Solving time: About 50 minutes.
This felt like quite a tricky one. I started it last night, but only got about a third of the way through in half an hour. So I went to bed and got up early to finish it.
No time for more insight now or I’ll be late for work!
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | HAVE A FIT – dd |
| 9 | REARMOST = ARM (branch) + O |
| 10 | M(O)USER |
| 11 | TOUCH + STONE – A court jester in As You Like It |
| 12 | KILN – rev hidden |
| 13 | SELL-BY DATE = ( |
| 16 | DECLAIM – dd, with the second being a fanciful reversal of CLAIM, hence the question mark |
| 17 | CRYSTAL = CRY + (LAST)* |
| 20 | ANTAGONISE – ANT (soldier) + AGONIES (great pain) with the last two letters switched. |
| 22 | LOIN = LION with the middle two letters switched |
| 23 | ANDY WARHOL = AND (with) + HOLY WAR with the first three letters moved to the end. |
| 25 | IN STEP – dd – ‘one on foot’ = INSTEP |
| 26 | TATTOOER = TOO (extremely) in TATER (Murphy, a variety of Irish potato) |
| 27 | DEEP-DYED = P in DEED + YE’D – I originally had DEEP-DOWN, thinking ‘you had once’ was just OWN, although OWNED would’ve fit better |
| Down | |
| 2 | AMORTISE = IT (appeal) rev in A + MORSE – not a word I knew |
| 3 | EAST ANGLIA = (AGAIN LET’S)* + A – My neck of the woods and my FOI |
| 4 | FORTISSIMO = I’M in (FOR + ‘TIS + SO) – I’m not sure about ‘hiding’ indicating ‘inside’, it feels the wrong way round to me. |
| 5 | T + ROUBLE |
| 6 |
|
| 7 | BOGOTA = G wearing BOOT + A |
| 8 | ETHEREAL = HERE (present) in ET AL (and the others) |
| 14 | BORDERLINE – dd |
| 15 | DIS(PL)EASED |
| 16 | D(I AM)ANTE |
| 18 | AS IT WERE = (IT WAS)* + ‘ERE (before) |
| 19 | RICH + HARD – with one of the Hs removed |
| 21 | TO DATE – dd |
| 24 | AGO + |
I’m pretty sure I had 20ac as A(NTA)GONISE; where our soldier is the second ANT with his A dropped to the end. But, as I said, I don’t have the whole thing here and could be remembering badly.
I have ANTAGONISE as Dave, with ‘moving rear a little’ as the instruction to move the final ‘s’ in agonies up (along) one. DEEP-DYED was an unknown/forgotten. Rather liked REARMOST.
AMORTISE (or its alternative -IZE) has surely come up here recently as that’s the only reason it came to my mind so readily. CRYSTAL meaning ‘watch glass’ was the only thing new to me, I think, but I may simply have forgotten it.
I agree with Dave and Ulaca about ANTAGONISE. I’ve been trying to make mct’s alternative work but I can’t quite see it. This was my last to parse as during the solve I had left its penultimate letter blank to allow for another possible -IZE ending.
Can’t make up my mind about 4dn.
Edited at 2014-03-14 07:21 am (UTC)
Nice surface, but dodgy cryptic reading, seems it to me.
Edited at 2014-03-14 07:33 am (UTC)
BTW, Dave thanks for the blog. The puzzle was another beast in my view. So glad to be able to come here and get some of the wordplay explained.
I had ANTAGONISE like mctext, but I was clearly wrong, because “agonise” doesn’t mean “great pain”.
ANDY WARHOL was very cleverly clued, I thought, but I don’t think I’d have ever worked it out from the wordplay. I preferred DECLAIM as my CoD because of its whimsy.
AMORTISE will be familiar to the accountants and actuaries. I see after “inbreed” the other day we’re back with Dr Thud again today at 3D. Clearly he’s having an effect upon our setters.
I guess there’ll be another pen on its way to me. I shall have a matching pair!
Edited at 2014-03-14 01:11 pm (UTC)
Fortunately ‘amortised’ was the nine letter word in the City AM Wordwheel last week, so I knew it from there!
LOI TATTOOER which I thought was never going to come until I eventually made the connection to getting under one’s skin. I can’t think that the word’s ever used in practice – surely always a TATTOOIST.
Nice to have a Shakespearean clue making a (now) rare-ish appearance, and it was good that all that accountancy training eventually came useful with AMORTISE. A bit unconvinced by absolute = DEEP DYED, but there you go, no doubt some complete, thoroughgoing dictionary has it. Once that hurdle fell, the rest of the SE, which had been delaying me, opened up. CRYSTAL one of those, for me, perfectly obvious solutions – after I’d spent over 5 minutes working it out. Obviously not IN STEP, AS IT WERE, with the setter today!
Edited at 2014-03-14 11:58 am (UTC)
Edited at 2014-03-14 12:17 pm (UTC)
– I agree that 4d doesn’t quite work and there should be an “in” or something;
– As I work in finance amortise was a gimme;
– I didn’t know crystal as a watch face;
– I have no idea how I kne the clown but it was one of my first in;
– I didn’t like stomach to indicate the middle bit as it doesn’t mean that does it?
– I thought the wordplay for both sell-by date and Andy Warhol was excellent.
Happy week-end everyone
Nairobi Wallah
I agree that this puzzle wasn’t quite as good as yesterday’s but it was still a quality offering.
Guessed Touchstone from checkers and by reckoning ‘st’ was in the middle.
Much, much harder for me than yesterday’s, but at least I finished it all correctly, in several sessions, throughout the day. Lots went in unparsed, and it’s only now, with the help of this blog – thanks! – that I can appreciate the cleverness.
Another very fine puzzle.
I was relieved to get out the other side of this one. FOI was KILN (easy enough), but from then on it was a slow grind with every answer yielding only to hand-to-hand combat. Not helped by my being unfamiliar with TOUCHSTONE as a clown (and forgetting that meaning of “touch”), and by having only the vaguest knowledge of AMORTISE. I also agonised over TATTOOER, which I never did get round to parsing.
Surprised to see my very own EAST ANGLIA in there, as “part of the kingdom”. I always think of myself as living (and I use the term loosely) in the flat bit just to the right of England.
One clue I’d take issue with: the crystal is not the face of a watch; it is the glass or acrylic cover that protects the dial and hands.
To be honest, I enjoyed having finished this one more than doing it. I don’t mind difficult clues, but I prefer more of them to be of the “aha!” variety – many of today’s just felt like hard work.
My optimism last night proved well-founded – a late-night fog is always good for business. Today hasn’t been bad either so far, with Accident of the Day going to a man who almost severed two fingers with a prosthetic leg. In case you’re wondering how this is possible, he’d been trying to un-bend a bent bit when something gave way and the joint folded shut on his hand. He did see the funny side, which made us all feel a little less guilty for laughing.
Even if the clue may be said to work, it is ugly and clumsy.
Edited at 2014-03-15 09:28 am (UTC)
The comma only reinforces my argument, which follows the logic of English grammar as shown by the previous emails.
If setters are not prepared to use correct English grammar logic, what hope is there for sensible and solvable crossword clues?
It’s very possible we’re arguing two different things, both of which may be correct.
From the standpoint of picking apart the surface of a cryptic clue, I’m reading ‘too’ is inside something. I then look for what could be outside = tater and then the definition. That’s what I mean by the comma breaking the clue up – otherwise what is it there for? So I think this worked as a solvable clue.
Had this debate been on the day I’m pretty sure that the assembled company would have come uo with some elegantly intelligent and probably witty comment to round this up.