually relaxed.
Thanks for the interesting blog (and further comments) BTW, particularly as I hadn’t come across the Criterion Collection before. Sadly it’s a bit late for me to hope to catch up on more than a small fraction of those I’ve missed – of which The Silence of the Lambs is one I’ll happily omit!
Failed to parse RE-ENTRY, INSHORE, VESTMENTS.