FOI was 1D – thanks, classical education – and then it was a case of chipping away at the shorter words to try and find entry points to the longer and more convoluted solutions. I ended in the bottom right corner, making heavy we(a)ther of 17D and then just staring blankly at 16D, even though I’d completely parsed how it worked and was racking my brains for the name of that chap with the violin, but somehow just couldn’t summon up anyone apart from STRADIVARI. Like I said, exhaustion.
I do sort of quibble with “lacking belief” as a definition for pagan, but that’s just the injured pride talking. Oh, the other clue that stymied me for the longest time was 2D: the solution was very obvious from the crossing letters but for the longest time I was trying to find some kind of degree in chauffeuring abbreviating to L.A. – perhaps the Knowledge of a cabbie was “London Accreditation” or similar? When the penny finally dropped (at least another half-hour after the half-hour) my groans were audible for afar. Slightly tortuous…
On the COD front, I do love crossword clues about crossword clues, so 6D was a winner in my book, but the devious-on-multiple-fronts 24A met all my criteria for a clever clue, concealing all sorts of complex things in plain sight, while at the same time generating a surface that could be a scene from classical mythology, the adventures of Odysseus perhaps. So that’s my personal favourite.
I should stop my yapping now, but lovely to meet those I met at the weekend, sorry to miss those that I missed, and see lots of you and the next one I hope!
Across | |
1 | SILK – “person taking case”, i.e. legal case: S [“entrance to” station] + ILK [kind] |
3 | VAUDEVILLE – show: U [university] + DEVIL [Dickens] in VALE [farewell] |
9 | BOMBING – double def, in senses of going very fast and failing miserably |
11 | VACCINE – “that’s used for certain shots”: VAC [holiday] + CINE [sort of camera] |
12 | HYDROFOIL – method of transport: HYDRO [hotel] + FOIL [block] |
13 | ON ICE – “being held back”: O NICE [appreciative exclamation] |
14 | LICKETY-SPLIT – quickly: LICK [defeat] + (YET*) [“re-formed”] + SPLIT [disunited] |
18 | WELL I DECLARE – gracious: WELL ID [healthy credentials] + E CLARE [European girl] |
21 | OLLIE – “Hardy maybe”: O L [“tips from” original] + LIE [tale] |
22 | OSTEOPATH – “profession manipulating”: (A PHOTOSET*) [“fantastically”] |
24 | FLYLEAF – “sheet with nothing on”: LEA [“where cattle graze”] “is wrapped in” FLY F [cunning female] |
25 | PASTIER – “looking less healthy”: PA’S TIER [rank of secretary] |
26 | HYPOTENUSE – long line: HYPO TEN USE [needle shared by a few] |
27 | WIRY – tough: WI [organisation associated with jam] + RY [line] |
Down | |
1 | SUBPHYLA – groups: H [hours] in (PLAYBUS*) [“organised”] |
2 | LAME DUCK – “one useless”: L [chauffeur learning, i.e. learner driver] + A DUCK [zero] about ME [yours truly] |
4 | AGGRO – difficulties: GR [gross] “interfering in” AGO [past] |
5 | DEVELOPED – picked up: DERV – R [fuel “having run out”] + ELOPED [made off] |
6 | VICTORIA CROSS – award: VICTOR [winner] + I ACROSS [top clue] |
7 | LAID IN – reserved: L [professional “finally”] + AI DIN [smashing racket] |
8 | EXETER – see: {t}EXTER [one sending SMS “without beginning”] “to grasp” E [English] |
10 | IN ONES ELEMENT – at home: I + NONES [service] + ELEMENT [heating component] |
15 | YELLOWFIN – fish: (FEW ONLY I L*) [“remarkably”] |
16 | PAGANINI – PAGAN [lacking belief] IN I [in one] |
17 | WETHERBY – Yorkshire racecourse: HER [the girl’s] with WET BY [soaked through] “going round” |
19 | LOOFAH – bath cleaner: LOO [toilet] “tops” FAH [note] |
20 | PLAY UP – double def: cause trouble / stress |
23 | TYPES – sorts: TYPE [letters] + S [“opening of” sack] |
Then got stuck in the SW, assuming (from the surface only) that 24ac had to be FIGLEAF. That left me with CLOG UP or PLUG UP as candidates for 20dn. Neither, obviously, worked. So back to actually parsing 24ac.
Not sure, with our esteemed blogger, that PAGANs lack belief. The ones I once knew (for my sins?) banged on about the most ridiculous rubbish all the time. Even ODO’s first entry is: “a person holding religious beliefs other than those of the main world religions”. Or else the perfectly ordinary expression “pagan god” makes no sense.
COD has to go to VICTOR, 1 ACROSS. Could have won the clueing comp??
Lastly, I hope the NINA in the middle column was unintented rather than ominous.
On edit re 26ac: should you have had the misfortune to share needles, you would re-write the clue as “Needle shared by quite a few …” where the last three words mean “far too many”.
