Solving time: 44:42
I struggled in the NW corner today. It took me an age to work out 1a. I was assuming the piano reference in the surface was intended to mislead, and was trying to fit ORTHODONTAL or PERIODONTIC or something similar around the wordplay – and I didn’t see the obvious POP at 1d for ages either.
No particular stand out clues for me today, although I see 1a is popular on the forum. It’s a good clue, but it somehow seems a little strained to me. It probably is the best of the day, but certainly not of the month as has been suggested. But that’s just my opinion.
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
Across | |
---|---|
1 | P |
7 | CUB |
9 | PRAYERFUL = PR + FREYA rev + U |
10 | WORST = S in WORT |
11 | TI(T + MIC)E |
12 | PRIVATE – dd |
13 | A(MP)LE |
15 | S + MOULDERS |
17 | INNOCENCE = IN NO SENSE with both Ss replaced by Cs |
19 | WEAVE = “WE’VE” |
20 | OUT + BACK |
22 | DROP + LET |
24 | EVICT = E (European) + CT (Court) about VI (6 = half a jury) |
25 | REARGUARD = REAR (bring up) + (A DRUG)* |
27 |
|
28 | LIVING DEATH = LIVING (income) + (HATED)* |
Down | |
1 | POP – Abbreviation for Population / Popular music |
2 | A + WAI |
3 | ONE-TIME = I + T |
4 | OFF SEASON – I think this is just saying that a SON is OFF the SEA, hence an OFF-SEA SON. |
5 | T(U + L)IP |
6 | SAWMILL – cd |
7 | CARTAGE + NA |
8 | BITTERSWEET = (WEBSITE + |
11 | TRAGICOMEDY = (DO I CRY AT + M |
14 | PONY (£25) + TAILS (toss-up result) – Barnet Fair is CRS for hair |
16 | OVERDRAWN – dd |
18 | CHAT + TEL |
19 | WRONGED = (RED GOWN)* |
21 | KIROV = KV (Kilovolts) about IRO |
23 | LLAMA = A + MALL all rev |
26 | DOH – dd |
The best Spanish port I could invent was CARRATENA. CARTAGENA would have been equally inventive given my knowledge of Spanish ports, but it was a fair clue and I can’t complain.
Agree with Dave that 1ac was a little too tortured to be classified as brilliant.
And….Clarke’s out. Ulaca will be pleased.
So is there any part of you that can sit back and admire Faulkner’s innings? Quite extraordinary I thought.
I haven’t seen a ball, thank goodness – just Cricinfo and the (English) papers.
…and that one was the Spanish port, which was an unknown. Couldn’t get ‘carriage’ out of my mind, but knew it couldn’t be that.
When the blog didn’t appear overnight I worried I had missed my turn, what with Jimbo changing weeks and confusing me (it doesn’t take much!).
Edited at 2014-01-17 09:07 am (UTC)
PRIVATE was my last in once I’d twigged that it was not about archbishops and monkeys.
I thought 17 was rather clever – a neat device with a credible surface, and PONYTAILS had a full on Chas ‘n’ Dave feel to it.
Is the definition for WRONGED, “described misleadingly” a touch whimsical? It does have the Qmark at the end.
I wonder if François Hollande likes pork scratchings.
Thaks to Dave for sorting out the parsing of TRAGICOMEDY.
The heading refers to the possibility that England might win an interntional match on this benighted tour for the first time. But while Haddin is at the crease, who knows? I shall then, if only temporarily, be on top of Galspray and McT…
I didn’t like 7dn. A straightforward reading of the wordplay gives you CARRATENA. The actual answer relies on a rather unusual word (“cartage”) so unless you know the town I can’t see how you’re going to get the right answer.
I can’t see 1A as brilliant. Like many I never bothered to work it all out – with 1D and 2D give aways I just stuck it in assuming a wierd cryptic definition.
Luckily I’ve been to CARTAGENA because I agree with Keriothe – if you don’t know it it’s ungettable. Roll on next week.
