Solving time : 20 minutes, 48 seconds on my handy-dandy smartassphone timer, but a full 10 minutes of that was spent on the top left corner which decided to evade my probing forever. Funny thing was I thought of the answer for 2 almost straight away and then rejected it as “that’ll never fit the wordplay”. Could have shaved six or seven minutes off easily by trusting “there’s only one or two republics of eight letters that end in an I” logic and bunging it in.
So I’m going to file this under “tricky but fair”, and I really enjoyed a number of clues, and certainly enjoyed a lot of the answers.
I’ve just finished typing up the analysis, and I’ve realised there’s no really obvious clues here – simple hidden answers, direct anagrams. It’s very tough to decide what to leave out (see “about this blog” for why there are omitted answers).
Away we go!
Across | |
---|---|
1 | IDEOGRAM: I DOG(follow) with E inside, then RAM. This took me forever as the definition is masterfully concealed as “Airport sign”, such as an icon that means something to one who would not speak the language. |
9 | ACID(drug), TEST(match): so the idea of an acid test is that you drop nitric acid on something that is meant to be gold – if it tarnishes and bubbles, not gold. If it doesn’t, gold (or something as inactive as gold). That degree in Inorganic Chemistry is not going lacking! |
10 | SIGNAL: I’ve never used it this way, but SIGNAL is listed in Chambers as “remarkable, notable” as an adjective. Any examples? That was a totally signal left cross, m’lud? |
11 | LADY GODIVA: anagram of GLADLY AVOID missing one L |
12 | HUG,0: Took a while to put together HUG as “closely follow”, but I guess “hugging the corner” while driving would count |
13 | ROLLICKING: another double definition when I haven’t seen the second one used (rebuking or scolding) |
16 | HIDEOUS: S for T in HIDEOUT. Loved this clue! |
17 | OFF(run down), SIDE(wing) |
20 | DOTTED LINE: Where DOT and TED may sign |
22 | deliberately omitted m’lady |
23 | ACT THE GOAT: Anagram of TO GET AT CHA |
25 | ISAIAH: 1 then HAS reversed about A1(capital) |
26 | ANACONDA: A CON in AND,A |
27 | LYNX-EYED: sounds like LINK SIDE |
Down | |
2 | DJIBOUTI: D(end of lanD), JIB(sail),OUT(away),I(Island) |
3 | OMNIPOTENT: anagram of (MEN,POINT,TO) |
4 | RALLY(pick up), ROUND(circular) |
5 | MANDALA: MAN then LAD reversed, A |
6 | BIOG: I in BOG, short form of BIOGRAPHY |
7 | GEMINI: MINI(something to wear) in E.G. reversed |
8 | STRANGLE: L in STRANGE |
14 | INFLECTION: L in INFECTION |
15 | KISS ME KATE: K then (I,SETS,MAKE)* |
16 | HIDEAWAY: IDEA(plan) in H, WAY(means) |
18 | deliberately omitted (enumeration may give it away) |
19 | PIVOTAL: 1,VOT |
21 | TITIAN: an anagram of INTIMATE without the non-consecutive(separated) letters in ME |
24 |
|
The most annoying thing was I immediately saw the literal for 7 down, and couldn’t remember the sign after Taurus – that needed all the checkers. I made heavy work of ‘ma’am’, too, although it should have been perfectly obvious with the checking letters in place.
The NE was indeed tough, and I had to get Djibouti from the cryptic before remembering there was such a country. I was mixing it up with djelleba, I think, which is an entirely different thing. Well, at least I didn’t put ‘Dogo’ for the writer.
Thanks to the setter for the fun and to George for unravelling HIDEOUS, where I was getting nowhere trying to derive ‘us’ from ‘at the front’.
• Why specifically “airport sign” (1ac)? Ideograms are all over the place like the proverbial. Especially if you’re in China.
• Why is “run down” OFF (17ac)? [Usual lack of vocab on my part, I guess?]
Apart from those, though, a top-flight puzzle; and a clear COD to 16ac (HIDEOUS).
