Solving time: 1:16:32.
The blog title says it all. Fell into every trap possible. Had to make a few wild guesses on the basis of crossing letters and got in a stew about parsing them later. No state of mind for a Championship puzzle. (Might have made the 56%, but only after all the others were down the pub and on their 4th or 5th.)
Can’t think of anything to leave out and, since the puzzle’s been out for a while, I won’t.
| Across |
| 1 |
ENCO,RE. Anagram of ONCE; RE for the corps. The def is ‘again’. |
| 4 |
S,EA(COA)ST. S (for south); EAST; around COA{l}. It would be natural, I suspect, to think SE,A <= ‘SE area’, and then to wonder about the final ST. I did. |
| 10 |
PRESS-GA(N)G. A ‘D notice’ is a one of these. |
| 11 |
ORG{y},AN. The def is ‘Newspaper’. |
| 12 |
D,IS,CRIMINA{l},TORY. |
| 14 |
E(N)D,ED. The journalists are ED and ED. |
| 16 |
AV,ALAN,CHE. For the first part, see here. |
| 18 |
CA,MC,ORDER. CA (about); MC (first and last of ‘monastic’). |
| 20 |
PETRA. Odd letters of ‘Pretty road’. |
| 21 |
INDIRECT SPEECH. Anagram: predict Chinese. |
| 25 |
OWNER. RENO reversed, inc W (for ‘wife’). |
| 26 |
IN,A,NI,MATE. NI for Northern Ireland. |
| 27 |
GREEN TAX. GREET inc N and A X (vote). |
| 28 |
LATEST. Take the B from ‘battles’, then anagram. |
| Down |
| 1 |
EX,PE(DIE)NCE. The contained is DIE{t}. Lift and separate ‘Convenience | food’ |
| 2 |
{s}CREWS. My first in, leaving me in hope of a fast finish. Some hope! |
| 3 |
ROSE-RED. Two kinds of wine and John William Burgon’s description of Petra: “a rose-red city half as old as time”. Obscure? |
| 5 |
EGG ON. Lift and separate ‘this | urge’. Two defs, one humor-ish. |
| 6 |
CRO,ATIA. Sounds like CROW and ASIA. One for the split personalities. |
| 7 |
ANGORA CAT. Reversal of CAR inside AN and GOAT. |
| 8 |
TUNA. The middle of cANUTe, reversed. |
| 9 |
FAR,M,LAND. Reversal of RAF (fliers); M{ountain}. |
| 13 |
DETACHMENT. Two defs. |
| 15 |
D(OM,IN)ANCE. The Lancers is a chaotic set of human movements thinly disguised as choreography. OM=Order of Merit. |
| 17 |
AM,RITS,AR. AM{erican}, reversal of RA (artillery) and STIR. |
| 19 |
O(MICRO)N. |
| 20 |
PAP,RIK,A. Sounds like REEK, cf 24dn. |
| 22 |
ELIZA. Last letter of ‘seE’; LIZA{rd}. |
| 23 |
ELATE. Reversal of E-TALE. |
| 24 |
P,ONG. P for ‘piano’; {s}ONG. |
The thing about this sort of puzzle is that you have to keep telling yourself that the answers are not obscure words, it’s just the wordplay.
I did mess up on ‘seacoast’ for a while, having ‘seacoals’ instead, as kind of a perverted &lit. That was my only serious error, as I exercised great caution not to put in wrong answers. I had heard of Petra and its famous sobriquet, it was ‘Amritsar’ that had escaped my prior knowledge. But the cryptic is very helpful once you get the last crossing letter and realize both ‘RA’ and ‘stir’ are reversed.
On revisiting it this morning I realised that although ELIZA was correct, ESCORT and AMRITRAJ were not – the last one I put down to having tennis on the brain at the moment because of the ATP finals.
Those of a certain age will remember The Lancers as performed by Mr Pastry: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0DXDV1xThU
What fun that having been deprived of hum meaning a bad odour yesterday it should turn up today!
It’s refreshing that the Times puzzle recently used the Queen of the Iceni and now refers to the Danish King of England both spelt the way that I was taught in school instead of the alternatives that seem to take precedence these days.
Wed to a east-European, PAPRIKA doesn’t really work for me, but I thought PONG was clever and ELATE a cute e-device.
When Burgon described Petra as “half as old as time” he probably meant it literally. As a devout and literally-minded churchman he would have believed Bishop Ussher’s calculation that the world was created in 4004 BC (at 9am on Monday 23 October, to be precise!)
ANGORA CAT was a new beast to me. If it looks the way I imagine I wouldn’t want one that was moulting.
Surprised to see 3D in a Championship puzzle. I solved it from the “wines” and checking letters. And add me to the list of folk for whom PAPRIKA doesn’t work. Quite some time since we’ve had a really contentious homophone.
A difficult puzzle under competition conditions I would think
I suspect there needs to be an element of achievement, hence winning/beating/overtaking would require success, whereas singing/playing tennis/looking would involve any half-arsed effort worthy of the name.
I would suggest that commanding is definitely in the first category, hence the orignal objection should stand.
“I command you to stop”
“Get stuffed”
… sums up the story quite well!
GLENDOWER
I can call spirits from the vasty deep.
HOTSPUR
Why, so can I, or so can any man;
But will they come when you do call for them?
Thanks, as ever, for helpful blog.
I do agree with those who query the homophone in 20.
Re CANUTE above, or rather CNUT, he didn’t claim to have dominium over the waves; he was merely demonstrating to his fawning courtiers the limits of his power. That doesn’t invalidate the clue, because presumably he uttered some such command for the benefit of his entourage, but it does rather invalidate Private Eye’s cartoon in a recent edition.
Regardless I’m glad I was in Prelim 1 and didn’t have to face this under competition conditions.
Eliza was one of my first in without checkers. Re 8 I too was trying to get the TUN out of Neptune to make tuna, having been put off, as Jack suggests, by old whatshisname more commonly being Cnut than Canute in the Times.
COD to farmland.
Thanks to Jack for the link to Mr Pastry whom I can just about remember watching as a samll child.
Pretty tricky, I thought. Not a puzzle that inspires me to take part in the Championships in the foreseeable future!
Tomorrow is the Thanksgiving holiday in the US, so a happy one to all, whether celebrating or not. We all have something to be thankful for, and it’s good to be reminded from time to time. Best to all.
A most enjoyable puzzle, and IMO very well judged at exactly the right level for a Championship preliminary.
I couldn’t parse 12ac until I realised it ended with TORY not TING, which gave me the unknown ANGORA CAT, and skimmed over the MC in CAMCORDER until I saw mctext’s explanation. I also missed the merit M in 15d having picked up on the dance which I used to do as a youngster. I too was pleased to see the more familiar spelling of Canute used for 8d. Took me a while to spot Reno rather than ROV as well. As a computer technician, I liked OMICRON.
Thanks to mctext for the very welcome explanations.