Didn’t know 7dn, so had to look in Bradford – before I had 7ac I was trying to make something of BARCELONA.
Also I am ill. But I am at work, because I am not quite as ill as the others, who contracted Office Snot-Ebola (Marbogey variant 6.3432) after me. So like England, I have returned to the field too soon. Cough.
Yes. Wading through/ swimming in treacle: somehow this one did not cut the mustard, and even 1ac failed to impress. Never mind, there’s always Monday.
Edited at 2014-01-17 12:06 pm (UTC)
Last in .. PRIVATE
I agree that 1a ain’t all that. Like Dave I would expect to see some misdirection soemwhere and the surface isn’t great – don’t all the white keys represent notes?
Like Z8 I liked 17a ad that’s my COD.
Goodness knows how I knew Cartagena and Kirov but the GK was in there somewhere. I dallied a bit at 24 as for some reason my brain had shut down after getting the port and ballet and was trying to convince me that Roman for 6 was IX.
Edited at 2014-01-17 12:59 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2014-01-17 01:34 pm (UTC)
26min, which I was quite happy with.
“TITMICE” has always puzzled me as a word. If they’re birds (tits) that resemble mice, why aren’t they mousetits?
Also pleased that, for once, my very limited classical education was enough to get me through the Homeric reference at 26d.
Edited at 2014-01-17 02:29 pm (UTC)
I’m never fond of made-up words, and in annoyance I would say FAH to, for example, my smug Australian cricket friends well before I’d say DOH. So: Fah! And more Fah!
Edited at 2014-01-17 02:58 pm (UTC)
Several rather unsatisfactory clues today, starting with PIANOFORTES. OFF-SEASON and WRONGED, had rather tenuous word-substitutions. LOI the relatively straightforward SMOULDERS. Total just under half an hour – Balham to Tottenham Court Rd on the tube and back!
Time was when a Homeric allusion in The Times was something else entirely. Ah well, tempora mutantur, nos et mutamur in illis. D’oh!
Not too sure if I can stay in this nest of titmice much longer. 27, 28.
Things have been rather dull, and sadly I am not today invited to the recurrent party that is the Friday night shift. The only moments of levity today were provided by (a) a young gentleman with a spectacular perineal laceration occasioned by a skateboarding accident (serves him right for showing off) and (b) a man who had managed to run himself over trying to bump-start his car single-handed. Given the wet weather and the density* of cyclists, I was hoping for better.
*in both senses.
Of the other clues SMOULDERS was my LOI, and I entered 1ac and 11dn without bothering to parse them. I knew CARTAGENA and don’t consider it obscure or ungettable, although the wordplay could certainly lead to an alternative if one doesn’t know of it. Horses for courses and all that. I’ll always struggle with certain scientific clues that some of you will find extremely straightforward.
Edited at 2014-01-17 06:01 pm (UTC)
I knew CARTAGENA because of a visit about 20 years ago, but I have sympathy for those that didn’t – as has been mentioned by others, the wordplay was ambiguous if one didn’t already know the answer, with the correct parsing making use of another word (CARTAGE) that’s hardly common currency. I don’t think I’ve seen CARTAGENA mentioned on the news or in a book or even in a crossword before, so I’m not unhappy with it being described as obscure.
I got completely bogged down with 1ac, imagining that the answer was going to be some strange animals ending in DONTES (the last five letters being an anagram of “notes”). I’d thought of keyboard instruments as soon as I read the clue, but dismissed that as a possibility because I took “a number representing notes” to imply that a number didn’t represent notes, which I couldn’t make any sense of (and still can’t). I class this as an “iffy &lit”. Whereas I reckon 6dn is an “iffy cd” since “logs” would surely produce “boards” rather than a single “board”.
I thought of POP straight away as well, but failed to spot “population”. (26dn!)
I’m another who looks forward to thud_n_blunder’s contributions.
Have a nice weekend all.