Solving time : well 18:23 on the club timer, but I’ve got two wrong. One was a typo, but there was one that I put in a rather spectacularly wrong answer, and I can now see what it should have been. This was a weird experience, one clue made me think that I was in the world of Mephistos and barred-grid puzzles, and then there was one clue where I have no hesitation in pulling out the term whirredploy. Some may find this pretty straightforward, but to me, it was a struggle and I was only occasionally on the wavelength of the setter.
I did learn a few new things from the wordplay, so an interesting challenge.
Away we go…
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | APPEAL: Sounds like A PEAL. PEAL can mean the changes rung on a set of bells |
| 5 | BASALTIC: AS in BALTIC – figured what the wordplay should be but took until I got 5 down to see which sea went in the middle |
| 9 | CLOISTERED: S in LOITERED, next to C(clubs) |
| 10 | TOLD: Sounds like TOLLED – a mini-theme with the PEAL? Edit: misread the clue when writing the blog, it’s just two definitions of TOLD |
| 11 | PRIE-DIEU: PR(pair), I(in), then DIE(long) in EU(Europe). New word for me, pieced together from wordplay |
| 12 | SEXTON: Double definition (maybe a triple – was there a Blake who was a SEXTON?) |
| 13 | SCOT |
| 15 | ANISETTE: Meant to sound like ANNE’S ATE? I call whirredploy! |
| 18 | PLAYGOER: well someone who goes to a play could sit in the gods, but I don’t get the rest of the clue? mctext has it – GO in PLAYER |
| 19 | HIND: add BE and you’ve got BEHIND |
| 21 | A,MULE,T |
| 23 | AUTOBAHN: A then OB in (HAUNT)* |
| 25 | let’s omit this from the acrossings |
| 26 | REGRETTING: EGRET for A in RATING – this was the one that struck me as barred-grid style wordplay |
| 27 | UNDERLIE: double definition, and a nice one too, I like the idea of UNDER LIE as to tell the truth too much |
| 28 | MARTYR: T(from Tower) in MARY R (maybe a little naughty as “old queen” but nice surface) |
| Down | |
| 2 | POLAR: double definition that it took me forever to spot! |
| 3 | EMINENTLY: MINE,N.T. in ELY |
| 4 | LATVIA: (VITAL)*, A |
| 5 | BERMUDA TRIANGLE: (A,DUMBER)* then TRIANGLE(figure) |
| 6 | SIDESLIP: ID ES |
| 7 | LATEX: sounds like LATE EX |
| 8 | ILL-GOTTEN: L,L(two pounds), in (GET,INTO)*. Edit: I originally had points instead of pounds, thanks for the correction |
| 14 | COLUMBIAN: BIA |
| 16 | and we won’t show this one from the downs |
| 17 | POST,URAL: CARRIAGE meaning STANCE in this case |
| 20 | ST,REAM |
| 22 | LEVEE: EVE in LE – never heard of this use of LEVEE as a morning reception |
| 24 | HONE,Y: HONE coming from EDGE as in SHARPEN |
Thanks for picking up on 18… I’ll edit those two in.
Even if it’s ANNIE’S ATE that’s a stretch
A person who looks after a church and churchyard, sometimes acting as bell-ringer and formerly as a gravedigger.
There was some tricky wordplay here, I thought ‘basaltic’ and ‘autobahn’ were quite good….just as ‘anisette’ was quite bad!
I’m moving on tomorrow, be back later.
Two errors in my 17:56 – a careless COLOMBIAN and I plumped for HAND after pondering HIND. Didn’t know HIND as a rustic type and thought this was a convoluted cryptic around BEHINDHAND.
Some people do pronounce ‘ate’ as ‘et’, but for the many of us who don’t the use of it in a crossword always feels like a stretch. Probably best avoided.
COD: UNDERLIE. Lovely.
In 11ac, when I finally got there, isn’t the first I from ‘one’??
Apart from that, I rather enjoyed it, despite walking right into the ‘Sir Walter’ trap and getting another Caledonian clue wrong, putting ‘hand’ for HIND. Tucked away for the future, that one is …
Incidentally, I open my Shakespeare at As You Like It, and there’s a grumpy Orlando in Scene I moaning about his big brother making him ‘feed with his hinds‘.
Then there’s this with apologies to Chaucer…
Whon thotte Aprylle swythyn Potrzebie,
The burgydde Pryllye gyves one hebijebie.
(UK ‘figure’ is actually exceptional, since g/k+u normally takes a y in both UK and US dialects: regular, cute, etc.; cf. news, stupid, dune.)
I wonder if the educated American’s animus towards ‘figger’ has anything to do with its closeness to the dreaded ‘n’ word?
Don’t worry about Fowler. He’s more a figyure of fun than anything else these days.
I also put HAND with a big question mark against it to remind me to revisit it and fortunately worked out it had to be HIND despite not actually knowing the required meaning.
SIDESLIP, LEVEE and BASALTIC all from wordplay alone. RH much easier than LH as it was opened up early on by the long gift at 5dn.
Thanks, George, for the blog; and thanks, too, to the setter for a demanding, but reachable, challenge – it makes a change from some recent offerings.
Are we being given a bit of a slap over the wrist for querying the “foreign” word HWYL? We had three French, one German, one Scottish (I looked up HIND) and arguably one Greek in MARTYR today.
Otherwise, lots of entertainment, and CoD goes to UNDERLIE, which was chucklesome despite a whiff of conker (should that be marron today?) about it.
The proximity of TOLD and SEXTON is surely no coincidence.
Like linxit I narrowly avoided SIDESPIN because I couldn’t justify the P. When you have an apparently superfluous bit of wordplay like this you’re invariably on the wrong track. Likewise I paused on HAND.
My problem with ANISETTE is that I’m pretty sure the pronunciation (derived from “anis”, which is pronounced ANEESS) is such that ANNIE SET would be a valid homophone but ANNIE’S ATE is dodgy whatever one thinks of ET/ATE. Am I imagining this?
Jim
I interpreted the whirredploy as Anne is et (eaten).
I had no idea how playgoer worked and had never heard of thedesk which I assembled from wordplay and bits of old French I had lying around.
I’m going to underlie and say the homophone is the worst we’ve had for some time. Surely a rather risky choice of clue type for such a word – pronounciation is bound to vary hugely
Quite enjoyed the rest of it, even if it was a bit of an uphill battle
His death, which happened in his berth/ at forty-odd befell/ They went and told the sexton/ And the sexton tolled the bell.