Edited at 2014-10-24 09:21 am (UTC)
Does 10dn concern the perverted mahout with a speech defect?
The last thing I’d say about a pagan is that they lack belief – indeed (like others) quite the contrary in my experience
A HYPOTENUSE is the “longest line” (in a right angled triangle) but not necessarily a “long line” – could be microscopic in length
But some excellent clues to balance such things so thank you setter
The clue works better if you substitute “a” for “long” to give “….a few forming a line”
LICKETY-SPLIT and VAUDEVILLE worth a mention for sheer cunning, but WELL I DECLARE wins my fickle heart today.
Edited at 2014-10-24 09:58 am (UTC)
I wondered about ‘profession’ for OSTEOPATH (rather than OSTEOPATHY) but then I remembered we’ve done this one before, and it’s fine.
I didn’t know HYDRO for ‘hotel’
Edited at 2014-10-24 09:01 am (UTC)
Edited at 2014-10-25 07:04 am (UTC)
Luckily for us Antipodeans, the famous Hydro Majestic in Sydney’s Blue Mountains reopened this very weekend after years of refurbishing.
Good to see that yesterday’s seminar on tautology has been taken on board.
Sorry, Andy. Couldn’t resist it.
My old next door neighbour sat next to me on the train this morning so I did the crossword in between chatting. Thus I’m not exactly sure of my time, but somewhere around 30 minutes. I did take advantage of his horse racing knowledge by getting him to give me WETHERBY before I’d tackled the clue. Another good quality crossword I thought.
Another nice puzzle after yesterday’s. Good on yer ed. Many thanks for the lovely blog too.
Chris.
After having a couple of anagrams sorted for me, and finding 14ac from L + enumeration, was able to finish in another half-hour with 1ac. LOI. (Whenever I see ILK, I think ‘same’ and only afterwards remember that most people misunderstand it as ‘sort’)
Like Joe, PAGANINI went in without parsing
My lack of a classical education made 1d difficult. Conversely, my decision to make my home in a village 2.5 miles from the lovely Yorkshire market town of Wetherby made 17 easy.
I don’t think I’ve heard anyone other than Mary Poppins say lickety-split.
50mins for me, enjoyable puzzle with SUBPHYLA the only unknown, and VAUDEVILLE the only unparsed.
Thanks to both setter and blogger.
ETA: Aha!
“In modern use, ilk is used in phrases such as of his ilk, of that ilk, to mean ‘type’ or ‘sort.’ The use arose out of a misunderstanding of the earlier, Scottish use in the phrase of that ilk, where it means ‘of the same name or place.’ For this reason, some traditionalists regard the modern use as incorrect. It is, however, the only common current use and is now part of standard English.”
Edited at 2014-10-24 02:30 pm (UTC)
Time taken 10.20.34 mercifully unrecorded as the program crashed on submit. Could not find value 0 or some such.
VC was a fun clue. Pagans will just have to put up with being “without belief” until setters and editor change their minds. Chambers does give: “more recently, someone who has no religion” but I’m incline to agree with those above whose personal experience of pagans suggests too much belief.
On edit. Ah, there my first post isn’t.
Edited at 2014-10-24 05:44 pm (UTC)
I rather liked this – VAUDEVILLE, DEVELOPED, VICTORIA CROSS and FLYLEAF wonderfully cunningly clued.
Got WETHERBY completely from wordplay, so thanks for making that nice and clear setter.
Richard Hooker – 16th century theologian – numbered Judaism, Christianity and Paganism as the three great religions.
In 1792, William Carey’s astonishing “An Enquiry into the Obligations of Christians to use Means for the Conversion of the Heathens” available on project Gutenberg, uses “pagan” throughout for anyone who isn’t Christian, Jew Papist, or Mohametan. What makes it astonishing is his survey of the world’s nations and populations, giving a world population of 731 million, 420 million of which “still live in pagan darkness”.
FOI Silk, LOI Laid In.
Like you I was confused by the A in LAME DUCK, and I’m still not terribly keen on it, but overall I thought this was a very fine puzzle. My compliments to the setter.
After an hour, I gave in and resorted to the “reveal” option for the first letter of WETHERBY. Wasn’t helped by having “WIRE” (“tough line”) instead of “WIRY” at 27ac.
Like others, I’m not completely sure about LAME DUCK – clueing “a duck” as “zero” (rather than “a zero”) doesn’t feel right to me. And we had “bomb” recently, did we not? Still, a nice puzzle, and my compliments to the setter.
Today’s ‘Accident of the Day’ award (which was also nominated for ‘Dental Misadventure of the Week’) goes to an elderly gentleman who, having a deep-seated fear of dentists, attempted to remove his own decayed molar. He did succeed, at the cost of a fractured lower jaw, but removed the wrong tooth. It really does make you wonder if evolution was worth all the trouble.
Edited at 2014-10-24 11:37 pm (UTC)
Can’t see what all the fuss is re pagan, Collins says “a person without any religion; heathen” which is good enough for me. Or re ilk or a duck, for that matter
Bob
Bob