Am I the only visitor here to own a copy of Sheik Yerbouti?
– the airport is there (a) to add a layer of misdirection, and (b) to tee off those who habitually and endlessly wrongly complain about dbes.
– you can feel a bit off or a bit run down, as I do each December
– yes, very probably.. 🙂
Since it caused me so much grief along the way I’m going to quibble about 1ac where the inclusion of “airport” creates a DBE. None of the usual sources mentions anything about airports so they are just one of many possible examples of where ideograms may be used.
I thought I remembered “signal” with this meaning in a Flanders and Swann lyric about Doctor Beeching but on further thought I remembered it’s a song by Kit and the Widow which describes the privatisation of the railways as “a signal failure”.
I thought this was a super puzzle. There were a few I didn’t understand fully, including the “airport” bit of 1ac. Now that I understand it I think it’s rather neat. Likewise HIDEOUS, which I wanted to be HATEFUL for ages.
I’ve heard the second meaning of ROLLICKING and always assumed it was a euphemism. It might be, according to Collins.
Edited at 2011-12-15 08:49 am (UTC)
Enjoyed this puzzle, and completed it apace bar the two in the top left, and 6dn (omitted from blog!). I eventually worked out the cryptic for 1ac, which then gave 2dn.
6dn required a solver, so technically another DNF (bar one) again for me today.
Ooh, and like ulaca I spent several moments trying to work out ‘us’ from ‘at the front’.
Can someone help with the ’employment’ bit of 21ac please? Is it in the sense of ‘what’s your line?’?
Edited at 2011-12-15 09:27 am (UTC)
Like others, struggled over the IDEOGRAM and the Airport bit. I wonder if it would have had complaints if it had just said “sign”?
A typical Aries, I’ve never bothered with memorising the signs of the Zodiac, so the cryptic was a bit helpful there too.
On the other hand, OFFSIDE, to one happily used to Bale and Lennon carving up the position flanks needn’t have been cryptic at all.
ROLLICKING has to be Ealing Studios cleaning up army slang, surely?
CoD to LADY GODIVA for a likeable attempt at something original.
cod to 1ac for demonstrating that dbes should not be objected to as a species, but only when they result in a problematic clue
Conclusion: any deficiencies in this puzzle lay entirely with the end-user. Nice work.
COD to BIOG for the definition.
I always theought the telling off was rollocking to rhyme with that similar word that means the same thing. Good job the i was checked.
18:00 … No problems with the NW but the disparate trio of BIOG, GEMINI and ISAIAH caused me a lot of brow furrowing at the end.
I’m with Jack on 1a. I’m not a big fan of unindicated DBEs, and this is a proper shocker. Other than that, a good crossword. My COD goes to 7d for the beautifully disguised definition. Even with all the checkers in place, it still took me a moment or two to spot – and it’s my star sign! Although I’m a June person, rather than a May one.
I didn’t know the words MANDALA or IDEOGRAM, or the relevant meaning of SIGNAL. Hence my problems in the NW, but I got there eventually.
I think the clue for ROLLICKING is just a double definition – “Very lively and amusing” + “lecture”.
Mctext: I have several Zappa albums – including the matchless Absolutely Free – but not (yet) Sheik Yerbouti.
Enigma
I suspect that one of the reasons why it falls down, is that those with photographic memories/mental dictionaries will see D…I and stick in the answer fairly quickly.
I hadn’t considered J as a possible second letter for the former, and it was only when I finally worked my way through the alphabet in desperation that light dawned.
As for HUGO, I was looking for a rather older writer (like Publius Virgilius MARO) and again missed the obvious.
A most enjoyable puzzle, with several first-rate clues (including 2dn).
Like shortstops, outfielders will need to see the overall situation and know how to respond to it. This [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale Jerseys Free Shipping[/url] is especially important when they are moving the ball into the infield. If another player [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale Jerseys China[/url] isn’t ready to respond to them, [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys China[/url] it will allow the other team to stay a step ahead. Whether the outfielder is in right, left or center field, they will need to have the ability to put the ball back where it belongs in the game.